Town shows ‘love for Shandford’ as Budleigh battles to save care home

Families of vulnerable pensioners being cared for at a soon-to-close care home in Budleigh Salterton came out in support for an SOS campaign to Save Our Shandford.

Owl comments at the end.

Becca Gliddon East Devon News:


A drop-in public meeting held on Friday evening at Budleigh’s football club was to glean interest in forming a Friends of Shandford group with the aim of setting up a Community Interest Company, to allow the care home to continue, and its residents to remain.

The town has come out in support of Shandford since Abbeyfield, who took over the site in 2012, announced its decision to close the care home, saying it was no longer viable to run.

Friday’s meeting tested the waters for setting up a Community Interest Company for Budleigh to run Shandford as a not-for-profit community venture.

The public was invited to pledge their time volunteering, helping with Shandford’s day-to-day management and maintenance, or giving a small annual subscription.

Abbeyfield said its decision to close Shandford, moving residents out by the end of March, followed a ‘lengthy consultation’, which concluded it was ‘not a viable option’ to keep the home open.

Relatives of residents living at Shandford have hit out at Abbeyfield’s decision to close the home, showing support for the SOS campaign, attending Friday’s public meeting.

Shirley Ann Woodman’s mother-in-law Ivy Woodman, aged 91, who retired to Budleigh, suffers from dementia and must leave Shandford when it shuts.

“She’s devasted,” said Shirley Ann, of Isaac Close, Otterton, “I am absolutely dreading settling her in somewhere else. She took a little while to settle in there, but that’s normal. To have to do it all again, that’s criminal.

“She’s very distressed. She has dementia. She knows it’s closing, I had to tell her. It’s all she talks about now.”

Gerald Moyle, 89, who also has dementia, moved from East Budleigh to be cared for at Shandford, and is visited regularly by his wife, Kathy, aged 77

Kathy said: “It’s heartbreaking. They are forcing us to move them out so quickly. I have told Social Services my husband’s not going anywhere. They can’t force us out.

“It’s the underhandedness. It’s all about money and greed at the end of the day.

“Nobody knows what’s going on, it’s fishy, it’s so smelly. You can’t say something isn’t viable unless you provide evidence.”

A confidential transfer agreement means Abbeyfield must hand Shandford back to the town.

The hope is to protect the home from sale or development, and for it to be owned and managed by Budleigh’s community.

Setting up a steering group is the first step to forming a Community Interest Company, to safeguard Shadford’s future, SOS organisers said.

The public meeting was an opportunity for people to pledge time, money, or express and interest in helping.

Helen Tickle, a spokeswoman for Save Our Shandford said there would be other opportunities for people to pledge support.

She said: “I have been very encouraged by the amount of love there is for Shandford in the town.

“Almost everybody you meet, their lives have been touched by Shandford in some way.

“My feeling is there’s sufficient support, but there are other options on the table.”

The SOS campaign said it was ‘last chance saloon’ for the care home after Abbeyfield gave notice of its intention to close the home.

Without sufficient support, the closure of the ‘valued’ home will be ‘inevitable’, and its 25 residents forced to move out of the town – four who are more than 100 years old.

“It doesn’t matter where these people have come from, they are residents of Budleigh Salterton, said Helen. “I feel as neighbour I have to do what I can for them.”

Shandford was set up on 1958 for and was run by a management committee of trustees until 2012, when Abbeyfield took over.

Shandford’s most recent Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspection found the home to be Good.

Abbeyfield said it was ‘with great regret’ it had to close Shandford, saying the decision was taken after a lengthy review of the service.

A spokesman for Abbeyfield said: “ This decision follows a lengthy consultation period in which we carefully considered the future of the home.

“A group of local people, made up of former professionals in areas including care home management, finance, property and law, undertook a detailed review of the infrastructure, building condition and financial performance of the home.

“Unfortunately, they also concluded that keeping the care home open was not a viable option.”

The spokesman added: “We will now work with residents, their loved ones and all the relevant authorities to find residents a suitable new home that will meet their individual care needs.

“Our priority at all times remains the comfort and wellbeing of residents and we are committed to supporting them throughout the closure process. We hope to complete this process by 31st March 2020.”

Owl’s correspondents say that Simon Jupp MP promised that he would put the questions residents’ relatives and concerned local people made to him the previous Friday to Abbeyfield. They understand this meeting took place elsewhere, at the same time as the drop-in. As yet no information on the outcome has been released.

Owl thinks it is worth reiterating some of their main concerns. Lack of transparency over who authorised and conducted the “local review” which concluded that keeping Shandford open was not a viable option. Local opinion finds the conclusion on non-viability runs counter to perception. The building was bought by the local community in the fifties and is unencumbered by debt. It has been reasonably maintained and, although, some further, modest, improvements are needed there is no immediate pressure to undertake them. The CQC report is good, it is full of contented residents and their relatives say that the charges are modest compared to the competition (i.e there could be scope for modest increase in income if that is a problem). It has a low staff turnover and the current manager has increased staffing levels to reduce the need for  expensive agency staff. Shandford is also the beneficiary from a recent legacy. Lastly, locals don’t see anywhere else in Budleigh where the assets released by a sale could be employed to provide residential care for the local elderly.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.