Town Council finds apparent inconsistencies and contradictions in Brown Application.

After listening to the points raised by an EDA spokesperson at the Ottery St Mary Town Council (OSMTC) Planning Committee this evening, it was agreed, by four votes to nil (with 2 abstentions) to write to EDDC expressing OSMTC’s concern at the evidence submitted by Graham Brown, and pointing out what seem to be inconsistencies and contradictions in it.

Reporters from the Herald, the Pulmans View from, and the Express and Echo were present.The Chair wryly commented,”We only need the Exchange and Mart and we’ve got the set.” He discreetly didn’t mention the Daily Telegraph.

The Daily Telegraph reporters’ secret filming of an interview with Mr Brown in March 2013,took place at Ware Farm, pictured below
Ware Farm East Hill

Full story about Mr Brown’s Application is at the Western Morning News link on our previous post http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Disgraced-Tory-attempts-lift-300-000-tie-farm/story-22963165-detail/story.html

Cuts to local hospital beds and services: MP says “not a time for whipping up excitement”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/NHS-bed-closures-scrutiny-hospital-admits/story-22951197-detail/story.html.

A public meeting is being arranged on this urgent matter to discuss the situation in Ottery St Mary on 7 October – more details to follow.

In the meantime MP for the Ottery and Sidmouth area, Hugo Swire, has apparently said this is “not the time for whipping up excitement” and, on the bright side, means more time and space for clinics:

http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/site/comments/hugo_swire_on_ottery_hospitals_bed_losses_this_is_not_the_time_for_whipping

As yet there seems to be no comment from the area’s other MP, Neil Parish (cuts at Axminster Hospital).

Local hospital bed closures – consultation

Axminster and Ottery St Mary hospitals are set to lose all their beds and Sidmouth hospital will lose its minor injuries unit under the cost-cutting proposals.

12 weeks consultation on these plans start today.

Full Report here:

http://www.newdevonccg.nhs.uk/get-involved/get-involved/community-services/101039

The East Devon section is here:

http://www.newdevonccg.nhs.uk/file/?rid=105273&download=true

Just one problem: none of the recommendations (which should also include doing nothing as a costed option) have ANY numbers attached to them. So, we don’t know what things cost now, we don’t know what the new recommendations will cost, so there is no idea what savings, if any, may be made.

But no doubt our District Council will come to our aid …..

Daisy the Cow

An interesting couple of comments on Councillor Claire Wright’s blog in response to a post by EDDC Conservative Whip, Phil Twiss, who pointed out to a commentator that he had got the wrong property when questioning that disgraced ex-councillor Graham Brown was still farming when he said he all but gave it up more than 10 years ago:

…..”10. At 06:19 pm on 11th Sep Damien Mills wrote:

Sincere thanks to Cllr Twiss for pointing out my error.

On this occasion, he’s quite correct; I did, inadvertently, confuse Ware Farm with Ware Farm house. However, further investigation reveals Mr Brown’s property is on the market – but not for £385,000 as I had mistakenly thought but, rather, a cool £1,550,000:

http://www.rightmove.co.uk/property-for-sale/property-41090060.html

What is more, all my other points remain. So, essentially, it seems Mr Brown is looking to his friends at OSMTC / EDDC to help him secure the certificate of lawfulness without which it will, one assumes, be very difficult, if not impossible, for him to sell Ware Farm. That aside, it’s reassuring to know that Cllr Twiss is such an avid reader of this blog and will, of course, be duty bound to report back what he has learnt on here to the planning department at EDDC before it considers Mr Brown’s application.

Indeed, given the controversies surrounding Mr Brown, one must assume that Cllr Twiss and his fellow Tories will go the extra mile to ensure there can be no suggestion of any impropriety in the way EDDC deals with this application from their former colleague.

Once again, thanks for your help Phil, it really is very much appreciated!

11. At 08:19 pm on 11th Sep Sandra Semple wrote:

From the particulars:

“A barn with open yard area measuring 10m x 15m with a self filling trough provides ideal space for wintering young horses, there is an isolation stable measuring 3.6m x 3.6m in the corner of this barn.

The adjacent barn currently (sic) houses cattle and is 15m wide by 17m long and has a self filling water trough and an external feed trough along the short side of the building.

There is an open fronted 45m x 15m pole barn currently used for straw and hay. The field behind the house has a useful field shelter.”

Currently houses cattle? Agricultural business? Or just family pets?”

A correspondent mentions that the land may be sub-let – but surely, in that case, the owner would still be conducting an agricultural business.

Disgraced ex- councillor Graham Brown breached planning conditions on his own home for more than 10 years!

Well done, Express and Echo for getting this story!

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Disgraced-councillor-seeks-make-Ottery-St-Mary/story-22898229-detail/story.htm

So, just to be clear, the man who dominated Planning in East Devon for many years, who indicated in the Telegraph that he was interested in receiving tens of thousands of pounds in exchange for winning planning approvals, was all along living in a new property he had promised his own Planning Department would always remain for someone working in agriculture. When in fact he was living there pursuing other commercial activities all along.

Did no fellow councillors, or planning officers – all fully aware that he was a planning “consultant” and builder – think this a bit odd. Did nobody pipe up?

Still, a splendid entertainment is promised at the district in the next few months. How will Planning Chairman Helen Parr deal with this when it comes – as it must – before the Development Management Committee? Will Mr Brown perhaps grace the chamber with his presence? And just how hard will EDDC strive to keep this one off any public agenda before next May?

Let us not forget that while he was illegally occupying this property, he was:

A district councillor

Chairman of the first Local Development Framework (Local Plan) panel (which met in secret)

Chairman of the East Devon Business Forum – a group fully-funded by East Devon District Council, and with one of its senior officers as its Secretary, and made up of local landowners and builders who persuaded EDDC to ignore two sets of consultants in order to favour their figures, particularly on employment land

Director of a local planning consultancy (Greygreen Planning Ltd) and building company

For part of the time EDDC Business Champion

AND

Councillor for Feniton and Bucketell when, by coincidence, that area was flooded by developers wanting to increase the size of the village by 40%

And all this time he was breaking planning rules …..

Public at fault for not understanding planning practices?

Is this what EDDC thinks? And do officer recommendations hold more sway than reasoned arguments from Councillors and the public?

Councillor Roger Giles raises these and other crucial matters regarding the Development Management (DMC) and Overview and Scrutiny ( O&S) Committees, here: OTTERY ST MARY TOWN COUNCIL REPORT 7 JULY 2014

Beavers on the River Otter – will the public be able to have its say?

Beavers are a native species, hunted to extinction 500 years ago. Re-introductory trials (at some expense) are taking place in Scotland but it seems that Nature is taking is taking her own course here in the river Otter.

beaver 2014 mod

The photo above was taken very recently in Otterton. Defra, whose first response to most problems seems to be to cull, wants to get rid of them.

Devon-based wildlife consultant Derek Gow, who was responsible for three imported beavers destined for an animal sanctuary in Scotland, is a long-standing campaigner for the animals to be returned to the wild. He is reported as saying: “At the moment they [Defra] are ringing all the zoos and asking them if they will take the beavers. “What Defra should do is look at a more informative project where by the beavers are left and studied – it becomes an English beaver trial.”

He blamed angling groups for demanding the beavers be removed [beavers are vegetarian]. “Why should three beavers be three beavers too many?,” he said. “This will be the first time in history that we have exterminated a native mammal twice, setting an extraordinary historical precedent”.

Only recently have Otters returned to the lower Otter. The water vole has been in decline nationally attributed partly to the American mink, an aggressive predator of the vole, together with unsympathetic farming and watercourse management which destroyed parts of the water vole’s habitat. The water vole, an important indicator of a healthy environment, has not yet returned to the lower Otter.

American mink are a non-native, carnivore species, introduced to Devon so that they could be farmed for their fur. Over the years escapees have naturalised and there are still mink in the Otter. EDDC Countryside Service monitored the mink rafts in the Otter, owned by Clinton Devon Estate, for many years because of the threat that they posed, but this has now stopped due to budget cuts. The Axe, which belongs to EDDC, has priority for funding and monitoring continues there.

Some believe that beavers make a positive contribution to flood prevention and river quality. With the Environment Agency expressing concern over the bathing water quality in Budleigh Salterton, and flooding a well-known vexation, one wonders whether we have got our priorities right.

More information, including reference to two “save the beaver” on line petitions, can be found here:
http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/petitions-Devon-beavers-remain-large/story-21312530-detail/story.html#comments
http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/beavers_found_living_wild_in_devon_countryside_to_be_sent_to_the_zoo

Exeter Airport “a sleeping giant”

Oh dear – watch out Skypark, Cranbrook and Ottery and everywhere inbetween:

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Exeter-Airport-owners-forcast-growth-Devon/story-21288262-detail/story.html

Otter estuary consultation

Public consultation events are being held on the Lower Otter Restoration Project, which could see tidal flooding reintroduced to the Otter, allowing it to burst its banks.

It is hoped the plan would help prevent the flooding of homes and farmland, and create a better habitat for wildlife, while making sure access is preserved. …..

….. The project is being led by Mike Williams, who has been assigned by the Environment Agency to work with landowner Clinton Devon Estates.

http://www.exmouthjournal.co.uk/news/consultation_on_estuary_plan_1_3647793

The consultation events will be held at East Budleigh Village Hall on Tuesday, July 1, between 2pm and 7pm, and Lime Kiln car park in Budleigh Salterton on Saturday, July 5, between 10am and 2pm.

Governance and accountability for town and parish councils

http://www.slcc.co.uk/news-item/governance-and-accountability-for-local-councils/768/

A few of our town and parish councillors and clerks might need a refresher here – Ottery, Talaton and Newton Poppleford spring to mind.

Claire Wright officially launches bid to become East Devon’s MP

Claire Wright, EDDC Councillor for West Hill and DCC Councillor for Ottery St Mary Rural officially launched her campaign to become Member of Parliament for the East Devon Constituency at the Annie Leigh Brown Room, Dissenters Chapel (URC) Sidmouth this morning. She will be up against current MP Hugo Swire (Conservative) and others standing for other parties at the General Election in May 2015.

She was introduced by fellow Independent Councillor Roger Giles and made a short speech to an invited audience which included journalists. She then answered questions from the audience.

Details of visits she will be making to towns and villages in the area during the next year will appear on her personal website www.claire-wright.org which also has a link to an online donation site for her campaign.

Claire has signed the EDA Charter.

Independent Councillor Claire Wright to run for Parliament against Hugo Swire

Independent Councillor Claire Wright (EDDC Councillor for West Hill and Devon County Councillor for Ottery St Mary Rural) has announced HERE that she will be running for Parliament in the next general election in May 2015.

Claire has signed the EDA Charter.

Also link to Express and Echo article HERE.

Launch of photo competition for new book on East Devon

The sheer variety and volume of writing inspired by our local area  is behind the idea for a new book, Literature and Landscape in East Devon, to be published later this year.

As announced at last Friday’s hugely entertaining East Devon Writing event, original, relevant, high quality photographs are now being sought for inclusion in the book. Please see PHOTO COMPETITION on the EDA Home page, for precise information.

For a flavour of the forthcoming book, see the following list compiled by Mike Temple of Sidmouth (N.B. only some examples from the list will be included!) the-literature-of-east-devon-by-location . Another ‘taster’ is Robert Crick’s sharply humorous view on the Napoli shipwreck, Cargoes

 

 

East Devon Literature: from Exmouth to Axmouth

Although not an East Devon Alliance event, many members attended Michael Temple’s fascinating evening on the literature of our district last Friday in Ottery St Mary.

Many great writers have been inspired by our area: Coleridge, Conan Doyle, Defoe, Tennyson, C Day Lewis, Wells, Raleigh and Patricia Beer. In an hour and a half of readings, we heard from all of them, and from living local authors too.

Beautifully narrated by Michael, this ninety minute feast reminded us that our part of the world – from Exmouth to Axmouth – has as distinct an identity and a place in literature as any other part of the country.

Thanks were given to all who helped, including local libraries, bookshops and newspapers. Prizes were generously funded by the Sidmouth/ Ottery Herald. The prizewinners were warmly applauded. They were Philip Smith, for  Beer Beach in January: ; and budding author Libby Dean (aged 12), for A Scene from Sidmouth Folk Festival .

(Please note that contrary to an earlier report,Harry Guest did not win a prize in the writing competition – his excellent poem, the Boyhood of Raleigh,pointing to things today which would be unfamiliar to a child of that time, was published back in 1997).

Organiser Michael Temple has added: “I should like to warmly thanks all the readers and living authors who read the extracts and poems so well. (I was the link-man.)”

Don’t miss East Devon Writers event TONIGHT at Ottery St Mary !

A lively evening of free entertainment, celebrating East Devon’s literature and the exceptional landscape that has inspired so much of it.

Venue: The Institute, Ottery St Mary

Time: 7.30 -9 pm

Parking: Free  after 7 pm at nearby Sainsbury’s car park

 

Oh, no, Mr Developer – we don’t want cash for the communiyt; Ottery loses out (again)

One has to wonder whether this is a “scorched earth” policy.  What developer these days can’t afford a £30,000 payment for their development given current house prices?

 

http://www.sidmouthherald.co.uk/news/news/town_could_lose_out_on_developer_s_cash_1_3603890

EDDC to administer flood relief grants

Flood resilience support given approval
Measures designed to help home and business owners protect their properties from future flood events have been approved by the council.
Last week, members agreed to give delegated authority to the chief executive to administer the East Devon elements of a scheme that forms part of a nationwide Government initiative prompted by the devastating storms and floods experienced during the past winter.The Government has launched a number of initiatives to assist householders and businesses recover from flooding and make their premises more resilient to future bad weather.

Councils have been invited to administer several schemes to:
• provide grants to householders and business owners to protect their properties
• offer Council Tax and Business Rate relief
• provide small ‘one-off’ grants called the Business Support Scheme.

The offers are available to owners of properties actually flooded between 1December 2013 and 31 March 2014 and for work designed to prevent future flooding as opposed to work that should be covered by insurance.

Guidance issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government working with Defra means councils can administer the scheme on behalf of the Coalition.

EDDC’s local scheme is based on guidance issued in March and is mostly concerned with administration of the Repair and Renew Grant, which councils can award and then claim back from Westminster.

 

Measures designed to help home and business owners protect their properties from future flood events have been approved by the council.
Last week, members agreed to give delegated authority to the chief executive to administer the East Devon elements of a scheme that forms part of a nationwide Government initiative prompted by the devastating storms and floods experienced during the past winter.

The Government has launched a number of initiatives to assist householders and businesses recover from flooding and make their premises more resilient to future bad weather.

Councils have been invited to administer several schemes to:
• provide grants to householders and business owners to protect their properties
• offer Council Tax and Business Rate relief
• provide small ‘one-off’ grants called the Business Support Scheme.

The offers are available to owners of properties actually flooded between 1December 2013 and 31 March 2014 and for work designed to prevent future flooding as opposed to work that should be covered by insurance.

Guidance issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government working with Defra means councils can administer the scheme on behalf of the Coalition.

EDDC’s local scheme is based on guidance issued in March and is mostly concerned with administration of the Repair and Renew Grant, which councils can award and then claim back from Westminster.