New GP surgeries costing councils millions in appealed rating valuations

Good for GPs and local health authorities (who receive refunds) bad for councils.

If this applies to EDDC, it, together with the £7m black hole which is soon to appear in EDDC’s council rent account must surely lead some councillors to wish that EDDC had invested in Knowle maintenance rather than allowing the building to deteriorate so they can build themselves new, expensive, offices in Honiton and massive refurbishment charges for offices in Exmouth.

“… According to Wychavon District Council, a number of GP surgeries had made successful appeals to the Valuation Office against the value given to their property in 2005 and 2010.

The council estimated that surgeries in its area alone would receive a £3.5m refund and £600,000 a year on an ongoing basis from this financial year.

Wychavon, the county council and Hereford & Worcester Fire Authority are expected to be responsible for half of the total losses.

The district said it would have to pay the majority share which will total £1.4m and £250,000 a year ongoing. …”

http://www.localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=24008:councils-in-plea-for-help-after-tribunal-ruling-on-gp-surgeries-and-business-rates&catid=58&Itemid=26

Criticising the critics of the NHS – fat cats criticise thin cats!

Health watchdog bloated with staff, top-heavy with runing costs:

http://www.snouts-in-the-trough.com/archives/14006

and:

The UK’s health regulators are currently unfit for purpose and need to be urgently reformed so they better support healthcare professionals providing services, a new report has claimed.

According to the report, Rethinking Regulation, published by the Professional Standards Authority, the UK’s current regulators – including the CQC – are too expensive to fund, and are over-complicated.

The report also claims that it is not clear as to whether regulators have improved the quality of care for patients, and questions if the benefit of this approach outweighs the ‘very considerable cost’ to carry the regulatory process.
The chief executive of the Professional Standards Authority, Harry Cayton, said: ‘Piecemeal adjustments to health and care regulation have, over time, made the system cumbersome, ineffective and expensive. Every part of our health and care system is changing in order to meet future needs. If patients are to benefit, regulation must undergo radical change too.

‘Regulation is asked to do too much – and to do things it should not do. We need to understand that we cannot regulate risk out of healthcare and to use regulation only where we have evidence that it actually works. Ironically, the regulations that are meant to protect patients and service users are distracting professionals from this very task.’

http://www.pulsetoday.co.uk/your-practice/regulation/health-regulators-are-not-fit-for-purpose-says-new-report/20010686.article#.VcOgsue9Kf1

“Free” NHS at risk

NHS patients may face widescale charges, warns financial thinktank:
http://gu.com/p/4b8pv?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

We already pay for dental treatment, chiropody and spectacles – so “free” is perhaps not the right word.

Neil Parish to campaign to keep Axminster hospital open

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Letter-Neil-Parish-campaign-reopen-ward-beds/story-27512283-detail/story.html

Now, where is the same sort of letter from Hugo Swire about Ottery? Not just the anodyne phrases he has trotted out so far – some real fighting words.

He will say that, as a Minister, he cannot bring this up in Parliament. So why did people choose to vote for him?

Imagine what an Independent MP could have done, free from party shackles – including joining forces with Neil Parish to double exposure of the situation in Parliament.

It is all up to former parliamentary candidate and current DCC councillor Claire Wright now – and a great job she is doing.

More on the NHS and Cabinet Minister Michael Gove’s ankles

Following on from our story on Michael Gove’s journalist wife writing about his visit to an NHS minor injuries unit: over last weekend

https://eastdevonwatch.org/2015/07/25/cabinet-minister-michael-goves-wife-complains-about-his-treatment-at-minor-injuries-unit-and-a-nurse-replies/

the following has just appeared on “The Sun” website:

More than 9,000 people have shared an open letter to Ms Vine (wife of Michael Gove) from consultant Tony Cartwright, who vented his anger on Facebook. The doctor – who says he’s left Britain for Abu Dhabi after becoming fed up of Tory reforms – accuses the Goves of making ‘no effort’ and resorting instead to ‘open vitriol’.

He’s the latest medic to sound off at the Tories’ plans for a 7-day NHS, which medics say is badly thought-out and ignores the many services already offered on the weekend.

Addressing Ms Vine, Mr Cartwright wrote: “I am another UK doctor who is writing a letter to government, if only to satisfy my own anger and frustration. You must all be getting quite tired of this, really.

“Ms Vine, you took your husband to a 17 bed community hospital out of hours… and you really expected the full flow of a trauma centre? This is an unrealistic expectation and will never be the case.

We could staff Shepton Mallet Community Hospital with a 24/7 radiology department for the use of ‘people like us,’ as you describe yourself and as you suggest at the end of your missive. However I suspect your husband’s friend, Jeremy, and indeed the PM himself may have something to say about that and the funding and staffing involved.

Your nearest emergency department is either in Yeovil or Bath, both a fairly tiresome 40-60 minute drive. Had you gone to either of these hospitals you would have had an X-ray at any time of the day or night and been referred immediately to orthopaedics if required, oh, and been reviewed by a Consultant, for urgent treatment if required. That would have resolved your issue later on the Sunday, however I suspect you had many more important things to do than ensure the comfort and health of your husband.

It was your and/or your husband’s choice, for whatever reason, to not take your husband to a doctor in an emergency department in a timely fashion following his injury.

You see, with repeated changes to funding and allocation of resources within the NHS, the local A&E departments that I remember as a child have been wound down and closed.

You and your husband have the freedom to be able to choose to live in a beautiful leafy part of Somerset far from the madding crowds. Surely you could have used a little of your husband’s 10% pay rise to cover the cost of a little petrol/diesel and some hospital parking to get either to Bath or Yeovil, both centres of NHS excellence?

Your decision not to is not our fault. Do not blame us for your lack of effort or forward thinking.”

Source: The Sun Website today

Cabinet Minister Michael Gove’s wife complains about his treatment at Minor Injuries Unit and a nurse replies

A bone to pick with NHS
My husband tripped over a toy and banged his foot in the middle of the night on Saturday (as you do).

The next morning, I drove him to the nearest minor injuries unit, where a nurse said it was probably broken and required an X-ray. Except, being a Sunday, radiology was shut. She suggested he come back on Monday.

But his work diary was packed (he left home before 8am and returned after I was asleep); Tuesday’s, too. He is still hobbling around on crutches, chucking down painkillers and groaning melodramatically. The foot has not yet been X-rayed. Obviously it’s not life threatening. But it is very painful.Trouble is, like most people, he doesn’t have a spare half-day to sit around awaiting the pleasure of the hospital radiographer.

No one is suggesting NHS staff don’t work very hard and do an excellent job. Just that the service needs to be a 24/7 one. And that means all departments — not just acute emergency departments — need to be available at weekends.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-3170220/SARAH-VINE-m-proof-nanny-make-worse-mum.html

A nurse replies

Dear Mr Cameron and Mr Gove,

The hits just keep on coming as they say.

I read with interest this article published in the Telegraph yesterday. It would appear that the practice of besmirching the reputation of the people that keep the NHS working (predominantly on the basis of goodwill alone I might add) is spreading within the Cabinet that governs this nation.
Perhaps I could enlighten you on a few issues that have been grossly misrepresented in this article.

1. The headline claims that Mr Gove was ” left on crutches after doctors were unable to see him over weekend”. Well if Mr Gove attends a nurse lead minor injuries unit why would he expect to see a doctor? Its likely Mr Gove would have known he was visiting a minor injuries unit and it also clearly stated on the hospital’s website that its nurse-lead. Surely it is not beyond the wit of a former Education Secretary to realise this and if indeed a doctors opinion was specifically required, why not make use of the out of hours service? Finally and perhaps most important, is it being implied that an experienced nurse is incapable of providing sound medical advice?

2. Mr Gove was unable to receive treatment because of a lack of “Sunday services”. Again if you visit a hospital with a minor injuries unit who’s main function is rehabilitation (see website) what do you expect? It cannot be claimed that such a small community hospital is representative of NHS acute services. I’m pretty sure that Mr Gove would have been redirected to a hospital with an A&E if it was clinically indicated. There I’m certain he would have found plenty of consultants and dare I say it radiographers too!

3. “NHS radiology departments are closed on Sundays”. On what planet?! Ask the thousands of people involved in road traffic accidents, the people attending hospitals over the weekend with chest complaints, the inpatients who need urgent scans, the patients suffering heart attacks that need cardiologists; the list goes on. Most importantly, ask the legion of radiographers and radiologists who perform and interpret the images 24 hours a day 365 days a year. How dare you tell such a bare faced lie Ms Vine?!

4. Ms Vine also states that Mr Gove “like most people, doesn’t have a spare half-day to sit around awaiting the pleasure of the hospital radiographer”.

What an incredibly offensive statement. This exemplifies the total lack of understanding this government has. If you want 7 day services, PAY FOR IT! If you cannot or don’t want to pay for it be honest, say so and stop LYING to the public.

Indeed on this particular point, it is claimed that Mr Gove was too busy to see a doctor during the week because of his busy schedule. I’m afraid it was Mr Gove’s decision to wait till the weekend when his condition and pain worsened before seeking medical attention. If you are ill, see a doctor promptly if its that bad; preferably when the medical services are better staffed and equipped to deal with your complaint. If you insist on using under resourced acute and emergency services to fit in with your working life, please do not complain when you have to wait to see the hardworking and dedicated professionals that are prioritising their time according to clinical need.

Finally Gentlemen, lets stop with the propaganda and political games. It is simply dangerous to continue having this steady drip of negative press, its not journalism. There are far bigger issues to deal with and these “stories” are divisive and ultimately dangerous especially when given any semblance of legitimacy by the national press. We healthcare professionals understand this danger which is why we will never give in. So please roll up your sleeves and do what you were elected to do, solve the problems of our nation and don’t allow the NHS to fall apart under your watch.

Which Health Care Commissioning group advertised its board meeting the day after in happened?

Yes, ours.

Board Meeting of the Eastern group which covers East Devon and now has no tenderers for its out-of-hours services advertised its latest board meeting in the Express and Echo which was published today (23 July) when the board meeting took place yesterday.

No wonder we are in an NHS nightmare.

Loved what it said though:

Although the meeting will be [was] held in public, it is not a public meeting. You are invited to listen to the Board’s discussions, observe the decision-making process and have the opportunity to ask questions related to issues discussed at the invitation of the chairman of the locality board. Questions can be submitted to the Board 3 days in advance”

So, you can’t speak about what they say on the day, only on guess what you think they might say and submit a question that the Chairman may or may not allow!

Contract for urgent care in Devon has no bidders – with fewer community hospitals what next?

Devon Doctors has withdrawn its tender to provide out-of-hours services to the NHS Northern, Easters and Western Devon Commissioning Group, as the money offered to provide urgent care services is less than the service will cost. They will cease provision in March 2016.

They were the only bidder (and current providers) of out-of-hours GP services, dentistry and minor injury treatment.

“When asked what impact this would have a spokesperson said …”Clearly this uncertainty is not helpful and could have an unsettling effect on staff and clinicians”.

We must also assume that this is one of the services meant to enable people to have treatment that, where possible, would allow people to be cared for at home.

With Axminster and Ottery St Mary hospitals now closing how on earth can people be treated at home if a crucial part of the service is not available?

Anyone remember the antiquated Army “Green Goddess” fire engines that were used many years ago when firefighters went on strike? How long before we have army ambulances and army doctors in East Devon?

Source: Express and Echo “Setback for delivery of urgent care”, page 2, Anita Merritt (no web link found)

Hugo Swire – good or bad timing?

Isn’t it interesting that Hugo Swire seems to criticise controversial decisions in East Devon just after those decisions have been mad.

Knowle relocation – condemned only after the decision had been made and just before the election.

Closure of local hospitals – criticised the day AFTER the decision was made.

Good or bad timing?

Tory Health Minister questions publicly-owned free health service

“The idea that the NHS can remain taxpayer-funded and free needs to be re-examined as costs rise”, a Conservative health minister has said.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/the-principle-of-a-free-taxpayerfunded-nhs-must-be-questioned-says-tory-health-minister-10395991.html

The Conservative Party Manifesto for this election promised a free high-quality health service.

Added to which, the cap on cost of residential care promised for 2016 has been delayed until at least 2020:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-33552279

Hospital closures: the spin – and where are Hugo Swire’s comments?

“…County Councillor Claire Wright said: “It’s an absolute travesty. We heard that 11,000 people signed petitions to save the hospitals and they didn’t answer my question as they said they didn’t have enough information on how much a health hub would cost. The CCG say they are saving £500,000 but they haven’t costed in how much it will cost to create a health hub, which in Budleigh Salterton cost £800,000 and they haven’t costed how much home-based care will cost. It doesn’t stack up financially as they say that’s detail and are using numbers to their own advantage.”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Anger-frustration-East-Devon-plans-axe-community/story-26919959-detail/story.html

Beds cut by 30% in East Devon to make remaining hospitals “more resilient”

You couldn’t make it up!

“Dr Jenner said: “Of course we understand that some people will always want to have community beds in their own area and this decision may disappoint them but making sure everyone has the same level of access to services is very important.

“We are looking to continually improve services to support people in their local communities whether they are cared for at home or in hospital and this is one step forward on that journey.”

Dr Jenner blamed health provider, Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust which runs North Devon District Hospital in Barnstaple and a series of community hospitals in east Devon, for putting extra strain on such hospital because of staffing issues.

He said: “Over the last few years the hospital provider Northern Devon Healthcare NHS Trust has had to temporarily close some community hospital inpatient units due to staffing issues.

“Consolidating from 10 to seven units means we will have much more robust staffing at our hospitals in the future.”

“This will improve the resilience of care at our community hospitals in the face of financial and workforce challenges.”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Hospital-beds-slashed-30-East-Devon-make/story-26915985-detail/story.html

So, all you people in Axminster and Ottery don’t worry – you will be cared for in your own home by staff they don’t have.

Ottery and Axminster hospital beds will close

Announced on Spotlight and also closure at Crediton. 11,000 petitioned for them remaining open. They will now have “health hubs” – but no-one knows what these are or how much they will cost. Closures will start in the autumn.

RIP the National Health Service in East Devon.

Exeter MP says he was threatened when asking too many questions about state of NHS in Devon

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Exeter-MP-allegedly-threatened-Government-Minster/story-26906327-detail/story.html

Demonstration against Ottery and Axminster hospital closures

Claire Wright’s blog:

There will be a placard demonstration at

12.30pm on Thursday 16 July,

outside Newcourt Community Centre, Exeter – map here – https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/Newcourt+Community+Centre/@50.701755,-3.474879,15z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x0:0xd9a1e2f62015b734

The Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group will meet at 1pm and will take a decision on whether to shut all the beds at Ottery and Axminster Hospitals, moving them to other local hospitals, as well as closing minor injuries units at Axminster, Ottery, Seaton and Sidmouth.

We are not allowed to speak during the meeting, although questions can be submitted in writing to staceyavery@nhs.net

For more see – http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/the_last_battle._d_day_for_ottery_hospital_please_attend_this_meeting

This is our LAST CHANCE to be heard. Please come. And bring your friends. I would be grateful if you would drop me a line at claire@claire-wright.org if you plan on coming. Thanks very much.

http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/demonstration_planned_for_last_battle_to_save_east_devon_hospital_beds_and

Was YOUR cataract or hernia operation unnecessary? NHS supremo thinks so. And die at home to save the NHS more money

“As many as one in seven hospital procedures are unnecessary, leading to “profligate” waste in the health service, a senior NHS official has said. …

… 500 million a year could be saved by reducing the use of “low value” treatments and procedures such as cataract and hernia operations and tonsillectomies. Currently the NHS carries out more than 300,000 cataract operations a year at a cost of just over a quarter of a billion pounds a year, 79,000 hernia repairs at £147 million a year, and 52,000 tonsillectomies at £63 million. …

… £36 million a year could be saved if the NHS stopped over-treating patients dying of terminal illnesses such as cancer in hospitals. It would be better, and cheaper, for dying patients to receive expert palliative care outside of the hospital environment …”

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/11733871/One-in-seven-treatments-not-necessary-warns-NHS-chief.html

So, if you can’t read or drive because of your cataracts, you can’t work because you have a hernia or you can’t die at home because there are no palliative nurses available – tough up!

IF some operations do not result in improvements, surely we should be training doctors to make better decisions with more care, not blaming them. Does anyone really think doctors offer these operations just to waste money?

The last battle for local hospital services

From the blog of Independent DCC Councillor Claire Wright (Ottery Sy Mary). We assume local MP Hugo Swire will be at the meeting … in our dreams.

The last battle. D-day for Ottery Hospital – please attend this meeting!

The decision on the fate of Ottery St Mary Hospital will be made next Thursday (16 July), and the Northern, Eastern And Western Clinical Commissioning Group (NEW Devon CCG) appear as determined as ever, to close it.

Also at risk across East Devon, are all of Axminster Hospital beds, and minor injuries units at Ottery, Axminster, Sidmouth and Seaton Hospitals.

The CCG’s board papers, published yesterday, argue strongly in favour of closing Ottery Hospital’s beds and minor injuries unit and against any other option, including the recommendations presented by the stakeholder group – a group set up by the CCG in January.

The paper, in my view, has totally misrepresented the stakeholder group’s recommendation on hospital beds, by implying that the group supported “consolidation” as a long-term measure (moving hospital beds out of Ottery and Axminster to other hospitals).

The stakeholder group’s recommendation was that beds should remain at all our community hospitals and a minor injuries service should be retained in each town.

The paper that goes before the CCG’s governing body on Thursday states that the cuts will be implemented immediately once a decision has been made.

The paper acknowledges the significant projected population increase in East Devon over the next few years – over 11 per cent by 2026), but seems to believe that the best way of handling this is to move community hospital beds to other nearby hospitals.

At the last health and wellbeing scrutiny committee meeting on 18 June, the CCG’s update report, scarcely mentioned the work of the stakeholder group, bar a passing reference. Certainly it did not allude to its recommendations, despite the group being established by the CCG in January!

You can view discussions at this meeting here. The speakers names are now included within the webcast – http://www.devoncc.public-i.tv/…/portal/webcast_inte…/159084

I have not been able to find any mention of the CCG’s plans for Ottery Hospital, if the beds and minor injuries unit closes, yet paperwork claims that the stakeholder recommendations will cost an additional £200K. And the savings from closing all the beds at Axminster and Ottery will be £500,000.

The existing 15 bed stroke unit housed at Ottery is set to move to a site in Exeter – probably the RD&E. Ottery is viewed as an interim measure.

One of the stakeholder group’s recommendations included that no changes should take place until integration with a new provider had taken place (a decision about who gets to run local community hospitals – likely to be the RD&E).

But the papers submitted for next Thursday’s meeting tacitly admit that providers have not even been consulted with.
The CCG makes a strong case for its own proposals and dismisses the alternatives.

To view the recommendations turn to page 110 of the papers, in this link –

file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Claire/My%20Documents/Downloads/GB%20Pack%20PUBLIC%2016%20July%202015.pdf

The meeting starts at 1pm on Thursday 16 July, at Newcourt Community Centre, Exeter. It is open to the public, but please bear in mind that the relevant agenda item isn’t likely to start until after 3pm.

It is absolutely vital that there is a big public attendance from across East Devon, as this is when the decisions are made.

There is no facility for public speaking unfortunately (I did ask twice but was refused). However, there is the option of submitting questions in advance, in writing.

http://www.claire-wright.org