SWW discharges unmonitored raw sewage next to Budleigh Lime Kiln car park

A recent comment on Information requests:

Dear Owl,

As a Budleigh resident I was shocked at the FOI describing the unmonitored discharge coming out of the SWW Lime Kiln sewage pumping station into the Kersbrook.  INTO A SITE INHABITED BY THE MOST BEAUTIFUL KINGFISHER which has brought such joy to many.

I cannot understand how the Environment Agency, which has spent so much money on the Lower Otter Restoration Project (LORP), could possibly allow this illegal, disgusting practice to continue.

I also cannot understand how the LORP project included the replacement of the old sewage outfall pipe which will allow raw sewage to continue to discharge on the eastern side of the Otter Head. ( 269.69 hours in 2022) The money should have been spent upgrading the sewage system so no untreated sewage needed to be discharged into the sea.

The Otter estuary is now a nature reserve and attracting so many new species but has raw sewage from places such as Honiton, Newton Poppleford etc.etc. passing through it.

Was permission given for extensive use of Glyphosate on the Otter Restoration Project?

From Louise who has launched an as yet unanswered Freedom of Information request to Natural England concerning permission to use glyphosate extensively during the Lower Otter Restoration Project:

Owl, the LORP is to become a formal nature reserve… however the spraying of glyphosate all over the site seems to contradict this…I included my EA FOI  Response within my application to Natural England and  as you will see the spraying was widespread🙄..  I will be Interested to see the response from Natural England which is subject to a delay… surely they cannot carry on using toxic chemicals when it has nature reserve status!

Dear Natural England, 11 December 2023

I have received the below information in response to a FOI made to the Environment Agency regarding the use of Glyphosate on land being treated as a Nature Reserve which is also adjacent to a SSSi.

Please confirm the following:
1. Was any contact received by Natural England, from any person involved in the Lower Otter Restoration Project (LORP)regarding the use of Glyphosate on any part of the LORP site.
2. If so what are the details of that communication.
3. If permission was required for the use of Glyphosate within the LORP site, was permission applied for.
4. If contact was received by Natural England was it made clear that the spraying was taking place within approximately 12-20 inches of waterways
5. Was permission granted by Natural England for the use of Glyphosate on the LORP site which is adjacent to a SSSi and is being treated as a Nature Reserve with a view to full nature reserve status.
6. . Was a copy of the contractors NPTC certificate seen by Natural England.
7. If permission was not required please give an explanation of why
8. If permission was required but not applied and granted, for what are the consequences for the companies/landowners/ persons involved who have not complied with the relevant legislation.

The below is FOI information received from the Environment Agency regarding the use of Glyphosate within the LORP site.

Herbicide has been used to suppress weed growth and ensure successful establishment of planting. Glyphosates are the only non-selective herbicide licenced to be used adjacent to watercourses in the UK. There is no further spraying planned this year and we are seeking to avoid its use next year.

Locations and dates used are as follows:

21/7/23 – South of South Farm Road around tree planting
28/7/23 – North side of South Farm Road, large area prior to cultivating & grass seeding
25/8/23 – North East path around tree planting
31/8/23 – Car Park edges
4/9/23 – Around plants to both North & South side of South Farm Road
13/9/23 – Triangular section of additional planting at end of North West path / start of Big Bank
25/9/23 – Spot spraying of growth coming through North West path (car park to farm)

The control of weeds using a herbicide is needed to prevent the weed growth overtaking and potentially smothering the grass and tree planting. Please note that the spot spraying was targeted and the actual chemical dose was very low.

Whilst strimming can sometimes be used for weed control, it is less effective and where we have invasive species such as Himalayan balsam (endemic in the lower otter), we would risk spreading the seeds.

The reason for spot spraying on the footpath which runs north of South Farm Road path was to stop the growth of weeds and grass which were actually growing through the path surfacing. We did not want these to establish and break up the surface. Without this action it is possible that the Council would not adopt the surfacing.

On a final point, whenever we have sprayed around trees near pathways we have always had a banksman in operation to control the movement of pedestrians. An alternative to this would be to close footpaths. However, we wanted to avoid this, as maintaining access has always been a priority for the project team. We have asked our contractors to put up signage when they have applied herbicide in the future where this is adjacent to public areas.

We respond to requests for information that we hold under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and Environmental Information Regulations 2004. Please refer to the Open Government Licence: http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/o… which explains the permitted use of this information.

Please get in touch if you have any further queries or contact us within two months if you would like us to review the information we have sent.

Devon, Cornwall and Isles of Scilly enquiries team:

Good afternoon

The Environment Agency is named as a major partner in the Lower Otter Restoration Project, (LORP) and applied for the planning permission for this project.

I have been advised by the Kier project team that a herbicide containing Glyphosate is currently being used on the land which forms part of LORP, they have also confirmed that spraying is taking place, has been taking place, and may take place in the future.

At approximately 07:45 on Monday 25 September, I witnessed the herbicide being spayed on either side of the western path north of South Farm Road. There was no signage in place, no verbal warnings were were given, and the path was fairly busy with walkers and dogs. After inhaling an extremely toxic lungful of the herbicide, it was apparent that a hazardous chemical was being sprayed, hence I approached the “sprayers” to find out what it was. (This is not their fault, they are only acting on instructions)

In relation to the geographical area of the Lower Otter Restoration Project site which runs from Lime Kiln Carpark to the 200 metre section of Little Bank, East Budleigh, I am requesting the following information:

1. On how many occasions, within the LORP site/ Lower Otter has the spraying of herbicides taken place during the project.
2. What herbicide/s have been used. If they are not branded please provide the mix of chemicals contained within them, and levels of glyphosate.
3. On what dates has the herbicide spraying taken place.
4. In which locations within the area has the herbicide spraying taken place
5. What risk assessments for both wildlife and humans were in place prior to, during, and post the spraying.
6. What non toxic options were considered, and if any, why were they not used.
7. What is the rationale for using a herbicide containing the extremely hazardous chemical Glyphosate which is lethal to wildlife, within an area which has high levels of wildlife, is adjacent to a SSSi, and is being promoted a bio diverse.
8. Who/which department or unit authorised the use of herbicide for use within the project area.

Please acknowledge receipt of this email and in line with current legislation I look forward to receiving a response within 20 working days.

Yours faithfully
Mrs L Arnesen

More quotes on what makes Paul Arnott tick

“The instant focus for me will be around environment. We know there’s the crisis with South West Water, but that’s not just about beaches, that’s about rivers as well.  

“We’ve got an absolute crisis around insufficient homes, particularly for younger people, but it does present as an issue for older people as well

Paul Arnott (courtesy: Todd Olive/Exmouth and Exeter East Liberal Democrats)

Will Goddard, local democracy reporter www.radioexe.co.uk

The Liberal Democrats have chosen East Devon District Council leader Paul Arnott to stand as their candidate for the newly formed Exmouth and Exeter East constituency at the next general election. 

The new seat will be formed from much of the old East Devon seat, including Exmouth, Topsham, Budleigh Salterton and Cranbrook, but also eastern parts of Exeter like Pinhoe.  

East Devon and its former incarnations has been Conservative since before Queen Victoria came to the throne, whilst Exeter has been held by Labour since 1997.  

Despite this, Cllr Arnott believes he has a realistic chance of winning and has received the backing of Claire Wright, who gathered more than 40 per cent of the vote in East Devon in the 2019 general election as an independent, leaving the Conservatives with a majority of 6,708. 

He also highlighted the success of the Lib Dems in the area in the 2023 local elections. 

Cllr Arnott said: “I think it will become apparent that it’s a two-horse race.  

“Claire’s 25,000 votes have to go somewhere, and I would be hoping to get a healthy chunk of those.  

“In the East Devon part of the constituency, at the district council, there are 12 Lib Dems, there are two Greens and one Labour [councillor]. 

“I think that shows that the Lib Dems are the people, by the most recent electoral evidence, who are there to beat.”

However, not all of Claire Wright’s votes in 2019 would have come from the new constituency. The politically independent Boundary Commisison has also created a new area called Honiton and Sidmouth. It reviews constituency boundaries periodically to try to roughly balance them in terms of population numbers.

Clrr Arnott continued: “When you come to St Loyes and Pinhoe, clearly they sit within a Labour city council. The Lib Dems are definitely getting stronger within that and campaigning, and that is somewhere where I will obviously pay a lot of early attention and get out there and meet people.” 

Mr Arnott was born in London and was adopted at birth. Educated at Exeter University, he later worked as a journalist and in television and has published four books. He became the leader of East Devon District Council in 2020 and has lived in Colyton since 2001. He is married with four children and one grandchild. 

Asked why he thinks he would make a good MP for the area, he said: “My entire work as a district councillor has been across the whole district and I would say disproportionately around what would be my constituency.  

“As district leader, I can say truly that I work in the constituency. And I think that’s pretty fine bona fides to want to become a member of parliament.  

“I know its major settlements really well, and I lived in Exeter for years, and I lived in Topsham. 

“I live nine miles outside the constituency, which I think in Devon terms is more or less next-door neighbour. It takes me about 15 minutes to drive into the constituency. 

“What I would hope to bring is the knowledge – the deep knowledge and understanding that I’ve managed to gather as district leader at East Devon, which covers absolutely everything from homes to economy and environment. 

“I’ve dealt with those in the constituency, and I’ve dealt with them nationally as well. As a candidate, I come ready with that knowledge. I understand it. I know a lot of people in the constituency.  

“I’m not the youngest candidate, but sometimes that’s not such a bad thing. I’m not a career politician knifing his way up. I’m just there to try and do stuff for the benefit of the people of Exmouth and Exeter East.” 

Cllr Arnott describes himself as “absolutely centrist” and was an independent councillor before the 2023 local elections, in which he retained his seat in Coly Valley after joining the Lib Dems. 

He said: “In order to become selected as a Liberal Democrat candidate, you have to make a study of the Liberal Democrat manifesto.  

“I think it’s really strong, and it’s what we’ve been doing at the district, in effect.

“The instant focus for me will be around environment. We know there’s the crisis with South West Water, but that’s not just about beaches, that’s about rivers as well.  

“We’ve got an absolute crisis around insufficient homes, particularly for younger people, but it does present as an issue for older people as well.  

“That’s about getting stuck into the planning system and about trying to get new social housing going. And I know at East Devon, that is a priority for us already. 

“It’s about continuing the good work on the economy, because actually it’s thriving, I think largely due to the work of the district council. We have the [Exeter and East Devon] Enterprise Zone and that’s working very well.  

“For me, working with my continuing district contacts on homes and homelessness will be really important. 

“And then finally, it’s about working to protect the NHS, which does seem to be coming under consistent attack from the government, tragically.” 

A general election must be held by the end of January 2025.  One other candidate, Conservative David Reed, has been announced for Exmouth and Exeter East so far.
 

“Top of the Poops”. South West Water pollution onto beaches, rivers and the shellfish food chain revealed

According to the “Top of the Poops” web site South West Water pollutes rivers for longer than any other water company and is the top polluter of shellfish. River pollution is not recorded on SWW’s WaterFit Live but all discharges into rivers end in the sea.

In Owl’s view this makes SWW Waterfit Live “unfit for purpose”.

Swimming in sewage

Most, if not actually all, of the beaches and designated coastal bathing locations around England and Wales are regular recipients of a good layer of sewage.

Accuracy Warning We use data from the water companies, but we are seeing many anomalies, that make us believe that bathing location information is quite poor. The situation is likely far worse than reported here.

Water companies have a duty to report on the summer bathing season separately, and this made grim reading in 2022. For more details check out Surfers Against Sewage Water Quality Report 2022

Top of The Poops – Beaches

1.United Utilities – New Brighton 7,056 hours

2.United Utilities – Allonby 6,754 hours

3.United Utilities – Morecambe North 5,348 hours

4.South West Water – PLYMOUTH HOE (EAST) 5,158 hours

5.United Utilities – St Annes 4,700 hours

6.United Utilities – Morecambe South 4,614 hours

7.United Utilities – Seascale 4,545 hours

8.United Utilities – Southport, St Annes Pier, St. Annes North and Blackpool South 3,671 hours

9.Southern Water – COWES, GURNARD 3,161 hours

10.South West Water – MOTHECOMBE BEACH 2,884 hours

[See all beach rankings]

Rivers & Streams

Of the 4700 rivers in England, few escape from sewage dumping

Top of The Poops – Rivers

1.South West Water – Unknown 19,395 hours

2.Yorkshire Water – River Calder 18,079 hours

3.Severn Trent Water – River Severn 17,495 hours

4.Dwr Cymru Welsh Water – River Garw 16,134 hours

5.South West Water – River Tamar 15,546 hours

6.Dwr Cymru Welsh Water – River Teifi 14,079 hours

7.Dwr Cymru Welsh Water – River Tawe 13,981 hours

8.Yorkshire Water – River Aire 13,810 hours

9.United Utilities – River Irwell 12,939 hours

10.United Utilities – River Eden 11,780 hours

Sewage in the food chain?

Shellfish are sensitive to the quality of water that surrounds them, and as they filter the water, they can become contaminated with bacteria from the water around them.

Top of The Poops – Shellfish

1.South West Water – Teign 10,838 hours

2.South West Water – Fal Estuary 9,245 hours

3.United Utilities – NORTH WIRRAL (EAST) 8,665 hours

4.United Utilities – MORECAMBE BAY EAST 8,528 hours

5.South West Water – Exe 6,411 hours

6.South West Water – Dart 6,123 hours

7.United Utilities – MORECAMBE BAY (LEVEN) 5,529 hours

8.United Utilities – RIBBLE 5,155 hours

9.United Utilities – Morecambe Bay East and Lune (Broadfleet and Plover Scar) 5,104 hours

10.United Utilities – Solway 4,604 hours

[See all shellfish rankings]

A dozen freedom of information requests to SWW on sewage spills and monitoring failures in Exmouth and Budleigh

Although South West Water is a private company it must comply with Freedom of Information (FOI) requests on environmental issues.

A correspondent has just pointed out to Owl that SWW has been deluged with FOIs from Exmouth and Budleigh residents in the past few days. Below are the details of one that caught the correspondent’s eye regarding unmonitored raw sewage discharge into the Kersbrook at the Lime Kiln car park Budleigh Salterton. This discharge is only metres away from the popular bathing spot in front of the car park.

This is followed by a short list of a dozen recent requests with links to the details.

[The reason these are in the public domain, visible for us to see, is that the requests were made through the “What do they know?” website. An essential tip for anyone launching a FOI]

Request for discharge information, Emergency Overflow from Lime Kiln SPS, Budleigh Salterton

10 February 2024

Dear South West Water Limited,
We have recently become aware that there is an Emergency Overflow (EO) which comes out of the Lime Kiln SPS
 [sewer pumping station] at Budleigh Salterton. This EO is not monitored through EDM [event duration monitors] sensors.
I have video and photo evidence that this EO has discharged sewage and related items, including sanitary pads, into the Kersbrook channel and from their to the beach through a culvert. This site is due to become a National Nature Reserve this week.
Information I would like please:
1) How many times, and which specific dates, has this EO discharged since 1st January 2022 (ie: 2 years)?
2) How long have these discharges lasted, and what volume has been discharged?
3) What reporting has been made on these discharges, both to EA and to the public?
4) In view of this site being newly categorised as a National Nature reserve, when will this be monitored through EDM, and data published in near real time?Yours faithfully,
Peter Williams

The list

Exmouth SPS Pump Failure information

Response by South West Water Limited to Geoff Crawford on 13 February 2024.

 Awaiting classification.

Exmouth, Phear Park SPS maintenance records 2019 – 2024

Response by South West Water Limited to Geoff Crawford on 13 February 2024.

 Awaiting classification.

Maer Road pumping station Exmouth overflows

Response by South West Water Limited to Karen Powers on 12 February 2024.

 Awaiting classification.

Exmouth SPS pump capacity and volume

Response by South West Water Limited to Charlie Edwards on 12 February 2024.

 Awaiting classification.

Hartopp SPS storm tank, Maer Road and Phear Park Emergency Overflows

Request sent to South West Water Limited by Geoff Crawford on 11 February 2024.

 Awaiting response.

Sewage Sludge and Fertiliser Cake HGV transportation and Environmental Impact

Response by South West Water Limited to Geoff Crawford on 30 January 2024.

 Successful.

Exmouth – Request for Clear and Accurate Schedule of Inspections, Asset Lifespan, and Replacement/Upgrade Plan

Response by South West Water Limited to Geoff Crawford on 6 February 2024.

 Delayed.

Faulty EDMs at Budleigh

Request sent to South West Water Limited by Karen Powers on 11 February 2024.

 Awaiting response.

Exmouth discharges between 30 Dec & 2 Jan 2024

Response by South West Water Limited to Karen Powers on 5 February 2024.

 Awaiting response.

2023 bathing water discharges

Response by South West Water Limited to Karen Powers on 5 February 2024.

 Awaiting response.

Request for discharge information, Emergency Overflow from Lime Kiln SPS, Budleigh Salterton

Request sent to South West Water Limited by Peter Williams on 10 February 2024. – See below

 Awaiting response..

Tankers at Budleigh Lime Kiln January 2024

Response by South West Water Limited to Karen Powers on 5 February 2024.

 Awaiting classification.