Planning Application: Tipton St John primary relocation plus housing development in Ottery St Mary- Refused

At another long session this afternoon EDDC Planning Committee went against the Planning Officer’s recommendation and refused the application.

This application conflated the relocation of the school with a development application for 150 houses.

The final decision hinged on councillors balancing harm against benefits and coming down on the side that the harms: from building the school and houses in a countryside location; and the wider visual impact on Ottery; outweighed the benefits especially considering that the proposed development did not meet the 50% affordable housing requirement for building outside the built up area boundary. I.E. that the proposal contravened several Local Plan and Neighbourhood Plan policies.

Refusal: 11 votes to 2 with 2 abstentions

 Here is what Claire Wright has to say:

Claire-wright.org

EDDC planning committee refuses 150 houses and relocation of Tipton school

East Devon District Council’s planning committee has just refused a “tough” application for a relocation of Tipton St John Primary School, accompanied by 150 houses, on the edge of Ottery St Mary.

The application was refused by 11 votes, with two votes in favour and two abstentions.

The application, submitted by Devon County Council, was triggered to try and protect school places in the Ottery area, as Tipton St John Primary School has been deemed a ‘risk to life’ by the Environment Agency for flooding reasons.

There were 132 objections, including from Ottery St Mary Town Council and EDDC ward members Geoff Pratt and Vicky Johns, both of whom spoke this afternoon.

Several objectors, who live near the proposed development also raised concerns.

Speaking in favour were two governors, a representative from Devon County Council and Tipton St John Primary School headteacher, Colin Butler, whose testimony relating to the danger for his young pupils crossing the road to the upper site to safety when in flood, made me feel really sad.

I have worked with Colin on various projects for years, including trying to resolve this issue. He is an excellent and caring headteacher.

I spoke firstly to outline the background, which was essentially that the government rejected a bid under the priority schools programme in 2015 to rebuild the school away from the floodzone.

A piece of land in the village had been identified and there had been positive negotiations with the landowner. Sadly, after almost a year, the government rejected the funding bid, despite being fully aware that there was risk to the life of the pupils.

It left Devon County Council with a £5m shortfall and casting around in vain for other options and the application that was refused today, was the option it pursued.

Unfortunately, because of the £5m shortfall, Devon County Council’s proposal for a new school, also included 150 houses to help finance it. The application was contrary to the existing Local Plan, the Ottery St Mary and West Hill Neighbourhood Plan and is outside Ottery St Mary’s built up area boundary.

Officers said it was a finely balanced application and recommended approval on the basis the benefits outweighed the downsides.

The planning committee disagreed but still took almost two and and a half hours to refuse it.

Chair, Eileen Wragg, said it was a ‘tough’ application.

It isn’t clear yet whether Devon County Council will appeal.

While I believe the decision was the right one in the circumstances, I fully felt and identified with the understandable anger of the governors who spoke – and also the sadness in Colin Butler’s voice as he addressed the committee.

I have spoken at EDDC planning committees maybe hundreds of times over the years and won some and lost some.

But I have never felt so sad about the position I took as I did today.

Pic. Helping clear up after a flooding event in 2016.

Lower Otter Restoration Project – latest

Owl has received reports that EDDC planning committee approved the Lower Otter Restoration Project unanimously this morning. A few more conditions were added to those recommended by Planning Officers as a result of the committee listening to the concerns of residents in Frogmore Road.

The debate lasted all morning.

Consultation extended over masterplan for Clyst Valley regional park in East Devon

A public consultation has been extended to give people more time to consider plans for a huge new regional park spanning the Clyst Valley in East Devon.

About Author Becca Gliddon eastdevonnews.co.uk 

The closing date for the Clyst Valley Regional Park public consultation has been extended by more than a week to 9am on Monday, January 18, 2021.

The extension has been made to give people more time amid coronavirus restrictions to comment on proposals for the large green space.

The green space will take in Clyst St George, Broadclyst, Poltimore, Killerton, Ashcylst Forest, Cranbrook, Whimple and Bishops Court.

Many areas proposed for the Clyst Valley Regional Park are not currently accessible to residents and visitors.

A masterplan for the project suggests improvements for the next 25 years and aims to restore nature and historic buildings, create trails, and tackle climate change and flooding.

Councillor Geoff Jung, East Devon District Council’s (EDDC) portfolio holder for coast, country and environment, said:“I’m very pleased to see the number of people and organisations that have responded so far with some very interesting suggestions and ideas.

“However, because we are unable to hold public meetings or meet people at the moment due to the pandemic, it has been agreed to extend the consultation period to allow people some extra time to read the proposals and to submit their views.”

Some of the ideas mooted in the masterplan include:

  • A Clyst Valley Trail linking the Exe Estuary Trail to the Exe Valley Way;
  • An extension to Cranbrook Country Park;
  • A land-based learning centre and café at Broadclyst Community Farm;
  • A new cycle trail linking Cranbrook to Exeter along a quiet route;
  • Renaturalising the River Clyst between Clyst Honiton and Cranbrook;
  • A major increase in trees through both planting and natural regeneration;
  • A new visitor hub at Ashclyst Farm and cycle/pedestrian links into the forest from Cranbrook, Broadclyst and Killerton.
The area covered by the proposed Clyst Valley Regional Park. Image: EDDC

The area covered by the proposed Clyst Valley Regional Park. Image: EDDC

EDDC said the Clyst Valley was ‘on the doorstep of a rapidly growing population’ in the west end of East Devon.

The district council said ‘now more than ever, it is crucial that local people can get outside, enjoy nature and explore the East Devon countryside for their health and wellbeing’.

Devon MPs have their say on Lockdown 3

“The Government has spent billions of pounds on its failed track and trace system and an app that has never worked – it needs to be investing similar sums in a 24 hour 7 day a week vaccination programme – which is the quickest and only guaranteed way out of this crisis.” (Ben Bradshaw MP)

Daniel Clark www.devonlive.com 

Devon MPs have reluctantly agreed that a third national lockdown is necessary and have called on residents to their bit to win the fight against Covid-19.

England has entered lockdown 3, with the measures set to be approved in Parliament tomorrow, with the restrictions likely to last for at least six weeks.

People will have to stay at home and only to leave their house for essential reasons, including shopping, working (if not possible to work from home), exercise, and medical assistance.

Primary and secondary schools and colleges are to move to remote learning, except for children who are vulnerable or whose parents are key workers, and people identified as being clinically extremely vulnerable must begin shielding.

MPs have said they will be voting for the measures, except for Anne Marie Morris, who said that it will do more harm than good and a national lockdown is not the right solution because the virus is not impacting everywhere equally.

Ms Morris, who has been sceptical of previous lockdowns and who voted against the second lockdown, said: “Devon has been both luckier and better prepared than most to deal with the unpredictable impact of Covid. Indeed Devon is taking urgent cases from elsewhere that are not coping. That is the strength – and the duty – of a national NHS. The facts are the virus is not impacting everywhere equally.I do not therefore believe a national lockdown is the right solution for the following reasons.

“Clearly we must all take personal responsibility for limiting transmission. And the vast majority of us do. Tiering guidance was helpful. But a national lockdown won’t make bad people good. Our police forces are not equipped to enforce all these new- and confusing rules- across the whole country.

“We should not underestimate the huge steps made to deal with this virus in healthcare terms – including medicines and new vaccines. But it will still spread.

“So we need to get to grips with the urgent priority of properly resourcing our hospitals with the doctors and nurses needed and the oxygen supply in high demand. There are medically qualified people coming forward but not getting to the front line because of bureaucracy and red tape- cut it. The Nightingales have the oxygen and the delivery system – let’s use it not keep them in mothballs.”

She added: “Every action has consequences- some unintended and some unknown. This new lockdown will have as the last ones did very serious non-covid health consequences. It’s not just missed hospital appointments for those with other urgent and acute conditions, it’s the unseen mental health consequences which are just as life threatening as Covid. Mental health problems in the young have doubled.

“The economy and the state of the nation’s health are inextricably linked. It’s easy to say health matters more than the economy- of course it does -but a poor economy will drive up ill health. Depression is sky rocketing. Mental health support isn’t there in the quantity needed- and that will have consequences.

“With so little analysis and so little data across all these issues the government has made a decision to impose lockdown. I cannot support it. I very much fear it will do more harm than good.”

But the rest of the cohort of representatives have indicated that they will be supporting the lockdown, however difficult that the decision is and despite the impact it will have on our lives, but have demanded that the rollout of the vaccine is sped up.

Simon Jupp, MP for East Devon, said; “Although the restrictions on our everyday lives are difficult to accept, they are in place to protect us, our loved ones and the NHS. I’d like to thank everyone involved in the rollout of the two vaccines, which has already resulted in thousands of people in East Devon receiving their first dose. We have a duty to protect lives and livelihoods, and the multi-billion-pound package of measures announced today will support hospitality and small businesses through this difficult period.”

Sir Gary Streeter, MP for South West Devon, said: “Of course, I will be voting for it as the new variant is threatening to overwhelm the defences we had very carefully put in place. It is vital that we ensure that the NHS is not overwhelmed. The good news is that by the end of February most of the vulnerable people in our country should be vaccinated and during March we can expect some return to near normality.”

Neil Parish, MP for Tiverton and Honiton, said: “I will be voting for the new measures. The new strains are highly transmissible and spreading very seriously across the country. We need to stop the transmission and protect those most vulnerable to the disease until vaccination. The furlough scheme has been extended, new business grants are available and we need to do everything it takes now to support people in staying at home and saving lives.”

Selaine Saxby, MP for North Devon, said: “It is very disappointing that 2021 has to start with another national lockdown, but the situation with the new variant, and pressure on much of the NHS, unfortunately in my mind makes this a necessary step.

“The vaccination programme will rollout alongside this lockdown, which I hope will give us all hope that this will be the light at the end of the pandemic tunnel.”

For more of the latest news near you, sign up to receive our newsletters.

The daily and weekly bulletins are simple, easy to read and we’ll only send the most important stories.

Our teams are committed to bringing you the latest news, guiding you through this global pandemic and writing the stories that matter.

See our Devon newsletters here, sign up for bulletins from Cornwall here and pick your Plymouth emails here.

MP for Central Devon Mel Stride said: “This latest lockdown is sadly necessary. We now need to see the vaccine distributed as quickly as possible.”

Kevin Foster, MP for Torbay, said: “As the Prime Minister outlined, our nation faces a significant danger and we cannot pretend there is an easy alternative to the work which must be done to meet it, especially given the pressure on our NHS today and what it is expected to face over the coming weeks. We must therefore unite to face this threat.

“Thanks to the hard work and dedication of our local health and care teams, plus the commitment of the whole community to do their bit, our bay has thankfully not faced the impact other areas have had, but it is all too predictable what would happen if the virus did hit our bay hard. Therefore whilst this evening’s announcement is not what anyone wants, it is what is needed.

“While in these dark winter nights we face a darker threat from the pandemic, we can all see the ray of hope offered by the vaccination programme and the promise it brings of ultimate victory.”

Ben Bradshaw, the Labour MP for Exeter, said: “This will come as a bitter blow, but is clearly essential to save lives and prevent the NHS being overwhelmed. We are paying a very high price for Boris Johnson’s dither and delay. We went into the autumn lock down too late, came out too early and the chaotic relaxations over Christmas have created a perfect storm.

“Mr Johnson & his Ministers must urgently now deliver a support package to affected businesses and for individuals being forced to self-isolate. The vaccination programme is also proceeding too slowly.

“The Government has spent billions of pounds on its failed track and trace system and an app that has never worked – it needs to be investing similar sums in a 24 hour 7 day a week vaccination programme – which is the quickest and only guaranteed way out of this crisis.”

Anthony Mangnall, MP for Totnes had previously said that he would not vote for any further lockdown, but that the speed and scale of the rise in cases, hospitalisations and deaths meant that he reluctantly had to change his mind.

He said: “The numbers are that much higher and in a short period of time they have jumped up, so you have got to move with where the numbers are. It has to be the last one now that we have the vaccine as the cost is crippling, but it is important that we get this right and we are able to say to people it is the last mile in the marathon, while it is frustrating and difficult, the finish line is there and we are going to cross it and we are going to cross it together

“But we must get the vaccine rolled out at pace and be on a war time footing to get people vaccinated. Vaccinations are happening but I want to see the Government doing millions of doses a week, not 300,000 a day.

“We should be bringing in military reservists and using empty schools, empty pubs, any building that has been closed because of Covid, and we have to streamline the system so volunteers can come forward, get the logistics companies in to the move the vaccine across the country at pace and have mass vaccination sites open as well.”

Devon County Council have said they stand ready to help those who are most badly affected by the latest lockdown, the council leader John Hart declared today.

And Cllr Hart appealed to everyone in the county to abide by the rules and defeat the latest virulent strain of the virus,

“I have been speaking to the county’s MPs this morning and I will be chairing a meeting of Team Devon tomorrow,” said Cllr Hart.

“I know so many people have already been badly affected by this terrible virus and the measures we’ve had to take to try to control it.

“Grandparents haven’t seen their grandchildren, families have had to balance working at home with helping to care for their children and those children have missed out on learning and seeing their friends at school.

“And now we are asking them to make those sacrifices all over again. So I want to be clear that we stand ready to do all we can to help those most badly affected by this lockdown, as we did in the two lockdowns last year.

“At least this time we can see some light at the end of the tunnel with the vaccination programme, which I hope the Government will ensure is rolled out at speed.”

Cllr Hart said he welcomed the Chancellor’s new package of aid for the hospitality industry, saying: “I have been calling for the Government to provide specific help for hospitality businesses which are so vital to Devon and the South West but we need to see all the details. Many of these small businesses are already on their knees and they may need more support.”

He praised people’s efforts during the last nine months which had kept Devon’s infection rate amongst the lowest in the country but he added: “We need people to behave now. This is a more virulent strain of the virus and it’s spreading rapidly in other areas.

“People need to go into lockdown and stay there to prevent it getting more of a hold in Devon. This virus doesn’t spread itself, it’s people who spread the virus.”

Cllr Neil Jory, Leader of West Devon Borough Council, added: “Despite the best efforts of our communities, we find ourselves once again in lockdown, which is disappointing, but not entirely surprising when we look at the national picture.

“I thank our residents again for continuing to follow the government’s guidance, with the increased hope that infection rates will soon decrease now that vaccines are being administered around the country. By mid-February, our most vulnerable residents and critical health workers will be protected, with the rest of our residents following soon afterwards.”

Cllr Judy Pearce, Leader of South Hams District Council, said: “We are of course disappointed to be in national lockdown, however it was inevitable that it would happen sooner, rather than later as infections rise quickly around the country.

“There is growing pressure on hospitals in our region and we must do what we can to support the NHS. We know that these difficult times are extremely hard on our communities and we want to assure them that we are continuing to do everything we possibly can to support them.

“It seems there is light at the end of this tunnel with vaccines now being rolled out and we must continue, as we have been already, to work together to keep our vulnerable residents and communities safe.”

Tomorrow is “Super Wednesday”: EDDC planning committee to determine two applications that have divided communities

The first is the Lower Otter Restoration project and the second is the Tipton St John primary school relocation to Ottery St. Mary and associated 150 new homes.

Both have been recommended for approval by planning officers.

Youtube link to virtual meeting which starts 10am:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmNHQruge3LVI4hcgRnbwBw

St. Isidore Farm, Combe Raleigh,Planning Application 20/2563/FUL – time running out for comments

This application seeks associated operational development in conjunction with the approval 20/0686/PDR for the change of use of an existing agricultural building to a shop. The prior approval was granted on the basis of permitted development. However, the impact on this small village will be considerable as is described by Dunkeswell and Otterhead District Councillors Colin Brown and David Key. The current “operational development” proposals are not considered in keeping with the relevant AONB and Local Plan policies. 

Is this another example of the thin edge of a development wedge of which Owl has seen and is seeing too often in East Devon’s AONBs? Barn to shop to …… 

Tomorrow is the deadline for comments.

Link to previous post.

Covid: Can we really jab our way out of lockdown?

“Fill and finish” is the catch phrase – Owl

[Your place in the queue can be found at the bottom of this post.]

Nick Triggle www.bbc.co.uk

With the country in lockdown and a new faster-spreading variant of coronavirus rampant, it’s clear the UK is in a race to vaccinate.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson wants all the over-70s, the most clinically vulnerable and front-line health and care workers to be offered a jab by mid-February, to allow the restrictions to be eased.

That requires about 13 million people to be given the opportunity to be vaccinated – but so far only one million have been.

And ensuring a quick rollout to the rest is fraught with difficulties.

There is enough vaccine in the country, BBC News has learned, but getting it into people’s arms could be hampered by:

  • a global shortage of glass vials to package up the vaccines
  • long waits for safety checks
  • the process of ensuring there are enough vaccinators

How could a shortage of glass disrupt supply?

Two Covid vaccines have now been approved – one produced by Pfizer-BioNTech and another made by Oxford University and AstraZeneca.

The UK government has ordered 140 million doses – enough for the whole population.

The first hurdle is manufacture of the vaccine.

This involves two crucial stages – the production of the substance and then a process called fill and finish whereby the vaccine is put into vials and packaged up for use.

And there is already a concern about the latter stage, with the availability of key ingredients and equipment including glass vials a key issue.

England’s deputy chief medical officer Prof Jonathan Van-Tam says fill and finish was a “critically short resource across the globe”.

That is part of the reason why the amount of the two vaccines ready to go is more limited than ministers had hoped.

UK plants have made somewhere around 15 million or so doses of the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine – that in itself is less than ministers said would be made at this stage (early in the pandemic they said there would be 30 million by the autumn).

But only four million have been through the fill-and-finish process.

The UK has used plants in Germany and the Netherlands to do some of this for the early batches.

But the government has also invested in a plant in Wrexham to ensure there is domestic capacity.

The Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, meanwhile, is made outside of the UK – it comes from a plant in Belgium.

When it arrives in the UK, it has already been placed into vials.

But so far, fewer than five million doses have been delivered – less than half the number that should have been – because of problems with manufacture, including the fill-and-finish process.

Are the final checks taking too long?

Even once a vaccine is in the vials though, there is still one more step before the NHS can start using it.

Each batch has to be checked and certified by the Medicines and Healthcare Products regulatory Agency.

And it can be several weeks before the vaccine can be given to the NHS to put in people’s arms.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson has called this a “rate-limiting factor”.

About four million doses of the Oxford vaccine have been available for some weeks – they were put into vials last year – but as yet only just over 500,000 have been certified as safe to use.

Sources close to the NHS vaccination programme said this had been one of the key frustrations – saying it was taking up to 20 days for batches to be tested and released.

The MHRA said each batch had to be biologically tested for quality, while the manufacturer’s documentation describing its production and quality-control testing process was reviewed.

Those close to the process say it does take a couple of weeks – and with more vaccine being produced, there is increased demand on the labs that do the work.

“You have to remember this is being injected into people,” they said. “We cannot rush this.”

Both vaccines have to go through this process.

What have hospitals, GP practices and racecourses got to do with it?

Once batches have been certified, they are ready to be distributed to the NHS vaccination centres.

Eventually, there will be a network of more than 1,000 local centres across the UK.

Currently, just over 700 are up and running.

These are being run from a wide variety of venues, from hospitals and large GP centres to community venues, racecourses and, perhaps in the future, conference centres and sports stadiums.

The instability of the Pfizer-BioNTech has been well documented.

It has to be kept in ultra-cold storage and, once thawed, used within five days.

This has meant it is stored at major hospitals and gives the local vaccination centres just days to use up batches after they are delivered.

The Oxford vaccine, meanwhile, can be stored at fridge temperature, which makes it easier to distribute.

But even once they are at these vaccination centres, delivery of both vaccines is dependent on having the right numbers of staff available.

Currently, GPs, nurses, healthcare assistants and pharmacists are giving the vaccines.

But as the vaccination campaign ramps up, these will need to be supplemented by additional vaccinators.

Provision has been made to train other health professionals, from physiotherapists and dentists to dieticians.

But there are reports an “overload of bureaucracy” – including mandatory courses in fire safety and preventing radicalisation – is slowing down this training.

Ministers have said they will try to reduce the bureaucracy – amid warnings by the National Audit Office an army of nearly 50,000 vaccinators will be needed.

Although at the moment, there are thought to be enough staff to cope with the limited amount of vaccines available.

British Medical Association GP leader Dr Richard Vautrey said: “We will need support eventually but not now.

“At the moment, the biggest issue is the NHS having enough supply of the vaccine to give.”

Can the UK hit its mid-February target?

Nearly a million doses have been given since people started to receive the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, in early December, which puts the UK third globally in the most vaccinations done per head.

And with the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine being used from this week, the NHS is hoping to double that number in the next seven days.

Government sources said there would be disappointment if it did not reach two million doses a week by late January.

That – and a little bit more – will be needed to hit the mid-February target.

But even then, and assuming most people in these priority groups have come forward, the impact would not be immediate.

It takes a few weeks for the immune response to kick in.

So it would be early March before the full impact of the vaccination of these priority groups is felt.

Then, however, it could have a significant effect.

Close to nine in 10 Covid deaths have been in these priority groups.

They will have had only one dose, which, for the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine, is effective at preventing 70% of infections.

But the evidence suggests this will be enough to stop serious illness.

So if all goes to plan, the pathway to significantly easing restrictions comes into view.

But the complex nature of the supply chain coupled with the complexity of delivering vaccines to large numbers of people means it will take just one thing to go wrong to cause serious problems getting the UK out of this lockdown in the timeframe hoped.

Paul Arnott: What does 2021 hold for East Devon?

“Actions in 2021 need to speak louder than words.

East Devon District Council leader Paul Arnott writes about the challenges ahead.

www.exmouthjournal.co.uk

So here we are, Christmas has come and gone and we are hurtling towards 2021. It all feels like we have been on a bumpy spaceship ride across the solar system, can’t quite now find somewhere to land, and despite this have to fly on for another year in the slightly damaged craft we’ve been steering since March.

The patch of this country which I feel responsibility for – East Devon – faces the same extremely tough questions as the rest of the nation. Schools – open or close? Vaccinations – do we have the capacity, and is it going quickly enough? Food – supply chains are holding, but more and more people are genuinely going hungry. How can we all expand and co-ordinate campaigns to help?

Sports and Leisure Centres – ours have been hammered by Covid-19, and everyone wants to support them. But with one a quarter million pounds of district council money needed to support them up to Easter, can we afford to, when the government is only helping us to the tune of a quarter of a million? That’s a £1 million shortfall.

What about climate change? The clock is ticking, but can we move fast enough to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels and move to greener energies? What more must we do to conserve our local environment?

And that’s before we start to worry about the local economy. Most people want to work to support themselves and their families, and to fulfil their potential. Yet we are looking at an awful contraction of the economy this year, and for many new jobs will not exist. So how do we get our heads together to support new endeavours and to skill up and train our local people?

Where, too, will we all live? The need for genuinely affordable, attainable homes is more marked than ever. How do we structure our strategic planning efforts at the district council to put this at the forefront of our efforts? Could we use publically owned land, should we go into partnerships with small or medium building companies to deliver it, and perhaps also encourage self-building? Or are we doomed to have massive developments pushed upon us against our will by stock market listed developers?

What will next year’s tourist season look like? If vaccination has been rolled out to cover most people by June, will we have an amazing three and four months of greater visitor numbers than ever? And can we cope with that, do we have the vision and the joined up infra-structure?

If anyone is interested in what keeps a council leader awake at night, I offer you the above for starters.

But in spite of it all, I have always been a glass half full person. For good things to happen, however, there are two crucial words we need our ruling government class to abide by – Good Faith.

National politicians of the governing party have made a series of promises on the Brexit-dividend, a Green-led economic recovery, a vastly better-resourced National Health Service. On the basis of those promises, just over a year ago the Prime Minister was given an eighty seat majority in the House of Commons.

Those voters were not stupid – they put a cross on the names of Simon Jupp, Neil Parish and Mel Stride (our MPs covering various parts of East Devon) in Good Faith. We all understand the extraordinary headwinds of the year just gone, and how some shocking mistakes were made from the man at the helm.

Our MPs, however, are meant to represent our needs and views to the national body politic. I have no reason to doubt that all three men are characters of Good Faith. In 2021, in all of the issues above, I will be seeking confirmation of that in the interests of the people of East Devon.

Actions in 2021 need to speak louder than words.

What do we know about vaccine supply and is it rate-limiting?

There is,as yet, little official information on some of the critical factors in the vaccine roll-out.

Owl has been scouring the press to try to find out what is known about vaccine supply when it became clear that the Government’s original target had not been met. 

This comes from a longer article in the Telegraph: 

Robert Mendick, 3 January 2021 www.telegraph.co.uk

On Vaccine Supply: 

“Mr Johnson has blamed a lack of vaccine supply for the current take-up. “The rate-limiting factor at the moment, as they say, is supply not distribution,” he told a Downing Street press conference. Professor Chris Whitty, England’s chief medical officer, has said “vaccine shortage is a reality that cannot be wished away”.

But the pharmaceutical companies disagree. There are officially 530,000 doses of the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine ready to go from Monday, along with an additional 450,000 arriving in the next 24 hours, according to Professor Sir John Bell, the Oxford University regius professor of medicine and a Government adviser. 

On top of that, a further three million Oxford doses are in vials awaiting safety checks – a process that should take a few days – with 15 million more waiting for “fill and finish”, the process of filling vials and packaging the vaccine for distribution. AstraZeneca says that process is straightforward and also should take only days. 

Each batch, according to Government sources, needs to pass a 20-day sterility test and randomised quality checks before it can be used, requiring a staggered delivery.

Meanwhile, Pfizer has shipped “millions” of doses to the UK in 21 shipments, the first of which contained 800,000 doses. The Telegraph understands there are about five million Pfizer doses in vials ready for use in the UK. 

Added up, there are close to 24 million doses of vaccine either ready for use or available in a short space of time. 

The Government has committed to buy 40 million Pfizer doses and 100 million from Oxford/AstraZeneca. Both firms say they are on track to deliver the vaccines to the Government’s agreed timetable.”

Lockdown and schools to close in England – Lockdown 3

What Boris Johnson’s announcement means.

Eve Watson www.devonlive.com 

Prime Minister Boris Johnson has placed England into a third national lockdown from midnight.

Mr Johnson said earlier today that “further steps must now be taken” to stop the spread of the virus and save lives.

A No 10 spokesman said: “The spread of the new variant of Covid-19 has led to rapidly escalating case numbers across the country.

“The Prime Minister is clear that further steps must now be taken to arrest this rise and to protect the NHS and save lives.”

The new strain of the virus means cases are rapidly increasing. There were 26,626 Covid patients in hospital in England recorded on January 4, which is an increase of over 30% on the same day just one week earlier.

The peak of admissions in first wave of coronavirus was 18,974 on April 12, but the nation is now 40% above the highest level of the first wave.

It has been confirmed that the UK has increased from Alert Level 4 to 5, which is the highest level. This means there is a real risk of healthcare services being overwhelmed within 21 days without urgent action.

This comes after an announcement earlier today by Nicola Sturgeon, who said mainland Scotland will be plunged into a new national lockdown from midnight tonight for the rest of January – with schools closed.

The First Minister unveiled tougher measures to curb spiralling infection rates.

Schools across the mainland will stay closed until at least February.

The Christmas holidays had been extended until January 11, with online learning until January 15 – but children were expected to resume face-to-face lessons on January 18.

Ms Sturgeon confirmed schools will now be shut to the majority of pupils – all those except vulnerable kids and key workers’ children – until February 1.

That includes nurseries, primary and secondary schools.

Devon is currently in Tier 3 restrictions, after moving up from Tier 2 in December.

Six hospital patients in Devon who tested positive for coronavirus have died according to today’s NHS England figures.

The figures, taking into account deaths reported in the 24 hours up to 4pm on January 3, show that six deaths were confirmed across Devon and Cornwall’s hospitals.

Four were recorded at Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital (RD&E) and two at North Devon District Hospital.

This brings the total deaths of patients with coronavirus at RD&E hospital to 165.

The announcement this evening is to try and combat the rising number of deaths and cases nationwide.

These are all the things you can and can’t do in Devon, and the rest of the nation, in lockdown.

What can I do?

You can leave the house to:

Go to work if it’s impossible to work from home, e.g. construction or critical worker who can’t work from home

To shop for necessities including food and medicine

To exercise, which can be with up to one other person from outside your household or bubble. The exercise should ideally be limited to once per day.

To provide care or help to a vulnerable person

To attend medical appointments or seek medical care or fleeing the threat of harm or violence.

Police will have legal powers to enforce through fines and dispersing orders.

All primaries, secondaries and colleges will move to remote provision from tomorrow except children of key workers and vulnerable kids who can attend in person.

Early years – e.g. nurseries, alt provision and special schools – remain open.

Childcare and support bubbles – existing rules will apply.

Nursery age, vulnerable and kids of critical workers over 5 can still attend childcare.

Students will not be able to return to uni and will be expected to study from their current residence where possible until at least mid February.

In person teaching at university only for a small number of critical courses previously announced such as those studying to work in the health service.

Business and hospitality

All non essential retail hospitality and personal care services must shut if not already/remain closed.

Restaurants and similar can continue delivery or takeaway – BUT takeaway or click and collect of alcohol will no longer be allowed.

Essential retailers e.g. supermarkets, pharmacies, garden centres, builders merchants may stay open.

Places of worship open for individual prayer and communal worship but obey social contact rules and only attend with household and support bubble.

Zoos and other animal attractions have to close.

Playgrounds remain open.

Outdoor sports venues including gyms, tennis courts and golf courses must close.

Outdoor team sports will not be permitted.

Elite sport – Premier League etc – that will continue as can PE lessons and sports clubs for children attending school (i.e. critical workers / vulnerable kids).

Shielding

Stay at home as much as possible and should only leave for exercise and health appointments.

Don’t go to work even if you cannot work from home, and avoid busy places including shops and pharmacies.

International travel

Essential journeys are permitted

Jenrick must stop this race for houses at all costs

Phillip Inman, writing in the Observer, discussed the division between those who want to rethink their lives after Covid and those wanting to return to “normality”.

Top of the list for change in his opinion is the need to re-examine housing:

“ …… Inside the Treasury, there is a conviction that only volume matters. It rules all other considerations and leads the housing, communities and local government secretary, Robert Jenrick, to side with developers at every turn. He has torn up the plans of countless local authorities on the grounds that they don’t include enough housing.

Jenrick cares little about the size of the homes and whether the abundance of pokey one- and two-bedroom flats with open-plan kitchen/dining/living areas is fit for a 21st century in which at least one person may be working from home.

It only takes one graph revealing a decline in the annual rise in commuting to a city – any city – from the surrounding area for all the profits from a major housing development to evaporate.

There are still projects across the south-east being promoted by Jenrick that need extra public transport links to be viable. How will these work when many people say they will refuse to travel on public transport until the vaccine has done its work, and maybe not even then?

Hopefully, a Labour government would begin to see towns as places that people should want to live and work in, and would aim to reduce the number who commute, going with the grain of modern urban ideas. The party should challenge the outmoded view that large cities are the only routes to growth and say that a reassessment of what an economy needs to be successful – GDP growth is not necessarily the measure – is a priority……”

Phillip Inman www.theguardian.com

‘Impossibly high number’ of new homes for East Devon scrapped by government

There is good news! – Owl

The Government has announced a U-turn decision on the number of new homes that must be built annually in East Devon.

Becca Gliddon eastdevonnews.co.uk 

Proposals to build 1,614 houses in the district each year have been cut by almost 700 after The Government announced its decision to shelve original plans.

East Devon District Council (EDDC) today (January 4) welcomed the changes, which will see an annual reduction of 686 new builds – a 42.5 per cent decrease.

The district council had raised concerns with The Government over the proposed numbers – similar to other authorities – with councillors saying the proposals ‘lacked any rhyme or reason’ and would have been ‘impossible’ to achieve without putting pressure on East Devon’s protected landscapes and habitats.

The council also raised fears of the ‘immense pressure’ original numbers would put on services and infrastructure such as schools, hospitals and roads to accommodate the increase in population.

In a report to the council’s strategic planning committee meeting, on 16 September 2020, councillors declared ‘no logic’ to The Government’s proposed approach other than to deliver the 300,000 homes nationally per year and reach targets.

Councillor Dan Ledger, EDDC portfolio holder for strategic planning, said: “This is great news and I am massively relieved that we do not now need to plan for an impossibly high number of new homes in the district for no good reason.

“Instead, we can focus on delivering a new Local Plan which delivers an appropriate balance between protecting everything that makes East Devon so special while delivering the new homes and jobs that our communities need.”

Last August The Government consulted councils across the country on the changes to the way it calculated the number of new homes that must be built.

The Government has now published a response to the findings, taking EDDC’s comments on board, along with that of other local authorities.

Consultation results included deciding to scrap the proposed changes and keeping unchanged the way Westminster calculates the number of homes that must be built in each area.

In a bid to deliver more homes, numbers are to increase by 35 per cent on previously-developed or brownfield land

As a result of The Government’s findings, more homes will be built in Plymouth and Bristol.

Beggars Belief

Best Western hotels could be turned into hundreds of ‘cottage hospitals’ to ease NHS Covid strain

But what about the staff? – Owl

Alex Winter www.thesun.co.uk

HUNDREDS of Best Western hotels could be turned into ‘cottage hospitals’ to ease the strain of the pandemic on the NHS.

The chain has offered to hand over as many as 500 of its inns to support the health service as another strict lockdown begins in England.

Area breakdown as 1,259 new Covid-19 cases recorded across Devon

There were 1,259 new cases of Covid-19 recorded across Devon in the seven days to December 29, according to figures released today (January 3).

Ian Hughes www.devonlive.com

Cullompton reported more positive tests than any other area during that time, with 48.

Elsewhere, there were increases of 35 in Cranbrook, Broadclystand Stoke Canon, 32 in Ottery St Mary and West Hill, and 29 in Middlemoor and Sowton.

Over the same time period, the highest infection rate was also recorded in Cullompton  – with 545.8 new cases per 100,000 people.

It was followed by rates of 381.4 in Alphington and Marsh Barton, 372 in St Leonard’s, and 359.3 in Ottery St Mary and West Hill.

Across the UK, the death toll now stands at 75,024 and 2,654,779 people have tested positive since the beginning of the pandemic.

This represents an increase of 454 and 54,990 respectively in the past 24 hours.

AreaNew positives23-Dec to 29-DecRate per 100K23-Dec to 29-Dec
Alphington & Marsh Barton28381.4
Appledore & Northam North349.2
Ashburton & Buckfastleigh449.8
Axminster664.4
Babbacombe & Plainmoor589
Bampton, Holcombe & Westleigh13189.9
Barnstaple Central463.1
Barnstaple Pilton6102.9
Barnstaple South18202.5
Barnstaple Sticklepath7118.7
Bere Alston, Buckland Monachorum & Yelverton9142.1
Bideford North12201.4
Bideford South & East13101.5
Bishop’s Nympton, Witheridge & Chulmleigh687.9
Bishopsteignton & Shaldon9134.4
Blatchcombe & Blagdon649.8
Bow, Lapford & Yeoford8125.6
Bradninch, Silverton & Thorverton19227.2
Bratton Fleming, Goodleigh & Kings Heanton348.8
Braunton14148.4
Brixham Town774
Budleigh Salterton7112.6
Central Exeter23190.3
Chagford, Princetown & Dartmoor10144
Chelston, Cockington & Livermead12109.6
Chillington, Torcross & Stoke Fleming353
Chudleigh & Bovey Tracey10102.5
Churston & Galmpton8118.2
Clifton & Maidenway9126.6
Clyst, Exton & Lympstone7102.4
Countess Wear & Topsham12155.6
Cranbrook, Broadclyst & Stoke Canon35260
Crediton8100.9
Cullompton48545.8
Dartmouth6110.6
Dawlish North13153
Dawlish South344.7
Dunkesewell, Upottery & Stockland8137.8
Ellacombe468.6
Exmouth Brixington11169.9
Exmouth Halsdon12173
Exmouth Littleham20266.2
Exmouth Town681.2
Exmouth Withycombe Raleigh15202.3
Exwick & Foxhayes15198.3
Feniton & Whimple23262.6
Fremington & Instow13203.2
Goodrington & Roselands456
Great Torrington350.2
Hartland Coast8122.9
Hatherleigh, Exbourne & North Tawton882.9
Heathfield & Liverton21325.5
Heavitree East & Whipton South9119.3
Heavitree West & Polsloe16187.4
Higher Brixham00
Holsworthy, Bradworthy & Welcombe988.8
Honiton North & East7115.7
Honiton South & West12218.1
Horrabridge & Mary Tavy9148.3
Ilfracombe East474.3
Ilfracombe West467.8
Ipplepen & Broadhempston00
Ivybridge16136.1
Kilmington, Colyton & Uplyme559.9
Kingsbridge7107.8
Kingskerswell12195.3
Kingsteignton778.6
Lifton, Lamerton & Bridestowe12180.5
Loddiswell & Dartington25346
Lynton & Combe Martin591.2
Marldon, Stoke Gabriel & Kingswear12160.1
Middlemoor & Sowton29231.1
Mincinglake & Beacon Heath457
Morchard Bishop, Copplestone & Newton St Cyres794.3
Moretonhampstead, Lustleigh & East Dartmoor14237.9
Newton Abbot, Broadlands & Wolborough8138.7
Newton Abbot, Highweek697.6
Newton Abbot, Milber & Buckland9160.6
Newton Abbot, Town Centre9143.9
Ogwell, Mile End & Teigngrace13155
Okehampton792
Ottery St Mary & West Hill32359.3
Paignton Central00
Pennsylvania & University1194.6
Pinhoe & Whipton North19202.8
Poppleford, Otterton & Woodbury00
Preston & Shorton14158.7
Roundswell & Landkey12129.8
Salcombe, Malborough & Thurlestone10193.6
Seaton00
Shebbear, Cookworthy & Broadheath342.4
Shiphay & the Willows766.2
Sidbury, Offwell & Beer474.1
Sidmouth Sidford00
Sidmouth Town357.3
South Brent & Cornwood336.1
South Molton990.3
St James’s Park & Hoopern993.9
St Leonard’s25372
St Marychurch & Maidencombe8138.4
St Thomas East16195.5
St Thomas West14192.4
Starcross & Exminster14162
Tavistock15119.6
Tedburn, Shillingford & Higher Ashton10185.8
Teignmouth North670.9
Teignmouth South00
Tiverton East9121
Tiverton North & Outer16184.2
Tiverton West8126.8
Torquay Central10131.4
Totnes Town00
Uffculme & Hemyock16234
Upton & Hele693.6
Watcombe00
Wellswood789.2
Wembury, Brixton & Newton Ferrers10147.6
Westward Ho! & Northam South9141
Willand, Sampford Peverell & Halberton9123
Winkleigh & High Bickington795.7
Wonford & St Loye’s16193.1
Woolacombe, Georgeham & Croyde11204
Woolwell & Lee Mill11179.3
Yealmpton, Modbury & Aveton Gifford8103.8

Covid UK: Critically-ill patients from overwhelmed wards in London will be sent to West Country

More reports of critical patients being transferred to the South West:

Health officials today warned that people as young as 30 ‘will die from Covid’ as NHS hospitals in the West Country brace for an overspill of critically-ill patients from London under emergency plans.

Trusts in London and the south-east at the centre of the UK’s epidemic are preparing to transfer patients to hospitals in the south-west while patients in the east of England will be moved to the Midlands.

The massive Nightingale hospital at the London Excel Centre, which was created in record-time early in the pandemic only to be swiftly mothballed, is also expected to reopen within a fortnight, the Times reports.

National pairing arrangements have been put in place amid warnings from doctors that hospitals in the South have come under ‘immense pressure’ due to a surge in cases of ‘mutant’ Covid, with hospitals across the UK being told prepare to face the same Covid pressures as the NHS in the capital.

Full article can be found here: Jack Wright www.dailymail.co.uk

Struggling first time buyers living in Dorset ‘ghost village’ buy homes built for locals only

The nine homes have been built in Worth Matravers on the picturesque Isle of Purbeck, a  peninsula in Dorset.

Sixty per cent of the 180 houses there belong to second homeowners and lay empty most of the time. The average price of property in the area is about £400,000.

But the new homes have been sold at 75 per cent their market value and offered to people who live or work in the village or surrounding area.

When the homes are eventually sold on in the future there is a covenant stating they must go to local people with the 25 per cent price reduction in place.

The new-build properties have been built by Dorset-based housing association East Boro.

Full article here: Milly Vincent www.dailymail.co.uk 

Planning applications validated by EDDC week beginning 21 December

Vaccination – How quickly can the Government deliver?

There are a number of press articles discussing different aspects of the administrative task facing the Government and questioning whether it can expedite the vital task of getting “jabs into arms”.

For example, yesterday’s Times published an article under the heading: “Postcode lottery for life‑saving Covid vaccination”. This claimed that almost one in four people in England live in an area with no vaccination centre and 13 million people live in a constituency with no hospital, GP practice or community building for administering vaccines.

It contained a graphic showing that the three Devon coastal constituencies of: Totnes; Torbay and East Devon only had one centre each whilst all the other Devon constituencies had two and Exeter three (the two Plymouth constituencies have one each).

But the roll out of the the Oxford/AstraZeneca virus doesn’t necessarily require dedicated centres and is likely to be administered in a similar way to the ‘flu vaccine. The next two article indicate where, in Owl’s opinion, the real bottleneck lies.

The Observer view on information about the rollout of the Covid vaccine 

Observer editorial www.theguardian.com 

Tomorrow, Britain will witness an extraordinary moment in its grim struggle to limit the devastation caused by Covid-19 when the first Briton is injected with a vaccine developed by the University of Oxford and the pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca. The fact that this inoculation is occurring within a year of the emergence of a disease that has since ravaged the globe is an astonishing achievement, a tribute to world-class British science and a highly effective pharmaceutical industry. More importantly, the vaccine has arrived just in the nick of time. The newly discovered variant of Covid-19 is threatening to spread across the country and savage our beleaguered health service. A vaccine offers escape from the mounting horrors of this pandemic.

It is therefore right to celebrate the arrival of the AstraZeneca vaccine, though we should also note the pitfalls that await us. We are led by a government that has bungled so much of the Covid response – from its initial, criminally tardy response to the virus, to the shambolic distribution of PPE kit for health workers, to the pitiful rollout of test-and-trace programmes and to the bewildering U-turns on lockdown measures. We need drive and competence to undertake the speedy administration of the vaccine to millions of UK citizens. These qualities have not been displayed in abundance by the government to date.

On the other hand, early signs suggest the vaccine programme has been handled well. Shrewd choices were made in the selection of vaccines to purchase. The early rollout has been managed well and there is evidence of careful thought in the choice of early recipients. Equally, the decision to postpone the administration of second doses – to maximise numbers receiving first doses – suggests scientists and doctors advising the government are responding to the rapidly changing shape of the virus’s spread.

The decision has not been without its critics, and it will certainly have caused some alarm among older and more vulnerable citizens and their carers. They had expected to receive a second dose within days but will now have to wait for weeks. Rearranging thousands of appointments at short notice adds to the administrative burden facing already hard-pressed clinics and surgeries.

Nevertheless, chief medical officers are agreed this is the right move, both ethically and practically. Recipients of the first dose of the Covid-19 vaccine still gain strong protection. Indeed, delaying a booster jab may even trigger longer-lasting immunity. This, in turn, allows millions of others to be given protection in the short term against a virus that threatens to spread rapidly across the UK. Any alternative would mean that people who could have been saved might face death.

Scientists, doctors and nurses have worked wonders. Now, politicians and administrators must seize the advantage they have been handed and bring an end to the suffering this terrible virus has inflicted on us. And they need to do so in a manner that reassures the public that salvation is at hand.

Here, the signs are less encouraging. Boris Johnson was asked last week how many vaccine doses are going to be made available over coming weeks but claimed exact answers would be unhelpful. Nothing could be further from the truth. The nation needs to know – specifically – how many doses are going to be administered week by week. Will it be a million? If so, we will have to wait a long time before lockdown ends. Or is it going to be 2m doses a week? In this case, an enjoyable summer would look a more realistic prospect. (Nor is vaccinating two million people a week that difficult. We inoculate against flu every winter on a similar scale.) A lot depends on these figures and Britain now needs to be told if we have the supply chain to match the efforts of our scientists and doctors. In blunt terms, our hopes of ending our misery rest on being given an accurate account of those numbers.

Britain ‘pays price’ for running down vaccine factories

Anyone in Whitehall ever consider the need for “strategic industries” are we just a service based economy? – Owl

Rhys Blakely, Science Correspondent www.thetimes.co.uk 

A lack of investment in capacity to produce vaccines left Britain woefully unprepared to face the pandemic, one of the country’s leading scientists said yesterday.

Sir John Bell, regius professor of medicine at Oxford, was instrumental in forging the partnership between the university and Astrazeneca to develop a British vaccine.

Yesterday, however, he voiced frustration that years of neglect by successive governments had left the country without the means to manufacture the vaccine at the pace required in a pandemic.

Britain has been forced to rely on repurposed infrastructure to make the Oxford vaccine, he said. “The government has been completely disinterested in building onshore manufacturing capacity for any of the life-sciences products,” he added. “I’m not talking about this government, I’m talking about all governments for the last ten years.

“And it turns out that manufacturing is a strategic asset for health security when stuff gets tough, which it is now.”

In May the government said that 30 million doses of the Oxford-Astrazeneca vaccine could be available by September but the target was later slashed. Last week Matt Hancock, the health secretary, said that only 530,000 doses would be ready to go on Monday.

Meanwhile, Pfizer-Biontech, which produce the UK’s only other vaccine in Belgium, said yesterday that their supply chain was overstretched.

Chris Whitty and the chief medical officers for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland warned that supply was the biggest barrier to maximising the number of eligible people who receive the vaccine. “Vaccine shortage is a reality that cannot be wished away,” they said.

Sir John said vaccine production had been allowed to wither in the UK. “When the pandemic started, we were not in great shape and I think we are probably paying the price for that. It’s not Astrazeneca’s fault — it’s a national legacy issue, and it’s one of the things we’ve got to fix.”

Other countries had shown it was possible to produce the vaccine in large amounts, he added, with the Serum Institute of India (SII), the world’s largest vaccine maker by volume, saying it has at least 50 million doses in vials ready to be used in clinics.

“We know people can make this vaccine at scale, that’s absolutely for sure,” Sir John said. “I think the fact that some people have many more stocks than we do probably reflects that we are operating on repurposed infrastructure.”

Astrazeneca was chosen as a partner by Oxford as one of the few companies with the ability to win regulatory approval for a new vaccine and to oversee large-scale production. It has struck deals to produce 3 billion doses around the world.

However, to produce the UK’s doses, the company has relied on a consortium of outside partners. They include Oxford Biomedica in Oxfordshire, Cobra Biologics in Staffordshire as well as a company called Halix in the Netherlands.

Once those companies make the vaccine in bulk it goes to a plant in Wrexham, run by an Indian company called Wockhardt, where it is decanted into vials, or transported to a similar plant in Germany.

In May the government said it would invest up to £93 million to speed up construction of the new Vaccines Manufacturing and Innovation Centre in Oxfordshire.

First announced in 2018, it is expected to eventually have capacity to produce enough doses for the whole UK population in as little as six months. However, it will not open until this summer and Sir John noted that Britain also lacks capacity to produce other medical products, such as monoclonal antibodies, at large scale.

He said Professor Whitty had been right to warn about supply problems. “There’s a potentially huge capacity to get vaccines into people,” he said. “And I think Chris was right when he alerted everybody to say supply is going to be an issue. If I had unlimited vaccine, I’d try and get the whole bloody country done in a month — because if you really wanted to you could.”

The Serum Institute of India supply is nearly ten times the 530,000 doses the British government has said will be released to the NHS on Monday.

SII expects to double its stockpile to 100 million doses — enough for 50 million people to be fully immunised — by the middle of this month. Half will be kept for India and the rest will go to 67 low and middle-income countries.