Seaton Heights Hotel complex: is it ready to start building?

The developer says yes:

http://lymebayleisure.co.uk/seaton-heights/

but EDDC says no: the site is listed as “awaiting decision” because no Section 106 agreement has yet been signed.

These can take months so perhaps Seaton should not bring out the champagne just yet.

Coastal communities: will they change their voting patterns in the next election?

If the things that are currently happening in Exmouth (selling the seafront to the highest bidders, knocking down Elizabeth Hall), Budleigh (the Longboat, inappropriate development), Sidmouth (coastal erosion and job losses) and Seaton (strange statues in the wrong olaces and more retirement homes) it seems a good possibility!

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/economic-reality-resorts-bring-political-shift/story-23270023-detail/story.html

Local Health service “consultation”

We have been told by our local health group that we are being “consulted” on widespread changes to community care, particularly community hospitals.

Then almost immediately we hear that in Ottery there is to be a “temporary” stroke unit
http://www.northdevonhealth.nhs.uk/2014/10/trust-to-centralise-community-stroke-rehabilitation-services-in-ottery-st-mary/

and Axminster’s inpatient beds are to close over winter and nurses will be transferred to Seaton

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Hospital-beds-Axminster-set-close-relocate-Seaton/story-23207587-detail/story.html

The so-called “consultation” document did not include either of these plans nor did they include costings of ANY of the various other alternatives in their report.

So what exactly ARE we being consulted about? And is it worth the paper it is written on?

Harry Potter, Darth Vader and elephants: last night’s “full” council meeting

Halloween

 

Elephants and Dark Forces rampaged around the room at EDDC’s first full council since July last night and  the public address system squealed and howled as if possessed by Harry Potter’s Dementors (or perhaps by the elephants).

The man with the screwdriver on the night was the Chief Executive himself, but his best fiddlings with an array of knobs could not prevent speeches from the dais sound like Darth Vader (mixed movie metaphors here surely?) summoning those from the Dark Side of the Sid Valley and beyond. Or was it a protest on the part of the elephants because they were missing the dulcet tones of unusually absent Leader Paul Diviani? Maybe see if one of those miraculously recruited 25 new canvassers knows a good sparks before the next meeting, Mark.

Longest-serving councillor Douglas Hull did his best to deliver the devastating news he had just received in the previous hour that Axminster Hospital is to lose all its overnight beds, but for some reason fellow Axminsterite and Chairman of the Council Graham Godbeer did everything he could to fluster him, made all the more menacing by the Darth Vader microphone set-up.

It was not dirty laundry Mr Godbeer or Leader-for-the-Night Andrew Moulding (also Axminster) wanted washing in public. Not when there were so many best kept village and long service awards to be dished out.  Whilst nobody would be grumpy enough to deny these good people due recognition, it does make it more soul destroying for this to be followed by bland supplementary answers to incisive written questions (and bland written answers) from Independent councillors sent in prior to the meeting.

The Independents shrewdly chose to reserve comment on many matters until the Leader’s chair can be filled again by Mr Diviani in person. Other Tory councillors must have known it was understudy night because we lost count of the apologies for absence. Unusual this for October – it is usually August when councillors are away from their posts. Perhaps Harry Potter or Darth Vader strike again and those unavailable were preparing themselves for Halloween by sharpening their fangs or preparing for an assault by the Dark Forces at a later date – like election day, perhaps.

Claire Wright did her best, yet again, to induce Deputy Exec Richard Cohen to give the people of East Devon the merest hint of a suspicion of a whiff of what his action resisting the Information Commissioner was currently costing us, but he seemed neither to have an estimate of what has been spent so far, nor any idea of what final cost would ultimately be. Not sure how this sits with public sector procurement policy?

Two questions from the public. Paul Arnott asked Mark Williams why he had not told Tim Wood, Chairman of the Overview and Scrutiny Committe, that he had been summoned before an all-party Select Committee at Westminster on electoral matters to explain why he had done no legally-obligatory door-to-door canvassing of the electorate in recent years. Mr Williams replied that he had taken “soundings”, and that’s why he hadn’t told Cllr Wood. “Soundings” lovely word that – should be the opposite of transparent.

Paul Freeman gave a forensic analysis, following up his lauded previous work, on why Mr Williams stated strategy at Westminster of relying on land-line phone canvassing might not be working in the era of the mobile phone, and mentioned again Cllr Eileen Wragg’s experience of finding house-after-house in one Exmouth street with unregistered voters (a fact brought to the attention of Mr Williams at the time).

The Tories did their best to fluster the redoubtable Mr Freeman with their usual background rumblings, and Chairman Godbeer tried to cut him off before his three minutes was up (is this a portent of things to come: cutting down the number of people who can speak and then gradually cutting down the time to nothing!) but they would do well to listen again to what he was saying. Not least, why South Somerset, where Mr Williams is also CEO, has discovered more than tens thousand extra voters in recent years by knocking on doors, while East Devon (CEO Mark Williams) has discovered none by not knocking on any doors.

Mark Williams thanked Mr Freeman him for being the cause of his being summoned to Westminster, where he said he was able to boast to the nation of a consistently more than 90% registration of the electorate. The elephant in the room here was, more than 90% of what, precisely? More than 90% of 100% of the electorate minus the ?% of missing voters. Difficult equation to process that one.

The other standout event was the presentation of a 900 strong petition to the council from the people of Seaton asking Helen Parr’s Development Management Committee not to approve any planning application for a site next to Tesco other than for the much promised and much needed hotel. The site is now being hunted down by McCarthy Stone as yet another retirement complex. An excellent speech from Seaton councillor Steve Williams, followed by the delivery of the petition, which will now be put before the DMC as a consideration before any application is debated, was probably the only moment when the electorate were actually heard in the entire pantomime.

elephants

And in other news …

Whilst we await our Chief Executive’s appearance at tonight’s council meeting, here is some other news that has been happening over the last few days:

.

Supermarkets – the new charity shops?

EDDC’s flagship regeneration policy of putting a supermarket in all seaside towns as close to the seaside as possible already looks to be a busted flush.

Tesco has just announced it will abandon its plan to build a superstore on the seafront in Margate to which Pickles had given a green light!

In an article in the business section of the Guardian we read:

“Pickles was criticised for backing the Tesco Margate scheme by the self-styled Queen of Shops Mary Portas, who said it showed the government was only paying “lip service” to the idea of reviving Britain’s high streets as the store would have a “catastrophic” impact on the town.

Margate was among the “Portas Pilot” towns which won £100,000 in funding to back new ideas to boost trade and refill empty shops on some of the UK’s most battered high streets.

Louise Oldfield, a local hotel owner who pushed for the judicial review, said she was shocked that Tesco had pulled out but it was good news for Margate. “We hope we can now move forward towards a more sustainable proposal for Margate. This proposal would have had a massive impact on the seafront,” she said.”

But what irrevocable damage has now been done to our seaside towns in East Devon? Certainly too late for Seaton.

Source: http://www.theguardian.com/business/2014/oct/09/tesco-ditches-plans-build-superstore-margate-seafront

 

Cranbrook to double in size

In addition to the 6,000 homes already planned, developers are to submit plans for a further 1,500 homes. They also say they will build infrastructure but with still no Community Infrastructure Levy in place there is almost nothing in place to ensure that it happens.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Cranbrook-set-double-size-new-proposals/story-23165420-detail/story.html

 

DIY repairs to Devon roads

Brush up those tarmacking skills – you are going to need them. Can’t wait to see DCC Councillor for Highways, Stuart Hughes, in a blue boiler suit:

At a time when the news tells us that Devon has some of the most dangerous country roads which have ten times more fatalities than motorways comes a call for local people to voluntarily maintain their own bits of road and fill in their own potholes.

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Campaign-launched-West-s-rural-roads-revealed/story-23063234-detail/story.html

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Road-wardens-pot-holes-cash-strapped-Devon-County/story-23089269-detail/story.html

 

Feniton developers issued with breach of conditions notice by EDDC

Finally developers Wain Homes are put under pressure to do what they were supposed to do:  build attenuation tanks for surface water run off which should have been done BEFORE homes were occupied.  At least six are now in occupation with no sign of the tanks

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/East-Devon-serves-Breach-Condition-Notice/story-23155904-detail/story.html

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A life on the ocean wave? Not in Seaton! EDDC screws up another of its own planning applications!

EDDC suddenly sprang a planning application for an “artwork” in a very prominent position in Seaton – an area known as Fisherman’s Gap in the middle of the town’s seafront. It was accompanied by much trumpeting of its beauty, its form, its desirability! Several town councillors were not enamoured, saying thar the view itself already had beauty, form and desirability but that did not stop the town council from supporting EDDC’s planning application.

However, the Environment Agency slapped everyone’s wrists:

A letter, dated September 18th, to EDDC from the Environment Agency said: “We object to this proposal for the following reasons.

“The proposed sculptures are located on land that forms part of the Seaton Coastal Defence Scheme; a flood alleviation scheme that is operated and maintained by the Environment Agency.

“The proposed sculptures and interpretation pillar appear to be located in a manner that would: a) prevent the closure of the main flood gates that facilitate vehicular access through the sea wall, and, b) would restrict our access to the flood wall for necessary inspection, repair and maintenance purposes.

“It is also important that the applicant notes that any structures such as those proposed within seven metres of such coastal flood defences will require our Flood Defence consent under the terms of the Water Resources Act 1991.

“We will withhold our consent for any structures that would restrict our ability to safely access, operate, maintain and rebuild such a structure.”

An EDDC spokesperson said: “We are working with the Environment Agency to address their concerns about the exact location of the hot spot.

“Of course public safety with regards to flood defence is always our priority and we will therefore be considering how we can overcome any such concerns. We are committed to the hot spots as a way of extending the reach of Seaton Jurassic to the seafront and encouraging visitors to see for themselves our amazing beach and coastline.”

Full details of the proposal and how to comment are available on EDDC’s website at http://www.eastdevon. gov.uk via the planning portal (planning ref 14/1897).
http://www.viewfrompublishing.co.uk/news_view/33708/20/1/seaton-environment-agency-to-block-sculptures

EDA Chairman 1 – Leader of East Devon District Council own goal – and a STUNNING revelation!!!!

This morning the Chairman of East Devon Alliance, Paul Arnott, once again went head-to-head with a top EDDC councillor – this time EDDC Council Leader Paul Diviani on the lack of a Local Plan.  The EDA Chairman said that he was not surprised but still disappointed that, having been dealing with this project since 2007, EDDC still is not in a position to put a (third) draft Local Plan forward to the Planning Inspectorate and leaving the district vulnerable to speculative development.  And he comes up with a STUNNING REVELATION why he thinks current research for the Local Plan is wrong and the reason why it is being held up.  Read on …

Councillor Diviani trod the well-worn track of saying that there really is nothing to worry about – EDDC has so far won more than 70% of its appeals and (occasionally) says no to developers.  The EDA Chairman noted that it is NOT EDDC alone that champions these appeals – particularly in the case of Feniton and Seaton, where it was local people who raised funds and made their case to inspectors, so implying that EDDC alone does this is somewhat disingenuous.

However, then came the total shock.  You may recall that two sets of consultants employed by EDDC before the last iteration of the Local Plan said that they thought that around 12,000 homes should be built in the district.   EDDC (and, it has to be said members of the East Devon Business Forum and developers, sometimes the same thing) said, no, no – this could not be right and at least 15,000 homes were needed – which is what got put in the draft put before the Inspector.

The Inspector threw out the plan, specifically saying that he could see no back-up research that confirmed the 15,000 number that EDDC came up with.

And what does Leader Diviani say to this – if we take his interview at face value believing that he is being topical  we could read it as THREE sets of consultants coming to around the same figure but we must assume he is talking about the two reports?  He says, no no – they CANNOT be right.  The government wants us to build more houses, we NEED more houses so we are going to “look at the figures again” because they must be “realistic”.

HOW MORE REALISTIC CAN YOU GET THAT TWO DIFFERENT SETS OF CONSULTANTS COMING TO THE SAME CONCLUSION THAT WE NEED 11,000 – 12,000 NEW HOMES AND NOT 15,000?

So, here we have it – Councillor Diviani thinks he is more expert than consultants and will not give up until – presumably – another set of consultants comes up with the figure that he and the government want.  A figure not based on evidence.  As usual – fire the arrow, then draw the bulls-eye around it.

So, we ask ourselves:  where did the figure of 15,000 that Councillor Diviani so desperately wants come from?  Developers?  Out of thin air?  from the Government which has told us (via the NPPF) to come up with LOCAL figures backed up with LOCAL evidence?

Some very, very, trenchant questions need to be asked.  Not least by our councillors and, particularly, by Councillor Diviani

Source:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p024pn5v

(THE INTERVIEW IS 2 HOURS 6 MIN AT 8.38 AM)

 

“Who dares gets battered” at Colyton Council says editor of local newspaper.

Four out of 13 members of Colyton Town Council represent the nearby village of Colyford and those four are becoming increasingly annoyed as Colyton appears to be grabbing all the goodies for the town rather than sharing them with the smaller village.

Editor of the View newspapers, Philip Evans, criticised Colyton Town Council for trying to stop reporters writing

” … on matters that the council would prefer not to be publicised, despite such matters being discussed in open council, the inference being that we should onbly report on the positives and never the negatives. That view, of course, is contrary to the basic prinnciples of democracy and we have resisted any attempt to stop us doing our job responsibly.

We really upset the council recently when we had the audacity to record their deliberations at a particularly controversial meeting, to ensure we got it exactly right. To do was contrary sto the council’s standing orders (rules). We had never been sent a copy of tose standing orders and they are not listed on the council’s website, at the library, on the council notice board or any other place.

The council threatened to report us to the Press Complaints Commission for contravening their rules but common sense prevailed and if we want to record their meetings in future, we have to seek permission, which, from time to time, we will do.

[The Editor is wrong in this matter: since 6 August 2014 it has been illegal for ANY council to stop anyone recording, tweeting or videoing their meetings as long as they are not causing an obstruction].

He continues: ” … But it was his [The Mayor of Colyford’s] democratic right to riase the matter and he should not be unnecessarily castigated because he did not toe [not tow as appears in the editorial} the party line.

District councillors can pull out all the stops when objecting to a planning application – albeit in another district!

http://www.trinitymatters.co.uk/index.php/uplyme-east-devon/item/960-dorset-cc-lyme-regis-landfill-site-can-anything-still-be-done

Would that EDDC AONB sites in other areas (within our own district) received such support.

“Record new planning consents for Mc Carthy and Stone”

Currently planning to build in Seaton and rumoured to be interested in Knowle site:

http://www.theconstructionindex.co.uk/news/view/record-new-planning-consents–for-mccarthy-and-stone

Seeds of change

In this period of rebellion in the ballot box, the incumbent East Devon Member of Parliament may be expecting to have a battle on his hands at the next election, less than twelve months’ from now  (May 2015). As signalled in our earlier post, one very popular, Independent, County and District Councillor, a signatory of the EDA Charter, has today declared her intention to stand against him, and others may of course follow ( We’ll keep you informed).  This was how Councillor Roger Giles, the long-standing and much respected District Councillor for Ottery St Mary, introduced her to the assembly in Sidmouth:

“A very warm welcome to everyone. Welcome to the Dissenters’ Room, which was provided by Annie Leigh Browne. Annie Leigh Bowne is a local heroine who not only gave Sidmouth the Byes and the Cottage Hospital, but was also a leading suffragist who successfully led the national campaign for women`s representation in local government, which was achieved in 1907.

A very appropriate location for the launch of Claire`s parliamentary campaign!

Many of you will know of all the fantastic work that Claire has done whilst she has been an East Devon District Councillor. She has been a beacon in the cause of openness and transparency and fairness at EDDC – often in the face of animosity and hostility from conservative party councillors.

One of her great successes was to expose the undue influence of East Devon Business Forum members on EDDC`s planning policies, and also the undue influence in their own members` planning applications. The Chairman of EDBF was former Councillor Graham Brown.

When Claire raised this matter at the EDDC meeting on 25 July 2012, she was accused by senior Conservative Councillors of:

“impugning integrity”; of engaging in “speculation, misinformation and
innuendo”; “debating through the media”; and making “scurrilous”
allegations.

There never has been an apology. Not even after the Daily Telegraph exposure of March 2013.

Claire has been amazingly energetic and persistent. Just look at some of the things she has done:

* Successfully campaigned to retain maternity services at Honiton Hospital

* Provided the first play park at West Hill

* Pressed for better protection for trees

* Fought against the Government relaxation of planning policy (NPPF)

* Vigorously opposed unnecessary and damaging levels of development on
greenfield sites in East Devon

* Got EDDC to allow recording of its meetings

* Pressed for the creation of a cycleway from Feniton to Ottery to Tipton to
Sidmouth on the disused railway line

* Regularly engaged with and sought the views of people, young and old

* Communicated extensively with electorate by various means, including the
extensive use of her excellent blog

* Opposed planned cuts to local services, and is currently fighting to save
Ottery`s youth centre, childrens centre, and library

* Pressed for openness and transparency in planning at EDDC, demanding
that planning committee members reveal if they have been lobbied

* Fought EDDC`s vanity project to relocate its offices at a cost of millions
of pounds of taxpayers money at a time when EDDC is slashing the
services it provides to the public
That is an amazing level of energy and determination.

Claire`s work was recognised by the electorate of the Ottery Rural ward in the Devon County Council elections of May 2013. She obtained 74% of the vote. She got the biggest vote; the biggest share of the vote; and the biggest majority of any councillor in the South West.

We know what you have done Claire – and we thank you for it.

And we are delighted to come here today to endorse your campaign to be the next Member of Parliament for East Devon.

Ladies and gentlemen I give you Claire Wright – our next MP.”

More comment, with photographs of today’s campaign launch at http://susiebond.wordpress.com/2014/06/03/cllr-claire-wright-launches-her-campaign-for-a-seat-at-westminster/

 

 

EDDC HQ for Seaton?

Why not?  New build on virgin site exactly like Skypark but with the added benefit of helping to regenerate the town.  On the far edge of the district, just like Skypark so just about as difficult for people to get to.  In an area that desperately needs jobs (probably more than Cranbrook does with its proximity to Exeter), next to a lovely big Tesco and with a great walk by the sea at lunchtime!

Do your job, click and collect, walk by the sea, go home – what could be easier.

But it isn’t next to Exeter or its airport …..  ah well.  Bring on the Zimmer frames.

Protest group formed in Seaton after site on regeneration site for hotel changed to McCarthy and Stone retirement flats

We have received the following message from Seaton:

 The Seaton Regeneration area (Tesco site) had a plot set aside for a hotel to replace tourist beds lost when the holiday camp was demolished but the developers of the site (Tesco and Bovis Homes) say they were unsuccessful in marketing the site for a hotel.

Now McCarthy and Stone has take an option for yet another block of retirement flats.  Seaton is already highly over-represented with elderly people and retirement blocks which are to the north (Jubilee Lodge), east (Haven Court) and south (Homebaye House) of the regeneration area and will nowtotally encircle the planned new Visitor Centre.

Recently Tesco won the right to delete all the affordable housing that had been planned for the site.  No affordable housing has been built for many years in Seaton.

A protest group has been set up to oppose the latest development and will have its first meeting at

The Hook and Parrot

on Seaton seafront at

7.30 p.m. on

Thursday 5 June 1014 at 7.30 pm

to which anyone who objects to this planning application is warmly welcome.

 

Launch of photo competition for new book on East Devon

The sheer variety and volume of writing inspired by our local area  is behind the idea for a new book, Literature and Landscape in East Devon, to be published later this year.

As announced at last Friday’s hugely entertaining East Devon Writing event, original, relevant, high quality photographs are now being sought for inclusion in the book. Please see PHOTO COMPETITION on the EDA Home page, for precise information.

For a flavour of the forthcoming book, see the following list compiled by Mike Temple of Sidmouth (N.B. only some examples from the list will be included!) the-literature-of-east-devon-by-location . Another ‘taster’ is Robert Crick’s sharply humorous view on the Napoli shipwreck, Cargoes

 

 

East Devon Literature: from Exmouth to Axmouth

Although not an East Devon Alliance event, many members attended Michael Temple’s fascinating evening on the literature of our district last Friday in Ottery St Mary.

Many great writers have been inspired by our area: Coleridge, Conan Doyle, Defoe, Tennyson, C Day Lewis, Wells, Raleigh and Patricia Beer. In an hour and a half of readings, we heard from all of them, and from living local authors too.

Beautifully narrated by Michael, this ninety minute feast reminded us that our part of the world – from Exmouth to Axmouth – has as distinct an identity and a place in literature as any other part of the country.

Thanks were given to all who helped, including local libraries, bookshops and newspapers. Prizes were generously funded by the Sidmouth/ Ottery Herald. The prizewinners were warmly applauded. They were Philip Smith, for  Beer Beach in January: ; and budding author Libby Dean (aged 12), for A Scene from Sidmouth Folk Festival .

(Please note that contrary to an earlier report,Harry Guest did not win a prize in the writing competition – his excellent poem, the Boyhood of Raleigh,pointing to things today which would be unfamiliar to a child of that time, was published back in 1997).

Organiser Michael Temple has added: “I should like to warmly thanks all the readers and living authors who read the extracts and poems so well. (I was the link-man.)”

No hotel on the Seaton regeneration site: more retirement housing

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Retirement-home-developer-McCarthy-Stone-unveil/story-21108921-detail/story.html

Is EDDC out to make sure that Seaton has more retirement housing than current leader Christchurch?

Pretty soon you won’t get accommodation in Seaton unless you show a bus pass!

McCarthy & Stone will share its proposals with local residents at a public exhibition on Thursday, May 29, between 3.30pm and 7pm at Seaton Primary School on Valley View.

Anyone who is unable to attend the public exhibition or would like more information can call a freephone information line on 0800 298 7040 or view the proposals online at http://www.mccarthyandstone-consultation.co.uk/seaton

Anyone want to find out more about why Tesco couldn’t afford affordable houses in Seaton?

Well, after this ruling you might be successful!

http://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/property-firm-told-to-come-clean-on-social-homes-cut-9369941.html