Farmer Swire! Calls out Countryfile and says Chris Packham “absurd”

Do you think he had his Barbour wellies on whilst saying this? And nice to see he got a publicity shot in for his developer friends at Crealy!

South-west Agriculture and Fishing
– in Westminster Hall at 4:38 pm on 19th October 2016.

“I pay tribute to my hon. Friend Scott Mann for securing the debate, which is particularly timely for me because I have my catch-up with the National Farmers Union at Crealy park in East Devon on Friday. We will hear a lot over the coming months and years about the threats and opportunities of Brexiting and it is up to us as parliamentarians to ensure that the opportunities trump the threats.

The threats are pretty obvious to the farming and fishing sectors. There are threats of access to markets—we do not know what shape they will take—and we have heard about freedom of movement issues, and of labour in particular, in the south-west, be that for people working in the poultry business or picking vegetables or daffodils further west. However, it seems to me that none of us will lament the passing of the common agricultural policy or the EU common fisheries policy.

We have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to answer the question: does farming have a future? That is a question that, if we get it right, we will no longer have to ask ourselves. This is a time to shape our farming, shape our fishing and shape our countryside, to show people that there is indeed a future. It is self-evident, of course, that we continue with arrangements as they are for now. It does need the Secretary of State to confirm this; we can continue with the status quo until we sign the decree absolute in the divorce from the EU. It is what happens after that is important, as we change the existing legislation to reflect what we want for UK policy.

I think this is genuinely a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for our farming industries and I very much hope that Ministers in the Department will not spend the next few months or years talking to lobbyists or large organisations, but talking to the practitioners on the ground. I hope they will talk to the supermarkets and finally get some sense out of them in promoting British products at fair prices. I hope they will talk to the Environment Agency and Natural England and other organisations to ensure they are refocused to support a farmed countryside, not the sanitised version of the countryside as evidenced weekly by programmes that the BBC so loves, such as “Countryfile”— or, even worse, by the absurd Chris Packham.”

https://www.theyworkforyou.com/whall/?id=2016-10-19a.375.0&s=speaker%3A1

Why is East Devon’s MP cherry-picking only his own community hospitals to save?

Hugo Swire says he is “fighting for” Exmouth and Sidmouth community hospitals. Though his idea of fighting for them whilst suggesting the NHS must economise, is somewhat disingenuous.

Neil Parish, whilst fighting for his own, says MPs should also be fighting for all of them.

Parish is right.

What happens if you live in Sidmouth and Exmouth and Sidmouth hospitals are full?

What happens if you live in Swire’s constituency and yet your nearest community hospital is in Parish’s constituency?

What happens if your hospital is closed because of infection? What happens if your hospital is closed for repairs?

What happens if the RD and E has a major incident on the M5 or Exeter Airport and has to ship out the least ill patients to other areas to cope?

People do not live in isolation and do not get sick in “efficient” places.

We need ALL our community hospitals for ALL of us everywhere.

Though East Devon’s MP, living as he does in mid-Devon and usually in the constituency on the odd Friday (when he fills his diary with photo opportunities and meetings from which he excludes the district’s county councillor) will quite likely never experience these choices.

Claire Wright on local NHS

Claire Wright has been battling to save our local NHS for YEARS while our two local MPs only noticed the problem a few weeks ago. The voice of common sense:

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/tories-playing-political-football-with-the-nhs-claire-wright/story-29821791-detail/story.html

Swire’s question in Parliament today – not about NHS or East Devon

Swire’s priority:

Sir Hugo Swire, a Conservative, asks if May will back the first ever meeting of Commonwealth trade ministers.

May says the government applauds this and is looking for trade deals with the Commonwealth. It wants to make a success of Brexit.”

And what a WASTE of a question! Was May REALLY likely to say: “The government thinks this is really daft and it wants to sabotage Brexit”?

No, it was one of those brown-nose, planted questions to make the government look good.

Swire on the NHS in Parliament – prepare to be shocked

Owl only had time to make quick notes on what Swire said about the NHS in Devon in the Parliamentary debate this afternoon. It will appear on BBC iplayer later so you can see for yourself.

Martyn Oates, Spotlight reporter, gave an overview of the afternoon with a few short clips of the debating chamber.

North Devon MPs said there was a crisis, especially in their area, there was not enough funding. Tory MP Cox said it funding was inadequate.

The ?Minister of State (Dunne) admitted it was a “challenging situation”.

Swire began by saying he thought the Minister was in a difficult situation as the plan is out for consultation [so why organise the debate if the Minister can’t say anything!] but it was good to see the Devon MPs there.

He said “we are where we are” [duh!] and “we have to make do” and it is a “process of change”, continuing with “we need a genuinely 21st century NHS”.

He toed the party line that the NHS had already been given an extra £8 billion for the year and then an extra £2 billion extra and Mrs May has said there is no more money.

Martyn Oates asked him for a comment on what Neil Parish MP had said [a flattering direct quote from Owl earlier this week on this blog] who said they should not be pitting themselves against each other hospital by hospital but fighting for them all.

Swire said that it should not become a “Dutch auction”. That was a bit difficult to understand for Owl, as a Dutch auction is one where the price (in this case number of hospitals) goes down and down till a buyer is found (or in this a minimum number is reached?) for what remains of them. As Swire IS championing keeping only Sidmouth hospital beds open, not keeping all Devon’s beds open, he is actually guilty of making it into what he says it should not be – some sort of auction – Dutch or Double-Dutch, who knows?

But Swire is an ex-auctioneer, so maybe he can explain that to us!

He then made what Owl considered a very snide remark about Parish being OK as, whatever happened, the 24 bed Tiverton hospital in his constituency would remain whilst saying NOTHING about the fact that Parish’s constituency is definitely losing beds at Honiton and could lose those at Seaton leaving his part of East Devon with no beds at all – Axminster already having list theirs).

He said there is a role for ” much-loved” hospitals but what that role is remains to be seen [double duh!].

He then finished with what he keeps repeating and which we must challenge: he said it is NOT true that a hospital without beds us not a hospital.

EAST DEVON: we MUST get this constituency out of this man’s hands.

Swire – which hand do you talk to when he holds opposing views at the same time!

BBC Devon – Martyn Oates repeats Swire tweet:

East Devon MP @HugoSwire: “We are using the NHS as a very expensive social care service and then asking it to make efficiencies”.

1. It’s you, not we – you, Mr Swire will rarely if ever need to use the NHS as you can easily afford private health and social care.

2. THIS IS WHAT YOU VOTED FOR IN PARLIAMENT AND YOUR BLOG SAYS EFFICIENCIES ARE POSSIBLE.

Hugo Swire bans Claire Wright from a meeting in her ward

“Hugo Swire bars me from a meeting about Tipton St John Primary School flooding problems

I was bizarrely barred from a meeting in my own ward this lunchtime, with East Devon’s MP and the chief executive of the Environment Agency, James Bevan, who met with Tipton St John school staff about the ongoing challenges of flooding at the school – an issue I have been active on for three years.

I have been involved in discussions on how the situation at Tipton St John may be remedied since I was elected as a Devon County councillor in 2013.

I asked to attend the meeting this morning, however, was informed by Hugo Swire’s office that I would not be welcome as he was “keeping the meeting very small and focused and had to limit numbers.”

I was very disappointed about being excluded as crucially important issues would be discussed that I have been actively involved with. Last year I provided funding from my county council locality budget for a flood survey and helped to clear up after at least two flooding events, arranging with the chief fire officer for Devon and Somerset, for the fire and rescue service to be involved in these clear ups.

I have attended meetings with residents about the future of the school and worked with the school – and the community on trying to find a solution to the flooding problems.

As the Devon County councillor for Tipton St John with a clear interest and involvement in supporting the community I would have thought it was entirely appropriate that I should have been invited to a meeting with the chief executive of the Environment Agency.

It was a poor decision”

http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/hugo_swire_bars_me_from_a_meeting_about_tipton_st_john_primary_school_flood

Swire on health and social care

Summary:

Home care is currently in trouble with local authorities having cut their funding.”

NO! NO! NO! YOUR GOVERNMENT HAS CUT FUNDING TO LOCAL AUTHORITIES!

“… social care is means tested and supplied by the local authority, whose grants, throughout the recent period of austerity have been cut.”

BY YOUR GOVERNMENT!

As to the blame game, it simply won’t get us anywhere.”

YES IT WILL – YOUR GOVERNMENT’S AUSTERITY POLICY GOT US HERE! YOUR GOVERNMENT HAS CHOSEN TO STARVE THE NHS TO FEED HS2 FOR EXAMPLE. IT HAS INSISTED ON TARGETS THAT CANNOT BE MET BY A DEFUNDED NHS AND THEN FINES HOSPITALS FOR NOT REACHING THEM!

(And be honest, if it was Labour in power YOU would be blaming Corbyn!)

Britain spends less as a share of its GDP on health care than most other rich countries. If taxpayers want that to change they will have to pay for it. And yes that might mean patients, diverted from expensive systems of care into cheaper ones.”

NO! IT CAN SPEND MORE ON THE NHS – IT WAS A CHOICE OF YOUR GOVERNMENT TO SPEND LESS AND UNDERFUND HEALTH CARE COMPARED TO OTHER COUNTRIEs AND TO SPEND MORE ON WASTEFUL VANITY PROJECTS. THIS IS A RICH FIRST-WORLD COUNTRY NOT A POOR THIRD WORLD ONE?

“As for surgeries, why can’t doctors deal with some patients by e-mail? it would mean they could devote more time to the seriously ill when they come in. Some people already pay for prescriptions, as they do for dental health, so is the answer for some other services to be charged for?

OWL CAN BARELY REPLY. YOU KNOW IMMEDIATELY THAT THIS MAN HAS PRIVATE HEALTH CARE! CAN YOU IMAGINE PEOPLE DESCRIBING THEIR SYMPTOMS BY EMAIL! AND HOW MUCH EMAIL DOCTORS WOULD HAVE TO PLOUGH THROUGH! AND WHAT IF THE PATIENT THINKS THE PROBLEM HAS TO GO TO EMAIL AND IT TURNS OUT TO BE AN EMERGENCY! OR WHAT IF EMAIL GOES DOWN OR YOU HAVE NO COMPUTER? WHAT ABOUT SECURITY AND CONFIDENTIALITY?

I have an online booking system for my surgery but my doctor tells me only a quarter of people turn up”

SO DOESN’T THAT MEAN EITHER IT IS NOT FIT FOR PURPOSE OR EVEN THAT THERE IS MORE SPACE FOR THOSE WHO DO TURN UP ON THE DAY!

And finally:

These are only ideas, and for many they will feel like a bitter pill to swallow.”

INDEED A BITTER PILL BUT, FORTUNATELY WE DON’T HAVE TO SWALLOW IT … WE CAN FIGHT BACK.

But it’s useful to see Mr Swire’s total toeing of his party’s line. We do know where we stand with him and his party – and for the majority it is NOT shoulder to shoulder but eyeball to eyeball.

Swire’s trips to Maldives fail to pay off

Hugo Swire was particularly fond of the Maldives during his time as Foreign Officer minister and made many tweets about its political situation and hope for future relations:

“The Maldives has withdrawn from the Commonwealth, accusing it of interfering in domestic affairs and “unfair and unjust” treatment.

The Commonwealth had warned the Maldives of possible suspension if it failed to show progress on democracy.
It has faced questions over freedom of speech, the detention of opponents and the independence of the judiciary.
The Indian Ocean nation became a multiparty democracy in 2008 after decades of autocratic rule.

The Maldives foreign ministry said in a statement: “The decision to leave the Commonwealth was difficult, but inevitable.

“Regrettably, the Commonwealth has not recognised progress and achievements that the Maldives accomplished in cultivating a culture of democracy in the country and in building and strengthening democratic institutions.”
It said that President Abdulla Yameen’s government had introduced a raft of measures promoting human rights and strengthening the rule of law.” …

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-37647310

Swire challenges “opposition”

…””My local political opposition [is] going to find it rather difficult to criticise me now… I’m afraid I’m going to slightly shoot their fox,” he says.

“Because all the things they say I don’t comment on, I now can and am… I no longer have to support the government.”

Topping the agenda in his newly assumed role as a backbencher is the region’s ailing infrastructure.

He shares the view that for too long the Westcountry has “suffered unfairly” from underinvestment.

“Just imagine if HS2 wasn’t going to go ahead – how much money that would release for the kind of infrastructure development we need in the South West,” he states.

“We had a good meeting with Network Rail and GWR this week, looking at their new rolling stock and the challenges to upgrade the line. [But] that’s something we’re going to have to really watch and make sure the funding is in place.”

He is also following developments with Devon Success Regime, including the campaign to keep beds in the local community hospital.

And he wants to make sure the region catches up with the roll-out of superfast broadband services.

“Every single Conservative candidate in the South West was elected on a Conservative manifesto, and it is up to every single member of Parliament to ensure their delivery is as good as their pledge,” he says.

Going from being one of he most well-travelled ministers in Government to a member of the “rank and file” has taken some getting used to.

The responsibilities associated with Mr Swire’s previous role made him heavily reliant on staff to manage his diary and provide briefings. Now, he admits he often struggles to make it to meetings on time.

However, he is staying involved with international affairs as deputy chairman of the Commonwealth Enterprise and Investment Council and head of the Conservative Middle East Council.

He says he hopes to see the UK taking more of a lead on Syria – pointing out that it would be a “wonderful opportunity” for Boris Johnson “to show what hes made of”.

“You’ve got Putin.. responsible for some biblical atrocities [and] I weep for the people of Syria,” he says. “This is a good opportunity for Britain to show some leadership.”

http://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/no-plans-for-a-quiet-retirement-to-the-backbenches-for-devon-mp/story-29806840-detail/story.html

Er, not quite true Hugo – your work with the Conservative Middle East Council seems to be taking up an awful lot of your time – breakfast meeting the Egyptian Ambassador (London), talking at a Conservative fundraising dinner in Kensington and Chelsea (London), meeting about Christians in Syria (London), chatting to the Saudi Foreign Minister … still busy on non- constituency matters in London.

And heaven only knows how busy you will be as deputy chairman of the Commonwealth Enterprise and Investment Council!

Oh, and as for getting to meetings on time – don’t forget to add in the time it takes to get from your mid-Devon second home to your constituency.

A tale of two AONBs

A gas-fired power station has been proposed for the East Devon village of Hawkchurch on the East Devon- West Dorset border NEAR an AONB (Area of outstanding Natural Beauty) in Dorset. It was not put out to consultation to the local community.

West Dorset MP Oliver Letwin says of it:

This development will have an impact on the West Dorset AONB.

“I do not believe it is appropriate, or in line with national planning policy, for industrial installations to be located in ways that have such impact on landscape of national importance. I hope, therefore, that this application will be refused.”

Councillor tries to extend consultation period on ‘power station’

In East Devon, an industrial site is being planned WITHIN the AONB at Sidford – after it had been agreed that it would not be allowed in the Local Plan but slipped in because officers did not offer up evidence to a Planning Inspector to remove it.

The local MP, Hugo Swire, has said …

… absolutely nothing at all.

Hard-working MP

Hugo Swire has put nothing on his MP web page since a very lukewarm response to East Devon bed closures on 22 September, after which he was made Chairman of the Conservative Middle East Council.

He has done 19 tweets since then: 10 on national or international issues and 9 on local issues – including 5 retweets from other sources.

His three latest (written) questions to Parliament were all about penalties for using mobile phones whilst driving:

https://www.theyworkforyou.com/search/?pid=11265&pop=1#n4

According to his official MP page his wife, who is his paid assistant at £35,000-£39,999 pa, does his website and press releases, though we don’t know if she also does any of his tweets:

http://www.midweekherald.co.uk/news/exclusive_hugo_swire_mp_in_the_herald_s_hot_seat_1_452145

Perhaps his wife is on holiday.

MPs who hire family must prove they are the best people for the job says watchdog

MP Hugo Swire has employed his wife Alexandra (Sasha) at a salary of between £30,000-£39,995 a year for many years.

Has anyone ever seen Mrs Swire or spoken to her in a parliamentary rather than political or personal capacity? If so, it would be great to know.

MPs who hire their wives and children as staff will be made to prove they are the best candidate available, the new head of the expenses watchdog has indicated.

In her first interview in the job, Ruth Evans, chair of the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority [IPSA], said the public now expects “equal opportunity employment” in MPs’ offices.

Around 150 MPs – close to one in four – have a family member working in their office, while a number of prominent politicians have faced complaints about their arrangements.

Currently MPs face few limits to hiring partners or children. They are limited to hiring just one at a time and must publicly declare the situation.

“We would want to see the best possible person for the job being recruited in order to provide public value for money.

But Ms Evans hinted that when a consultation ends later this month she will decided to tighten the rules so MPs in the future must prove other better candidates were not available.

“It is a controversial area. On the one hand, public expectations have shifted and there is an expectation for equal opportunity employment. On the other hand, you do have MPs who have specific requirements,” Ms Evans said.

“It all comes down to what the job is and could we define more clearly what the responsibilities and roles are.

“Because it may be that if you can more clearly define specific roles, the answer becomes apparent as to who can take on that role.

“We would want to see the best possible person for the job being recruited in order to provide public value for money. That’s the key.”

Earlier this summer, Ms Evans became only the second ever chair of the IPSA, a watchdog created after The Telegraph’s investigation into MPs’ expenses.

During her 35-year career she has helped regulate the police, lawyers, doctors and broadcasters as well as chair two independent inquiries into healthcare, before beating around 30 rivals to get her new role.

“This isn’t about regulation, this is about encouraging them to account for the work that they’re doing in order that their constituents can be reassured.

Ms Evans is urging MPs to publish a yearly explanation about how their expenses are spent so voters better understand what is being funded.

The more that MPs can tell their constituents how they use the public’s money and what they do in their jobs, so much the better,” she said.

“It makes sense for MPs to provide as much information as they can. We don’t want to burden them with excessive regulation.

“This isn’t about regulation, this is about encouraging them to account for the work that they’re doing in order that their constituents can be reassured.”

The first ever “annual account of expenditure” by MPs will be published in November and is designed as a way of them to get on the front foot.

For example MPs could explain how many constituents’ cases were dealt with from the salaries paid to staff or explain that unusually high office costs came only because of a change of address.

“MPs should be paid a fair wage for a job and in return MPs, in Ipsa’s view, should be accountable for the work that they do,” she said.

Ms Evans also defended allowing MPs to claim for first class travel, saying: “There’s no issue here because they only take first class travel if they can get it at the same rate as second class travel by booking ahead.

“We do not pay for first class travel that costs more than standard.”

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/10/08/mps-who-hire-family-must-prove-they-are-the-best-candidates-says/

Millionaire property developer hosts Cameron’s 50th birthday party

Wonder if Hugo Swire knighted by Cameron in the cronies honours list – is invited? Ah, apparently not, says the article.

When plans were first being made for David Cameron’s 50th birthday party it was going to be a grand affair at Chequers, the stately home where Sir Winston Churchill made some of his wartime broadcasts.

But the EU referendum and Cameron’s tearful departure from Downing Street changed all of that.

The former prime minister will not exactly be slumming it, however, when he celebrates his half century tonight, the day before his actual birthday.

Cameron and his wife Samantha will be the star turn at a discreet dinner party in one of the most magnificent homes in private ownership in Britain. They will be entertained by property developer Tony Gallagher at Sarsden House, a listed 17th-century Oxfordshire mansion set in 459 acres.”

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3827953/Cameron-celebrates-50th-ultra-exclusive-party-Just-23-guests-invited-Dave-s-low-key-birthday-albeit-26million-country-pile-owned-favourite-Tory-donor.html

Our MP busy with his new Middle East job

CMEC SYRIA WORKING GROUP ROUNDTABLE

Syria: what does the future hold?

Monday, 17 October 2016
18:00 – 19:00

Chaired by:
The Rt Hon Sir Hugo Swire MP KCMG

Speakers:
The Rt Hon Alistair Burt MP
Sir Jeremy Greenstock KCMG
Michael Stephens, Research Fellow, RUSI

The event will provide an opportunity to discuss future scenarios in Syria following the breakdown of the Geneva agreement reached between Russia and the United States.

Swire’ Middle East Council looks forward to doing business in currently war-torn areas

Swire is Chairman of the Conservative Middle East Council.  Here is what one of its members says about business opportunities in Yemen, Libya, Syria, Iraq – they represent “huge prosperity opportunities”:

When is a hospital not a hospital?

Can we nail the belief, shared by MP Hugo Swire, that “no hospitals are going to close” in the Lack-of-Success Regime’s plans for East Devon.

When you take away ALL the hospital beds from a hospital you are left with a so-called “health hub” which takes out-patient appointments and, if you are lucky, some minor procedures. It is NOT a hospital.

If, during one of those minor procedures, you suffer a serious problem and need to be an in-patient or need to receive emergency care, you will be transferred to a REAL hospital – if you can find one.

Maybe the next step is to designate residential homes as “low impact hospitals” and nursing homes as “satellite hospitals”. After all, polytechnics became universities overnight, so anything is possible.

Swire’s puzzling parliamentary questions on retrospective planning applications

Owl thinks the third question is most interesting – where he asks about fees paid by developers. Why “developers” rather than “people” or “applicants” or “homeowners”?

Just who is he representing? Local residents or developer pals?

1. To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, what estimate his Department has made of the cost of retrospective planning applications to local councils in (a) Devon and (b) the UK in the last five years.

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2016-09-02.44219.h&s=speaker%3A11265#g44219.q0

2. To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, what proportion of the cost of a retrospective planning application is covered by the (a) applicant and (b) local authority.

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2016-09-02.44220.h&s=speaker%3A11265#g44220.q0

3. To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, whether he plans to change the proportion of the cost of retrospective planning applications currently paid by developers.

http://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2016-09-02.44221.h&s=speaker%3A11265#g44221.q0

NB The answers from the Secretary of State are pretty useless!

Lies, damned lies and retweets about housing figures from Hugo Swire

Swire retweeted this:

“Gavin Barwell MP ‏@GavinBarwellMP
New figures released today show since 2010 government schemes have helped 330,000 people buy a new home #OwnYourHome”

NO! NO! NO! It has not helped 330,000 people to buy new homes!

When you follow the link it says: 185,000 people have bought new houses BUT, when you read further, actually it only talks about 91,000 of those homes having used various government schemes.

The press release says ”

The government is committed to helping people achieve their aspiration of home ownership, through the range of Help to Buy schemes, including: ISA, Shared Ownership, Equity Loan, London Help to Buy and Mortgage Guarantee.”

Remember that some of these schemes allow wealthy people to buy homes worth up to £650,000 for their children with huge discounts, that the ISA was revealed to only be helpful AFTER you had bought a home AND paid a deposit when people thought they were signing up for help WITH deposits, and equity loans grab a share of your home as does shared ownership.

Nowhere does Mr Barwell, or Mr Swire, explain where the figure of 330,000 comes from – except to say that it is “since 2010” when ?some ?all, ?most of these schemes did not exist!

Donald Trump, eat your heart out – post-truth politics flourishes here in the UK!