Report finds the impact of a new development proposed for an East Devon village ‘so harmful’ it would ‘significantly’ outweigh its benefits

Background

The 2013 Tory administration set East Devon an eighteen year target to build a minimum of 950 houses/year (17,100 in total by 2031).

This binding target (Poisoned Chalice) is what the Lib Dem, Independent and Green Coalition inherited, and they are lumbered with it. Worse, under government rules, they have to ensure a five year rolling plan to supply these houses.

Because of the impact of Covid on house building, EDDC currently can only demonstrate that it can bring forward development sites to provide 4.68  years worth (including a 5% buffer) of development. 

Under government rules, which keep changing, unless a local authority can show a 5 year supply, a presumption of development will apply to all development irrespective of neighbourhood plans, built-up area boundaries, green fields etc. – Owl

The impact of a new development proposed for East Devon has been deemed ‘so harmful’ to the area it would ‘significantly’ outweigh its benefits, a new report has found.  

Local Democracy Reporter eastdevonnews.co.uk

Plans to build houses on a field just outside a village near Ottery St Mary received just one letter of support – and that turned out to be a sarcastic note of ‘approval’ from an objector, writes local democracy reporter Guy Henderson.

Now East Devon District Council (EDDC) has underlined its opposition to the plan and has called for an inquiry into the scheme to be held in public.

Members of the council’s planning committee met last Friday (July 28) to consider the proposal for 23 homes off Oak Road at West Hill. They heard that because the council had not ruled on the application by a legal deadline, it would have to be decided by a planning inspector at an appeal.

However, they decided to send a clear message to the inspector that the Morrish Homes scheme should not be allowed, and that any inquiry should be heard in public rather than being decided in private by the inspector reading written submissions.

Planning officers said any future residents wouldn’t find it easy to access local facilities and services, meaning the development would be ‘car-dependent’. A number of ‘significant protected trees’ would also be at risk.

The applicants say that because the site will be expensive to develop, the amount of affordable housing they could provide would be diminished. Officers disagreed.

Their report summed up: “Taking all of the evidence into account, the adverse impacts of the proposed development are so harmful as to significantly and demonstrably outweigh its benefits.”

But members were warned that because the district can’t meet its government targets for a five-year supply of land for housing, it is vulnerable on housing developments.

Neighbours Richard Green and Peter Shrubsole spoke against the proposal, with Mr Shrubsole saying: “Not a single supportive submission has been made, with the exception of one very sarcastic one which was, in fact, an objection.”

Villager Robert George said the development was not sustainable, and Alan Cook described it as ‘dense and unsympathetic’.

West Hill Parish Council chair Alison Carr said local schools and GP surgeries were already over-stretched, and Cllr Jessica Bailey (Independent, West Hill and Aylesbeare) said there were ‘very compelling grounds’ to throw out the plans.

Cllr Brian Bailey (Con, Exmouth Littleham) told the committee: “There are so many things that this scheme goes against, and there is no provision for affordable homes.

“As far as I am concerned it is not going to fly at all.”

The committee agreed unanimously to tell the secretary of state that the council would have refused the application, and to urge the planning inspector to decide the issue at an informal hearing rather than through written submissions.

Summer crackdown on anti-social behaviour

Police are cracking down on anti-social behaviour and other offences in East and Mid Devon.

It’s part of what they call Operation Loki, which a number of councils across the county have lauded as a positive step to make their areas safer or more attractive to residents and visitors.

Radio Exe News www.radioexe.co.uk

The latest campaign started last week in Seaton, Sidmouth, Honiton and Axminster. It will continue in Tiverton, Cullompton, Crediton and Exmouth later this month.

People will see officers on foot patrols, as well as in marked police vehicles during the period of intensification. They will focus on locations where ASB is a problem or issues have been reported to them.

Inspector Phil Gray, inspector for rural East Devon, said: “Over the course of the last few days we were joined by officers from the Devon & Cornwall Police Professional Development Unit, members of the Special Constabulary, colleagues from Roads Policing and the Prevent and Detect Team. We also worked with Youth Intervention Officers, homeless outreach staff and some members of the council who form part of the Community Safety Partnership.

“We work with partners to make sure that we reach those people in vulnerable groups who may need extra support. We like to engage with as many people as possible of all ages and get feedback on how we can help with any local concerns or priorities. We want to keep our communities safe, disrupt incidents of Anti Social Behaviour and make arrests where appropriate. If you see the officers out and about please come and say hello and let us know how we can help you.”

In Seaton, several vehicles were checked with the help of automatic number plate recognition systems and three people were also stopped and dealt with for drugs possession. 

On Friday, police were joined by representatives from Sidmouth Town Council, Gateway Homelessness Action Group, East Devon District Council Community Safety Partnership and other departments including roads policing.

Two vehicles were seized for having no tax, seven motorists were reported for vehicle and document defects and there were several stops for suspected driving whilst under the influence of alcohol or drugs resulting in two arrests. Foot patrols took place in areas of anti-social behaviour and at least 30 motorists were detected for speeding through Sidford.

In Honiton, a specialist undercover team arrested someone for driving whilst being unfit through drugs, having no insurance and being in possession of a class B drug. Enquiries found they were also a disqualified driver.

The local neighbourhood police team stopped a motorist for having no insurance and no driving licence and another vehicle was seized as that motorist also had no driving licence. Two people were searched under the Misuse of Drugs Act and a vulnerable person was located and escorted home with the appropriate referrals to support agencies being made.

Police in Axminster searched a motorist and their vehicle which led to cocaine, cannabis, money and phones being seized. An arrest was made for drug driving, possession with intent and possession of an offensive weapon. The car was seized. A separate vehicle was seized after it was discovered the driver had an expired driving licence.

Teetotal PM heckled as he pulls a pint

How desperate to win votes do you have to be to be seen pulling a pint when you don’t even drink the stuff?

Will he be vaping next?

And as the heckler points out, forget the spin behind this stunt, overall alcohol duties are going UP – Owl

Why are Rishi’s trousers so short?

Is he trying to be trendy, albeit 20 years too late?

Is it, as some have suggested, an attempt by a diminutive man to create an illusion of height on the world stage? 

Or is the wealthiest UK prime minister in history wearing children’s sizes to avoid paying VAT?

Just asking. – Owl

[Sunak comes up short as he tries to stay on-trend www.thetimes.co.uk]

Councillors miffed as police scrap training

No resources for councillors’ police training

Despite Alison Hernandez’s bumper 6% hike in the police slice of your council tax. – Owl

Torridge councillors have got the hump with the police over their refusal to give them training sessions to help tackle crime.

Alison Stephenson, local democracy reporter www.radioexe.co.uk

Members of the council’s external overview and scrutiny committee said police are always asking for their support, but not willing to give them bite-sized training sessions  – a move which has left them feeling miffed.

Meeting chair Cheryl Cottle-Hunkin (Lib Dem, Shebbear and Langtree) said when she was a new councillor four years ago she went on a police workshop which was available to all councillors and gave them a snap shot of how police build intelligence, such recognising the signs of ‘county lines’ drugs operations.

“They are saying now they don’t have the resources to put together a programme,” she said. “They want our support but when we request it of them, they say they don’t have the capacity to provide it.

“The police talk about connecting communities and say all the right things but if there is nothing in place to coordinate it’s not going to work.”

Vice chair Cllr Annie Brenton (Lab, Bideford West) said at the first meeting of the new council following the elections, a police officer assured councillors that police wanted to support them and encourage them to get involved.

“It’s a two-way street actually. If they want us to support them and encourage our community to support them then they have to support us,” said Cllr Brenton.

She said the programme was already available, and it was a poor excuse not to be able to provide it to the rest of the council.

“To not let us sit in on this scheme and get this bite-sized information is ludicrous,” she said: “Our community is concerned about policing in our area. We need to go back to the police on this.”

Pressure will be put on police officers at the community safety partnership meeting in the autumn.

Untreated sewage spilled into protected areas for 300,000 hours

Untreated sewage was discharged from storm overflow pipes into protected areas across England and Wales for more than 300,000 hours last year, research has found.

Kieran Gair www.thetimes.co.uk

Untreated wastewater was released within 50 metres of a protected nature site more than 1,000 times, according to data obtained by Greenpeace.

The worst-affected areas included the Solent and Dorset coast, a large special protected area (SPA) spanning the West Sussex, Isle of Wight and Dorset coasts, with 14,174 hours of sewage spills last year. Bognor Regis, a coastal town popular during the holiday season, falls within a special area of conservation (SAC) and was given a “poor” bathing status this year. Human waste was identified as the main cause of pollution.

The River Derwent and Bassenthwaite Lake, a conservation area encompassing parts of the Lake District, was one of the worst-hit areas, receiving more than 6,600 hours of sewage. It is the constituency of the Tory MP Trudy Harrison, the minister for natural environment and land use.

Pembrokeshire Marine SAC, one of the largest marine conservation areas in the UK, suffered 6,997 hours of sewage spills last year. Waste spilled into the River Avon SAC, which runs from Bristol to Bath, for 6,960 hours last year. People have reported getting seriously ill from swimming in the River Avon.

Plymouth Sounds and Estuary SAC, which straddles the borders of Devon and Cornwall, is another popular holiday destination that was heavily hit with sewage discharges, receiving 11,436 hours last year. This year, the utility company South West Water was fined £2.1 million for incidents dating back to 2016, including one discharge from Torpoint sewage treatment works into Plymouth Sounds.

The data found that rivers, lakes and marine areas “already in danger” received more than 200,000 hours of sewage.

A separate analysis of Environment Agency data by the Liberal Democrats found that there were 1,504 sewage dumps last year on “blue flag” beaches — which are meant to have the highest water quality — lasting 8,497 hours.

Much of Britain’s sewer network built before 1960 is designed to handle surface water from rainfall and sewage together, meaning that systems can be overwhelmed during downpours and are prone to overflowing.

The industry estimates that to fix the problem will require £56 billion of investment. Under present plans, sewage releases will be ended by 2050. McMahon has introduced a private member’s bill to bring this forward to 2030, introducing legally binding targets for water firms.

The water sector recently apologised for sewage spills from storm overflows and promised to spend £10 billion this decade to tackle them.

The Times Clean it Up campaign has urged regulators to take stronger action against polluters, and to consider the idea floated by Emma Howard Boyd, a former Environment Agency chairwoman, of jail sentences for water company chiefs behind the worst incidents.

Man bought private jet with borrowed council money

Plus a Bugatti and yacht. www.bbc.co.uk

So the Tories abolished the Audit Commission in 2015 – more importantly WHY? 

Turned out well hasn’t it… how many Tory councils are now effectively bankrupt having treated ratepayers money like a spin of the roulette wheel with hugely speculative investments. – Owl

Sunak on ‘Wrong Side Of History’

Former Tory Minister Savages PM over North Sea Oil Plan. He added:

also on “wrong side of a future economy” based on renewables;

and on “wrong side of modern voters, who will vote with their feet at the next general election for parties that protect, and not threaten, our environment”.

Three strikes and you’re out? – Owl

Kevin Schofield www.huffingtonpost.co.uk 

A former Tory minister has condemned Rishi Sunak’s decision to give the green light to more oil and gas drilling in the North Sea.

Chris Skidmore, who used to be the government’s net zero tsar, said issuing hundreds of new exploration licences was “the wrong decision at precisely the wrong time”.

Sunak has insisted that new oil and gas extraction from the North Sea is compatible with the UK’s goal of achieving net zero by 2050.

He said it would also make Britain less reliant on having to import energy from abroad.

But in a blistering statement, Skidmore – who served in Boris Johnson’s cabinet as energy minister – said it was a disastrous move for the country as well as the Conservatives.

He said: “It is on the wrong side of a future economy that will be founded on renewable and clean industries and not fossil fuels.

“It is on the wrong side of modern voters, who will vote with their feet at the next general election for parties that protect, and not threaten, our environment.

″And it is on the wrong side of history, that will not look favourably on the decision taken today.”

Skidmore, who is standing down at the next election, also said it was wrong that the announcement was made whole parliament is in recess, denying MPs the chance to scrutinise it in the Commons.

Speaking in Aberdeenshire, where he also announced plans for a new carbon capture scheme, Sunak defended the move despite the mounting criticism from environmental campaigners.

He said: “It’s really important for everybody to recognise that even in 2050 when we are at net zero, it is forecast that around a quarter of our energy needs will still come from oil and gas.

“What is important is that we get that oil and gas in the best possible way and that means getting it from here at home – better for our energy security, better for jobs but also better for the climate because if we’re going to need it, it’s far better to have it here at home rather than from halfway round the world.”

Dartmoor wild camping to resume after appeal win

The public can ‘wild camp’ in Dartmoor again without landowners’ permission after the National Park Authority won their appeal case.

By Esme Stallard www.bbc.co.uk

The right to do so had been allowed under a decades-old local law until January this year, when it was challenged by a local landowner.

It will now return as the only place in England where wild camping is allowed without permission.

Open Spaces Society, which also brought the appeal said it “was delighted”.

At the centre of this case was whether wild camping can be considered open-air recreation, which is allowed in the Park under the Dartmoor Commons Act 1985.

Local landowners, Alexander Darwall, a hedge fund manager, and his wife Diana – who have owned a 4,000 acre (16-km sq) estate in southern Dartmoor since 2013 – argued that it did not and wanted to revoke permission to their land for camping.

Their original High Court challenge and victory in January brought thousands of people out in protest and sparked a nationwide debate on public access in the English countryside.

The National Park Authority and the UK’s oldest conservation charity, the Open Spaces Society (OSS) brought an appeal this month against that decision.

In the summary judgement, confirming victory for the charities, Lord Justice Underhill said that wild camping “plainly fell” within the definition of open air recreation as many people “took pleasure in the experience of sleeping in a tent in open country”.

On hearing the result Kate Ashbrook, general secretary of the Open Spaces Society said: “This is an excellent outcome, we are relieved that the judges ruled unanimously and conclusively that open-air recreation includes backpack camping on the commons.”

Kevin Bishop, chief executive for Dartmoor National Park Authority, said: “[the judgement] means people can experience the joys of backpack camping on Dartmoor, provided everyone follows the leave no trace principle.”

A representative for the Darwalls has been approached for comment.

The hearing, which took place two weeks ago included some bizarre exchanges between the lawyers and judges.

Timothy Morshead KC acting for the Darwalls, had argued that sleep cannot be considered to be “recreation” as you are not conscious.

But Sir Geoffrey Vos, one of the judges presiding said there was no difference between a walker or painter who rested on the ground after their activity and fell asleep and a walker that came into the park and erected a tent.

Morshead said that the Darwalls took objection to the erection of tent ‘structures’.

The judges proceeded to asked him where the line should be drawn on erecting structures – would inflatable goalposts from Argos for children to play football be allowed, they asked?

Tim Straker KC acting for the Park and OSS said the practice of wild camping does not involve significant structures like camper vans “which on Dartmoor are directed to designated or registered sites”.

The victory was met with delight by environmental charities on Monday after the verdict broke.

But Guy Shrubsole, co-founder of campaign group Right to Roam, said this was not the end of the fight for land rights.

He called for a new Right to Roam Act for England so that wild camping can be extended beyond Dartmoor.

Breaking: Claire Wright roots for Richard Foord to win Honiton & Sidmouth

Claire Wright, the three-times Independent parliamentary candidate for East Devon, is backing Liberal Democrat MP, Richard Foord, to take the new Honiton & Sidmouth constituency at the next general election.

Philippa Davies www.midweekherald.co.uk

Running against Conservative candidates, Claire achieved second place in the last three general elections, gaining almost 26,000 votes and over 40 per cent of the vote in December 2019.

She has now revealed that she has been talking with Richard over the last few months about how she can best support his campaign to win the newly formed constituency, which includes Claire’s home town of Ottery St Mary.

Richard spectacularly won the Tiverton and Honiton seat last year in a shock 6,144 majority by-election result, after disgraced Conservative MP, Neil Parish was forced to stand aside. It had previously been a safe Conservative seat.

Claire said: “I remain as fascinated with politics as ever and have been following Richard’s work since his election. What I have observed over the past year is a dedicated, hard-working, thoroughly decent man who cares very much about his constituents, so I contacted him to pledge my support.

“Richard’s priorities are very similar to my own, which were established after surveying hundreds of people and listening to thousands of others during my role as a county councillor for many years.

“Richard has already demonstrated that he is a committed champion for our precious NHS, which has been eviscerated after years of deliberate neglect by a government that doesn’t appear to believe in the welfare state.

“He also cares very much about, and is active on, environmental issues, including working to prevent sewage in our rivers and coastal waters and most recently speaking at a parliamentary debate to save our migratory birds from extinction, following the submission of a petition signed by over 100,000 people.

“Richard argued in favour of creating a new ‘swift brick’ policy – a simple and cheap option to help the birds nest, that ministers (and other local Conservative MPs) have disgracefully dismissed.

“He has also demonstrated that he cares very much about people who are desperately struggling in society, speaking out on local decisions to remove funding from the most vulnerable people, including those who are homeless.

“This is the man I want to be my MP.”

“Unfortunately, the government and its local representatives are attempting to hoodwink us by claiming that they will fix the very things that they have so badly and knowingly broken, while blaming other events and people for what has gone wrong.

“I really hope that local people will see through the hackneyed lines and lies and turn their backs on this endless deceit, instead supporting a conscientious and hard-working man, who cares far more about his constituents than he ever would about the slippery career pole and desire to divide and rule, that appears to motivate other local parliamentary representatives.

“By-elections are very different beasts from general elections and last year Richard was supported by thousands of Liberal Democrat activists from across the country. This time, he will need the support of a large number of local people to win the seat.”

Anyone interested in helping the campaign to get Richard elected is asked to contact Niamh Purvis at organiser.tivhonlibdems@gmail.com

Planning applications validated by EDDC in week beginning 17 July

40,000 shotguns in Devon! Highest in the country.

Yet Owl still flies!

The licence fee to keep a shotgun in Devon and Cornwall is to go up – although it hasn’t been agreed to what level, or when.

Nearly two years after the tragic shootings in Plymouth, the rise was endorsed by members of the region’s police and crime panel as they were told of measures to reduce the risk to the public.

Alison Stephenson, local democracy reporter www.radioexe.co.uk

Five people in Keyham died at the hands of gunman Jake Davison in August 2021, and earlier this year significant failings were found in the police’s handling of the initial shotgun licence given to him.

Speaking to the police and crime panel in Plymouth, police and crime commissioner Alison Hernandez, whose job it is to hold the chief constable to account, said she was assured that appropriate steps were being taken to respond to risk since the shootings.

Ms Hernandez said another £500,000 on top of £750,000 of additional funds had been invested in the force’s firearms and explosives licensing team to train offices in handling licence applications. Staff numbers have also  increased from 44 to 99.

An alliance with Dorset Police has also been scrapped so the force can concentrate on the issues it faces.

Devon and Cornwall Police manages the highest volume of firearms certificates and licences in the country – 40,000. It is claimed this is because of the rural and agricultural nature of the region.

Members of the panel raised concerns over the cost of processing licence applications and pleaded for temporary licences to be scrapped to save money.

“Temporary licences should be stopped and people should have their guns confiscated until they have the appropriate licence,” said Cllr Mandy Ewings (Ind, Tavistock South West).

Cllr Laura Wright (Lab, St Thomas, Exeter) said administrators were vital when it came to tightening up procedures but, at under £15 an hour, they were not coming into the service. More money needed to be made from the licences to pay for the cost of issuing them, she said.

“I pay a licence fee to watch BBC which is £159 a year and I’m happy to pay this but is it right that someone can own a potentially lethal instrument for £79?”

Miss Hernandez said the £79 was not just for one year but for five years: “It’s absolutely out of kilter with public feeling. It cannot be justified that’s it only that over a five year period. For people who don’t use guns in their day to day lives, it doesn’t feel right anyway, and gun users accept it’s got to change. The licence cost has not been reviewed since 2012.”

She said that she would support a fee which was rational but was not supporting “full cost recovery” which drove inefficiencies and put the burden on the customer.

His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary said that although Devon and Cornwall had made significant progress, concerns remained over a backlog in processing licence applications and the improper use of temporary permits.

Tory support collapse leaving rural voters ‘politically homeless’

Rural voters are becoming increasingly “politically homeless”, ministers have been warned, as polling suggests that support for the Conservatives in the countryside has rapidly declined.

Aubrey Allegretti www.theguardian.com

Labour is the main beneficiary but must “up its game” to see the change translate into votes at the next general election, said Jonathan Roberts, the director of external affairs at the Country Land and Business Association (CLA).

Fears about a drop-off in support across traditionally Tory-leaning rural areas have been compounded by a string of byelection losses, most recently in Selby and Ainsty, the North Yorkshire seat in which Labour overturned a mammoth Conservative majority.

Concerns that rural communities have been neglected by Westminster stretch back much further and are the fault of governments of all colours, argued Roberts.

“It’s very difficult for rural people to fully understand who is championing way of life,” he said. “There hasn’t been a robust and ambitious plan to grow the rural economy, and create good jobs and strengthen those communities and allow rural businesses to grow.”

Polling conducted by Survation found that support for the Conservatives among voters in the 100 most rural constituencies had dropped by 18 points to 41% compared with the 2019 general election. The party narrowly stayed out in front of Labour, whose support rose by 16 points to 35%. The Liberal Democrats fell by three points to sit on 13%.

The cost of living, a lack of growth and building more homes were among the most pressing issues highlighted by those surveyed.

Too often, Roberts said, the countryside is viewed “a place for people to go and to visit, rather than a fundamentally important part of our society and economy”.

The Lib Dems have performed well at byelections in rural seats such as Tiverton and Honiton, Somerton and Frome, and North Shropshire, but Roberts argued that at a general election voters are “less likely to cast their vote as a protest and looking at more seriously who is likely to form the next government”.

The CLA, which represents 28,000 rural businesses across England and Wales, fears that the divide between cities and the countryside has been widening. If closed, the productivity gap in the rural economy could raise the economic output of England alone by £43bn, according to the group.

A 28-page strategy for “unleashing rural opportunity” was published by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in June.

Roberts acknowledged that the government had shown “some signs of responding” to the CLA’s concerns. But he cautioned: “There’s a question as to whether that’s going to be a little bit too late.”

A more longstanding failure by multiple governments to unlock the potential of the rural economy “has led to a political homelessness of many people in rural areas”, he said.

Jim McMahon, the shadow environment secretary, is among those Labour sources have suggested could be moved in a reshuffle. Roberts also hinted at dissatisfaction with his performance, saying that support for Labour among rural voters in the polls “belies the effort that they’re making to engage with rural communities”.

He added: “I think where the Labour party does need to up its game is on engagement with rural communities.”

Environmental groups accuse Rishi Sunak of playing ‘political football’ with the climate crisis

Leading environmental groups have accused the Government of using the climate as a “political football”, as they warned they will “not stand by” if Rishi Sunak waters down the UK’s green commitments.

Poppy Wood inews.co.uk 

The National Trust, the Woodland Trust, Greenpeace and the RSPCA are among a handful of organisations who have written to Mr Sunak voicing their alarm that the Prime Minister appears to be poised to downgrade the Government’s green policies.

They demanded an urgent meeting with the Prime Minister to discuss the climate crisis, as they called for “public reassurances” on his plans to take action.

It comes as Mr Sunak has signalled he could delay or even abandon green policies that impose a direct cost on consumers, as the Conservative party looks to create a clear dividing line with Labour ahead of the next general election.

The Prime Minister has hinted he will look again at measures that will carry additional expense to consumers, with sources insisting that protecting households from rising costs is his number one priority.

The move follows the Tories’ surprise win in last week’s by-election in Uxbridge, with support for Labour dented by plans to expand London’s ultra-low emission zone (Ulez) expansion, due to come into force next month.

It has prompted a rethink of the Government’s green policies, with the Prime Minister saying earlier this week that the drive to reach the UK’s net zero targets should not “unnecessarily give people more hassle and more costs in their lives”.

Downing Street also confirmed that the Government will “continually examine and scrutinise” measures including a ban on new petrol and diesel cars by 2030, phasing out gas boilers by 2035, energy efficiency targets for private rented homes and low-traffic neighbourhoods.

But environmental groups said it was “with deep alarm that we have read reports over the last few weeks of your government considering watering down its commitments on almost every front of environmental policy”.

“We will not stand by whilst politicians use the environment as a political football,” they wrote.

“It is courage and leadership that we need now. In the past, we have mobilised many of our members collectively with extraordinary results, and our resolve to stand firm now against any and all attacks on this critical policy agenda remains absolute.”

The groups, which claim to represent more than 20m people in total, warned Mr Sunak that he does not have a “public mandate” for delaying the UK’s climate targets.

They also said the prospect of abandoning climate targets was “baffling” considering the economic benefits that green commitments will deliver.

Hilary McGrady, director general of the National Trust, told i: “The climate and nature crises can’t be a matter for negotiation – they demand our urgent, unswerving attention. Political differences must be set aside if we are to safeguard our economy and food supply, and secure jobs, homes and health for future generations. Ambivalence sends all the wrong signals to the market.”

Ms McGrady warned that wavering on the climate agenda could cost both parties at the ballot box.

“A general election is coming and poll after poll shows that voters are resolute in their commitment to the environment. Instead of being gradually erased, robust green policies should be inked into the manifestos of every political party hoping to form a future government,” she said.

“Only a few years ago, UK leaders set world-leading targets and promised the public good green jobs, cleaner air and seas, and a restored natural environment. Now is the time to double down on those commitments.”

Darren Moorcroft, chief executive of the Woodland Trust, said it was “incumbent” on environmental groups to express their concerns as political parties set out their stall ahead of the next general election, expected in late 2024.

“We will make our voices heard with regard to how people should view any political party as it runs into the general election on what it is doing for the environment,” he told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme.

“So instead of backtracking on environmental policies, we believe every political party that’s serious about winning should be setting out plans to get those good green jobs, to get cleaner air and seas to restore our natural environment.”

Labour also faces a reckoning over its green policies, after leader Sir Keir Starmer laid the blame for the party’s failure to take Boris Johnson’s old seat in Uxbridge on the London mayor’s Ulez policy.

At Labour’s National Policy Forum (NPF) in Nottingham day after the by-election, Sir Keir told his party: “We are doing something very wrong if policies put forward by the Labour party end up on each and every Tory leaflet.”

However, party figures have insisted Labour is still committed to its green policies, and sees it as an opportunity to create a clear ideological division between the Conservatives at the next ballot box.

A senior Labour source told i earlier this week that the clean energy target – one of Sir Keir’s five missions – “absolutely” remained in place and that there was no contradiction between pursuing policies to tackle climate change and reducing the cost of living for people.

“There is no circle to square. All our policies are about reducing bills, providing energy security and creating jobs,” they said. “So everything we’re proposing helps with the cost of living.”

Sewage puts a quarter of people off swimming in the sea

“No one should have to go for a swim or build a sandcastle next to raw sewage. This Conservative government needs to stop letting water companies off the hook and finally ban these disgusting sewage discharges and defend our tourism sector.” – Tim Farron

Around a quarter of UK sea swimmers are being put off their hobby because of the levels of sewage, according to a new poll.

Matt Drake www.independent.co.uk

Just over 30 per cent of UK adults said they go sea swimming during the summer, and of these, 23 per cent said they will not do so this year because of sewage dumping by water companies.

The poll, carried out by Savanta with 2,272 UK adults between July 21 and 23, found 43 per cent of regular beachgoers said they were less likely to visit the British seaside this summer because of the sewage discharges.

Liberal Democrat environment spokesperson Tim Farron said: “Sewage dumping by water companies is ruining the British beach holiday.

“Coastal communities are at the mercy of water companies who unapologetically discharge raw sewage into popular swimming spots.

“If this continues, tourists will turn away from British beach holidays, leaving small businesses and local tourism to suffer from their mess.

“No one should have to go for a swim or build a sandcastle next to raw sewage. This Conservative government needs to stop letting water companies off the hook and finally ban these disgusting sewage discharges and defend our tourism sector.”

An analysis by the party earlier this year showed there were 1,504 sewage discharges in 2022 on beaches with a blue flag rating – a standard that is supposed to signify that a beach is free from such pollution.

They want sewage dumps on blue flag beaches to be banned and have warned that tourists may decide not to visit beaches at all, which would deprive coastal communities of revenue.

The government has recently said it will allow the Environment Agency (EA) to impose unlimited fines on water companies that pollute unnecessarily.

Current penalties are capped at £250,000, making it cheaper to pay than to fix the pollution issue, environment secretary Therese Coffey told MPs earlier this month.

Thames Water’s interim chief executive, Cathryn Ross, recently described many of her company’s pipes as “ageing assets” that should have been replaced.

The utility firm gathered a £14bn debt pile, with many critics blaming shareholders for taking too much money out of the company over the previous 30 years without investing enough in infrastructure.

Many other water companies have faced similar condemnation. They are only supposed to release raw sewage after heavy rain to stop sewage from backing up the system and flooding homes and businesses, with the most recent data showing they had collectively dumped sewage 372,533 times in 2022.

A Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) spokesperson said: “Banning discharges overnight without any plan to fix storm overflows is reckless and would see sewage backing up into people’s homes and the street.

“The secretary of state demanded action plans on every storm overflow in the country and our Storm Overflow Discharge Reduction Plan requires water companies to spend £56bn to eliminate the harm from storm overflows – the largest infrastructure investment in water company history.”

An online interactive map of sewage discharges, using information taken from water companies, showed on Friday afternoon dozens of live pollution alerts along the English and Welsh coasts.

A Water UK spokesperson said: “Just one out of every 10 beaches achieved an excellent water standard in the 1990s.

“Thanks to water company investment, that has increased to seven in 10 beaches today. The majority of remaining pollution comes from other sources.

“Nevertheless, we recognise that more should have been done sooner to tackle the harm to our seas caused by sewage overflows. We have listened and have an unprecedented plan to start to put it right.

“Over the next seven years, water and sewerage companies plan to spend £10bn – a tripling on current levels of investment – in the biggest transformation of our sewers since the Victorian era.

“As part of this, bathing waters will be prioritised and among the first to receive funding.”

By-election victories for Labour in Plymouth

Labour wins city by-elections (One gain from Conservatives, one seat held)

Labour is celebrating after by-election victories in the Plymouth City Council wards of Plymstock Dunstone and St Peter and the Waterfront.

Alison Stephenson, local democracy reporter www.radioexe.co.uk

Stefan Krizanac gained Plymstock Dunstone from the Conservatives, winning 1,072 of the votes with Tory candidate Julie Hunt in second place with 919.

The seat had been held by political veteran Vivian Pengelly, a former leader of the council, who had represented the ward for the Conservatives since Plymouth became a unitary authority in 1997. She died last month after a battle with cancer.

Labour held St Peter and the Waterfront following the resignation of Sue McDonald, with seasoned politician Alison Raynsford winning a conclusive victory. She gained 1,126 votes, leaving Conservative Ian Fleming way behind with 488.

Mrs Raynsford, (nee Seabeck), was Labour MP for Plymouth Devonport from 2005 to 2010 and for Plymouth Moor View from 2010 to 2015.

Labour, which controls Plymouth City Council, now has 33 councillors.

Following the result in the early hours of Friday morning, Plymouth City Council leader Tudor Evans (Lab, Ham) Tweeted: “What a pair of ceiling smashers. Plymouth Labour now have 33 councillors, the highest we’ve had this century, thanks to a brilliant hold in St Peter by

Alison Raynsford and a stunning gain off the Tories by Stefan Krizanac in Dunstone.”

Devon village becomes extension of Exeter as population soars – Broadclyst Neighbourhood Plan

Broadclyst is the biggest parish and the fastest growing parish in East Devon. And it has been growing whether locals liked it or not.

Daniel Clark www.devonlive.com 

The population is estimated to have increased by two thirds over the past ten years. And that growth isn’t going to stop, with around 4,000 more homes set to be built in Westclyst and Tithebarn near its borders.

Historically, the main settlement and largest population was in Broadclyst Village, with smaller settlements at Westclyst, Budlake and Beare along the B3181, Columbjohn and Westwood in the rural north, and settlements at Broadclyst Station and Blackhorse along on the old A30. In the future, both Westclyst and Tithebarn will be where the largest communities of Broadclyst reside in the near future.

Once a rural haven mainly covered by forest and woodland, the rolling green countryside with wooded hills and broad floodplains, has been replaced by homes as the village becomes an extension of Exeter, where high density and new strategic development is being built. But the parish is trying to at least wrestle back some control.

A Neighbourhood Plan aims to change the community’s position from reactive to proactive, creating a Plan for the parish, as a clear mandate from the community and a proactive way to move forward was created. Local say they have been unable to stop the large strategic development allocated as part of the East Devon Local Plan, and ‘remains at the mercy of the District Council’s decisions who do not necessarily address local needs’.

When they went to the polls on it, 88 per cent of voters were in favour of the Broadclyst Neighbourhood Plan. That plan outlines the vision for Broadclyst, the infrastructure demands they are making, and sites for small scale development to occur within the parish itself. Having been agreed by East Devon District Council’s cabinet, it now become part of the development framework for the region.

THE PARISH

Broadclyst Parish is located around 3km (1.5miles) to the north east of Exeter City Centre. The western boundary lies next Pinhoe while the south-eastern boundary abuts to Cranbrook. There is coalescence between the Parish and Exeter, making it difficult to known where one boundary stops and the other starts.

It is the biggest Parish in East Devon and is the biggest growing Parish in East Devon with the population estimated to have increased by two thirds since 2011. It has an attractive rural setting and landscape character with the majority of the land belonging to the Killerton Estate owned and run by the National Trust.

The Killerton Estate houses are clearly identified throughout the Parish due to the recognizable vernacular of cream limewash / cream and brown sepia in combination with red brick, tile and local sandstone.

Historically the main settlement in Broadclyst Parish was Broadclyst Village with smaller settlements at Westclyst Budlake and Beare along the B3181. In the rural area lie the settlements of Columbjohn and Westwood. There are two further settlements at Broadclyst Station and Blackhorse both of which are in the south of the Parish lying close to the old A 30 road to London.

But new major strategic development at East Devon’s West End will continue until completion, to dramatically change the natural environment of this area of the Parish.

These developments bring forward new centres of population and commercial enterprise and the residential developments (projected number of 4,050 new houses) at West Clyst, and Tithebarn will result in a large population influx. Historically the main settlement and largest population was in Broadclyst Village, however both Westclyst and Tithebarn will be where the largest communities of Broadclyst reside in the near future.

Broadclyst Neighbourhood Plan’s Vision Statement says: “Our vision is for the parish to continue to develop and thrive, meeting the changing and diverse needs of our rapidly growing community and its responsibility to tackle national and global issues including climate change, whilst preserving and enhancing our distinctive character and landscape.”

HOUSING

Strategic Development sites, which are already allocated for development and not subject to the Neighbourhood Plan, will bring forward yet more new houses in the Parish. This will see the biggest centre of population move away from Broadclyst Village to the two new settlements of Westclyst and Tithebarn.

At Westclyst, 466 homes at Pinn Court Farm are allocated for development, (with 196 still to be built). There are 956 allocated for Old Farm Park (380 still be to build), 71 at Taveners Field, at 35 at Moonhill Copse, with the Tithebarn Green/Mosshayne site allocated for 1,500 homes (362 still to be built). A further site for 150 homes at the Blackhorse Science Park is also in the planning process.. However, the Neighbourhood Plan allocates several smaller sites within the parish whereby development will be supported.

A site at Blackhorse Gardens in Blackhorse is allocated for homes, land at Broadclyst Station for 24 homes, of which 12 will be affordable houses and five self-build plots, and a children’s play park, and provision of land for a 5m pedestrian and cycle lane for the Cranbrook to Exeter Cycle route.

Land on the edge of Broadclyst Village is allocated for a small scale development to include the following: 16 Houses, while further land allocated to provide a new residential development for the Killerton Estate to 20 homes.

Proposals for new dwellings on allocated sites in the Neighbourhood Plan will be required to provide 50 per cent affordable housing for those with a local connection.

ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT

Historically, Broadclyst was a rural Parish where the main employment was farming, cider making and businesses supporting the rural population. But the Broadclyst Neighbourhood Plan says that it wants to promote economic development across the Parish and to provide new economic sites and mixed development sites across the Parish and to support specific economic growth and opportunities.

Broadclyst parish is a commuter settlement for Exeter with commuting by car being the predominant travel choice, but this choice has resulted in road capacity and safety issues, and with the construction of 5,000 new houses, the existing road networks are struggling to cope with movements in and out of Exeter and north to south across the Parish.

The Plan provides support for less commuting to work and to provide more employment within the Parish, and for regeneration of sites for business or mixed development and support for new business provision across the Parish, for work hubs and work live units, for food/ drink production businesses, an increase in provision of holiday accommodation and an increase of tourism related businesses.

The Beare Farm site is allocated to be regenerated to provide flexible commercial space for offices, food and/ or drink production, and small light industrial workshops, but proposals for Class B2 and B8 industrial uses will not be supported.

And an area of Elbury Farm is to be regenerated to provide a new mixed development for the Killerton Estate. This would include 10 new dwellings and the conversions of existing brick buildings to provide residential accommodation, a Nature Reserve visitor reception and facilities, and the demolition of agricultural buildings will facilitate a car park for visitors and residents and business units.

TOURISM

Broadclyst has long been regarded as a popular visitor destination attracting around 300,000 visitors a year, with the main attraction being is the Killerton Estate owned by the National Trust.

Ashclyst Forest and Danes Wood, both on the Killerton Estate, are also popular, with Ashclyst is one of the largest woods and a known haven for butterflies, bluebells and birds, with waymarked trails for exploring the wood and surrounding countryside.

But the plan says that visitor accommodation is very limited and does not cater for all sectors of the holiday market, as there are no public camping and caravan sites, no hotels, but there are very few bed and breakfast establishments, Airbnb and selfcatering holiday cottages, with the total accommodation provision is of 8-12 properties within the Parish.

The plans says: “The community recognises the contribution tourism makes to the local economy and is keen to promote an increase in visitor numbers and accommodation particularly outside the main holiday season but reflects that growth must be balanced against protection of the very features and attractions which appeal to visitors.”

Development of sustainable tourism in the Parish will be welcomed and supported throughout the Parish including provision of sustainable tourism promoting visitors’ enjoyment and understanding of zero carbon living, nature recovery, high quality local food and drink and local character, history and custom

New small-scale low-impact high-quality built holiday accommodation will be supported but proposals will need to demonstrate that such uses are in character in landscape, heritage and design terms and do not adversely impact the setting.

New holiday accommodation will be approved subject to the following condition in order to ensure the accommodation remains in holiday use and prevents its use for residential purposes or second home ownership.

Applications for the development of sustainable tourism- related camp sites would be welcomed & supported by the parish, particularly if they are sympathetic to the surrounding countryside, the plan says, adding: “Development proposals for the use of land for small-scale sustainable high-quality touring caravanning and /or camping sites offering a range of styles, types and qualities of camping (to include Yurts & Shepherd Huts, Pods & Lodges) will be supported.”

INFRASTRUCTURE

The Broadclyst Neighbourhood Plan supports the development of a route providing safe and direct access for pedestrians and cyclists between Broadclyst Village and Broadclyst Station in order to facilitate residents of Broadclyst Station to as: Clyst Vale Community College, Broadclyst Primary school, Killerton House, and Ashclyst Forest and to facilitate residents of Broadclyst Village travelling southwards to Cranbrook Town Centre, Cranbrook Train station, Blue Hayes Primary School, and the Cranbrook Education Campus

A bridge over the Waterloo – Exeter Railway line is also supported by the Plan for cyclists and pedestrians to enable people to safely access Broadclyst Station, Cranbrook, Cranbrook railway station from the north and centre of the Parish.

Station Road is the most direct route from Broadclyst village, to Broadclyst Station and onwards to the A30. With the Build out of Cranbrook Blue Hayes phase this will be an even busier route and this route is unsafe for pedestrians and cyclists, the Plan says, adding: “To minimise the impact of the Cranbrook Western traffic and to satisfy the community’s evidenced aspiration, a bridge over the railway is supported.”

Proposals for the development of a bridge to take into consideration that the route to and from the bridge must connect into Cranbrook Western expansion cycle and pedestrian infrastructure, the bridge must be within easy walking distance to Cranbrook Railway Station and the bridge and associated infrastructure must provide safe access for residents.

The benefits of the bridge could include reduced traffic congestion for Broadclyst Parish residents by being able to access rail and bus at Cranbrook without using cars, increased use of road by Broadclyst Station and Cranbrook residents walking and or cycling to Clyst Vale Community College, provision of infrastructure which provides an environmentally friendly, reduced carbon emissions options due to reduced vehicular traffic, healthier lifestyle by encouraging station access by bicycle and on foot, facilitating access to Cranbrook Blue Hayes Country Park for Broadclyst village residents, and to provides a safe non-vehicular option for Cranbrook residents to access Broadclyst village and onwards to Killerton, Silverton Mill and Ashclyst.

Councillor Olly Davey, EDDC’s Portfolio Holder for Strategic Planning, said: “Neighbourhood Plans are an excellent tool for communities to express their vision and aspirations for the future development of their area. They can influence where development takes place, and the type of development they wish to see. They can give communities control over the design and appearance of new developments, and the infrastructure they should contain or support, to ensure that the whole community benefits from them.”

Plan to ‘reinvent Exmouth’ gathers pace as the focus falls on town centre improvements

Derelict and unoccupied buildings in Exmouth could be used as part of a plan to make the town centre more attractive to visitors, workers and residents.

An ambitious scheme to ‘reinvent Exmouth’ is gathering pace, writes local democracy reporter Guy Henderson. eastdevonnews.co.uk 

It follows a ‘placemaking plan’ launched last year, which aims to make the seaside town a better place for residents and visitors.

Its mission, according to East Devon District Council (EDDC) and consultants WSP, is ‘understanding and harnessing the value of Exmouth’s assets through a set of interconnected actions that reimagine and reinvent Exmouth as a cohesive place where people choose to live, work and spend time’.

In practical terms, the new study will explore ways to diversify Exmouth’s economy by looking beyond tourism, and improving the town centre.

Unoccupied and derelict areas will be targeted while maintaining the town’s character to continue to attract visitors.

Workshops will be held to talk to residents and other stakeholders before the proposals move to the next stage.

At a meeting of the council’s ‘placemaking in Exmouth town and seafront group’ this week, project manager Gerry Mills paid tribute to the local team who had secured 56 events for the seafront area as well as the return of a big wheel, which went up last week.

“They are extremely hard-working,” he said. “And they deliver so much more than we actually see.”

Council leader Paul Arnott (Lib Dem, Coly Valley) said it was ‘excellent’ to see the town so busy, but Cllr Olly Davey (Green, Exmouth Town) said the town’s transport links continued to be a problem.

“It would be good if people didn’t all come in their cars and we had a much better connection between the train station and the seafront,” he said.

“The words look great, but it will all be about what it looks like on the ground. Something has got to change, something has got to be built, or un-built, or re-built.”

Exmouth Town Council member Graham Deasy (Lib Dem, Littleham) urged the ‘placemakers’ to examine the long-term impact of climate change. He said: “I would like to see it included from the start, to accommodate what we are seeing and the potential effects on us as a tourist destination.”

Mr Mills replied: “Climate change strategy is at the core of this. It came across loud and clear during the consultation that the environment was considered to be an extremely high priority.”

Second homes and holiday pay neither business or council tax

Dear Owl,

I thought you and your readers may not be aware of this fact about second homes and holiday lets.

Real estate firm Colliers estimate that in Cornwall 12,065 holiday let properties DO NOT PAY either business rates or council tax.

Local authorities miss out on millions as holiday let crackdown backfires (telegraph.co.uk)

You can bet that Devon figures are not far behind!