Government statement on Local Government Reorganisation

From the horses mouth – Owl

Local Government Reorganisation moves forward in five counties

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government www.gov.uk

Five areas have moved closer to streamlined local government in their area as the government announced the next steps in its review of Local Government Reorganisation.

Following the announcement of a review last month, Ministers have confirmed that the programme is continuing and remains aligned with the wider plans to shift power out of Westminster and back to local communities, including those announced at this week’s Budget.

The government is now minded-to go ahead with reorganisation in five areas. There will be a period of three weeks minimum for further representations before final decisions are taken.

The five areas where the government is minded to proceed are:

  • In East Sussex and Brighton and Hove, the two unitary proposal including boundary changes requested by Brighton and Hove City Council, except for the parish of Falmer.
  • The one unitary proposal in Gloucestershire;
  • The three unitary proposal in Oxfordshire, including boundary changes.
  • The two unitary proposal in Warwickshire;
  • The two unitary proposal in Worcestershire;

The Government remains committed to the reorganisation programme. Ministers will consider the best way forward for all remaining areas in the programme – 15 in total, including the nine areas which had reorganisation paused in September and which now have their decisions withdrawn.

Withdrawing these decisions does not mean reorganisation has been cancelled in these areas. All options and proposals remain under consideration in these areas and every area will have an outcome by early next year.

Local elections in these areas will go ahead in May 2027 on existing council boundaries, providing certainty for local leaders and communities.  New councils will be established for 2029, with elections to shadow councils in May 2028.

All areas with previous decisions will receive £450,000 per the number of previously announced new unitary authorities from the £63 million capacity fund, to cover costs incurred in implementing reorganisation. Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and West Sussex will each receive £500,000 as decisions have yet to be made there.  This funding will be paid in the coming weeks. The remaining balance will be paid after final decisions.

Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth Jim McMahon OBE told Parliament today:

Yesterday’s budget showed that we are committed to giving local leaders, local councils and local communities the tools to shape their own future.

No areas want to see a return to two-tiers once strong unitary councils are in place… The decisions that we take now will be the building blocks for how this country is governed for generations to come.

Reorganisation in Surrey will remain unaffected with two new unitary authorities – East and West Surrey – going live in April 2027.

The government has heard concerns from places about retaining their city status and has committed to making it a priority to protect them and will consider all available options – including bringing in new legislation if necessary.

For more information:

Areas where government is minded to proceed:

  • East Sussex and Brighton and Hove: Two unitary proposal submitted by East Sussex County Council, Eastbourne Borough Council, Hastings Borough Council, Lewes District Council and Rother District Council – with the boundary change requested by Brighton and Hove City Council, with the exception of Falmer parish.
  • Gloucestershire: One unitary proposal submitted by Cotswold District Council, Gloucestershire County Council, Stroud District Council, and Tewkesbury Borough Council.
  • Oxfordshire: Three unitary proposal submitted by Oxford City Council, including the adjoining area of West Berkshire Council – with the boundary change Oxford City Council requested alongside the proposal.
  • Warwickshire: Two unitary proposal submitted by North Warwickshire Borough Council, Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council, Stratford-on-Avon District Council and Warwick District Council.
  • Worcestershire: Two unitary proposal submitted by Bromsgrove District Council, Malvern Hills District Council, Redditch Borough Council, Worcester City Council and Wychavon District Council.

15 areas remaining under review:

Nine areas where decisions are now withdrawn and will be reconsidered:

  • Derbyshire and Derby
  • Devon, Plymouth and Torbay
  • Hertfordshire
  • Kent and Medway
  • Lancashire, Blackburn with Darwen and Blackpool
  • Leicestershire, Leicester, and Rutland
  • Lincolnshire, North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire
  • Nottinghamshire and Nottingham
  • Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent

Four areas where decisions were withdrawn in September:

  • Essex, Southend on Sea and Thurrock
  • Hampshire, Isle of Wight, Portsmouth and Southampton
  • Norfolk
  • Suffolk

Two areas which are awaiting decisions:

  • Cambridgeshire and Peterborough
  • West Sussex

Breaking: ‘More chaos, cost and confusion’ from reorganisation update – Julian Brazil

Devon County Council’s leader has sharply criticised the Government’s latest decision on local government reorganisation, saying delay will mean “more chaos, cost and confusion” for councils and communities.

www.devon.gov.uk

Local Government Minister Jim McMahon told the House of Commons today that the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government was withdrawing plans announced in July to replace two-tier local government in Devon with four unitary councils.

The department will now review all the original options and proposals submitted by Devon’s councils, with a fresh decision expected in January 2027 and new unitary councils formed in 2029.

Devon County Council has launched a legal challenge against the four-unitary proposal, arguing that the estimated £100 million cost of implementing the changes would be better spent on frontline services. The council said that the Government had not properly applied its own criteria when reaching its decision.

Council leader Councillor Julian Brazil said:

“Here is a Government that cannot sort out issues that really matter to our communities, such as our maternity services and our failing water industry, yet seems hellbent on a reorganisation that risks disrupting the real progress councils are making to improve services.

“The Government talked today about bringing clarity to the situation, but this latest announcement simply brings more chaos, cost and confusion to local authorities which are already facing significant challenges.

“Council staff do an incredible job and are focused on our ambitions for young people. We need a Government that gives them a clear idea about what the future holds so they can get on with that work.”

Councils across Devon have already spent around £5 million preparing for changes which would represent the biggest shake-up of local government in the county for 50 years.

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government had agreed to provide £900,000 towards implementation costs for each new authority. However, the Government said today that only half that amount would be made available and shared between councils until a final decision is reached.

Cllr Brazil added:

“Instead of getting a firm decision from Government, we have had more delay and indecision, and now a U-turn on how much it will contribute financially.

“This makes it incredibly difficult for councils to plan their budgets, workforce and future. Devon County Council has continued to improve key services and focus relentlessly on creating better opportunities for young people, despite the uncertainty surrounding reorganisation. We could do so much more without this Halloween horror show hanging over us.

“Devon residents want better roads and better services. They want young people to be able to build healthy, happy and productive lives here.

“This week’s announcement that Devon is to have a Mayor and devolved powers gives us an opportunity to help achieve those ambitions. Endless uncertainty over local government reorganisation does not.

“We will continue to explore our legal options.”

Devon devolution on for 2028

Devon will get an elected mayor in 2028, it has been announced in the Budget.

Miles Davis, Andrew Segal www.bbc.co.uk

The position will be a figurehead for the county, which is split into three administrative areas: Devon County Council, and the Plymouth City Council and Torbay Council unitary authorities.

Devon leaders previously said they were keen to work with Cornwall on a joint mayoral authority, but Cornwall resisted that approach, with its unitary authority saying it was now “by exception” a “single strategic authority”.

The government had been trying to manage a reorganisation of local government with the abolition of all councils in Devon to be replaced by unitary councils but that plan has been put on hold.

The leader of Devon County Council said it was “fantastic” news that would give Devon “a seat at the top table” to bid for millions of pounds of funding for departments such as transport and housing, and potentially raise income from areas such as a tourism tax.

Leader and Liberal Democrat Julian Brazil said it would make a huge difference for people in Devon to be able to decide where money would be spent instead of those decisions being made by central government.

He said: “We’re actually pulling a whole layer of central government down to Devon so that we’ll be deciding how best to take decisions that are going to affect the people down here.”

Dave Thomas, Conservative and leader of Torbay Council, said: “It’s fantastic news, to be honest, because the thing is the new mayor will bring new powers, new money to the area.

“These are powers that normally sit in London, and are decided at a London level, will actually be decided down here in Devon.”

Tudor Evans, leader of Labour-run Plymouth City Council, said he was “absolutely delighted”.

He said: “It means that we can start now the real preparatory work to get an agenda, to get a wish list of important things that we need to do to accelerate growth in the region.

“Having a mayor to advocate for the region in a room full of mayors is so important. It means that we won’t get left behind.”

Elections for the directly-elected mayor for Devon are due to be held in May 2028.

‘Cornwall-only footprint’

While Devon was listed among places to become Mayoral Strategic Authorities, Cornwall was included with Budget documents as the only area on a pathway to become a Foundation Strategic Authority.

Cornwall Council leader Leigh Frost, county MPs and peers welcomed the Chancellor’s announcement, saying the decision reflected “recognition of our unique cultural status”.

They added: “This secures further devolution for Cornwall on a Cornwall-only footprint and without the need to introduce a mayor, which the council, MPs and peers representing Cornwall have long campaigned for… Government has listened to Cornwall.”

Frost said it was a “significant moment for Cornwall”.

He said: “Cornwall has its own identity and ambitions, but we also have our own unique challenges to face.

“That’s why it’s so important that decisions about Cornwall are made here in Cornwall by people who understand the needs of our communities.”

Devon and Government prioritising support for young people

Organisations from across Devon gathered together to focus on improving job opportunities and access to education for young people.

Chris Collman www.devonairradio.com

The Brighter Futures steering group has held its inaugural meeting to explore how it can build on its work, and strengthen local support to make sure it’s available to more young people.

Cllr. Denise Bickley, Chair of the Brighter Futures steering group

The County Council launched its Brighter Futures Strategy last year, with the aim of giving every young person in Devon the opportunity to succeed, regardless of the challenges they may face.

The latest figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show that 981,000 young people aged 16 to 24 were not in employment, education or training (NEET) across the UK between April and June, prompting the Prime Minister to describe the situation as an “economic catastrophe and moral failure”.

Devon County Council Leader Julian Brazil says Prime Minister Andy Burnham is “singing from the same hymn sheet” as Devon on its commitment to help young people into education, training or work.

Councillor Brazil reiterated Devon’s commitment to young people, with the Council’s Brighter Futures Strategy setting out how it’s working with partners to improve opportunities for young people across the county.

Almost 4% of 16 to 18-year-olds in Devon were NEET in 2024, lower than the national average of 5.4%, but the Council is committed to reducing this further. And while Devon’s overall figures compare favourably to the national picture, some young people face much greater challenges.

In 2024, 13.4% of young people with special educational needs and disabilities or Education, Health and Care Plans were NEET, while almost half of care leavers aged 19 to 21 were not in education, employment or training.

For young people in Devon’s rural and coastal communities, transport and access to opportunities can also present significant barriers. Through Brighter Futures, the Council is working with partners to address these challenges.

A few days left to have your say on Devon’s mayoral plans

Devonians have now only 3 days left to have their say on the county’s bid to become a Mayoralty.

Chris Collman www.devonairradio.com/

A six-week public consultation, launched on September 16, lasts until Wednesday October 28 giving residents, businesses and organisations the chance to share their views on the proposal and what it could mean for the region.

The consultation outlines plans for the Devon and Torbay Combined County Authority (DTCCA) to seek mayoral status from the Government, and expand to incorporate the area covered by Plymouth City Council.

If approved, and Plymouth joins, a directly elected mayor would represent the wider Devon, Torbay and Plymouth area and oversee an economy worth £33.1 billion per year.

A mayor would oversee policy in key areas such as transport and have spending powers devolved from central government.

However, a mayor would not run local councils and services such as bin collections, schools, social care, housing and planning would remain the responsibility of councils and elected councillors.

Councillor David Thomas, Chair of the DTCCA, which is preparing the mayoral bid, said: “This is a conversation for everyone across Devon, Torbay and Plymouth. Working together gives us a stronger voice with Government and a greater opportunity to secure investment for our communities.”

Councillor Julian Brazil, Vice-Chair of the DTCCA and Devon County Council Leader, added: “Having a mayor is about bringing more power, funding and decision-making closer to the people and places affected by it.

“This consultation is about shaping the future of our region and ensuring local people have a voice in the decisions that affect them.

“This is an opportunity that we must not miss. The benefits that come with mayoralty are benefits that will be felt in very real and practical ways by residents and businesses alike.”

The consultation asks whether people support Plymouth joining a mayoral strategic authority, their views on a directly elected mayor, and the priorities a mayor should focus on.

The proposal would not merge councils, change council boundaries, transfer services or affect council staff.

The consultation findings will be reported in November. Plymouth City Council and the DTCCA, alongside Devon County Council and Torbay Council, will then decide whether to proceed with a formal proposal to Government.

You can find the consultation at Have Your Say Today – Devolution In Devon – Commonplace

In Owl’s view the key section worth looking at is the one describing how the proposed mayoral authority would work and be scrutinised. This can be found here.

We still await a ministerial decision on the reorganisation review “paused” in the light of judicial challenge (in Devon’s case, also paused).

Storms hit as Minister considers South West Water’s request to pull the plug on swimming pools, car washes etc

Request to ban non-essential water use for businesses in East Devon

Not content to pollute our bathing beaches with sewage, SWW now wants to ban filling or maintaining certain non-domestic swimming pools.

The Telegraph reports that Angela Eagle, the Environment Secretary, has fast-tracked the applications from SWW and South East Water because of concerns about reservoir levels in those areas, and will issue a ruling within days.

The Telegraph also says: If Ms Eagle agrees to the measures, businesses that regularly use water for non-essential purposes will effectively be forced to close, and could be liable for compensation from water companies.

Swimming pools in areas under the ban cannot be refilled or maintained, while companies cannot top up ponds, clean offices or run car washes.

A non-essential water ban was last used in 2006 in Surrey and before that in 1995 in Yorkshire.

According to Richard Foord MP, in an August report:

SWW’s leaky infrastructure led to the loss of more than 107 million litres daily between 2024 and 2025. [SWW currently plans to halve this leakage of treated water by 2050!]

Mr Foord acknowledged that dry ground can damage water mains, but said the problem has been worsened by long-term neglect of infrastructure and he criticised South West Water for awarding large bonuses “such as to its former Chief Executive.”

He is now calling for the Government to include stricter measures on reducing leaks in the upcoming Clean Water Bill, as promised in the recent King’s Speech.

Mr Foord said: “Infrastructure investment needs to be a priority for water companies.

“Leakage repairs have flat-lined since the late 1990s, so the regulator that replaces Ofwat will need to have teeth.

“South West Water and other water companies need to be held to account for their persistent failures.”

Here is how South West Water explain their actions:

South West Water has applied to ban non-essential water use for businesses in East Devon

www.southwestwater.co.uk Non-essential use ban application

We have applied for a ban on non essential water use for some businesses across Mid Devon and parts of East Devon and Dorset, after a lack of significant rainfall following a prolonged period of exceptionally dry weather continues to place significant pressure on local water resources.

The application has been sent to the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) for a drought order which would allow the water company to introduce restrictions on non-essential water use for affected businesses in the Exeter, Exmouth, Crediton, Sidmouth, Tiverton and surrounding areas across Mid and parts of East Devon, as well as a small part of Dorset including Lyme Regis.

The proposed non-essential use ban would include restrictions on:

  • watering plants on commercial premises
  • filling or maintaining certain non-domestic swimming pools and ponds
  • vehicle washing
  • cleaning non-domestic buildings and premises
  • cleaning industrial plant
  • dust suppression
  • other specified non-essential uses of mains water.

A non-essential use ban (NEUB) would not apply to households customers, who remain under a hosepipe ban across the wider South West region. Find out more information about the hosepipe ban.

Sam Bottomley, South West Water’s Director for Drinking Water Services, said: “The South West is entering a critical phase of an exceptionally prolonged drought. While recent rainfall is helping, water resources remain under significant pressure and South West Water continues to rely heavily on water stored in reservoirs to maintain supplies.

Every day we continue to draw on our reservoirs to keep water flowing to homes, businesses and communities while river flows remain below the levels needed to support public water supply.

Many people understandably think a drought is over once it starts raining. In reality, recovery takes much longer. After such a prolonged dry period, rainfall first has to replenish dry soils and the wider environment before rivers return to seasonal levels. Only then can reservoirs begin to recover properly.

Some of those rivers still remain at their lowest levels and with no significant rain forecast for the coming weeks, the immediate challenge is reducing demand and preserving enough stored water to maintain supplies until river flows and reservoir levels recover.

Applying for a drought order is a responsible step to help protect the environment and preserve the water we have available. Taking action now gives us the best opportunity to protect supplies, reducing the risk of further restrictions and supply outages while water resources remain under pressure.

While household customers would not be impacted, we recognise these restrictions have an impact on businesses, and we will provide clear guidance and support if the application is approved.

In the meantime, the hosepipe ban remains in place for all of our customers, and need customers to continue to take steps to reduce their water use as we do everything we can to protect water supplies.”

We are continuing to closely monitor river flows, reservoir levels and other water resources as the region enters the autumn and winter period.

We are also investing in the resilience of the region’s water supplies, including fixing around 70 leaks a day, strengthening our network, improving reservoirs and treatment works, developing new water resources and supporting customers to use water more efficiently.

No word from our former MP,  Simon Jupp, now firmly part of “Team SWW” – Owl

Leader Julian Brazil: drought declaration has been “decades in the making”

South West drought blamed on water firm’s ‘neglect’

A council leader has accused South West Water of helping create the conditions behind a severe drought declaration affecting parts of Devon and the wider South West.

Jonathan Morris www.bbc.co.uk

Devon County Council leader Julian Brazil said the drought had been “decades in the making” and the firm’s “neglect” had “put us here”.

He said the company had “not built the reservoirs Devon’s people and businesses deserved”.

South West Water said: “We are doing everything we can to manage resources, strengthen our network and fix leaks, and we need customers and local businesses to help reduce water use wherever possible to protect supplies until rivers and reservoirs can recover.”

On Thursday, the Environment Agency declared severe drought in parts of southern England including east Devon and west Cornwall.

South West Water’s drought programme director Richard Stanbrook said the declaration showed the “critical phase the South West is entering of this exceptionally prolonged drought”.

“While some recent rainfall has helped, water resources remain under significant pressure. We continue to rely heavily on reservoir storage to maintain customer supplies while river flows remain extremely low, with no significant rain forecast in the coming weeks.”

Wimbleball Reservoir, which serves about 300,000 properties across east Devon, north Devon, Somerset, west Dorset and West Somerset, is at 14.9% capacity and Stithians in Cornwall is at 21.9%.

The Environment Agency said it expected reservoir storage to be about 75% at this time of the year.

After the severe drought announcement, the government said customer supplies would be uninterrupted and declaring severe drought “ensures proactive steps are taken to safeguard water before any disruption occurs”.

Water companies have been ordered to monitor reservoir and river levels daily and the Environment Agency is stepping up compliance checks on firms that withdraw water from natural sources.

Brazil called on South West Water to pay for a large-scale public information campaign to encourage water conservation, reduce leakage and bring forward plans for new reservoirs.

He said: “From its own deep pockets, South West Water must fund a huge communications campaign to conserve water, cut leakage, bring forward plans for new reservoirs and make sure it is keeping every customer, business and public body fully informed so we can to do what we can to help.”

Brazil also said the company should compensate customers and businesses if they suffered losses during the drought.

“They agreed to pay 10 times the paltry minimum compensation level after the Brixham water poisoning incident. If businesses and customers suffer loss during this drought they must do so again.”

He urged people across Devon to use water carefully to help avoid restrictions, warning that any further measures limiting supply could have a serious impact on both the economy and daily life.

“As a council we will be doing all we can to save water while still delivering vital public services but we cannot allow South West Water to fail again and will be holding them to account in the months to come,” said Brazil.

Farmers have already reported the impact of the dry conditions. Andrea Semmens, whose family runs the 1,500-acre Raftra Farm, near St Levan, in Cornwall, said potato yields had fallen sharply.

“We normally average about 15 to 16 tonnes per acre and just because of the growth and the lack of wate we’re looking around 10 to 11 tonnes,” she said.

Semmens added: “When you’re growing 310 acres, that’s quite a lot of tons of potatoes that we’ve missed out on.

“That’s going to have a knock-on effect on our profit and money going forward for our next year’s harvest.”

About 56,000 households are within the severe drought area in west Cornwall.

Richard Foord on the challenges of providing health care to rural and coastal communities

Richard Foord MP tells it as it is to the government minister [Karin Smyth MP, Bristol South] during a Westminster Hall debate on underperforming NHS Trusts, inspired by the Lib Dems 14 October.

Richard Foord Liberal Democrat, Honiton and Sidmouth 

It is an honour to serve with you in the chair, Mr Stuart. I am grateful to my  hon. Friend Marie Goldman for securing the debate.

When we discuss underperforming trusts, we must recognise that some NHS trusts are operating in circumstances that would challenge even the best management teams. The Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS foundation trust serves a largely rural and coastal population, with an ageing demographic, workforce pressures and significant barriers to access. I do not want to blame the Royal Devon leadership team. This is certainly not about blaming hard-working staff, because they do a brilliant job in very trying circumstances. But let us face it: the geography and demographics are stacked against them.

The chief medical officer, Sir Chris Whitty, has repeatedly highlighted the unique health challenges facing rural and coastal communities, including when he visited Devon in May this year. Sir Chris has warned of

“the health challenges of coastal towns”, and that of attracting staff in such areas is significantly harder, noting that transport links are often limited. In his 2023 report Sir Chris warned:

“People living in peripheral areas experience issues relating to accessing primary and secondary healthcare, domiciliary care, medicines, shopping and transport. The response times of health care professionals are often longer because of the distances involved, which is particularly important for emergency presentations”.

Steve Brown, the director for public health in Devon, said:

“In Devon, our records show that some people are dying up to 15 years earlier than they should because essential building blocks of health…like reliable transport…and services that people can reach…are missing.”

My constituent Hilary Robarts-Arnold, from Seaton, wrote to me to describe the lack of transport and the difficulty of getting services in east Devon. Her husband is increasingly frail and suffers from skin cancer. Until recently, he attended dermatology services at Axminster hospital, seven and a half miles away. Those local services have now gone, and patients are instead forced to trek to Exeter, if they can. For her and her husband, that would be 22 miles, which is simply not possible because it is just too challenging a distance. As a result, his cancer is not being dealt with. The RDUH told me that

“this is a workforce and capacity issue, not a reflection of the clinical priority we place on patient care”.

If Government oversight of NHS trusts is to be meaningful, they must recognise the realities of rural and coastal healthcare and weight funding accordingly.

Devon leaders demand Government stop the money drain on Local Government Reorganisation

Local government minister Jim McMahon said he has almost completed his review and pledged decisions would be made “with a straight bat”.

[The government is facing legal challenges over local government reorganisation in the vast majority of two tier areas, with just four out of 19 of its decisions not facing judicial review, LGC research has found.]

Implementation of these proposals would have cost around £100m which instead should be invested in frontline services. We’ve already been forced to spend nearly £2 million on responding to the original proposals. – Cllr Julian Brazil

Chris Collman www.devonairradio.com

County leaders are demanding answers from the Government on its stalled plans for local government reorganisation to allow funds to be freed up for frontline services.

Last month, national plans including proposals to replace the two-tier local government structure in Devon with four unitary authorities from April 2028 were suspended by Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) following the threat of legal action from councils nationwide.

Since then, the County Council has been seeking clarity and also applied for a judicial review of the Devon proposals which will be triggered if they are resubmitted in their original form.

Approximately £2.1 million has been spent by the County Council in connection with the reorganisation and full implementation could cost an estimated £100 million.

County Council Leader Julian Brazil says he would prefer to work constructively with Whitehall to drive service improvement and growth instead of taking the matter to court.

Councillor Julian Brazil added:

“We welcome the fact that the Government has chosen to accelerate devolution and look again at Local Government Reorganisation. The government’s proposals for Devon would have introduced a model which was unworkable, unpopular, and threatened to derail enormous progress we’ve made in supporting young people.

“Implementation of these proposals would have cost around £100m which instead should be invested in frontline services. We’ve already been forced to spend nearly £2 million on responding to the original proposals.

“Local government delivers many of the day-to-day services that our residents rely on, especially the most vulnerable. Creating areas on maps and then trying to force services to fit those geographies is absolutely the wrong approach.

“I want us to work with Government and district councils, health bodies and the private sector to invest our energy and funds into rewiring Devon. If we can get these basics right first, then economic growth will follow. It doesn’t work the other way round.”

Councils need certainty on infrastructure before growth, Paul Arnott tells Prime Minister

The Leader of East Devon District Council has written to the Prime Minister warning that councils are being put in an impossible position when planning for new homes.

Chris Collman www.devonairradio.com

Councillor Paul Arnott says local authorities are having to identify sites for housing growth without enough confidence that the infrastructure needed to support those homes will be delivered. 

He argues that local authorities should not be forced into decisions that may risk environmental damage because of uncertainty over investment plans from infrastructure providers.  

The letter follows years of concern about wastewater infrastructure in the region. In 2024, East Devon District Council passed a vote of no confidence in South West Water, because of fears about the impact of inadequate infrastructure on local communities and the company’s ability to support future development.  

Now, Councillor Arnott is calling the Prime Minister to strengthen coordination between councils, regulators, developers and infrastructure providers so that growth and infrastructure are planned together. 

Councillor Arnott said: 

“We’re committed to building the new homes our communities need and have developed a clear plan for where growth should happen in East Devon through years of evidence gathering and public consultation. 

“But we’re increasingly being asked to make difficult decisions about future development because, if the promised infrastructure investment fails to materialise, there are consequences for our communities and environment.” 

The issue is particularly relevant to Marlcombe, the proposed new community east of Exeter.  The development is expected to grow to around 25,000 residents over time, but there are concerns that the preferred wastewater solution may not be operational until 2032, despite the first homes being planned from 2030. 

Councillor Arnott says the situation highlights a growing national risk that decisions on where development takes place could be driven by infrastructure constraints rather than democratically approved Local Plans.  

He said: 

“The Prime Minister has rightly talked about giving more power to local communities and supporting good growth in every postcode. For that to work our Local Plans must shape future investment, not the other way around. 

“I’m concerned that infrastructure providers could end up having a greater influence over development than local communities, because councils are left with little choice but to prioritise sites based on where utility companies say there is capacity, rather than those identified through democratically agreed Local Plans.” 

“If government wants local authorities to deliver ambitious housing targets, they need to get everyone around the same table and make sure growth, infrastructure and environmental protection move forward together. 

“At the moment, councils are carrying the responsibility for growth without the certainty they need to act in the public interest and to make that growth sustainable. That must change.” 

More correspondence on closure of Exmouth Post office

A correspondent writes:


The closure of the Exmouth’s Post Office is causing great difficulties to many people. We need a solution to be sorted out very quickly although I think the suggestion by Post Office Ltd (POL) that it might take up to 6 months is disingenuous. I believe 22 TG Jones branches that had post offices have been closed during September alone. According to press reports, TG Jones had post offices in 180 branches and ‘as many as 60 could be closed’. Does POL have the resources to set up new arrangements for that many locations within 6 months? It seems unlikely.

There is then the question of the contract that WH Smith had with POL.

On 15 May of this year, the Guardian reported that Modella Capital, the private equity group that bought and renamed the loss-making WH Smith branches, had ‘written to creditors saying it will amend Post Office contracts so that outlets that lose their leases can be closed with just 56 days’ notice – less than a third of the current notice period of six months’.

It appears that this plan was implemented, given that we had only about 5 weeks’ notice that the Exmouth branch was to close.

How was Modella allowed to ‘amend Post Office contracts’? Presumably POL agreed to the amendment.

Why did POL not insist that the Post Office branches remain operational for the full 6 months’ notice period? This could be done in Exmouth: it seems highly unlikely that the landlord will find a new tenant for the shop, so surely Modella could be made to keep the Post Office open even if the rest of the shop is bare?

Given Modella’s reputation, it seems possible that POL was told that if it didn’t agree to the change in the contract, Modella would put TG Jones into administration. There is nothing to suggest that this is what they did, but it might explain why POL appears not to have enforced the contracts: if it was a question of sacrificing 60 Post Offices to save 120, perhaps the managers thought that accepting the change was the lesser of two evils.

POL is, in effect, owned by the Government. It has a legal responsibility to provide specific services within communities. Surely the responsible Minister should be explaining why the country is facing the loss of branches that provide these vital services to millions of people?