- Proposed two single storey extensions and replacement garage
2 Trinfield Avenue Exmouth Devon EX8 3JURef. No: 23/1764/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Construction of a detached annexe, ancillary to the enjoyment of the existing bungalow.
9 Apple Close Exmouth EX8 4QNRef. No: 23/1760/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Certificate of proposed lawful development for side extension to form new entrance, existing hips to gables to the main roof and existing dormer size increased.9 Apple Close Exmouth Devon EX8 4QNRef. No: 23/1759/CPL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision
- T3: Norway Maple – approximately reduce to upper previous pollard points at 3m above ground level, leaving multiple points to encourage a balanced crown formation and allow continued vascular connection. T6: Pittosporum – reduce to growth point approximately 1.5 metres above ground level. T8: Sycamore – remove southern stem and reduce northern stem by approximately 40%. T9: Plum – fell to near ground level. T12: Holm Oak- crown reduce by approximately 2m or further if permitted. Maximum diameter of cuts 50mm. T13: Cypress – dismantle to near ground level. T14: Goat Willow – pollard at existing pollard points, approximately 1.5 metres above ground level.
12 Louisa Place Exmouth Devon EX8 2ALRef. No: 23/1753/TCA | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - T1, Magnolia : crown raise to 2.5m, clean up poor previous pruning cuts and remove epicormic regrowth on trunk.
Mead Fortescue Road Sidmouth EX10 9QGRef. No: 23/1750/TRE | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Ash: sectionally remove to the ground.
7 Wren Close Honiton EX14 2GWRef. No: 23/1741/TRE | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - G5 – Poplars (group): dismantle or fell approximately 11 poplars within the woodlands. T7 – Eucalyptus: dismantle in sections to near ground level.
Hollerfields Higher Metcombe Devon EX11 1SRRef. No: 23/1747/TRE | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Certificate of Lawful Development for an area of land at Wheelgates used as a residential garden for a continuous period of more than 10 years.
Wheelgates Cotleigh EX14 9HGRef. No: 23/1744/CPE | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Proposed loft conversion
Sunbeams Rhode Lane Uplyme DT7 3TXRef. No: 23/1737/FUL | Validated: Tue 08 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Lawful Development Certificate for construction of single storey rear extension.51 Millers Way Honiton EX14 1JBRef. No: 23/1734/CPL | Validated: Tue 08 Aug 2023 | Status: Withdrawn
- Covered farmyard manure store
Wadhayes Farm Awliscombe EX14 3PRRef. No: 23/1733/FUL | Validated: Tue 08 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Variation of condition no. 2 (approved plans) and 8 (inverter station and CCTV details) of application 20/2551/VAR (Variation of conditions 2 (Approved Plans) and 8 (Inverter station and CCTV details) of application 19/1056/VAR (Installation of ground mounted photovoltaic solar arrays with transformer stations; internal access track; biodiversity enhancement; landscaping; fencing; security measures; access gate and ancillary infrastructure (without complying with Condition 16 of planning permission 17/1378/VAR, to extend the operational lifespan of solar farm to 40 years) to reflect changes to layout, fencing, infrastructure specification and appearance, and to allow siting of an additional storage container.) to extend the operation lifespan of solar farm to 40 years.
Axe View Solar Farm Wadbrook EX13 7ASRef. No: 23/0009/EIA | Validated: Tue 08 Aug 2023 | Status: Decided - Lawful Development Certificate for a single storey rear extension1 Rosedale Terrace Colyford Road Seaton Devon EX12 2SPRef. No: 23/1730/CPL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Approved
- Construction of a replacement dwelling in pursuant to planning approval 22/2834/FUL (conversion of workshop to residential dwelling and creation of a new access)
Hand And Pen Garage London Road Whimple Devon EX5 2FXRef. No: 23/1729/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Outline application with all matters reserved for a permanent rural occupational dwelling to serve an established equestrian centre
Upton Pyne Equestrian Centre Seychelles Farm Upton Pyne Exeter EX5 5HYRef. No: 23/1731/OUT | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - The erection of a single storey rear extension with a flat roof, which would extend beyond the rear wall of the original house by 3.3m, for which the maximum height would be 3.7m and the height of the eaves would be 3m.
2 Redside Terrace Cowley Exeter EX5 5ESRef. No: 23/1728/GPD | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Extension to cattle shed and creation of approach ramps
Larkbeare Court Holly Ball Lane Whimple EX5 2QXRef. No: 23/1732/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Proposed single storey extension in place of existing timber structure
The White House Rosemary Lane Musbury Devon EX13 8ATRef. No: 23/1722/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - T1, Oak: Remove approximately 30% of the foliage area of the tree by via thinning. This pruning should be achieved by: – reduce lowest limb growing towards house by 4m, back to the two side branches making a 175mm diameter pruning cut; – prune back branch over topping lowest branch growing towards house to prevent shading of lower branch; – prune remainder of crown by reduction via thinning, seeking to removing 25-35% of overall foliage area; – pruning to target most heavily extended and laterally growing branches by removing 3-6m branch sections making pruning cuts of around 100mm in diameter.
Maybury Bendarroch Road West Hill Devon EX11 1UWRef. No: 23/1721/TRE | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Proposed new dwelling to the rear
37 Alexandria Road Sidmouth EX10 9HGRef. No: 23/1713/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Retrospective siting of a shipping container (for use as food and drink preparation area) and construction of adjacent seating/dining area, and proposed enlargement and alterations to entrance to main building.
Country West Trading Estate Tytherleigh EX13 7BERef. No: 23/1708/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Change of use from F2( Community Use) to a mixed use F2 (Community Use) and use Class E(F) (Day Nursery).
Aylesbeare Village Hall Village Way Aylesbeare Exeter EX5 2FFRef. No: 23/1709/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Use of a building as 2no. dwelling houses (Use Class C3).
Abbeywood Cottage Dunkeswell EX14 4SDRef. No: 23/1710/CPE | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Variation of condition no. 2 of planning permission 21/3350/FUL (Creation of 8 flats and staff accommodation for ground floor shop on first and second floors together with bin and cycle storage) to re-position the existing services and requirements under Building Regulations requiring internal layout changes) to amended drawings.
4 – 6 Rolle Street Exmouth EX8 1HERef. No: 23/1717/VAR | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Agricultural livestock building.
Chelsea Farm Feniton EX14 3BERef. No: 23/1720/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - T13, Ash : reduction of a southerly growing branch by approximately 3m, cut back to approx 1m from the trunk to remove from over the footpath
Lindens Mill Lane Uplyme Devon DT7 3TZRef. No: 23/1718/TRE | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Two storey rear extension with associated alterations to the existing cottage.
Lilac Cottage Whitford Road Musbury Devon EX13 7APRef. No: 23/1716/FUL | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - T1, Lime: (1) crown reduction by 2/3m to reduce canopy level; (2) Growth since last application; (3) General thinning due to light loss in upstairs lounge window; (4) To remove and lop branches close to building to reduce likelyhood of damage to slate roof/guttering etc.
1 Old Heazille Mews Rewe Exeter EX5 4HBRef. No: 23/1698/TRE | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Demolition of existing rear single storey extensions & conservatory and erection of two storey rear extension
Bulstone Mead Branscombe EX12 3BLRef. No: 23/1699/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Enlargement of existing window to south elevation of existing dwelling
9D Portland Avenue Exmouth Devon EX8 2BSRef. No: 23/1695/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Installation of a main entrance sign to the access of a new cats adoption centre (previously approved under application 19/2365/MFUL).
Axhayes Cattery Clyst Honiton Devon EX5 2HSRef. No: 23/1685/ADV | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Conversion of garage and store room to create extension.
Clarence House The Butts Colyton Devon EX24 6NURef. No: 23/1688/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Change of use of part ground floor to living accommodation including change in fenestration.
Sidmouth Garage Connaught Road Sidmouth Devon EX10 8TTRef. No: 23/1690/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Rear dormers and alterations to the front apex
Durlston Barline Beer Devon EX12 3LWRef. No: 23/1696/FUL | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Variation of condition no. 1 of planning permission (20/5054/VAR Change of use of redundant barn to holiday cottage) to allow for the removal of condition no. 1 in relation to planning permission to enable the holiday home to be used for residential purposes.
Orchard Cottage Apple Barrel Barn Dunkeswell Abbey EX14 4RPRef. No: 23/1669/VAR | Validated: Tue 08 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Proposed two storey side extension and 2 bed house with parking.
Coxes Farm Sidmouth Road Clyst St Mary Devon EX5 1DNRef. No: 23/1670/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Roofing over Slurry store.
Shelf Farm Road From Luppitt Common To Dolish Farmhouse Luppitt Devon EX14 4SLRef. No: 23/1672/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Conversion of hall to restaurant and bar (Use class E and sui generis, previously A3/A4), demolition of rear elevation and public toilet block and replacement with restaurant/ bar extension and a new public toilet block, external terrace to form seating area and addition of new flue.
Sidmouth Drill Hall The Esplanade Sidmouth EX10 8BERef. No: 23/1657/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Works to rear east elevation to include: replace roof and install rooflight on (primary lean-to); remove existing (secondary lean-to) and construct new extension; replace render on (primary lean-to); replace 1no. window on (primary lean-to) south elevation; elevation and replace guttering and downpipe on main house on south and east elevation and internal alterations to ground floor layout
Charnwood Payhembury EX14 3HRRef. No: 23/1640/LBC | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - T2, T3 Silver Birches : reduce the height of trees by 4m, to previous pruning points, mazimum diameter cuts of less than 200mm.
10 Sherwood Drive Exmouth EX8 4PXRef. No: 23/1646/TRE | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Development of 17no commercial units
Coastguard Road Ltd Devonshire Road Heathpark Industrial Estate Honiton EX14 1SDRef. No: 23/1631/MFUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Erection of a detached two storey dwelling, detached garage and wildlife lake with associated landscaping
Land North Of Higher Griggs Farm Fortescue Road SidmouthRef. No: 23/1619/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Demolition of existing garage, new two storey side extension and Juliette balcony, new porch and decking to rear
Graves End House Village Road Woodbury Salterton EX5 1PGRef. No: 23/1605/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Removal of internal boiler & flue [fed through the archway wall], new structure erected in garden to surround new boiler and oil tank [retrospective]
1 The Stables Shute Devon EX13 7NYRef. No: 23/1583/FUL | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - General purpose forestry buildingLand At Woodhouse Lyme Road UplymeRef. No: 23/1489/AGR | Validated: Mon 07 Aug 2023 | Status: Refused
- Proposed side extension to garage, formation of covered bin store, replacement external stairs, formation of two dormer windows on the front elevation and flat roof dormer on the rear elevation to facilitate the formation of an en-suite bathroom in the garage loft space.
Perky Pool Cottage Talaton Road Whimple Exeter EX5 2QZRef. No: 23/1333/FUL | Validated: Wed 09 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Replacement of 4no. ground floor windows on front elevation
The Forge Shute Axminster EX13 7PURef. No: 23/1255/LBC | Validated: Thu 10 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Demolition of internal wall, removal of roof to existing extension, construction of new extension with parapet and roof lanterns
The Lodge Gittisham Honiton EX14 3ADRef. No: 23/1206/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Demolition of internal wall, removal of roof to existing extension, construction of new extension with parapet and roof lanterns
The Lodge Gittisham Honiton EX14 3ADRef. No: 23/1207/LBC | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision - Change of use from a hotel (use class C1) to a dwellinghouse (use class C3(a)).
The Belfry Country Hotel Yarcombe Honiton EX14 9BDRef. No: 23/0782/FUL | Validated: Fri 11 Aug 2023 | Status: Awaiting decision
Daily Archives: 22 Aug 2023
**** you, Jack, I’m alright
Haul up the ladder, your pay rise would be inflationary – Owl
Fat cat bosses enjoy £500m pay rise as CEO salaries soar
Bosses at Britain’s biggest companies saw their pay surge by 16 per cent last year despite ordinary workers’ wages being outstripped by inflation, research has found.
Adam Forrest www.independent.co.uk
Chief executives for firms on the FTSE 100 enjoyed a pay bump amounting to around £500,000 in 2022, according to the High Pay Centre.
Unions said it showed that Britain had become “a land of grotesque extremes”, with well-off company chiefs benefiting from pay rises while hard-pressed families struggle during the cost of living crisis.
The gap between average top bosses and average workers widened further over the year – with the median CEO paid 118 times the median UK full-time worker in 2022, up from 108 times in 2021.
Median pay for a FTSE 100 CEO increased from £3.38m in 2021 to £3.91m 2022, the High Pay Centre said. It represents an upward trend after it dropped to £2.46m in 2020 after companies were hit by the Covid pandemic.
Pascal Soriot, boss of pharmaceutical giant AstraZeneca, was the highest-earning FTSE 100 chief after receiving pay of £15.3m for the year.
Other particularly highly paid bosses in 2022 – the year in which the energy crisis saw gas and electricity bills soar – included Bernard Looney of BP and Ben van Beurden of Shell.
The High Pay Centre has called for new requirements for companies to include a minimum of two elected workforce representatives on the remuneration committees that set executive pay.
Luke Hildyard, director of the High Pay Centre, said: “At a time when so many households are struggling with living costs, an economic model that prioritises a half-a-million-pound pay rise for executives who are already multi-millionaires is surely going wrong somewhere.
“How major employers distribute the wealth that their workforce creates has a big impact on people’s living standards,” said the campaigner.
Mr Hildyard added: “We need to give workers more voice on company boards, strengthen trade union rights and enable low and middle-income earners to get a fairer share in relation to those at the top.”
It comes a week after official figures showed that average wages are continuing to grow behind rises in the cost of living, despite progress in tackling price rises.
The Office for National Statistics (ONS) said regular pay growth, which excludes bonuses, reached 7.8 per cent over the three months to June compared to a year earlier, but actually dropped by 0.6 per cent once inflation was taken into account.
TUC general secretary Paul Nowak said: “While millions of families have seen their budgets shredded by the cost of living crisis, city directors have enjoyed bumper pay rises.”
The union boss added: “This is why workers must be given seats on company boards to inject some much-needed common sense and restraint. We need an economy that delivers better living standards for all – not just those at the top. But under the Tories, Britain has become a land of grotesque extremes.”
Meanwhile, Labour said the economy is “stuck in a low-growth trap” under the Tories, as its analysis of the latest economic forecasts suggests that UK growth will be the slowest in the G7 in 2024.
The Bank of England’s August Monetary Policy Report suggests that economic growth is expected to be weaker next year than previously expected, downgraded from 0.75 per cent to 0.5 per cent.
Labour said this meant the UK would experience the slowest growth among the G7 group of countries, with shadow Treasury minister Tulip Siddiq warning low growth was now a “hallmark” of Rishi Sunak’s premiership.
A Tory party spokesperson responded: “The biggest threat to growing our economy is a Labour government, with the same old plans that would push up debt, inflation and interest rates.
They added: “Since 2010, the UK has grown faster than France, Japan and Italy, and we are determined to meet the prime minister’s pledge to grow the economy further whilst halving inflation – something Labour have no plan to do.”
Government blasted as award-winning Devon pub shuts
Local leaders have lamented the closure of a popular pub in Devon and pinned the blame on the Government for not stepping in to curb the crippling impact of the cost of living crisis. The Swan closed recently after 16 years in the town of Bampton in Mid Devon.
[Simon Jupp nowhere to be seen, well Bampton isn’t in his constituency but that doesn’t seem to have deterred him recently. Photos of him supporting the hospitality sector, pint in one hand, used to be one of Simon’s things! Though his widely publicised campaigns have proved ineffectual. – Owl]
Lewis Clarke www.devonlive.com
The Swan, which had four AA Gold Stars and two Rosettes for culinary excellence, reached number 25 in the 2022 ‘Estrella Damm’ Top 50 Gastropub Awards. Alongside its sister restaurant, Spelt, it was also featured in the 2021 Michelin Guide and was named by the AA as the nation’s ‘Inn of the Year’ in 2019.
Announcing the news, owners Paul and Donna Berry said: “The strain we have been under for the last couple of years has been immense.
“We are extremely proud to have had The Swan over the last decade. We’ve had amazing customers and staff in that time. Thankfully most of the time has been positive. Clearly Covid was tough and today’s climate is very challenging.”
Councillor Chris Adcock, Liberal Democrat for Clare and Shuttern said: “This is a real blow to Bampton residents and the local economy. The Swan’s reputation brought people in to Bampton from across Devon, the UK and abroad. We would like to thank Donna, Paul and their team for all their hard work and wish them well with “Spelt”, their other restaurant on Brook Street.”
Councillor Rachel Gilmour, Liberal Democrat for Clare and Shuttern added: “This is a sign of the economic times. With the cost of living crisis, higher energy bills, enormously inflated mortgages and wages which don’t keep up with inflation, only the Conservatives are to blame for this and other pub closures. They have trashed our economy, leaving a trail of lost jobs and shattered dreams.”
Following the news, tributes and sadness at the closure of the pub poured in.
One said: “So sorry to hear this Paul as I know how much time and effort both you and Donna have invested in The Swan. You should both be very proud of yourselves for what you have given Bampton. Give yourselves a big pat on the back for all your achievements over the years and well done to all at Team Swan. Xx”
Another added: “Nooooooooo!!! Absolutely devastated for you. You’ve put your all in to it , what a challenge it’s been. Thank you for all our fabulous evenings with you. We will miss you all at the Swan soooo much Xx”
A third said: “Very sad news, quite understandable considering the financial climate. Glad you’ve still got Spelt to continue to deliver exceptional food and hospitality.”
UK housebuilders’ shares fall amid fastest drop in asking prices in five years
In its effort to push down inflation, the Bank of England has raised interest rates from 0.25% in late 2021 to 5.25% at its meeting earlier this month, the highest level since the financial crisis in 2008. That has prompted mortgage rates to rise rapidly, making borrowing for housing more difficult for many prospective buyers.
The widespread expectation is that the Bank will have to raise interest rates further. E.g. “The Bank of England should increase interest rates again to at least 5.5 per cent next month even though inflation is falling, a group of leading experts have told i.“
Jasper Jolly www.theguardian.com
Britain’s housebuilders were the top stock market fallers on Monday after one of the sector’s biggest companies issued a profit warning and data revealed the fastest drop in asking prices in five years.
Housebuilder Crest Nicholson said it expected to make a profit of about £50m this financial year, compared with about £74m expected in June, as the number of house purchases had fallen in recent weeks.
The alert sent housebuilding shares tumbling. Taylor Wimpey led the fallers on the FTSE 100, down 4%, with Persimmon, Berkeley and Barratt down more than 2% as more than £500m was wiped off the value of Britain’s largest housebuilders. The property website Rightmove also fell nearly 2% and Crest Nicholson was the biggest faller on the FTSE 250, down 10%.
It was the latest sign that rising interest rates to combat high inflation, a slowing economy and the wider cost of living crisis are weighing on the UK housing market. Home sellers reduced their asking prices by 1.9% on average in August, the most since 2018, according to data from Rightmove.
In its effort to push down inflation, the Bank of England has raised interest rates from 0.25% in late 2021 to 5.25% at its meeting earlier this month, the highest level since the financial crisis in 2008. That has prompted mortgage rates to rise rapidly, making borrowing for housing more difficult for many prospective buyers.
Crest Nicholson said the number of transactions was dropping. The amount of first-time buyers, who have generally not built up as much equity as older property owners, has dropped particularly sharply because of the end of the help to buy housing subsidy, the company said.
“Against a backdrop of persistently high inflation and rising interest rates, trading conditions for the housing market have worsened during the summer of this year,” it said in a statement to the stock market. “While pricing has remained resilient in a market with limited supply and few distressed sellers, the economic uncertainty is deterring prospective home movers.”
Victoria Scholar, the head of investment at the share trading website Interactive Investor, said: “Expensive mortgages, wider cost-of-living pressures and a general backdrop of macroeconomic unease with sluggish growth and increasing slack in the labour market are taking their toll on house prices, which are expected to feel further pain as the year progresses.”
While the slowdown is expected to affect builders’ profits, the drop in asking prices comes in the context of decades of rises which have put home ownership out of reach for many first-time buyers. The 1.9% drop in asking prices – equivalent to a £7,012 price cut – left the average asking price on Rightmove’s platform at £364,895, the company said. Even after the drop, average prices were £59,000 higher than in August 2019, a 19% increase.
Government data showed that the average UK house price was £288,000 in June, £5,000 higher than 12 months ago, albeit £5,000 below the recent record in November 2022.
Tim Bannister, who oversees Rightmove’s data, said: “There is no glut of properties for sale, with the number of available properties still lower than at this time in 2019 and homes still selling more quickly, with the average time to find a buyer now 55 days compared with 61 days in 2019.
“The lower level of agreed sales compared with this time in 2019 indicates the affordability challenges that many buyers currently face.”
Lucy Letby inquiry: Will ministers be forced to hand chair statutory powers?
(And the reasons why it may be reluctant to do so).
Ministers are under mounting pressure to grant the inquiry into serial killer nurse Lucy Letby legal powers following fears that it lacks the “teeth” needed to unearth potential failings.
Archie Mitchell www.independent.co.uk
The 33-year-old was found guilty on Friday of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder six others between June 2015 and June 2016 in the hospital where she worked.
The murders, which Letby carried out during her shifts on the neonatal ward at the Countess of Chester Hospital, will be subject to an independent inquiry, health secretary Steve Barclay has announced.
Mr Barclay said the probe would “ensure mothers and their partners rightly have faith in our healthcare system”.
But in order to ensure that the families of Letby’s victims receive justice, and that similar incidents do not occur in future, critics say it must be given statutory powers.
Here, The Independent looks at the difference it could make, and why the inquiry has been set up in the way it has.
What are public inquiries for?
Ministers establish public inquiries into events of major public concern or controversial policy issues.
They typically assess what happened, why it happened, who is to blame, and what can be done to ensure that it doesn’t happen again.
Previous examples include the ongoing inquiry into the government’s handling of the Covid pandemic, and the Bloody Sunday Inquiry, which looked at the mass shooting of Catholic demonstrators in Derry by British paratroopers in 1972.
What is a non-statutory inquiry?
Non-statutory inquiries lack the power to take evidence under oath that statutory ones have.
They also offer more flexibility over how they are run, which can make it easier to hear sensitive evidence in private where it is deemed necessary.
Mr Barclay has said that the families of Letby’s victims will be able to have their voices heard in shaping the scope of the inquiry.
But what do critics say?
Such an inquiry lacks the power to compel witnesses to produce evidence or give evidence under oath, leading critics to claim it is “not good enough”.
Lawyers representing the families of two of Letby’s victims say the inquiry will be forced to “rely on the goodwill of those involved”.
In a joint statement, Richard Scorer and Yvonne Agnew, of law firm Slater and Gordon, said: “The failings here are very serious and an inquiry needs to have a statutory basis to have real teeth.”
The lack of statutory powers has raised fears that key pieces of evidence will be missed – for instance, those that could provide the answer to how Letby was able to continue working in the hospital’s neonatal unit for more than a year after concerns about her conduct were first raised.
Why has the government chosen to hold a non-statutory inquiry?
One legal expert told The Independent that a statutory inquiry could “open up a can of worms” in exposing wider failings in the NHS – particularly in relation to allegations that bosses prioritised reputational damage over the concerns of hospital staff.
They said a “more rigorous” statutory public inquiry raised the risk of negative publicity for the government in the run-up to a general election, which is expected to be held next year.
But the government said a non-statutory inquiry was chosen in order to allow it to focus on “lessons that can be learned quickly”.
Will ministers change their minds?
The health secretary has so far refused to listen to calls from families, doctors and MPs to give the inquiry statutory powers, insisting that the current set-up will ensure that victims’ parents and families get the answers they need.
But Emma Norris, the Institute for Government think tank’s expert on public inquiries, said there was a “reasonable chance” that Mr Barclay will be forced to upgrade the inquiry to a statutory one.
She told The Independent that the case had similarities with the government’s inquiry into serial killer Harold Shipman, which was set up as a non-statutory inquiry but was changed following a judicial review.
When will the inquiry begin?
The Department of Health and Social Care said on Friday that it will appoint a chair and publish the inquiry’s proposed terms of reference “in due course”.
“Small Boats”, then the “NHS”. Does “Crime” lead this week’s grid?
Is Alison Hernandez on stand-by and on side?
Can she deliver a police force that will follow up “all reasonable lines of enquiry” to solve crimes that are reported to them? – Owl
Braverman set to launch crime blitz in reset after Cabinet infighting over small boats
Hugo Gye inews.co.uk
Suella Braverman is preparing to launch a crime crackdown in a drive to get the Home Office back on track after an eruption of damaging infighting.
The Home Secretary is set to announce that police must follow up “all reasonable lines of enquiry” to solve crimes that are reported to them.
The move, which will particularly cover offences such as the theft of cars and mobile phones which often go unpunished, comes after a period of turbulence in the Home Office.
An attempt to promote the Government’s policy on preventing asylum seekers from crossing the English Channel in dangerous small boats ended in farce earlier this month when dozens of migrants had to be evacuated from a barge where they were staying after legionella was discovered on board days after their arrival.
There are widespread reports of disagreements between Ms Braverman, department officials, and the immigration minister Robert Jenrick who is a close ally of Rishi Sunak.
Growing numbers of Conservative MPs want the Home Secretary to be fired in a reshuffle expected in the coming weeks, although her allies insist she remains indispensable as a leading figure from the right of the party within the Cabinet.
The Home Office is poised to issue new guidance to police which will specify that they are expected to investigate every crime after concerns that officers are ignoring potential evidence such as mobile phone tracking data. In London, as many as 98 per cent of phone thefts go unsolved.
Ms Braverman said in comments first reported by the Sunday Telegraph: “All victims of theft deserve more from the police and justice system than simply a crime number, and they should expect all reasonable lines of enquiry should be followed up.”
A senior Home Office source told i that the new policy was made possible by an increase in the overall number of officers and a reduction in other obligations such as responding to calls of mental health emergencies. The source said: “Now that we have record levels of police we have the resources to do this, and we’ve also lessened the burden of bureaucracy and red tape on officers.”
Government insiders are understood to be concerned about dysfunction in the department amid a failure to cut the number small boats arrivals significantly. “The whole thing resembles a circular firing squad,” a minister told the Sunday Times.
And Tory MPs have reacted with anger to claims that Home Office officials are told not to interrogate asylum seekers over sensitive details of their past, or to turn down their claim if they are found to have lied.