National Audit Office slams NHS ” transformation” plans

Owl’s summary: you haven’t done your homework, your models are untested, you don’t understand what you are doing and the NHS is underfunded NOT overspent!

Some quotes:

17. Plans to close the estimated £22 billion gap have not been fully tested.

“The Department, NHS England and NHS Improvement used a financial model to estimate the gap between patients’ needs and resources by 2020-21, and the savings their programmes need to achieve to close this gap. We found limited testing by the Department, NHS England and NHS Improvement of their estimates of how much they expect to generate from their savings programmes.

This raises concerns about whether planned savings can be achieved. For example, plans assume that growth in trusts’ acute activity (including specialised acute services) will be reduced from 2.9% to 1.3% through transformation and efficiency programmes such as Right Care, new care models and the Urgent and Emergency Care programme. However, NHS statistics show this will be challenging as hospital admissions, a key driver of activity, grew by 2.8% a year between 2013-14 and 2014-15 (paragraphs 2.4 to 2.7).”

18. The NHS is implementing its plans to make the NHS financially sustainable from a worse than expected starting point.

Plans to achieve financial sustainability were based on trusts ending 2015-16 with a combined deficit of £1.8 billion. The fact that trusts ended the year with an even larger deficit means that the level of deficit to be recovered is significantly greater than expected. This means that the trusts affected will need to catch-up by making more savings than planned to reach the intended starting position. For example, trusts with deficits greater than expected at the end of 2015-16 will need to make operational efficiencies above the 2% savings level applied to all providers of healthcare services in 2016-17 or subsequent years (paragraphs 1.8 and 2.8).

19. National bodies have not assessed the impact of all the wider cost pressures faced by local NHS organisations in plans for achieving financial sustainability.

The Department, NHS England and NHS Improvement expect trusts and commissioners to invest in transformation programmes. But they do not yet know what level of investment is required or whether local bodies will be able to make the changes at the scale and pace needed.

Furthermore, the government has made a commitment that the health and social care system in England will be fully joined together by 2020. We have previously reported that local authority spending on adult social care fell by 10% in real terms between 2009-10 (£16.3 billion) and 2014-15 (£14.6 billion). The accounting officer for NHS England told the Committee of Public Accounts that “over the next two or three years, there is likely to be a widening gap between the availability of adult social care and the need for social care. That, will, inevitably show up as delayed discharges and extra pressure on hospitals.” However, in our review of the plans for financial sustainability, we did not see any estimate of the impact of pressures on social care spending on NHS bodies (paragraphs 2.6 to 2.13).

24. The National Audit Office (NAO) perceives differences in the position articulated by the Department – which views the funding for the NHS as having been adequate over the last few years, and in line with what NHS England set out it would need to deliver the NHS Five Year Forward View – and NHS England itself. Confronted as NHS England is by the pressures of rising demand for services, these signs of differences do not help build a confident feel about the future of the NHS.