It is unusual for Hugo Swire to take such an active interest in constituency business (see below). Is the NHS becoming an “issue” so soon after the election in which we, the electorate, voted on the basis that it was safe in Tory hands?

“MP for hub talks
Journal 25 February 2016

“East Devon MP Hugo Swire says he is “deeply frustrated” by delays to the reopening of Budleigh Salterton Hospital.

The hospital, closed since last summer, had been due to reopen five months ago as a health and wellbeing hub, but this has been delayed due to an ownership dispute, with NHS Property Services said to be needing to generate a commercial rent for the building.

Mr Swire said: “I have always been a keen supporter of this project. Like many of my constituents in Budleigh and the wider area, I am deeply frustrated by this delay. It is my plan to set up a round table meeting with all of the stakeholders involved in this project in an effort to find a solution to this particular problem. I have already invited the Health Minister, Lord Prior* and hopefully he will be able to attend.”

*Lord Prior’s real title is: “Parliamentary Under-Secretaty of State for NHS Productivity” and he sits in the House of Lords, not the House of Commons. He formerly worked for Lehman Brothers as an investment banker.

“In April 2014 he [Lord Prior] had a hip replacement operation paid for by private insurance but was treated in a public ward at the Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital NHS Trust.”

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parliamentary_Under-Secretary_of_State

A couple of questions:

Will “stakeholders” include users and potential users of the hospital?

And don’t forget, everyone, Swire will not be able to bring the matter up in Parliament because he is a Minister.

Budleigh Hospital to remain closed while two parts of the NHS wrangle about who owns it and who can charge the other for it!

“The wait to reopen Budleigh Salterton Hospital as a multi-purpose health facility is set to continue for the unforeseeable future.

A dispute over ownership of the site means it is already five months behind schedule for when it was due to open its doors to the community again.

Nearly a year ago, NHS Northern, Eastern and Western (NEW) Devon Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) approved an £800,000 transformation of the facility owned by the Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust.

The hospital closed last summer and was due to reopen in September. NEW Devon CCG is in discussions to hand over responsibility for East Devon’s community hospitals to the Royal Devon & Exeter hospital.

It would mean the ownership of Budleigh Hospital would be automatically transferred to NHS Property Services, which would need to generate a commercial rent from the hospital building.

As a result, the scheme for a wellbeing hub in Budleigh will have to be put on hold until issues surrounding the ownership of the site can be resolved. …”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Budleigh-Salterton-Hospital-remains-closed/story-28784586-detail/story.html

HAVE YOU BOOKED FOR THE LEP ANNUAL CONFERENCE 2016?

The 2016 LEP Annual Conference on 22 March is attracting some heavyweight thought leadership to give you a valuable insight into what LEPs can do for your business to generate economic growth and drive up UK productivity. They include the newly appointed Director-General of the CBI, Carolyn Fairbairn, the Chair of the Local Government Association, Lord Porter, Chief Economist and Director of Policy at the IoD, James Sproule, and Martin Donnelly, BIS Permanent Secretary.

If you want to know how to effectively engage with LEPs, what they can do for you, and how they can help your business boost growth, make sure you book your seat to join other leaders of Government, business and local government who are at the heart of economic policy.”

http://www.lepnetwork.net/

But if you don’t have a business that needs to boost growth or drive up UK productivity – beggar off!

(How do you get “health and wellbeing” to boost productivity? when our LEP takes it over? Get more people to die quicker? Then pay fewer carers less money, perhaps).

Sometimes you simply cannot do cheaper and better at the same time

NHS to carry out investigation of 111 service in the southwest
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-35586997

Devon 999 response worsens again for sixth year:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-35585147

Why is anyone surprised? That’s austerity. There are some things you cannot do cheaper AND better.

Thanks, Mr Swire – not! Devon 143rd out of 152 authorities for funding spend per person on health

Hugo Swire has told us on countless occasions that he can’t speak for us in Parliament because he is a Minister. But he reassures us that he can and does talk about us in private to other Ministers (which Owl finds worse than talking about us in public when at least we could know what he is saying about us.

However, it seems that whatever he says (if he says anything at all as he is usually jetting around the world as bagman for the Foreign Minister) it has fallen on deaf ears:

A massive blow has been dealt to Devon’s health care after being told it will receive less funding.

For the next financial year in 2016/17, Devon County Council will receive almost £28m – £800,000 lower than anticipated, increasing fears over the a service that has already been recognised as being under significant financial pressures and demands.

It amounts to an allocation of £38 per person in Devon, compared to a national average of £69. In comparison, the city of London receives £200, and Middlesborough gets £126. …

…In the league table of public health grants per region, Devon is now ranked 143 out of 152 local authorities.

If Devon did receive the national average its public health funding would increase to over £51 – an extra £13 per person.

The public heath grant news arrived yesterday lunch time – the day before Devon County Council’s cabinet committee discussed the budget for the next financial year.

Speaking at today’s cabinet meeting, Andrea Davis, Devon County Council cabinet member for improving health and wellbeing, said: “That’s what I call shoving us right at the bottom. We are now fifth from the bottom in the league table. To say I’m unhappy is an understatement and we don’t have any reserves.”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Funding-blow-Devon-s-health-sees-ranked-near/story-28722938-detail/story.html

Shake-up for Devon-wide health services brought to you by the “Success Regime”

The first report on Devon health services since the county was put in special measures (re-branded as a “Success Regime” !) is published today and promises (threatens?) major changes, some of which “may” need public consultation at a later stage. Oh, and Owl likes the way the phrase “best performing” is used to mean “cheapest”!

The usual buzz words abound: transformation, best practice, latest thinking, latest technology …. One surprising finding is that community hospitals are under-used:

“Possible changes that could be considered to achieve the aims of the Success Regime programme range from looking at highly specialised services covering the whole of Devon and Cornwall, and possibly beyond; and further investigation into community hospital beds in Devon because the report says there is still a lot of space in community hospitals that is not being used.”

Is it that space is not being used or there are not enough members of staff available to use it? And which are the community hospitals that fall into this category?

What next? According to the (very long) press release:

“There have been 20 opportunities identified in the document. Out of those we will be looking at the options that might emerge, and how we engage with patients and the public.

“That will be by March or April, and those 20 opportunities will become four or five options to move into more diagnostic consultation.

“There will be some things we can just get on and do such as addressing agency staff as they are operational matters. Other options will require much more engagement and there will be some consultation with people in the summer months.”

In the meantime they have published some of their initial findings:

The ‘Case for Change’ facts:

. Health and social care spending in Devon was £1.9bn in 2014/15.

. Local health and social care organisations are facing a financial shortfall in 2015/16 of £122m, rising to £442m in 2020/21 if nothing changes.

. People in Devon are living longer. More than one in five people are over the age of 65, rising to one in four by 2021.

In Devon, 3.1 per cent are over the age of 85, higher than the national English average of 2.3 per cent.

. Devon is generally affluent but there are health inequalities in deprived areas.

• There are 280,000 local people, including 13,000 children, living with one or more long-term condition such as asthma, cancer and mental illness.

. Around 150,000 people in Devon have a mental illness.

.There are 40,000 people with cancer.

• Around 95,000 people with a long-term condition also have a mental illness.

. Local health and social care services are likely to be £442m in debt by 2020/21 if nothing changes.

. There is predicted to be 37,000 more emergency admissions to local hospitals over the next five years, an increase of more than 30 per cent. Many of these admissions are preventable.

• An estimated £85m is being spent on areas where staff may be able to provide the same quality of service but more efficiently.

. Over £30mwas being spent on temporary staff in hospitals in 2014/15.

. Up to £25m could be saved on clinical supplies if hospitals work together to buy them.

. Up to £21m could be saved by matching spend on continuing care to best performing areas.

. A third of bed space in community hospitals is empty or under-used.

. Every day, more than 500 people are in local hospitals when they could be elsewhere. Most of them are old and many have dementia.

. Over half the people in Devon who are fit to leave the community hospital have been waiting to leave for at least four days. It costs £250 per day to care for someone in an acute hospital bed.

• There are difficulties recruiting and retaining staff at all levels. Almost a quarter of GPs in Devon intend to leave the NHS in the next five years.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Unaffordable-unsustainable-services-lost-major/story-28715410-detail/story.html

What happens when you privatise care home inspections

The body responsible for ensuring care homes are run to an adequate standard is so short of qualified consultants to help with inspections that it has had to ask the charities it replaced with a private company to help out.

Remploy, the former government agency that has turned into a for profit firm, won a £7m contract to replace the charities in London, the North and South of England, starting a week ago. However, hundreds of “Experts by Experience” have refused to reapply for their jobs after Remploy offered half their previous £17-per-hour pay.

As a result, the Care Quality Commission has had to ask the charities to keep providing the consultants for another two weeks, despite choosing Remploy to take over the inspections programme.

The CQC offered to provide a “buffer” payment to existing experts so they would be paid £15 per hour for the next six months, after which their salary could drop to just £8.40 per hour (£9.25 in London) – which is what Remploy is paying new recruits.

… Every month more than 500 experts, with personal experience of care services, are sent on CQC inspections across adult social care, primary care and hospitals. They play a vital role in the inspection process. However, hundreds of experts have quit their roles – angered by a combination of the pay offer and the fact that a private firm, majority owned by US outsourcing giant Maximus, is profiting from the deal. …”

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/care-quality-commission-begs-for-help-from-charities-it-has-just-replaced-a6859326.html

“Rural hospital journeys by public transport almost twice as long as cities”

“People who live in rural areas of England take at least 57 minutes on average to reach their nearest hospital by public transport, almost twice as long as their urban counterparts at 33 minutes, according to a report published by the Department for Transport.

The report also finds that those in urban areas have, on average, access to between three and four hospitals within an hour’s journey compared with one for rural residents.

For both urban and rural residents hospitals are the key local service which takes the longest to reach, but the time required for rural dwellers to reach vital services is not restricted to hospital care. It takes people in rural locations longer to access all eight key services covered by the report, including employment, health and education facilities.”

http://gu.com/p/4f4k6

Government spends £30,000 to keep official diary of former Health Secretary secret

Health campaigners have been fighting for years for the release of the Ministerial diaries of Lord Lansley, who was finally sacked in July 2012 and is now a Tory peer.

They want to see which lobbyists and private health firms he met with in the run-up to his hated Health and Social Care Act 2012, which opened the NHS up to further privatisation.

A landmark ruling at a Freedom of Information tribunal in April found the public have every right to see his and other Ministerial diaries.

But the Government has now taken the case to the Court of Appeal.

Mr Frankel said it was ironic that Ministers claim FoI laws are too expensive to administer and must be scaled back – while at the same time blowing vast sums of taxpayers’ cash on court cases to keep information private.

“(They) talk about the ‘burden of FoI’ – some of the burden is caused by authorities trying to resist disclosure beyond the point at which they should simply accept the decision,” Mr Frankel said

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/ministers-blow-30000-trying-keep-7012284

Digital divide could affect rural NHS services

The digital divide could see rural residents in the West missing out on being able to access services at doctors’ surgeries and even online consultations with their GP, according to a broadband campaigner.

Parish councillor Graham Long was speaking after a review of digital services in the NHS in England called for GPs to actively encourage patients to go online to book appointments and order repeat prescriptions.

It was drawn up by Internet entrepreneur Baroness Martha Lane Fox, who was asked by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt to look at how take-up of Internet services could be made widely available. She recommended ensuring every NHS building provide free wi-fi, and that every GP practice should get 10 per cent of patients to go digital by 2017.

Mr Long, who is campaigning for fast broadband in rural areas of Somerset and Devon, said booking appointments and renewing prescriptions online could be beneficial for many people in rural areas, particularly those with poor public transport.

He said: “I live in the Blackdown Hills, and we had a bus service to the next village where there is a GP. That has been cut from five days a week to two. Ordering repeat prescriptions online would save an awful lot of travelling for people without their own transport. It has even been suggested that consultations could eventually be done online using Skype. But many people here would not be able to take advantage of this because of the slow speed connections.”

He added: “Fast broadband provides access to the trade routes of the 21st century. If you do not raise the urgency of deploying rural broadband, you will be consigning rural Devon and Somerset to Third World status.

“This should be one of the catalysts for getting fast broadband in rural areas. In the 21st century, it should all be about building fast broadband links. It is more important than improvements to the road network.”

Martyn Rogers, director of Age UK Exeter, said: “There are lots of people ordering prescriptions online now. It’s convenient because they can do it from home and it saves time and money at surgeries.

“But a government report last year on digital inclusion showed that 11 million people in this country don’t have sufficient digital capacity to do things like book appointments on line, and half of those were aged over 65.

“A lot of older people are not online. But I would encourage as many people as possible who want to do this to try it; it would seem to be cost-effective. Provided GPs are geared up, that’s great. But if it started to be mandatory, it would disenfranchise a large number of people.”

On Thursday (DEC 10) Mr Long addressed a full meeting of Devon County Council and raised the issue of the failure to provide fast broadband to many parts of the region.

He said: “Devon and Somerset’s superfast rural broadband programme, the largest in England, is now a basket case with district councils in Devon issuing press releases claiming they will run their own programme. Rural council taxpayers expect you to work with the districts to provide the publicly-funded infrastructure that cities and other rural counties now take for granted. This is not happening here and rural economies face serious decline with businesses moving out to the towns. Fast broadband provides access to the trade routes of the 21st century. If you do not raise the urgency of deploying rural broadband, you will be consigning rural Devon and Somerset to Third World status.”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Digital-divide-cost-rural-areas-access-NHS/story-28353010-detail/story.html

How Japan is supporting its ageing population

“Japan’s imaginative initiatives for its older population show that prevention, postponement and interventions do not have to be dull or rooted in a context of care and that there is a strong link between social capital and health.”

http://www.theguardian.com/healthcare-network/2015/dec/08/casinos-leaf-picking-new-god-supporting-older-people-japan-cities

Will innovations such as these happen in East Devon? Not a chance as older people were last week classed as “unproductive” by EDDC CEO Mark Williams and therefore, by implication, unworthy of attention or funds from East Devon District Council plc – a sub- division of Local Enterprise Partnerships Conglomerate Inc.

Pwtition on hospital bed closures delivered

“Health campaigners in Devon are due to deliver a 10,000-signature petition to the county council calling for action over the closure of community hospital beds

The petition calls for a debate of the full council over the funding of rural hospital provision.

The union Unite said the recent closure of beds at Bideford and Ilfracombe hospitals left Barnstaple as the only major town in north Devon with hospital beds.”

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-england-devon-34862887

Government consultation on NHS – but no-one told about it

And only until 27 November to respond – please pass on.

https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/setting-the-mandate-to-nhs-england-for-2016-to-2017

Pigs, snouts, troughs, gravy trains …

He says it is OK because none of them are health-related.

One is with the Roche drug company,

One is with The US private equity firm Blackstone “which was criticised in 2011 after the collapse of Southern Cross care home group under a mountain of debt. The lives of 31,000 elderly residents were thrown into turmoil through the actions of Blackstone, which had bought Southern Cross in 2004 and sold out three years later at a huge profit having sold most of its property assets”.

and

one is with a company that receives funding from “fitness companies” and Coca Cola.

These are in addition to his two other jobs
with management consultants Bain & Company and a consultancy set up by his wife called Low Associates.

“Low Associates helps people prepare before they give evidence to committees of MPs, and Sally Low has given speeches on improving lobbying skills, in which she said that lobbyists should “establish positive relationships with decision-makers before you need their help”. Lobbyist clients of Low Associates personnel have previously worked for a variety of companies including those with an interest in health, such as SmithKline Beecham, Unilever and Procter & Gamble.”

“Until December 2009, Lansley received £134 an hour from a firm of advertisers that represents clients such as Walkers Crisps, McDonald’s, Unilever, Mars and Pizza Hut; Private Eye suggests a link between these activities and Lansley’s desire to see a more lightly regulated food industry.[38] The same publication suggested a similar link to a Department of Health report on red meat in which the only products listed in the report found to contain suitable amounts of red meat to merit a “Good” rating were a McDonald’s Big Mac, and a Peperami (manufactured by Unilever)”

“The three jobs were taken by the former health secretary despite David Cameron’s promise in 2010 to end the ‘revolving door’ between government and the private sector.”

Last night Lord Lansley told the Daily Mail that he expected the majority of the work he does for the companies to be unrelated to health.”

SO WHAT EXACTLY ARE THEY ALL PAYING HIM FOR?

He was recently made a Lord by David Cameron

Sources:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Lansley

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3320858/Should-not-work-Ex-Health-Secretary-Andrew-Lansley-defends-private-sector-jobs-including-advising-drugs-firm.html

Staff allowed judicial review of downgrade of their hospital

“Irwin Mitchell lawyer Mathieu Culverhouse said: “Concerned members of staff at Wythenshawe Hospital truly believe that the loss of specialist status will have a catastrophic impact on the hospital’s ability to deliver quality care to patients and we are delighted that the decision not to award specialist status to Wythenshawe Hospital will now be reviewed.

“It is vital that decisions of this nature, which affect the health services available to the public of Greater Manchester, are made properly and in accordance with the law and we are determined to ensure that the decision making process is given the appropriate scrutiny by the court.”

http://localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=25101:court-gives-permission-for-judicial-review-challenge-over-hospital-downgrade&catid=174&Itemid=99

The health trust had already allocated £500,000 towards funding any challenge to their plans.

“The legal appeal by the Keep Wythenshawe Special group is being self-funded through personal contributions by staff at Wythenshawe hospital, along with former patients and their families and local people in Wythenshawe.”

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/judge-grants-judicial-review-campaigners-10418635

37,000 could end up in NHS care when care homes forced to close

Several towns in East Devon rely on care homes for many jobs. Most advertisements in local newspapers are for jobs in the sector. The increase in minimum wage and lower social care fees will cause many care homes to close. The closure of more community hospital beds will exacerbate the problem. Councils facing budget cuts of 40% cannot pick up any slack.

“The NHS could be forced to find room for 37,000 elderly and disabled nursing home residents by the end of the decade as the cash-starved care industry teeters on the brink of collapse, a new report warns.
A study of funding by the think-tank ResPublica concluded that a feared wave of care home closures and cutbacks could leave the NHS forced to pick up a bill of £3 billion a year.

The health budget has been given special protection from austerity cuts for the last five years but councils, which have a legal duty to provide social care, have seen their incomes slashed by 40 per cent. …”

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/elder/11987364/NHS-facing-37000-strong-influx-of-elderly-as-care-homes-close.html

Leaked letter: more bed closures for local community hospitals

A leaked letter has revealed that hospital bed closures are planned for Sidmouth, Seaton, Honiton and Ottery.
The closures are said to be temporary and part of a 15-bed package also affecting community hospitals in Exmouth and Exeter.
Sidmouth, Seaton and Honiton will each see two beds close, whilst the figure is three for Ottery, the letter reveals.
In addition, the Minor Injuries Unit in Sidmouth will also close temporarily.
Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust (NDHT), which manages the hospitals, did not inform Pulman’s View, but the details are in a leaked letter to stakeholders, dated November 2nd.
NDHT Chief Executive Dr Alison Diamond wrote: “We have had a spending limit (cap) on the amount of our budget that we can spend on agency staff imposed.
“We do not have permission to breach this limit and therefore were required to consider how we temporarily reconfigure our services in the safest possible way.
“Our approach was to explore only those proposals that maintained quality of care, addressed the risks of over-reliance on agency staff and which had the least impact on patients and our clinical workforce.
“It is important to note that these are temporary and urgent, in that they will be reversed in March 2016 and that we continue to recruit to our vacant clinical posts.
“So far the trust has spent £5million on nursing agency in six months, compared to £6million for the whole of last year.
“Our agency hotspots are mostly in the community hospitals.”
The most recent agency nurse figure for Sidmouth Hospital, for example, is 27.32 per cent.
The Chief Executive also said: “We would have preferred to have been able to involve you far more in the discussions about the safest way to maintain these services.
“However, the cap is being imposed from the middle of November and this means we must take emergency and temporary measures to address the safety concerns as well as ensuring we are not penalised for breaching the agency cap.”
Axminster GP Dr James Vann said he was not impressed by the decision when asked for comment.
Dr Vann played a leading role in pressure groups fighting the recent and much-publicised in-patient bed closures at Axminster Hospital.
He said: “We have heard this all before. NDHT does not make temporary cuts.
“In my opinion, previously they have been part of a closure campaign. “The sooner NDHT stops meddling with our community services in East Devon the better.
“I hope that the Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) will be more active in controlling the actions of this provider.
“NDHT has known for the past two years that recruitment is difficult. “They worked closely with a group in Axminster to try and improve recruitment and were successful to the degree that Axminster Hospital nearly reopened, finding 10 new whole time equivalent nurses in three months.
“They have failed to learn from this experience and are now back again having to employ excessive numbers of agency nurses and spending more than most trusts on agency nursing.
“Closing beds is a panic measure being undertaken by the trust and certainly at this time of year cannot be in the patient’s best interest. “Please can the CCG try to accelerate the start of their new chosen provider, the Royal Devon & Exeter Trust.”
Dr Alison Diamond, chief executive, said: “We are working with the CCG and RD&E to look at whether alternative options are available. Our priority is to provide safe and effective care as well as resilient services for patients.”

http://www.otterystmary-today.co.uk/article.cfm?id=101434

2,000 senior council officers get private medical treatment paid for by us

Figures obtained by the Mail show that over the past three years, £3.43million of public money has been spent on private health insurance for council staff in England and Wales.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3309667/The-NHS-Not-fund-private-health-Town-Hall-bosses-Taxpayers-1m-bill-fund-treatment-2-000-chiefs.html?ITO=1490&ns_mchannel=rss&ns_campaign=1490

Underfunding community hospitals “threatens the whole system”


A cash crisis in the NHS is starving community hospitals and threatens to undermine the whole system, it has been warned.

Former health minister and Exeter MP Ben Bradshaw said failing to fund community health facilities, such as community hospitals, physiotherapy and community nursing, was short sighted.

He said it played a vital role in keeping patients out of major hospitals and blamed under-funding as the latest casualty of the sweeping reorganisation of the NHS undertaken by the Coalition Government.

His words come as the Prime Minister has been urged to step into the row over cottage hospital closures in North Devon.

Meanwhile, in Cornwall healthcare commissioners have been forced to search for new providers of community care after a private company ceded its contracted saying it simply could not deliver for the money being paid.

Mr Bradshaw said lack of funding underpinned the whole problem and things had to change.

“The underlying problem here is the serious financial crisis affecting the NHS, which has mainly been caused by the Government’s disastrous and costly re-organisation of the health service at the beginning of the last Parliament.

“The independent regulator, the Care Quality Commission, warned this week that a growing number of organisations are unable to guarantee safe care and Monitor, which oversees Foundation Trusts, said the NHS faces its worst crisis for more than 30 years.”

Earlier this month, Northern Devon Healthcare Trust (NDHT) voted to close in-patient beds at Ilfracombe and Bideford Hospitals, despite protests from their own senior medics and patients and warnings from healthcare commissioners. In the latest twist to the saga, Great Torrington Town Council has urged David Cameron to see for himself the unique problems faced by their community.

The council urged Mr Cameron to see for himself the challenges in rural areas which were being made worse by “insufficient funding.” …

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Underfunding-community-hospitals-threatens/story-28055032-detail/story.html