Value of tourism

EDDC Leader Paul Diviani seems to have completely changed his tune about Sidmouth, now praising its ‘vibrant economy’ as a model for the vast new town at Cranbrook. Much of Sidmouth’s business depends on tourism. Visitors are attracted by its small shops and uniqueness, and unspoilt natural surroundings.

The following reports, from 2011, give a broader picture of the value of tourists’ spending power, and of why they come to Devon.

Click to access 2011%20Devon%20&%20districts%2011.pdf

2011 (all of Devon) but shows

Devon highest for staying accommodation
tourism-related employment 22%
day visits and spend are highest in Devon

E Devon see pp.16-24

Click to access TA_327_353.pdf

very interesting: page 7 – if only govt changed its policy re VAT on tourism, this could give a huge boost to the local economy… not a level playing field with the rest of Europe

• Of the 27 EU countries, the UK is one of only four that charges the full rate of VAT
on tourism accommodation (the others being Denmark, which has no reduced
rates of VAT, and Slovakia and Lithuania, which were persuaded to increase its rate
under IMF pressure). The UK now has the second highest rate of VAT on
accommodation in Europe.
• The average VAT rate for accommodation in the other European countries is 10.3%.
• The UK is one of only 14 EU countries that apply full rate VAT on restaurant meals.
The average for the rest of the EU is 8.8%.
• The UK is one of only 13 EU countries that apply full rate VAT on admissions to
amusement parks.
• The UK is one of only 10 countries that applies full rate VAT on admissions to
cultural attractions such as museums, theatres, shows and cinemas.
• A Deloitte/Tourism Respect study has estimated that reducing VAT on
accommodation and attractions could result in a net present value gain for the
Treasury of £2.6bn over 10 years.
• In the two years since France reduced VAT on restaurant meals from 19.6% to
5.5%, the Government has calculated that 62,700 new jobs have been created in
the sector, while employment in the rest of the economy has declined

EDDC Leader says “Cranbrook has much to learn from Sidmouth” but doesn’t exactly make plain what! And, of course, there is an elephant in the room!

In a somewhat confusing article, Leader Diviani rambles on about Cranbrook needing to follow Sidmouth’s example and have a “vibrant town centre”.

http://www.viewfrompublishing.co.uk/news_view/32635/12/1/sidmouth-cranbrook-has-much-to-learn-from

For a MUCH more coherent explanation of what triggered the above flim flam see

http://futuresforumvgs.blogspot.co.uk/2014/06/last-weeks-district-council-cabinet.html

where a number of pertinent questions are posed!

 

The elephant in the room?  Skypark, of course.  No doubt the answer to all Cranbrook’s problems!  An “information hub”, place of employment, etc.

Or is it?  Why do we get the impression that all is not well in Cranbrook these days?  And at Skypark, too.

Cranbrook has much to learn from Sidmouth, coos Council Leader

See extraordinary comments by Cllr Diviani and close colleagues, in today’s report at http://www.viewfrompublishing.co.uk/news_view/32635/12/1/sidmouth-cranbrook-has-much-to-learn-from

This, and EDDC Cabinet’s ‘ Vision for Cranbrook’ ,  raises many questions.  Some prime examples are given on the Vision for Sidmouth website today, in the following blogpost:   http://futuresforumvgs.blogspot.co.uk/2014/06/last-weeks-district-council-cabinet.html

 

 

What happens to ‘section 106’ money?

The question is asked in a comment left on this blog post about the example of Stowford Community Centre, Sidmouth, which has so far struggled to get used. https://www.streetlife.com/conversation/1t0wtw75x4r0m/?uid=1vqhj9eoi27am&utm_source=daily

McCarthy and Stone actively looking at Knowle?

As revealed by Cllr David Cox at last night’s  Cabinet meeting, Savills has been selected as marketing agent for the current EDDC HQ site at Knowle. It is strongly rumoured that  McCarthy and Stone have shown  potential  interest . Can anyone confirm this?

AND naughty DCC and Planning Inspectorate – you have upset EDDC too!

Same agenda as post below

Extract:

Rights of Way

 Another approach to attempt to restrict the Council’s development plans for parts of the Knowle has been Right of Way (RoW) applications.

 These applications were originally rejected by Devon County Council but on appeal against that decision the Inspector directed the County to make Orders in respect of two routes (one of which itself splits into two routes). The County made the Orders in March and the Council (and others) have lodged objections to the Order.

 The Planning Inspectorate will now deal with the matter. It is anticipated that the appeals will be heard (method yet to be decided) in the Autumn. The Council may well choose to withdraw its objections, which may shorten the process slightly, but it will still be determined by the Inspectorate due to other objections (unless they too are withdrawn). It is probable that a final outcome (so either a dismissed appeal or confirmed Order) is likely to take until early winter.

 As was made clear in the Feb 2014 Cabinet report there are a number of ways that objections may be mounted toward the Council’s relocation plans. Project costings have reflected the potential impact of delay and the costs that such objections may result in for the Council.

Launch of photo competition for new book on East Devon

The sheer variety and volume of writing inspired by our local area  is behind the idea for a new book, Literature and Landscape in East Devon, to be published later this year.

As announced at last Friday’s hugely entertaining East Devon Writing event, original, relevant, high quality photographs are now being sought for inclusion in the book. Please see PHOTO COMPETITION on the EDA Home page, for precise information.

For a flavour of the forthcoming book, see the following list compiled by Mike Temple of Sidmouth (N.B. only some examples from the list will be included!) the-literature-of-east-devon-by-location . Another ‘taster’ is Robert Crick’s sharply humorous view on the Napoli shipwreck, Cargoes

 

 

East Devon Literature: from Exmouth to Axmouth

Although not an East Devon Alliance event, many members attended Michael Temple’s fascinating evening on the literature of our district last Friday in Ottery St Mary.

Many great writers have been inspired by our area: Coleridge, Conan Doyle, Defoe, Tennyson, C Day Lewis, Wells, Raleigh and Patricia Beer. In an hour and a half of readings, we heard from all of them, and from living local authors too.

Beautifully narrated by Michael, this ninety minute feast reminded us that our part of the world – from Exmouth to Axmouth – has as distinct an identity and a place in literature as any other part of the country.

Thanks were given to all who helped, including local libraries, bookshops and newspapers. Prizes were generously funded by the Sidmouth/ Ottery Herald. The prizewinners were warmly applauded. They were Philip Smith, for  Beer Beach in January: ; and budding author Libby Dean (aged 12), for A Scene from Sidmouth Folk Festival .

(Please note that contrary to an earlier report,Harry Guest did not win a prize in the writing competition – his excellent poem, the Boyhood of Raleigh,pointing to things today which would be unfamiliar to a child of that time, was published back in 1997).

Organiser Michael Temple has added: “I should like to warmly thanks all the readers and living authors who read the extracts and poems so well. (I was the link-man.)”

Knowle should not be marketed until after outcome of village green application say experts

Page 55 of agenda for EDDC Cabinet merting of 4 June 2014:

Marketing of Knowle/Manstone

It was our aim to carry out a marketing exercise in time to report to July 2014 Cabinet and Council on developer interest. Land agents have been interviewed and, in discussion with the Relocation Executive Group, it is recommended the Council employs Savills, an experienced property agency, to manage a marketing exercise for Knowle and Manstone. The tendering exercise for the section of consultants has been completed, and marketing could commence. However, whilst all agents regard the sites as an attractive development proposition of significant value, their advice has been to hold off commencing marketing until there is clarity regarding the outstanding Town and Village Green application for parts of the Knowle.

EDDC to administer flood relief grants

Flood resilience support given approval
Measures designed to help home and business owners protect their properties from future flood events have been approved by the council.
Last week, members agreed to give delegated authority to the chief executive to administer the East Devon elements of a scheme that forms part of a nationwide Government initiative prompted by the devastating storms and floods experienced during the past winter.The Government has launched a number of initiatives to assist householders and businesses recover from flooding and make their premises more resilient to future bad weather.

Councils have been invited to administer several schemes to:
• provide grants to householders and business owners to protect their properties
• offer Council Tax and Business Rate relief
• provide small ‘one-off’ grants called the Business Support Scheme.

The offers are available to owners of properties actually flooded between 1December 2013 and 31 March 2014 and for work designed to prevent future flooding as opposed to work that should be covered by insurance.

Guidance issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government working with Defra means councils can administer the scheme on behalf of the Coalition.

EDDC’s local scheme is based on guidance issued in March and is mostly concerned with administration of the Repair and Renew Grant, which councils can award and then claim back from Westminster.

 

Measures designed to help home and business owners protect their properties from future flood events have been approved by the council.
Last week, members agreed to give delegated authority to the chief executive to administer the East Devon elements of a scheme that forms part of a nationwide Government initiative prompted by the devastating storms and floods experienced during the past winter.

The Government has launched a number of initiatives to assist householders and businesses recover from flooding and make their premises more resilient to future bad weather.

Councils have been invited to administer several schemes to:
• provide grants to householders and business owners to protect their properties
• offer Council Tax and Business Rate relief
• provide small ‘one-off’ grants called the Business Support Scheme.

The offers are available to owners of properties actually flooded between 1December 2013 and 31 March 2014 and for work designed to prevent future flooding as opposed to work that should be covered by insurance.

Guidance issued by the Department for Communities and Local Government working with Defra means councils can administer the scheme on behalf of the Coalition.

EDDC’s local scheme is based on guidance issued in March and is mostly concerned with administration of the Repair and Renew Grant, which councils can award and then claim back from Westminster.

Nort Devon council to spend £80,000 (yes eighty thousand pounds) on relocation

The equivalent, perhaps, to EDDC moving to the cash haemmoraging Thelma Hulbert Gallery … hhmmm

http://www.devon24.co.uk/news/museum_move_for_council_s_top_brass_1_3579621

‘What do they know’ about Knowle relocation?

EDDC has formally been asked for critical calculations, and other details. See https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/relocation_from_the_knowle#incoming-507521

Dates for your diary this Easter weekend.

Saturday 19 April, The Strand, Exmouth, 10a.m -4 p.m . Click here for details: EDA Exmouth

Monday 21 April  The Ham, Sidmouth 11a.m -5 p.m. Sidmouth’s first SeaFest…a community celebration of our coastal heritage. See http://futuresforumvgs.blogspot.co.uk/2014/04/sidmouth-sea-fest-bank-holiday-monday.html

Inspector is denied access to full Knowle costs

See report on yesterday’s continuation of the Sidmouth hearing: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/03/12/knowle-evidence-at-inspectors-disposal-is-inadequate-says-sos-legal-representative/

A quick round up of the week’s events.

On Wednesday (26th Feb) the EDDC council voted to push ahead with the relocation, probably to a SkyPark site (pending yet more consultation!), with costs of close to £1,000,000 approved for the purchase of land for the newbuild offices.
For a fuller report, please see following link…http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/knowle-sale-and-skypark-spend-voted-through-under-veil-of-cabinet-minutes/

On Thursday morning (27th Feb) Cllr. Claire Wright was interviewed on Radio Devon about the motion to have an independent survey of the Knowle Buildings done – Cllr. Diviani declined to make any comment

For Full story – http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/knowle-sell-off-diviani-declines-radio-devons-invitation-to-be-interviewed-this-morning/

For Radio Interview – http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p01r46tb Claire Wright Interview on BBC Radio Devon – from 40.10 mins

Last week Devon County Council (DCC) voted 32-23 against letting members of the Youth Service speak for 3 minutes about the proposed £970,000 cuts to their budget, on the grounds they had not sought permission within the deadline and to allow them to do so would set a bad precedent.

They failed to mention the deadline for submission was Friday 14th February, 7 days before the meeting, but news of the cuts was only released “accidentally” on Thursday 13th February, so leaving the Youth Service very little time to organise. The organisers contacted the council requesting permission to speak during the week in the run-up to the meeting, which confirms the council were fully aware of their request days beforehand, so could easily have avoided this shameful episode. For webcast of the DCC decision, see following link from 20.20 mins onwards.

Webcast of DCC Decision – http://www.devoncc.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/118409

And for Cllr. Moulding’s written justification of the decision, please see DCC Reply- http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/why_devon_county_council_tories_voted_against_against_allowing_young_people

To sign the Youth Service petition please follow the link… http://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/john-hart-protect-our-youth-services-from-budget-cuts

For latest news on the Local Plan Examination Hearings, please see recent posts on this EDA website.

No whipping at EDDC, so why the synchronised change of mind?

Some Conservative Councillors voted against the motion (only slightly differently worded) that they had vociferously backed and voted for at the Overview and Scrutiny Committee. No debate was aired, to indicate what had caused this complete reversal. A recorded vote was proposed, but firmly rejected ‘en bloc’ by the Tory Councillors. (Of course, it’s not obligatory to follow a whip. As Cllr Tony Howard told a group of EDA members at last night’s meeting, he has voted against the whip at least twice at the DMC.)

Comment on today’s EDDC press release is at this link: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/council-leader-says-eddc-will-be-engaging-with-customers-and-stakeholders-on-office-relocation/

Principles behind Knowle relocation have been abandoned, says EDDC Councillor

This speech was made last night:

EAST DEVON DISTRICT COUNCIL MEETING
26 FEBRUARY 2014

KNOWLE RELOCATION NOTICE OF MOTION

COMMENTS BY CLLR ROGER GILES

Chairman, when I first heard of the proposal to relocate the EDDC offices from The Knowle to Honiton, I thought that the principle of it had some merit.
To go from Sidmouth, despite all its many charms, to a much more central East Devon location at Honiton and the benefit of a railway station as well as the A30 and A35 appeared to be sensible.
To have new designed-for-purpose offices, rather than a converted hotel with myriad corridors and staircases also seemed sensible on the face of it.
Of course the principle often becomes much less attractive when the details of what is necessary become known – particularly the costings.

The costs of the project have rocketed.

And the principles behind it have been abandoned.

No longer is a central location proposed – but a location virtually in Exeter.

Quite understandably the people of Sidmouth and Sidmouth Town Council were very concerned about the proposed relocation. Concerned about the effect on The Knowle and its magnificent grounds and trees. Concerned about the effect on Sidmouth`s economy and the loss of jobs. Concerned about the consequent and excessive provision of 5 hectares of employment at Sidford.

But Sidmouth`s loss was to be Honiton`s gain. Lots of jobs for Honiton people, and a boost for Honiton`s economy.

Not now!

When this relocation project was first proposed the economy was relatively buoyant; people were relatively well off; and this Council was also relatively well off.

Not now! There is a much harsher economic climate. Many ordinary people – the better off – have had to pull their belts in. Many more are in a far far worse situation and are really struggling to pay their bills – including their Council Tax bills. This Council is suffering from unfair financial settlements from the Government.

It is important that we do not lose sight of the purpose of East Devon District Council. EDDC exists to provide services for the people of East Devon. To provide those services it spends taxpayers` money. Of course to enable it to provide services for the people of East Devon EDDC needs offices.

It does seem to me that there are some people who are running this Council who have lost sight of the purpose of EDDC. People who seem to be determined to press ahead, with what many members of the public see as a vanity project, regardless of the cost; regardless of what the people of East Devon think; regardless of the cost to EDDC`s reputation. And I very much suspect regardless of what the staff of EDDC think.

Yesterday afternoon all EDDC councillors received a letter from Mike Owen on behalf of the Cranbrook Consortium expressing concern about the decision to go for Skypark. The letter asked for the process to remain open.

Chairman the Council should listen to Mike Owen. But the Council should also listen to the people of Sidmouth; and also listen to the East Devon Council Taxpayer.

I urge the Council to support the Notice of Motion. To halt the reckless charge towards this damaging and hugely expensive project. And to stop the chain of devastation that would be left in its wake.

Knowle for sale

At what cost? Well, risking the economy of two major East Devon towns, for a start.
See this report on Full Council meeting: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2014/02/27/knowle-sale-and-skypark-spend-voted-through-under-veil-of-cabinet-minutes/

Councils on the move.

Some Councils decide to move with good reason, and clear cost-savings. East Devon District Council’s plan to relocate to newbuild offices at the faltering Skypark, has no such certainty.

So tomorrow’s Full Council meeting will hear vigorous calls from Councillors and the public, for more complete information about relocation costs and how they were arrived at. (In fact, EDDC’s own Overview and Scrutiny Committee recently voted with a two-third’s majority, and no objections, to ask for precisely that). The necessity for the move has also been called into question.

Despite a Councillor’s mention to an EDA member this evening that nothing is set in stone, the Cabinet seems to be feverishly pursuing the purchase of land for new offices at Skypark. The Full Council will be asked to approve £1,000,000 for this purpose, tomorrow evening (6.30pm at Knowle, Sidmouth). £350,000 (not including officer time) has already been spent, and an additional budget of £400,000 (over two years) has also been set aside just for preparing the move.

Other Councils, meanwhile, are responding to Government cuts in a different style, as reported in the Western Morning News:
http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Councils-look-new-homes-Government-cuts-bite/story-20691834-detail/story.html