Oh dear, Swire really doesn’t like the Lib Dems – surprise! Real Tories don’t eat tofu!

Atticus column, Sunday Times, page 21:

“Not every Conservative felt as comfortable in coalition as David Cameron. Former Foreign Office minister [Sir – Owl refuses to recognise croney titles] Hugo Swire, interviewed by the Institute of Government, explains the advantages of winning a majority in 2015: “We didn’t have to listen to the Lib Dems whingeing on about compulsory sandals or tofu for lunch or whatever.” Is that quite the spirit?”

Owl says: stereotyping, puerile and arrogant. Nothing new there then.

NHS crisis? Not in Swire’s backyard!

Our MP’s questions in the House this week:

Written Answers – Foreign and Commonwealth Office: North Korea: Politics and Government (26 Jan 2017)
https://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2017-01-18.60636.h&s=speaker%3A11265#g6

Hugo Swire: To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, what plans he has to discuss the political and human rights situation in North Korea with the incoming US administration.

Written Answers – Foreign and Commonwealth Office: North Korea: Politics and Government (26 Jan 2017)
https://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2017-01-18.60631.h&s=speaker%3A11265#g60631.q0

Hugo Swire: To ask the Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, what discussions he has had with his counterparts in (a) Japan,
(b) South Korea and (c) China on the political and human rights situation in North Korea.”

Swire to East Devon Alliance on NHS crisis – doctors are in control!

I think he may mean people with doctorates in things like “Economics of Privatisation” are in charge!

“You may be interested to see what my local MP Hugo Swire has to say about the NHS Bill and the mythical additional “£10billion”. Do doctors feel as though they are in “operational control for the day-to-day running of services”? I retype his letter here in full:

“Dear Cllr Dr Gardner, Thank you for your email dated 23 November.

I believe that the proposed NHS bill would be the wrong approach to improving the NHS. In my view, giving operational control for the day-to-day running of services to doctors was the right decision as they have the best understanding of their patients and local needs.

The Government has actively supported the NHS’ own plan for the future. that is why it is providing the additional £10 billion of investment per annum in real terms by 2020/21 – compared to 2014/15. Yours sincerely……H Swire”

Claire Wright on NHS cuts

This is the benefit of having a local person representing local issues – unlike our MP Hugo Swire who seems to have far too many fingers in other non-local pies.

And, if his debates on NHS underfunding and school funding cuts is anything to go by, no power whatsoever to change or even slightly affect his party’s line.

https://www.facebook.com/bbcspotlight/?hc_ref=PAGES_TIMELINE

Swire’s expenses

“The amount claimed in expenses by East Devon MP [Sir]* Hugo Swire during the last financial year has been revealed.

The data, published by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA), shows the amount claimed between April 2015 and March 2016.

The figures show that [Sir] Hugo claimed £164,381.75 – the fifth highest amount claimed out of the nine MPs who were sitting in Devon for the whole of the period in question.

This was made up of £140,905.27 spent on staffing, £8,506.29 spent on accommodation, £8,013.09 spent on travel, and £6,957.10 spent on office costs.

[Sir] Hugo declined to comment on the figures.”

*[Owl] refuses to recognise crony titles.

All this money spent for US – well, when he’s not so very busy chairing the Conservative Middle East Council and swanning around the middle east with our arms salesmen (more expenses) or relaxing in his mid-Devon second home.

But good to know his staff (including his wife) are being well remunerated.

And, post-Brexit, East Devon can surely look forward to many special trade deals with Saudi Arabia (though they are probably unlikely to be Fairtrade deals!).

Perhaps he could help us buy some cheap sand for our coastal defences.

And maybe Sidmouth could twin with Jeddah (though the ladies of Sidmouth might have to stop driving and have male guardians).

Swire worried about MPs being “taken down”

Hugo Swire MP
9 January 2017

Question in Parliament

On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Many will be alarmed by the recent reports of attempts by a foreign Government to “take down” Members of this House, including a senior Minister. Given the very serious implications of this matter, what measures will you take to investigate it, not least because one party to the discussions, according to the press coverage, was, or is, at least partially a paid employee of this House?”

https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2017-01-09a.68.0&s=speaker%3A

Catch up with Swire in London and hear his views about Palestine

Monday, January 23, 2017 from 6:00 PM to 6:45 PM (GMT)

CMEC PALESTINE PROGRAM

Palestine: the case for recognition

The Rt Hon Sir Hugo Swire KCMG MP, CMEC Chairman

in conversation with

Sir Vincent Fean KCVO, former Consul General to Jerusalem

This discussion will be focused on Palestinian statehood and what impact British recognition of a Palestinian state might have.

The discussion will also consider the recent UN resolution against Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem, the potential impact of Donald Trump on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, and the UK’s role in supporting a peaceful two-state settlement.

The event will include a Q&A session.

Hugo Swire and Theresa May: NOT a match made in heaven!

“Some things about her, already evident to those who studied her pre-prime ministerial career, have become clearer to a wider audience. She hates conceited and condescending men who think they are terribly clever, a category that includes rather a lot of her Tory colleagues. This helps to explain the humiliating manner in which she dispatched many of the Cameroons from the government.”

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jan/08/theresa-may-control-freak-brexit-queen-misrule

Could this sort of protest persuade our Tory MPs to back the NHS?

Conspiracy theorists and fake news enthusiasts are already saying that this was organised to make Trump look good – hhhm! And can we see parallels here – nationally and locally?

“WASHINGTON ―

After a torrent of bad headlines, countless phone calls to member offices, and two tweets from President-elect Donald Trump, House Republicans dropped their plans to gut the Office of Congressional Ethics Tuesday, just minutes before the House was set to gavel in for the 115th Congress and adopt their rules package for the next two years.

The amendment ― authored by Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte (R-Va.) ― would have placed the independent congressional ethics office under the oversight of the House Ethics Committee, changed the OCE’s name and barred the office from releasing reports to the public. In effect, it would have neutered Congress’ most aggressive watchdog.

The decision to strip the Goodlatte amendment came just before noon on Tuesday as Republicans planned to begin the 115th Congress. Earlier in the day, responding to numerous news reports about Republicans gutting the OCE, Trump asked in a tweet whether Republicans really had to make the “weakening” of the ethics office their first order of business, though he also didn’t necessarily come out against the idea of eventually overhauling the OCE.

Ethics groups were quick to criticize House Republicans for the effort. A coalition of groups including the Campaign for Accountability, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington and the League of Women Voters sent a letter to House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) on Tuesday calling for the reauthorization of the OCE.

Several other groups, including the conservative Judicial Watch, called the move “shameful.” The nonpartisan group Common Cause even pointed out that exactly 11 years ago, lobbyist Jack Abramoff ― whose crimes helped lead to the creation of the OCE ― pleaded guilty to charges including fraud conspiracy and tax evasion. (Abramoff told Politico Tuesday that Republican’s efforts to gut the ethics watchdog are “exactly the opposite of what Congress should be doing.”)

Members reported that they had started getting a flood of phone calls from constituents concerned that Congress was neutering a key ethics watchdog.

“The calls we’ve gotten in my district office and here in Washington has surprised me, meaning the number of calls,” said Rep. Walter Jones (R-N.C.), who noted before the amendment was stripped that he would vote against the rules package if it remained in the measure. “People are just sick and tired.”

Some Republicans, including South Carolina Reps. Trey Gowdy and Mark Sanford, were reporting Tuesday that they would vote against the typically party-line rules package.

Facing public pressure and an internal mutiny, GOP leadership called a special meeting and told Republicans they needed to strip the OCE amendment.

Leaders told members they would instead work with Democrats to come up with a proposal to reform the OCE before the August recess, though a number of Republicans were unsatisfied by the promise.

Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa) said he would now work to completely abolish the Office of Congressional Ethics, citing concerns over anonymous whistleblowers making accusations against members and the OCE leaking information to the press.

Asked to provide an example of the OCE leaking information to the press, King failed to come up with one and got testy.

“Just google it,” he said.

Pelosi issued a statement after the amendment was dropped, noting the “clear contempt for ethics in the People’s House” that she said Republicans showed with their plan.

“Once again, the American people have seen the toxic dysfunction of a Republican House that will do anything to further their special interest agenda, thwart transparency and undermine the public trust,” she added. “Republicans should remember the strength of public outrage they faced in the space of 12 hours as they scheme to do lasting damage to the health and economic security of millions and millions of hard-working families.”

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/house-republicans-ethics_us_586bdb14e4b0de3a08f99e66?

Lib Dem revival in south-west?

“The picture-postcard villages in the Blackdown Hills are not normally the scene of political upheaval, but this corner of south-west England could be the scene of an unlikely political revival for the Liberal Democrats.

The countryside electorate here on the Somerset-Devon border are historically staunchly Conservative, but just before Christmas the Lib Dem Ross Henley took 71% of the vote with a swing of more than 40% from the Tories in a Taunton Deane borough council byelection with a respectable local turnout.

“To be honest I thought we would run the Tories close, I never ever dreamt we would get this vote,” Henley laughed, sitting in the tiny village shop cafe. “But now morale is really high. People helped in this byelection from all over the country.”

Lib Dem strategists are pinning their hopes for rebuilding after the dire results in 2015 on a resurgence in the south-west, their former heartland, where the party lost all 10 of its seats in the last election. Since then, the party has been quietly notching up its best council byelection results in 20 years, with a net gain of 28 seats compared with net losses for Labour of four seats, Ukip of three and the Conservatives of 33 seats.

On paper, this part of the country does not look like a happy hunting ground for the fervently pro-remain party, because of the high number of leave voters in the south-west. Yet more than half of those byelections gains were in the west country, most recently in Taunton and Teignbridge in early December, with the seats all seeing swings upwards of 20%.

Henley, who is also the county councillor, said he thought local leave voters had still backed him because of a personal relationship, but that his party was consistently winning over Tory remainers. “People did actually want to talk about Brexit on the doorstep,” he said.

“It seems to be redefining British politics in the same way the Scottish referendum did, it completely shook up the way people voted. Parties that have a muddled view on the big issues of the day generally tend to struggle. And we know where we stand.” …

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jan/03/morale-is-really-high-lib-dems-scent-revival-in-south-west

Funding cuts? No worries – Jill and Hugo will fix it!

Councillor Jill Elson responds to news that new “fairer funding” that will cut £79,000 from Exmouth College (and even bigger cuts at other East Devon schools):

Reacting to the ‘fairer funding’ proposals, college chair of governors Jill Elson said: “We are very disappointed at the loss of £79,000, because we were hoping for an increase, as Devon is one of the lower- funded councils and we have to find this from our budget.

“We are very concerned about the loss when we have been asked to increase our pupil numbers to 2,900 by 2020.”

And she writes to Swire, who responds:

“Mr Swire said: “I welcome that the Government is committed to reforming the school funding system. The current system is outdated and inefficient, meaning that schools in areas such as Devon have not received their fair share of funding.

“However, I am disappointed that, under the Government’s initial proposals, some schools in East Devon would lose funding.

“This would clearly be entirely unacceptable and I will be raising this matter in Parliament.

“It is important to remember that these proposals only mark the beginning of a lengthy consultation and I would encourage anyone with an interest in how our schools are funded to take part in this.”

http://www.exmouthjournal.co.uk/news/education/exmouth_community_college_faces_drop_in_funding_1_4831471

“‘Cameron’s Cronies’ backlash: Nominated peers could have to prove they have ‘record of significant achievement’ “

(Un)fortunately, this will not include Hugo Swire – Cameron’s Old Etonian contemporary and holiday companion – who was only given a knighthood. OK for impressing social climbers but offering no further political influence.

“Theresa May’s ethics adviser has suggested aides and party donors nominated for peerages should be forced to prove their suitability in the wake of the ‘Cameron’s Cronies’ scandal.

Lord Bew, chairman of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, told The Telegraph the idea of putting political appointments through rigorous interviews should be considered.

The crossbench peer said his committee was “very interested” in tighter safeguards to ensure that only those suitable to enter the House of Lords are picked.

However he warned that peers selected by the Prime Minister should not face identical criteria to those picked for the crossbench and said parties must be consulted on any change.

The reforms – which would amount to the biggest shake-up in the selection of peers for a generation – have been gaining traction in Parliament in recent weeks. …”

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/12/27/camerons-cronies-backlash-nominated-peers-could-have-prove-have/

My constituency is better than your constituency?

f1826bea-1580-4b83-8932-11d6bf977304-8591-00000854218eed39_tmp

Is it just Owl’s cynical nature or does this sound rather an unpleasant comment?And totally untrue – see Swire’s recent blog post:

Wednesday, 21 September, 2016
East Devon MP Sir Hugo Swire has called for the stretch of the A303/A30 between Honiton and Ilminster to become fully dualled.

In their South West Manifesto, the Conservatives pledged to invest £2 billion in the A303 meaning that much of the road is due to become dualled.

However, under current plans the stretch from Honiton to Ilminster is to be replaced with a three lane road.

The three possible route options are currently under public consultation.

Commenting, Sir Hugo Swire said:

‘Admittedly the stretch of the A30 which runs through my constituency is already fully dualled. However, my constituents use the Honiton to Ilminster stretch of the A303/A30 as much as anyone else and that is the basis of my interest.

‘I welcome the fact that a brand new road is now due to be constructed between Honiton and Ilminster instead of the original proposal to simply carry out minor improvements to the current carriageway. This road is already due to consist of three lanes and I would question whether adding an extra lane would have anything other than a very minor effect both in terms of financial cost and environmental impact.

‘I am not convinced that insufficient traffic along this stretch is a reason not to go for full dualling. If traffic numbers are low then this might be down to the fact that the road is clearly inadequate.

‘The bottom line is that our transport infrastructure in the South West has historically suffered from underinvestment and it is about time this changed. Our local economy, and especially our tourism industry, needs a modern and efficient road network.

‘This has been a political football for too long. We need to bite the bullet and deliver a first class solution rather than a second rate compromise’.

https://www.hugoswire.org.uk/news/swire-bite-bullet-and-dual-a303

£3 billion to go to Saudi Arabia to build up UK defence presence

No doubt Swire, in his capacity as Chairman of the Conservative Middle East Council, is there with BoJo.

And that’s £3 billion which the NHS will never see.

Budleigh Salterton health hub – Swire proud to have pushed it forward

Delighted that the Budleigh Hub has been given the green light. Pleased to play my part in pushing this project forward.”

Hugo Swire, Twitter, 30 November 2016

Do remember this when, after doing your (private) art class, (private) yoga class and drinking your (private) juice you have your very public heart attack and wait for your overworked public ambulance crew to take you to your overcrowded public hospital, where you will wait for overworked staff to treat you.

http://www.midweekherald.co.uk/news/health_bosses_give_assurance_east_devon_hospital_beds_will_not_close_until_stringent_measures_in_place_1_4801160

and perhaps think about another post on his Twitter account:

@HugoSwire what are your thoughts on Budleigh LoF [League of Friends] needing to fundraise to cover not-for-profit rent of space. #NHSPS totally immoral.”

Exeter NHS Rally: East Devon Alliance well represented, no Tory councillors or MPs spotted!

East Devon Alliance:

img_1357

Spotted in the crowd (not an exhaustive list as crowd too large): East Devon Alliance councillors Marianne Rixon and Cathy Gardner (also on Spotlight and Radio Devon), Sidmouth campaigners Di Fuller and Robert Crick along with town councillor Martin Shaw of Seaton and Independent Councillor Roger Giles of Ottery St Mary.

Many people attended from Exeter, Okehampton and North Devon.

No East Devon Tory Councillors or MPs sighted at all. Nor Exeter MP Ben Bradshaw.

New Devon CCG transformation: as transparent as a lead block

Owl recalls that claims were made that the “transformation” plans for the NHS were ordered by the government to be kept secret, and that attempts by mere mortals to get information about them through Freedom of Information requests should be actively resisted.

Well, here is proof.

A local elector made two requests for information (community hospital bed occupancy and objective evidence for the decisions made by New Devon CCG). Both of these requests have been ignored ( no reply within 20 working days) and the first noted is now 40 working days overdue – with a request for internal review of the decision also ignored. This is a necessary step that must be made before a formal complaint to the Information Commissioner.

Link to the request 20 working days overdue and not acknowledging the Internal Review request made 20 working days ago:
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/community_hospital_bed_occupancy

Second needed to be answered yesterday to be in time.

This is the important one – it will be reasonable to assume that either they have no clinical evidence whatsoever, or that they are deliberately avoiding answering because the evidence they have is negative:
https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/objective_evidence_of_the_clinic

Owl notes that none of our MPs appear to be trying to get this information for us – it is being left to local people to try to find out for themselves.

Hugo still very caught up with the Middle East …

What would he have done if he had not got the Chairmanship of the Conservative Middle East Council? Oh, right – he would have JUST been a constituency MP!

“speaker:Hugo Swire : 1 Commons debate
=====================================

Aleppo (28 Nov 2016)

https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2016-11-28a.1246.2&s=speaker%
3A11265#g1251.2

Hugo Swire: I think my hon. Friend meant airdrops rather than
airstrikes, but he is right that we can be proud of what we have done as
a country for those who are in the camps surrounding Syria. Today’s
urgent question is about those who are trapped in the most hideous
situation in Aleppo. What I believe Members are trying to convey to the
Minister is that we regard this as possibly one of the most… “