A campaign to save a Honiton day centre from closure, made the front page of the Midweek Herald this week. EDA followers concerned by priorities in County Council cost-cutting might like to take a minute to sign the associated online petition, and ask friends to do so too. They just need to live in Devon to be able to sign. Honiton Town Councillor Sharon Pavey, who leads the campaign, is one of the signatories of the EDA Charter.
Details here: http://www.sharonpavey.org/save-st-michaels-day-centre
Author Archives: sidmouthsid
Local Government Ombudsman found EDDC at fault
The Chief Executive, Mark Williams, reported to Cabinet earlier this month, that the Ombudsman’s ‘recent finding of fault’ has been addressed by East Devon District Council. See page 109 at this link http://www.eastdevon.gov.uk/cabinet_mins_050314.pdf
“Skypark is blossoming”, says EDDC Leader
‘Exciting times for East Devon’ is the caption to a photo on p 19 of today’s Mid Week Herald. The photo in question shows Cllrs Diviani and Moulding at a ‘Pie and Pud’ presentation on Cranbrook and the East Devon Growth Point. Despite Cllr Diviani’s optimistic comment about Skypark, 4 years into the marketing of the project, there’s not much evident sign of Spring on site (nor at Cranbrook!) : https://eastdevonwatch.org/2014/03/16/skypark-knowle/
EDDC spin papers over the cracks!
See http://sidmouthindependentnews.wordpress.com/2014/03/18/communication-in-politics/
and our own report on the same meeting: https://eastdevonwatch.org/2014/03/14/why-stand-for-election-ask-the-younger-generation/
Planning policy blight reaches PM’s own patch
See Daily Telegraph report referenced here: http://sidmouthindependentnews.wordpress.com/2014/03/18/no-prime-minister-planning-in-his-own-back-yard/
“They’re not making new farmland,” warns NFU.
At a conference organised yesterday by the Devon WI (Our Changing Countryside. What does the future hold?), National Farmers’ Union (NFU) spokesman, Andrew Butler, warned of the dangers of “taking land out of the system, for urbanisation”.The NFU predicts increasing volatility in staples (rice, soya, wheat), leading to issues of food security and permanently rising food prices.There’s a need “to look more at the economic and social asset of farmland”, he said.
So the plan to lose two more East Devon farms to mass development seems seriously misguided. The urbanisation of Pinn Court Farm and Old Park Farm, (near Pinhoe and Westclyst), involves key players in the curiously collapsed East Devon Business Forum. What do EDDC officers think about this planning application? Details at this link:
http://sidmouthindependentnews.wordpress.com/2014/03/17/the-special-development-management-committee-meeting-express-and-echo/
CranBROOK
Will West End overdevelopment add to the flood risk on the River Clyst floodplain? Steven Moore of the Environment Agency recently assured EDA member, Graham Cooper, that flood risk measures for the Intermodal and Skypark have been fully in place for a number of years. He explained that the country park at the Intermodal and Cranbrook had lagoons in place and there were sub surface water retention tanks at Skypark.
The above photograph taken earlier this month, before any substantial development has taken place, appears to give other signals, as did the EA severe flood warnings in place for the area on 4th March, when the main A3052 was also flooded.
Skypark/ Knowle.
Photos above supplied for those who are not familiar with the two sites. EDDC plans to relocate its HQ from the tranquillity and parkland of Knowle, Sidmouth,just a short walk away from town centre shops. The present buildings will be demolished to pay for newbuild offices, possibly at the vast new fledgling business park (recently declared as the Cabinet’s preferred site), located next to Exeter airport.
“Why stand for election?” Ask the younger generation….
A special event at Knowle yesterday evening, involving the Parliamentary Outreach Service , was excellently organised by EDDC officers. Around 80 people attended the event, which had been advertised as an advice evening for prospective councillors. The session began well with a lively talk by Elizabeth Price of the Parliamentary Outreach service, who gave a quick overview of Parliament. The audience, including EDDC Leader Paul Diviani,listened attentively as she explained how its essential role is to hold government to account, represent the public, and to raise key issues. They also heard about parliamentary processes and, usefully, how to raise an issue in Parliament. The informal cross-party groups (All Party Parliamentary Groups, APPGs), may be of particular help to EDA as a member of Community Voice on Planning (www.covop.org). Ms Price also made a reference that seemed especially apt to the Knowle venue: she quoted Winston Churchill’s words, “We shape our buildings, and our buildings shape us”.
Julien Bassham of the Cabinet Office then described the Individual Electoral Registration (IER) reform which will be introduced in June 2014. It will concern only those people newly applying to register to vote, who will be required to give their Department of Work and Pension number along with their name. The aim is to prevent electoral fraud,largely in postal voting, where registration has sometimes been made by household. Questions from the audience showed some concern that this huge IT exercise could go awry (as with the NHS). We’ll soon see!
The high standard of presentations was impressively continued by George Downs and Alfie Weaver, speaking about the work of the Youth Parliament, the British Youth Council, and Devon Youth Service. George described various community action projects in detail, including the ‘Make Your Mark’ initiative to encourage young people to get involved, with the message that “Issues that matter, are politics in disguise”. Alfie stressed that the Devon Youth Service has no Party affiliation, but is “issue-affiliated”.
What a contrast this was, to the political mindset of the following speaker, EDDC Deputy Leader, Andrew Moulding. His closing talk was mostly based on trivialities (dogs harrassing political canvassers) and the implication that opponents’ leaflets (in this case, Councillor Douglas Hull’s) are only fit for the dustbin. No attempt was made to inform the listeners about what councillors do. This abysmal anti-climax to the evening provoked a sharp reaction from the audience. Further details reported here:http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/sparks_fly_at_eddc_elections_event_this_evening
A new bus service via Skypark would cost £100,000 a year
A new bus service via Skypark could cost £100,000 a year, confirm senior officers at Devon County Council.
Officers also confirm that the existing 4 service timetable would not permit it to be diverted into Skypark, due to time constraints.
At last month’s EDDC full council meeting, the conservative group voted in favour of starting detailed negotiations to buy land at Skypark for almost £1m and build new offices there.
Cllr Roger Giles (Independent – Ottery Town), who sought information from Dave Black (Head of Planning and Transportation at DCC) said: “The message shows that the claims made by EDDC cabinet member, Cllr Ray Bloxham – that an existing service will be diverted into Skypark – are wrong.
Cllr Ray Bloxham, EDDC Corporate Business Portfolioholder recently said that “a bus service currently passing Skypark will be diverted to serve stops within Skypark when it is completed”.
Roger Giles said: “In fact Mr Black demonstrates that it will be difficult and expensive to achieve a service into Skypark at all.”
Roger Giles also said: “The other great concern I have is that if a direct bus service to Skypark is achieved, is it will only provide a service for Cranbrook and Exeter residents.
“There would be no direct bus service for people living in the rest of East Devon.”
“By relocating from Sidmouth to Skypark on the edge of Exeter, EDDC will damage the economy of Sidmouth, and it will damage the economy of East Devon as a whole.
East Devon`s loss, will be Exeter`s gain.”
Concerns were expressed at EDDC’s full council by residents and councillors, that Skypark would be inaccessible for East Devon residents and EDDC staff who would have to relocate because of its location close to Exeter, and its lack of a direct bus service.
At the EDDC meeting on 26 February Cllr Roger Giles tabled a written question about the practicality of diverting the 4 (Exeter Cranbrook – Ottery – Honiton – Axminster) bus service into Skypark, because the tight timetable would probably not permit it.
Cllr Ray Bloxham in his written answer, and his answer to Roger Giles` supplementary question, was dismissive. He accused Roger Giles of “grandstanding”.
Subsequently Roger Giles wrote to Dave Black, about the matter. DCC is the authority responsible for bus services.
Dave Black also says: “Negotiations have been on-going with Science Park and SkyPark concerning contributions towards bus services. It is expected that these contributions would enable the funding of a new service between Cranbrook and Exeter, routing through Skypark and Science Park which would supplement the existing 30 minute frequency bus service.”
Inspector is denied access to full Knowle costs
See report on yesterday’s continuation of the Sidmouth hearing: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/03/12/knowle-evidence-at-inspectors-disposal-is-inadequate-says-sos-legal-representative/
East Devon Alliance calls for progress report on police investigation into Graham Brown affair.
It is now twelve months since the Daily Telegraph ‘Councillors-for-hire’ report, which included an undercover filmed interview with Graham Brown before his consequent resignation from East Devon District Council and from the powerful East Devon Business Forum, which he chaired.
There was an unfortunate delay of some months before the investigation started, and three changes of leadership of the case have since occurred. More on this disquieting matter has been published today, at this link: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Police-confirm-investigating-Graham-Brown-year/story-20793167-detail/story.html
Councillor-for-Hire investigation drags on
It’s now exactly one year ago that a scandal at East Devon District Council hit the national headlines. East Devon Alliance questions the way this has been dealt with, and asks how far the consequent police investigation has got, in this press release issued today 11 March 2014:
HAPPY ANNIVERSARY? … East Devon Alliance calls for transparency in planning matters at East Devon District Council, on the first anniversary of the Daily Telegraph expose of former Councillor Graham Brown – “If anyone can get you planning permission, I can, but I don’t come cheap”.
Disgraced ex-councillor Graham was the subject of an expose on the front page of the Daily Telegraph on 11 March 2013 (see below for links to this story and its follow-up)
East Devon Alliance is concerned that since then almost nothing has happened regarding ex-Councillor Brown’s possible conflicts of interest.
And what has happened in this last year?
It should be noted that East Devon District Council (EDDC) took several months to report the potential wrong-doing, as it first referred the allegations to the national ‘Action Fraud’ website – entirely the wrong action. Subsequently, the case was taken up by the Devon and Cornwall police.
Now, there is silence from the police force so we have no idea whether or even if the allegations have been investigated, though we do know that ex-Councillor Brown was forced to resign from the local Conservative Party and then chose to step down from EDDC.
Former Councillor Brown had been Chairman of the Local Development Framework Panel, which made decisions about where and how much housing and employment land should be developed in East Devon and, at the same time, he was Chairman of the East Devon Business Forum (EDBF) – a group made up of local landowners, developers and farmers concerned with the same matters. EDBF was funded by East Devon District Council and was given a named District Council officer to act as its Honorary Secretary. After public outcries about conflicts of interest, EDBF was disbanded and council funding and officer support ceased.
A District Council Task and Finish Forum (TAFF), set up to do an in-depth study of relations between EDDC and EDBF, was prevented from discussing or investigating planning matters on the instructions of East Devon District Council’s Chief Executive, Mark Williams and has therefore made no inroads into any of the possible conflicts.
East Devon Alliance calls for the immediate reinstatement of the EDBF Task and Finish group and a statement from Devon and Cornwall Police as to the current state of its investigations. Until these are forthcoming, members of the public cannot be certain that the conflicts of interest within the council have been properly addressed.
The council has been reluctant to embrace national guidance on lobbying which causes further disquiet.
We hope that we will not be writing again on the second anniversary of this event that nothing has changed within the council.
Notes for Editors:
The front page Daily Telegraph story can be found here:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/9921344/Councillors-for-hire-who-give-firms-planning-advice.html
and its follow-up story
here:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/9921333/If-I-turn-a-green-field-into-an-estate-then-Im-not-doing-it-for-peanuts.html
East Devon CPRE makes clear its position on protection of estuaries
Local CPRE Chair, Tim Hale, caused some consternation amongst those present at the February 14th hearing the Examination of EDDC’s Local Plan, when he seemed to be arguing for the removal of coastal preservation area status from the Exe Estuary. The matter has now been clarified, on the CPRE website: http://www.cpredevon.org.uk/topics/coasts-and-estuaries-designated-areas/
Further comment here:http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/campaign_to_protect_rural_england_clarifies_its_position_on_protection_of_c
Joining Forces
As recently reported on our website, East Devon Alliance is now part of Community Voice on Planning (CoVoP) , a nationwide network of campaign groups pushing for changes to the government’s National Planning Policy Framework, NPPF, (so-called ‘Developers’ Charter’).
We have had this news today from one particularly vigorous Northern group, in Formby.
Nick Boles visits Fragoff, in Formby Feb 2014 PRESS RELEASE
More at this website: http://www.covop.org
A quick round up of the week’s events.
On Wednesday (26th Feb) the EDDC council voted to push ahead with the relocation, probably to a SkyPark site (pending yet more consultation!), with costs of close to £1,000,000 approved for the purchase of land for the newbuild offices.
For a fuller report, please see following link…http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/knowle-sale-and-skypark-spend-voted-through-under-veil-of-cabinet-minutes/
On Thursday morning (27th Feb) Cllr. Claire Wright was interviewed on Radio Devon about the motion to have an independent survey of the Knowle Buildings done – Cllr. Diviani declined to make any comment
For Full story – http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/knowle-sell-off-diviani-declines-radio-devons-invitation-to-be-interviewed-this-morning/
For Radio Interview – http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p01r46tb Claire Wright Interview on BBC Radio Devon – from 40.10 mins
Last week Devon County Council (DCC) voted 32-23 against letting members of the Youth Service speak for 3 minutes about the proposed £970,000 cuts to their budget, on the grounds they had not sought permission within the deadline and to allow them to do so would set a bad precedent.
They failed to mention the deadline for submission was Friday 14th February, 7 days before the meeting, but news of the cuts was only released “accidentally” on Thursday 13th February, so leaving the Youth Service very little time to organise. The organisers contacted the council requesting permission to speak during the week in the run-up to the meeting, which confirms the council were fully aware of their request days beforehand, so could easily have avoided this shameful episode. For webcast of the DCC decision, see following link from 20.20 mins onwards.
Webcast of DCC Decision – http://www.devoncc.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/118409
And for Cllr. Moulding’s written justification of the decision, please see DCC Reply- http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/why_devon_county_council_tories_voted_against_against_allowing_young_people
To sign the Youth Service petition please follow the link… http://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/john-hart-protect-our-youth-services-from-budget-cuts
For latest news on the Local Plan Examination Hearings, please see recent posts on this EDA website.
‘Open Spaces’ at EiP hearing today ..where were the developers?
An Inspector Calls – on Climate Change Policy at EDDC.
An observer has sent us this report of Thursday’s hearing (27th February) in the Examination in Public (EiP), on the Local Plan policy on Climate Change:
An interesting 90 minutes at the Knowle yesterday. The admirable Mr Thickett calmly and powerfully demolished the EDDC policies and procedures. “This policy is so unspecific that it has no likelihood of being implemented.”
I suspect a new set of Building Regulations may emerge in due course.
The Green Party and Tesco had reserved places but failed to put in an appearance. There seemed to be no consideration of food security, water storage and drainage.
The Inspector unpicked the vague, inadequate or non-existent documentation on environmental impact, and sustainable design and construction – “The sustainable construction policy is more a ‘don’t annoy the neighbours’ policy.”
He advised them to rewrite a policy which suggests that the only low energy and renewable energy projects to be considered in East Devon would be as part of a building project, not as stand-alone developments.
The CPRE made a convoluted and unconvincing argument against wind and solar energy projects – but at least they agreed with AD, biomass and hydro. Nobody promoted fracking… EDDC expert advisers said that “CHP and other low carbon solutions are generally not viable”. The Inspector was dubious.
The Inspector probed the justification for inconsistency in the codes to be applied in different parts of the District. A representative for Cranbrook developers drew attention to the unfair treatment they get from the unequal rules for developments elsewhere.
In view of the high levels of mistrust generated among the public over the past two years of manoeuvring by EDDC I feel we need to ask why the documentation was so poor. Is it because
a) the officers are incompetent
b) the ruling group are indifferent
c) the residents of East Devon do not care
d) there is a conspiracy between senior officers, councillors, private developers and landowners – often the same people in different roles – to permit widespread under-regulated highly profitable piecemeal development all over the east of the District while getting brownie points for the fig-leaf of higher standards of compliance and comprehensive low carbon infrastructure within the eco-town of Cranbrook-on-flood plain.
No whipping at EDDC, so why the synchronised change of mind?
Some Conservative Councillors voted against the motion (only slightly differently worded) that they had vociferously backed and voted for at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. No debate was aired, to indicate what had caused this complete reversal. A recorded vote was proposed, but firmly rejected ‘en bloc’ by the Tory Councillors. (Of course, it’s not obligatory to follow a whip. As Cllr Tony Howard told a group of EDA members at last night’s meeting, he has voted against the whip at least twice at the DMC.)
Comment on today’s EDDC press release is at this link: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/council-leader-says-eddc-will-be-engaging-with-customers-and-stakeholders-on-office-relocation/
Principles behind Knowle relocation have been abandoned, says EDDC Councillor
This speech was made last night:
EAST DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL MEETING
26 FEBRUARY 2014
KNOWLE RELOCATION NOTICE OF MOTION
COMMENTS BY CLLR ROGER GILES
Chairman, when I first heard of the proposal to relocate the EDDC offices from The Knowle to Honiton, I thought that the principle of it had some merit.
To go from Sidmouth, despite all its many charms, to a much more central East Devon location at Honiton and the benefit of a railway station as well as the A30 and A35 appeared to be sensible.
To have new designed-for-purpose offices, rather than a converted hotel with myriad corridors and staircases also seemed sensible on the face of it.
Of course the principle often becomes much less attractive when the details of what is necessary become known – particularly the costings.
The costs of the project have rocketed.
And the principles behind it have been abandoned.
No longer is a central location proposed – but a location virtually in Exeter.
Quite understandably the people of Sidmouth and Sidmouth Town Council were very concerned about the proposed relocation. Concerned about the effect on The Knowle and its magnificent grounds and trees. Concerned about the effect on Sidmouth`s economy and the loss of jobs. Concerned about the consequent and excessive provision of 5 hectares of employment at Sidford.
But Sidmouth`s loss was to be Honiton`s gain. Lots of jobs for Honiton people, and a boost for Honiton`s economy.
Not now!
When this relocation project was first proposed the economy was relatively buoyant; people were relatively well off; and this Council was also relatively well off.
Not now! There is a much harsher economic climate. Many ordinary people – the better off – have had to pull their belts in. Many more are in a far far worse situation and are really struggling to pay their bills – including their Council Tax bills. This Council is suffering from unfair financial settlements from the Government.
It is important that we do not lose sight of the purpose of East Devon District Council. EDDC exists to provide services for the people of East Devon. To provide those services it spends taxpayers` money. Of course to enable it to provide services for the people of East Devon EDDC needs offices.
It does seem to me that there are some people who are running this Council who have lost sight of the purpose of EDDC. People who seem to be determined to press ahead, with what many members of the public see as a vanity project, regardless of the cost; regardless of what the people of East Devon think; regardless of the cost to EDDC`s reputation. And I very much suspect regardless of what the staff of EDDC think.
Yesterday afternoon all EDDC councillors received a letter from Mike Owen on behalf of the Cranbrook Consortium expressing concern about the decision to go for Skypark. The letter asked for the process to remain open.
Chairman the Council should listen to Mike Owen. But the Council should also listen to the people of Sidmouth; and also listen to the East Devon Council Taxpayer.
I urge the Council to support the Notice of Motion. To halt the reckless charge towards this damaging and hugely expensive project. And to stop the chain of devastation that would be left in its wake.





