Daily Telegraph says street protests could reduce NHS bed losses

The Labour Party has a national day of action on Saturday 26 November 2016.
Devon has a county-wide non-political protest (“Draw a Red Line”) on Saturday 3 December midday Bedford Square, Exeter (see above for information)

Hospital closures planned to shore up NHS finances could be derailed if enough people take to the streets in protest, a health service chief has said.

Chris Hopson, leader of England’s hospitals sector, said public unrest and opposition by local MPs could scupper so-called Sustainability and Transformation Plans (STPs), which are billed as crucial to the long-term viability of the health service.

On Monday the respected think tank The King’s Fund heavily criticised health bosses for trying to organise the sweeping closure of hospitals and NHS units in secret, moves which it said could put lives at risk.

Yesterday Mr Hopson, Chief Executive of NHS Providers, said architects of the schemes were so far failing to engage local communities, which “have the ability to sink plans they don’t support”.

“It’s very difficult for the NHS to proceed with wholescale change if you’ve got people out on the streets marching with placards and banners and saying “don’t do this”,” he said.

“Fundamentally you can’t make big changes to service provision without taking local people with you.”

The plans follow an admission in May that the provider sector overspent by a historic £2.45 billion in the last financial year.

The country has been divided into 44 areas, with each ordered to come up with a proposal that both closes the gap and caters for booming patient demand.

So far the plans involve the closure of one of five major hospitals in South West London, an A&E unit in the North East of England, the loss of almost 600 beds in Devon and the possible closure of two A&E units in St Helens and West Lancashire.

Mr Hopson yesterday said unit closures were too widely being regarded as a “silver bullet” to make the “overambitious and undeliverable” plans conform to tight budgets.

“We have become obsessed by the money and not got the public engagement right,” he said.

“We are also trying to do it too quickly.”

But Sir Bruce Keogh, the NHS medical director, has this week there was “plenty of time” for the public to shape the changes.

One thought on “Daily Telegraph says street protests could reduce NHS bed losses

  1. I am not as certain that demos will stop the destruction of the NHS as we know it as the head of NHS hospitals.

    Personally I believe that the people of every area need to fight the plans of their own CCG as hard as they can.

    As you may have read in my previous comments, our local NEW Devn CCG’s plans are dangerously immature, with huge gaps and holes, most notably an assumption that EVERY patient not needing hospital treatment is capable of surviving at home and is suitable for home treatment and an absence of ANY clinical studies mean that the CCG as failed to show that their proposals for home care are as medically effective and safe as hospital care. Substituting selective (i.e. biased) comments from a survey in which patients said that their visits were on time, is not a substitute for clinical data and leaves patients at risk and the CCG open to allegations of negligence.

    What is needed is proper analysis of the CCG’s proposals, documenting in detail the shortcomings and associated risks which will put patients at risk, and to submit this with as many people’s backing as possible.

    Whilst the CCG might be able to ignore thousands of comments from individuals, a single consultation response destroying their case by picking huge holes in the name of thousands of individuals cannot be so easily ignored.

    Like

Comments are closed.