64 Cornish parish and town councils unite to fight “death of democracy”

Cornwall Council faces a growing rebellion from a grassroots movement of local councillors angry at what they call “the death of democracy”.

A revolt of 64 town and parish councils has now formed an alliance which demands that the unitary “super council” puts its “house in order”.

The group – Cornwall for Change – accuses the local authority of “incompetent governance” and is set to descend on County Hall in Truro next month demanding answers.

Orlando Kimber, spokesman for the organisation, said the delegation was made up of “serious minded” individuals not a “bunch of people waving banners”.

Mr Kimber, a leading member of the Campaign to Protect Rural England who is standing for The Party for Cornwall (Mebyon Kernow) at the general election, called for a return to “ethical” and “transparent” government.

He singled out planning as a chief concern and blamed “edicts from Westminster and other sources” for “destroying the county”, adding that elected members have “all but lost their democratic right to make decisions”.

“We are not willing to witness the death of democracy in Cornwall,” he added.

We need to restore the structure of democracy; ensure that policies which affect us locally are fit for our common good and develop a culture of governance that is based on genuine dialogue with ordinary citizens.

“In short we must put our house in order. The first action is to discard everything that is rotten and useless -we cannot make progress until this step is taken.”

Representatives of the rebellious council group, which formed in September, met on Wednesday at Kingsway Hall, Fraddon.

The group was constituted to examine the “many and diverse anecdotal claims of poor administration” by the council.

They claim there have been too many homes and developments approved without without regard to infrastructure or employment capacity.

Much of this has been justified by the inflation of actual levels of housing need by using the waiting list or Homechoice Housing Register figures as a basis, they say.

Councils are unhappy about delegated powers to planning officers, a lack of democratic process in public meeting and a lack of transparency over accounts, including wholly or partially owned companies.

Cornwall for Change is currently amassing a dossier outlining all the complaints and plans to submit the “evidence” soon.

Armorel Carlyon, a former county councillor and mayor of Truro with 40 years continuous service in local government, said the group was not “gunning” for the council but wanted to work together in a “positive” spirit.

She blamed the replacement of the old committee system with the “cabinet and leader” model, which was introduced by Labour’s Local Government Act of 2000 and is common throughout Devon and Cornwall.

“The democratic rights have been eroded by the change from the committee system, under which every member was engaged in a more free way,” she said.

Mrs Carlyon said she was “sad” that some of the officers were “not as sharp” as in the past as the cash-starved authority could no longer afford to hire top quality workers.

“There are things that need to be sorted out and the best way is to work together,” she added.

“The leader John Pollard is an excellent man who tries his best in a difficult set of circumstances but he won’t have heard about all the problems as he has got a thousand things to do – once he has been made aware he can do something about it.”

Andrew Wallis, an independent councillor who now sits in the cabinet, said he had seen it from “both sides”.

“I have had my beefs with the way that the system was run but we do try to engage with as many people as possible – even under the committee system people often didn’t turn up and others moaned that it wasn’t inclusive either,” he added.

“People can spend too long chatting in local government – it is all about making the right decisions for the people of Cornwall.”

Mr Pollard said the group had twice declined an invitation to meet though the offer to discuss their concerns remains open and a date of March had now been fixed.

He added: “We also asked for a list of the parishes who had officially sent representatives but, so far, they have not given us this list.

“Whatever the issues, whatever the cause, whatever the background I am determined to work with all sectors to deliver the best for Cornwall and am sure that the meeting can only be useful.”

Read more: http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Cornish-rebellion-rages-death-democracy/story-26017806-detail/story.html

‘Candidates meet at HQ’: Express and Echo report on EDA news

ExpressandEchoEDA12thFeb15 001

 

Local press: holding power to account or power’s public relations?

Interesting article in a recent Guardian on changes in local and regional press which gives food for thought.

What’s more important to citizens – journalism or commerce? Which is more valuable to our democracy – public information or private profit? What matters most to people – holding power to account or acting as power’s PR?

Tony Watson, told a parliamentary committee: “Things have got so bad in the regional press now, courts and councils are not getting covered sufficiently.”

…The effects of that decline – the over-reliance by editors on filling space with single-sourced PR-provided “oven ready” copy – were highlighted in Nick Davies’s seminal Flat Earth News in 2008. He may not have invented the description for such material as “churnalism”, but he certainly popularised it.

..“One of the biggest market failures in the last decade is local journalism”, it says, arguing that “vast swathes of modern life are increasingly unreported or under-reported.”

Read more:

http://www.theguardian.com/media/greenslade/2015/jan/30/bbc-and-the-local-press-its-time-for-a-proper-factual-inquiry

Midweek Herald on ‘breath of fresh air’, and the delayed Local Plan

Two thorough articles in today’s Midweek Herald, on some burning East Devon issues, in case readers missed them in our earlier posts:

MidweekEDA10thFeb

MidweekLocalPlanFeb10th2015

 

The disconnect between local and national politics

In an article entitled “Labour closes its eyes and pinches its nose”, published in yesterday’s Sunday Times, Camilla Cavendish wrote principally about the problems of poor leadership in Rotherham Council. A Council she describes as an uncountable, one-party state, which has now had to be taken over by Eric Pickles, the Communities Secretary. She goes on, however, to make this more general observation on the disconnect between local and national politics:

“This [the takeover] is a massive intervention in democratic institutions. But there has been no outcry. For local democracy is getting thinner and thinner. Fewer and fewer people vote in local elections, especially if the outcome is a foregone conclusion. And fewer and fewer MPs sit on local councils. In 1960 about a quarter of British MPs’ were also local councillors; now it is fewer than 1% . This is at odds with France, Finland and Spain, where most national politicians sit on their local authority. This gives them both a greater stake and more say. Working in Lambeth, I saw how hard the indefatigable MP Kate Hoey had to work sometimes to exert leverage over the council on behalf of voters.”

“The disconnect between local and national politics has made councils defensive and MPs reluctant to interfere……. “

“..together, we really can do this”

…East Devon Alliance (EDA)  certainly believes this, as do the new network of Independent candidates supported by them.

And the same theme is in this message today from the Organiser of the Save Clyst St Mary Campaign:

‘I have been asked to point out that the Neighbourhood Plan meeting on 12th February is only for the original Planning Committee in this instance. There will, however, be another opportunity to view and comment on the Plan in early March. I apologise for any confusion this may have caused.

Due to the anticipated number of people who want to see Hugo Swire on the 19th February at 6.30, we have now been able to secure the Village Hall ( note the change of venue) . Please do come and ask our MP, who is responding in response to the invitation we sent, about any issues and questions you may have regarding planning in his Constituency.

Finally, thank you once again for your contributions towards paying for Charlie Hopkin’s reports. Do keep visiting the EDDC ‘s Planning website. The recent contribution for English Heritage is particularly interesting.

I know I seem to have said this many times before, but please remember – together, we really can do this.

Gaeron Kayley

http://saveclyststmary.org.uk/’

DEADLINE FOR OBJECTIONS TO KNOWLE LANDGRAB IS 20 FEB. Your voice counts!

More thoughts from the public on EDDC landgrab at the Knowle are here: https://www.streetlife.com/conversation/3w1f67nozab7/

Info and how/ where/ to object, at this link: http://saveoursidmouth.com/2015/02/04/fact-file-on-knowle-plan-and-land-to-be-appropriated-reminder-deadline-for-objections-20th-feb-2015/

“Ask difficult questions, rock the boat, annoy and upset powerful people …”

In an article titled “These failures show that Rotherham is not alone” by Gaby Hinsliff in today’s Guardian:

… “Casey signalled that an unhealthy culture had become embedded partly because this was a solidly Labour council, one where there was not much political opposition, but also officers who knew the same old people would be re-elected next time. It didn’t do to fall out with them. The same will be true not just in solidly Tory councils but in any organisation where people stay forever, where problem employees aren’t confronted but kicked upstairs.

And that’s why all institutions need faintly oddball, stubborn, counter-cultural people who may well be irritating to work with but ask the questions others don’t. Several of the MPs who have campaigned on institutional child abuse have the same quality; so do most of the investigative reporters who have pursued the story and so arguably does Casey.

It is to be hoped that Goddard does too, because if sunlight is the best disinfectant then contrariness – the ability to ask difficult questions, rock the boat, annoy and upset powerful people – is a crucial second line of defence. An organisation that can listen when the wrong people are talking inside it has at least a chance of listening to the wrong people outside too.

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/feb/05/child-abuse-failures-rotherham-management

Save Clyst St Mary..next meeting, 12 Feb 2015. Hugo Swire taking an interest.

Save Clyst St Mary Notice of meeting 12 Feb 15 (1)

Thank you to everyone for your support over and attending the meetings. A lot has been achieved in a very short space of time.

The Parish plan is progressing well and there is another meeting(Sorry!) on Thursday 12th February at 7.00pm this is to discuss the draft proposals of the village plan the venue is in the village hall. Once this plan becomes adopted it should help to stop our village from the continual threat of further large scale planning applications from developers!

Many of our residents have asked what our local MP is doing about all these planning applications and why Clyst St Mary has had so many in such a short space of time. Mike Howe has convinced Hugo Swire to come and talk to us on Thursday 19th February in the School Hall at 6.30pm (Sorry we couldn’t get the village hall it was already booked) I would really like to fill the hall to show how much support we have behind us and to ask what he is doing about it! Please Please come if you can.

Independent now “front-runner” to unseat East Devon’s MP

Message sent in to EastDevonWatch:

FIND OUT HOW CLAIRE WRIGHT WOULD REPRESENT YOU AS OUR NEW MEMBER OF PARLIAMENT IF EAST DEVON ELECTS HER IN MAY. She’ll be at a PUBLIC MEETING IN SIDMOUTH, WEDNESDAY 11 FEBRUARY 2015,
7PM, UNITARIAN CHURCH (AT THE JUNCTION OF HIGH STREET WITH ALL SAINTS ROAD).

The public meeting scheduled for 7 pm on Wednesday 11th February in Sidmouth’s Leigh Browne Room has been moved around the corner to the larger premises at the Unitarian Church on the corner of the High Street and All Saints Road.

A spokesman for Independent Candidate Claire Wright said: “Claire lives in West Hill, Ottery St Mary. Sidmouth was chosen as the first venue in her planned series of public meetings throughout the East Devon constituency as she bids to become our next Member of Parliament.

“Since the meeting was announced last month, Claire has been overwhelmed with messages of support from Sidmouth residents. She has therefore decided to move the event to a larger venue to accommodate the likely numbers.

“Another public meeting is scheduled for Woolbrook on 1st April and Claire will also be attending several events and taking part in election hustings with other candidates in Sidmouth during the run up to May 7th’s General Election.”

When Claire Wright first announced her candidature the bookmakers gave odds of 66-1 against her winning. The odds have shortened week after week since then and she is now seen as the front-runner to displace the current MP.

Action on Knowle landgrab

See https://www.streetlife.com/conversation/3w1f67nozab7/c/5/?eid=3487f7ff-687a-4c21-84ad-1a7cb9812f39&utm_source=immediate&uid=1vqhj9eoi27am

Planning meeting this evening… 05/02/15..reminder

Just a reminder that this evening there is a meeting in the village hall at 7.30pm to discuss the planning proposal to demolish no 16 Clyst Valley Road and build 40 new houses on the land sandwiched between the football ground and the back gardens of houses on Clyst Valley Road. Charlie Hopkins (Expert planning consultant) will be there.

Should anyone need transport please ask. We have several willing volunteers that have offered to ferry residents to and from the meeting.

Hope to see you all later on.

Best wishes

Gaeron
http://saveclyststmary.org.uk/

New East Devon Alliance of Independents “a breath of fresh air”

From today’s Exmouth Journal:
New group “a breath of fresh air”
David Beasley
A brand new alliance for independent candidates is vowing to change the political landscape across East Devon.
On Tuesday, just 93 days before the national and local elections on May 7, the campaign group East Devon Alliance (EDA) revealed that, as far as the Electoral Commission is concerned, it is now a political party, unveiling a website and manifesto.
However, in reality, the EDA is a broad, umbrella group for similar-minded activists – and now more independent candidates are set to contest district council seats in East than at any point since 1973.
At the launch at the Axminster Heritage Centre, its leaders urged residents – tired of the old political parties – to rally to their cause.
Its leader is Woodbury and Lympstone’s independent district councillor Ben Ingham, with freelance BBC documentary maker Paul Arnott as chairman and Ian Mckintosh, founder of the EDA, and retired circuit judge, its president.
Councillor Ingham said: “For years the three main national political parties have been telling us what they want to do instead of listening and then delivering what we need to have.
“People are so fed up they have even been voting for the nationalist parties as an alternative, but these alternative parties prey on people’s gravest fears… they preach division and separation instead of unity, respect and understanding.”
He said it did not have to be like that and insisted that prospective parliamentary candidate Claire Wright, EDA’s council candidates and other independent councillors had a ‘very definite set of ideas.’
“Our campaign is like a breath of fresh air in a stagnant room,” said Cllr Ingham.
“So, over the next few weeks, all of us in East Devon should open the windows to change, breathe in deeply and take part in the most exciting political event to happen in East Devon for decades.”
Their policies range from ensuring that East Devon District Council (EDDC) is more open and accountable, supporting local businesses, preserving the environment, keeping local hospitals open and backing new developments – but only if they are `sensitive’ to what local people want.
Mr Arnott said: “We will allow vulnerable independent candidates to stand as independent East Devon Alliance candidates in May
“We know how hard it is for independents to stand without the help of a party machine.”
He said that the EDA had heard many complaints from residents about the way things were done at EDDC ‘because of national parties first standing in local elections 40 years ago, it has led today to an atrophied one-party disaster…’
“There’s no point just moaning from the sidelines…the only way to reform our council is through the ballot box,” he said.
“In May, the people of East Devon will be offered independent candidates across the district on a previously unknown scale.”

Rotherham Council – just taken over by central government – BBC news main story tonight

The following headlines and story relating to the same council, , from only a few years ago, may have some bearing on our own District Council’s office relocation extravaganza.

£9.9m bill to equip Rotherham Council’s new offices
Published date: 26 August 2011 | Published by: Gareth Dennison
113998%20New%20Council%20Offices
Bill: Rotherham Council’s new offices.

ROTHERHAM Borough Council’s multi-million pound new offices will cost £9.9 million to furnish.

The £3 million-a-year rent paid to regeneration group Evans for Riverside House does not include kitting out the buildings.

The first staff will begin moving in before Christmas and the authority insists the total cost is less than staying put in its ageing existing buildings.

Britain run by “political gangs” say Bishop and MP

… “Political parties are run by gangs. The present gang running the Tory party was formed at university.

“They (the gangs) will bring people in when they need them but very rarely do those people go on to positions of leadership – they get spat out once they’re not needed.” …

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Political-8216-gangs-8217-ignoring-food-crisis/story-25972780-detail/story.html

Knowle landgrab fact file , & rapidly approaching deadline for objections (20 Feb)

See http://saveoursidmouth.com/2015/02/04/fact-file-on-knowle-plan-and-land-to-be-appropriated-reminder-deadline-for-objections-20th-feb-2015/

The function of scrutiny – excerpts from Rotherham Abuse Inquiry report

“… Even more significant is the apparent lack of effective scrutiny exercised by these several groups or bodies, and least of all by the Scrutiny Panels.

Scrutiny in its widest sense is an essential component of Cabinet government. Rarely does it appear from the minutes that councillors have held officers to account by checking the evidence for proposals or asking whether their ends could be met in other ways.

It may be that the minutes are written in bland, non-specific, language, but that does nothing to reassure the public that genuine accountability is being exercised.

It is important that councillors test proposals by reference to their broad experience and their knowledge of the Borough and their own constituents. There should be nothing threatening about this; good officers should welcome challenge as a central part of local democracy.”

“… Executive ‘leaders’ play a large part in defining organisational culture by what they say and what they do. In this respect, leaders such as senior officers and members in a Council should model good behaviour for their staff groups and others in setting the tone for their shared endeavour to deliver the best possible services. This includes values, attitudes and working language.”

38 Degrees campaign local group holds Sidmouth meeting this evening

7.30 pm to 9 pm at the Anchor in Sidmouth old Fore Street

This will be a TOTALLY non-political meeting to discuss issues that local people feel that 38 Degrees should support. No political campaigning or posturing will be allowed as 38 Degrees works hard to ensure it is politically neutral.

Find out more about 38 Degrees here:

http://www.38degrees.org.uk/

and more about their campaigns and local groups here:

http://www.38degrees.org.uk/campaigns