Talk at Exeter Uni by Chief Executive of NHS on 21st Century NHS

Simon Stevens:

Creating a 21st Century NHS

Part of the Exeter Lecture Series

Wednesday 2 November 2016, 19.00 – 20.00

Alumni Auditorium, The Forum (Streatham Campus)
Video linked to G10 Lecture Theatre, Truro (Knowledge Spa)
Tea and coffee available on Streatham Campus from 18.30

Register now at Eventbrite (free)

In this talk Simon Stevens, Chief Executive of NHS England, will talk about creating a 21st Century NHS.

Simon is the Chief Executive of NHS England, which leads the NHS’s work nationally to improve health and ensure high quality care for all. He is accountable to Parliament for over £100 billion of annual Health Service funding.

During this lecture you will be able to hear about plans for the NHS and have the opportunity to participate in a short question and answer session with Simon.

The lecture will be hosted by the Provost, Professor Janice Kay, and is open to staff, students and the general public. To register for this event and to read more about Simon please visit the event web page.

Please note: this event will not be recorded, therefore booking is essential if you would like to attend.
Launched in our Diamond Jubilee year, the ‘Exeter Lectures’ will bring high profile speakers from the worlds of academia, business, the arts and civil society to the University to share their thoughts and ideas, provoke discussion, and challenge us to rethink how we understand society.

Contact us: diamondjubilee@exeter.ac.uk

How many hospital beds make 5?

Disquieting information here:

http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/the_case_for_cutting_hospital_beds_in_eastern_devon_gets_off_to_a_shaky_sta

from ever-campaigning Claire Wright. It raises some very serious questions about where the “Success Regime” gets its ” numbers” from.

Well done Councillor Wright for not letting this slip through the net.

A Freedom of Information request needed here, methinks.

NHS set for “perpetual winter of Narnia”

That’s the standard technique of privatization: defund, make sure things don’t work, people get angry, you hand it over to private capital.”

Noam Chomsky,

“The NHS is missing so many of its key performance targets that it has entered “the perpetual winter of Narnia”, a medical leader has said, after figures revealed the highest ever number of patients on waiting lists.

Claire Marx, president of the Royal College of Surgeons, criticised the NHS’s failure to give patients planned care in hospital within the required 18 weeks, such as surgery for cataract removals, hernia repairs and hip and knee replacements.

The number of people in England who are awaiting such treatments has climbed to almost 3.9 million.

Demand for NHS care is dangerously high, says thinktank
Hospitals are meant to treat 92% of patients on the “referral-to-treatment” (RTT) waiting list within 18 weeks, according to guarantees in the NHS constitution. However, they did so in just 91.3% of cases in July, NHS-wide performance data released on Thursday shows. It was the service’s worst RTT performance in more than five years.

Hospitals met the 92% target in nine categories of RTT patients, including those requiring treatment for eye problems (92.7%), cardiac care (92.7%) and gynaecological problems (92.3%). However, it missed the target in 10 other categories. It treated barely four of of five (81.7%) of all those awaiting neurosurgery within 18 weeks, 86.9% of those needing plastic surgery and 88.9% of trauma and orthopaedic patients.

“It feels as if the NHS has stepped through the wardrobe and into the perpetual winter of Narnia,” Marx said. “We cannot forget that behind these statistics are potentially very ill and anxious patients who are being made to wait far too long for treatment. This is the true impact of the serious financial pressure we’ve seen the NHS come under in recent months.”

The NHS also missed targets covering A&E, ambulance response times, diagnostic tests, two forms of cancer treatment and rapid first treatment for those experiencing psychosis for the first time.

Dr Mark Holland, president of the Society for Acute Medicine, said: “This data reflects a system which is close to breaking down.”

Bed blocking has reached record levels. In July a total of 184,188 bed days were lost to delayed discharges – when patients are fit to leave but social care support is not in place – up sharply from 147,376 in the same month last year, and the highest number since records began in August 2010.

At midnight on the last Thursday in July, 6,364 patients who were fit to leave were still in their beds, up from the previous record of 6,105 patients the month before.

“For every 100 people who come to A&E, around 30 are admitted and, of these, 20 come under acute medicine. That number is increasing and our front-of-house workforce is depleted,” Holland said.

However, performance is most significantly hampered due to our inability to discharge people at the backdoor of our hospitals. Failure to get people home is, in my view, a national emergency.”

Medical leaders want ministers to urgently pledge more money for the NHS to tackle its growing problems.

Marx said: “The forthcoming autumn statement offers an opportunity for the government to provide more money for the NHS and social care, and to agree to a cross-party commission to review how we can make the NHS sustainable for the long term. Without a serious look at what the NHS needs in funding, we will remain in a state of constant winter.”

NHS England said that despite missing so many targets, its performance was still very good by international standards.

“As the NHS responds to ever increasing care needs, hospitals are continuing to look after more than nine out of 10 A&E patients within four hours, and more than nine in 10 patients are waiting less than 18 weeks for their routine operations,” said Matthew Swindells, its national director of operations and information.

“While this is probably the best performance of any western nation, these figures underline the pressures facing the NHS, and the obvious risks to patient care posed by weeks of further drawn-out industrial action.”

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2016/sep/08/nhs-perpetual-winter-waiting-list-record-bed-blocking

Swire: is the Maldives more important to him than the loss of NHS beds in East Devon?

On 22 September 2016, Hugo Swire issued a bland statement about planned hospital bed closures in East Devon, broadly supportive of the plan as long as Sidmouth hospital’s beds were amongst those to be retained:

https://www.hugoswire.org.uk/news/statement-proposed-hospital-bed-closures

On the same day, he tweeted that he had met with Devon Doctors and “agreed with them that some local politicians had mislead the local community and should apologise”.

(To date, Swire has not named those local politicians, nor has he elaborated on what they should apologise about).
Yesterday, he tweeted:

Just finished 2 hour meeting at County Hall with @NEWDevonCCG and Success Regime on hospital beds consultation.“.

He does not mention whether this was (yet another) private briefing for him and Conservative politicians or whether it included others not of that persuasion.

Since then he has Tweeted on the cessation of the “Right to Buy” scheme and “Daesh on the back foot”.

He has not added any clarification of his meeting about the NHS in Devon.

In the last week, all his (written) questions (4) in Parliament have been about the Maldives:

http://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/written-questions-answers-statements/written-questions-answers//?page=1&max=20&questiontype=AllQuestions&house=commons&member=1408

Hospital patients being discharged too early with dangerously inadequate social care”

“Patients are too often being discharged from hospital when it is not safe for them to leave due to poor levels of health and social care integration, according to MPs.

A report released today by the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, found that a lack of integration, caused by the historic split between health and care, meant that interdependent services were being managed and funded separately. This “political maladministration” was causing suffering for patients and relatives, it said.

The committee was responding to work carried out by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, which it said highlighted “harrowing cases that illustrated the human cost of poor discharge”. These cases were not isolated but were persistent problems across the health service.

Poor patient discharge can take the form of delayed transfers of care, where patients are kept in hospital longer than is necessary, and premature or early discharge, where patients are sent home before it is clinically safe to do so, or without appropriate support in place.

Barriers to the implementation of best practice are prevalent at the interface between health and social care, the committee said. Pressures on resourcing and capacity were “leading to unsafe discharge practices”, and it called on health and social care leaders to ensure that person-centred care remained the undisputed priority.

The report found that while excellent guidance was available, good practice was not being applied equally across the system and more data was needed on the scale and impact of the failures.

Responding to the report, parliamentary and health service ombudsman Julie Mellor, highlighted the human cost that could arise when people fell through the cracks, and blamed the underfunding of social care.

She said: “We see too many cases where discharge from hospital has gone horribly wrong, particularly for older, frail people who often don’t have the right support in place at home to cope on their own.

“These shocking failures will continue to happen unless the government tackles the heart of the problem – the chronic underfunding of social care which is pilling excruciating pressure on the NHS, leaving vulnerable patients without a lifeline.”

Committee chair Bernard Jenkin said some hospital staff felt under pressure to discharge people earlier than was appropriate.

“Hospital leadership must reassure their staff that organisational pressures never take priority over person-centred care,” he said.

He stressed that staff needed to feel a level of trust and openness that enabled them to raise concerns about unsafe discharge.

The report referred to the Better Care Fund and the Discharge Programme Board as being “promising”, in bridging the gap between health and social care. But, it cautioned that these plans were far from implemented.

The committee urged the health secretary to establish a set of objectives for the board, with measures and timelines, so progress could be monitored. Also, it advised the government to set out a route map, by March 2017, to demonstrate how arrangements for sustainable funding for integrated care will be implemented.”

http://www.publicfinance.co.uk/news/2016/09/poor-service-integration-blame-dangerous-hospital-discharges-mps-say

NHS bed closure ” consultation” to begin

“Consultation” – Owl really doesn’t know whether to laugh or cry!

This afternoon NHS Northern, Eastern and Western (NEW) Devon Clinical Commissioning Group’s (CCG) governing body gathered for an extraordinary meeting at Exeter’s County Hall, following the announcement to close 72 community hospital beds in its eastern locality.

Details of the proposed consultation were discussed which will reduce the number of community bed units from seven to three.

The Your Future Consultation was approved by the governors signalling the start on the consultation on Friday, October 7.

It will run for 12 weeks and ultimately it will be NEW Devon CCG who decide which beds to close.

The four options being proposed in the consultation are…

A) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Exmouth.

B) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Exmouth.

C) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Whipton.

D) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Whipton.

In the options Tiverton hospital will definitely remain open. Honiton and Okehampton have not been included in the options so will close.”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/devon-community-hospital-bed-closure-consultation-is-given-go-ahead/story-29760710-detail/story.html

YOUR COMMENT DOES NOT HAVE TO BE IN FAVOUR OF ONE OF THE ABOVE – IT CAN POINT OUT POOR OR MISSING OR MISLEADING INFORMATION AND/OR PUT FORWARD OTHER SUGGESTIONS.

The NHS is not overspent, it is underfunded!

Swire accuses “some local politicians” of misleading the community on NHS and should apologise

From Swire’s Twitter account 22 September 2016

5.13 am

1/2 Pleased to attend Exmouth Town Council on Monday. Good discussion with Devon Doctors on proposed changes to out-of-hours GP services.

5.18 am

2/2 Fully agree with them that some local politicians have been misleading the local community and should apologise.

Anyone have any idea what he means – he sounds very unpleasant – or perhaps on the back foot?

Any “local politician” heard from Swire with a demand to apologise?

And what’s he up to at 5 am – on his way to Saudi, perhaps!

Neil Parish adopts a butterfly

“TIVERTON and Honiton MP Neil Parish has ‘adopted’ one of the UK’s most threatened butterflies in a bid to help boost its numbers.

The nationally scarce Marsh Fritillary is in decline across Europe, but can be found in small numbers across Devon, including on Dartmoor.

Mr Parish visited the national park recently after becoming a ‘Species Champion’ for the rare butterfly.

He said: “I am thrilled to be working with Butterfly Conservation (BC) to raise the profile of the Marsh Fritillary and I’m hoping that by being a ‘Species Champion’ I can contribute to securing its future.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/neil-parish-adopts-rare-dartmoor-butterfly-to-help-boost-its-numbers/story-29745290-detail/story.html

Unfortunately, Parish has yet to tell us hovw he plans to secure the future of the NHS in East Devon.

Freudian slip?

Which hospitals in Exeter and East Devon will be affected by the cuts are the subject a public consolation scheduled to begin next month.”

Read more at http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/devon-community-hospital-closure-plans-vehemently-criticised/story-29744503-detail/story.html

Neil Parish: what do you have to say about NHS bed closures?

A correspondent has quite correctly pointed out that Owl has not shone the spotlight on Neil Parish and his views on NHS hospital bed closures on his patch in East Devon.

Owl is so used to Neil Parish saying nothing at all – except about dualling the A303 or, at a push, farming – that he does drop off the radar. Apologies.

Parish does indeed need to let us know his views as he has seen all in-patient beds go at Axminster hospital and now he is seeing them all go at Honiton and maybe at Seaton. A dire situation for East Devon – though leavened for him in that the hospital at Tiverton (also in his constituency but in Mid-Devon council area) will definitely stay.

However, a word of caution on his views – like Swire’s they can bend with the wind. During the referendum he called himself a Remainer but after it he first threw his weight behind Boris Johnson for Leader and then, when he withdrew, he backed Angela Leadsom – both fervent Leavers.

But, as with Swire, these are totally safe Conservative seats so he can say what he likes.

Or can he?

When is a hospital not a hospital?

If a hospital loses all its inpatient beds, is it still a hospital?

No, it’s a “health hub”, or some other fancy phrase.

Until it gets sold off by NHS Property Services for development.

Which creates more householders to become patients – of the hospitals we haven’t got.

Swire says no hospitals will be closed … how does he get that idea?

The commissioning group has given four (and only 4) options:

A) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Exmouth.
B) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Exmouth.
C) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Whipton.
D) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Whipton.

Swire says:

From the outset it is important to note that Devon’s NHS is currently in dire financial straits. Steps need to be taken now otherwise our local NHS could be facing a £400m deficit by 2020/2021.

Establishing a new, efficient and patient-centred model of care is absolutely vital for the long term sustainability of our local healthcare service. I am clear that a key part of any new model of care must be the provision of hospital beds.

‘It is also important to stress that the CCG are not consulting on hospital closures, they are consulting on hospital bed closures. Hospital closures are not on the table.”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/hugo-swire-releases-statement-on-planned-closure-of-community-hospital-beds/story-29741811-detail/story.html

NOW, LOOK AT THE FOUR OPTIONS AND TELL OWL HOW ALL THE HOSPITALS WILL BE KEPT OPEN?

To begin with, Honiton hospital isn’t mentioned – the presumption is that it will close come what may.

In Option A – Whipton, Seaton and Sidmouth go
In Option B – Seaton and Whipton go
In Option C – Sidmouth and Exmouth go
In Option D – Seaton and Exmouth go

Or, is Owl missing something?

http://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/600-hospital-beds-to-be-axed-in-devon/story-29739152-detail/story.html

Whatever, it is clear that Swire views our hospitals as overspent and not underfunded.

And where is that extra £350 million a week??!!

Honiton to lose all its hospital beds?

From the blog of Claire Wright, Independent councillor at Devon County Council and member of its Health Services committee.

Okehampton and Honiton Hospitals are set to lose all in-patient beds in a cost cutting exercise by local health services.

72 beds are to be cut from 143 in all, with four options that will be consulted on, although health bosses have a preferred option of keeping beds at Tiverton, Seaton and Exmouth.

Other hospitals at risk of losing all their inpatient beds are: Sidmouth and Whipton Hospital in Exeter

Health chiefs hope that the bed cuts will save £5-6m a year, with around 20 to 40 per cent of current running costs reinvested in creating health hubs and providing more care in people’s homes.

Some councillors had a briefing this afternoon from the chief executive of the “success regime” which has been drafted in by government to make significant cuts to counteract a deficit of around £430m by 2020.

We should remember that this area of Devon has already lost all inpatient beds at Ottery St Mary, Axminster, Crediton and Budleigh Salterton.

Discharging people from the RD&E in Exeter has never been more difficult.

Not only is there a funding crisis in the local NHS, there is also a funding crisis in social care locally, which is one of the reasons why people are unable to be discharged in a sensible length of time. This budget is hugely overspent at Devon County Council.

The consultation on the bed cuts is set to start on 7 October, with a decision made next February by the Northern, Eastern and Western Devon CCG (NEW Devon CCG). If agreed proposals will be implemented in March.

For my views on hospital bed losses see – http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/health_scrutiny_committee_to_ask_to_health_select_committee_to_investigate

I was interviewed by BBC Spotlight about the cuts. Here’s how they reported the issue this evening, at 3 mins 43 – http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b07v2gpz/spotlight-evening-news-21092016

For more detail see http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/where-will-72-community-hospital-beds-be-lost-in-devon/story-29738533-detail/story.html#R9PAwLxGj62bsWFV.99

(At least) 600 hospital beds to go in Devon – 72 of them in East Devon

Hospital being pitted against hospital (e.g. Sidmouthor Seaton to close)

“… the body which runs health services in most of Devon said that it was now looking at proposals to cut 72 beds in community hospitals in the east of the county.

The four options under consultation are…

A) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Exmouth.

B) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Exmouth.

C) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 beds in Seaton and 16 beds in Whipton.

D) 32 beds in Tiverton, 24 in Sidmouth and 16 beds in Whipton.

http://www.plymouthherald.co.uk/600-hospital-beds-to-be-axed-in-devon/story-29739152-detail/story.html

To repeat: the NHS is NOT overspent, it is underfunded

RIP Devon NHS – Conservatives get special advance briefing

“A ‘confidential’ briefing to Conservatives on Devon County Council confirms community hospital beds across the county will be cut and patients will not be admitted for treatment and care ‘unless it is absolutely necessary’.

The NHS has planned a series of carefully orchestrated announcements tomorrow (Wednesday 21st) but it has now been revealed that Devon’s Conservative councillors had a confidential email last week telling them about some of the planned cuts.

It’s angered other councillors who are demanding to know why confidential information was given to the Conservatives on Thursday last week (15th).

Cllr Alan Connett, Shadow leader of Devon County Council and leader of the Liberal Democrat opposition, said: “The NHS belongs to everyone. We are all concerned about what the new plans will mean and how treatment will be affected for residents.

“Yet again, we find the Conservatives at County Hall think the rules don’t apply to them. Isn’t it hugely arrogant of them to slip out a secret briefing in the early hours of Thursday to their own councillors a full week before NHS managers announce their plans publicly.

“It’s another Conservative shambles and will greatly undermine any confidence we can have in them or the NHS which, presumably has been telling county hall chiefs what’s in the cuts pipeline.

Across Devon, people may well be wondering if some grubby private deal has been stitched up between NHS bosses and county hall Conservatives over these planned cuts.”

In a confidential email to just Tory councillors, Conservative Stuart Barker, cabinet member at county hall for health and adult social care, said: “There are some consultation documents going out from the NHS which are likely to have an effect on the budget for adult social care.

“I am sending you a synopsis of some things that are in the consultation documents and included some information about how DCC (Devon County Council) could be impacted.

“We shall be working with NHS partners to ensure DCC has a share of any savings that can be found.”

And Cllr Barker goes on to tell his Tory colleagues: ” The NHS believe that there are too many people in community hospital beds across Devon, who don’t need to be there.

“Every day, in NEW Devon, there are 150 people in community hospital beds that could be cared for at home. In addition, of the current 247 community inpatient beds across the NEW Devon CCG (clinical commissioning group) footprint approximately 100 beds are unused.

Cllr Connett added: “We can see what’s planned, can’t we? The NHS is reported as saying they don’t need the 150 beds now being used and, by strange co-incidence, there are 100 beds not being used at all. Magically, the two come to around 250 – the same number of community hospital beds the NHS want to close.

“I’m as keen as everyone else to hear what the NHS plans are for health cuts across Devon, but I think it is totally wrong for the Conservatives to sneak out a private briefing just for their councillors, which will undermine the whole public consultation process the NHS is about to launch.”

http://www.theprsd.co.uk/2016/09/20/confidential-briefing-confirms-nhs-community-hospital-beds-close/

The myth of local health consultations and “choices”

Our local health services are NOT overspent, they are underfunded.

We are NOT having to make “difficult choices” – we are being told what has been decided for us behind closed doors about the consequences of that underfunding.

“Public consultation” is far too little far too late. The decisions were made long ago about which services will suffer and we cannot reverse those decisions without a MASSIVE revolt against them, and even then concessions will be zero or minimal.

That is the reality.

If we want to change that most of us will have to vote out the people who brought us to this. Unpalatable for some, but the only course available to us.

Sidmouth Blackmore Health Centre protest Monday 19 September 11.15 am

Press release from the Patient and Public Involvement Chair, Di Fuller:

“The public response to fears over the future of the Blackmore Health Centre have been very encouraging.

Increases in rent and other costs, as well as plans from NHS Property Services (NHSPS) to redevelop the Blackmore Health Centre with added flats and a pharmacy, would radically increase costs to the Practice and threaten the future viability of the Practice on that site.

Hugo Swire MP, is visiting the Blackmore Health Centre on Monday 19th September to discuss the issues in detail with Dr. Joe Stych, other Partners and patient representatives. NHS Property Services and EDDC planning department have also been invited.

We ask members of the public who are concerned about the future of the surgery and agree with our request to purchase the

Blackmore Health Centre

to demonstrate their support outside of the Centre from

11.15 a.m. on

Monday 19 September.

Joe Stych said, “The ideal solution here would be for NHSPS to sell Blackmore to the practice so we are in charge of its future.

We would like to ask patients to write to Hugo Swire and Jeremy Hunt to campaign for the building to be sold to the practice to protect it.

We need people to question NHSPS as to why an operational building cannot be sold to motivated health care providers who will make them more efficient and responsive to our communities needs for healthcare provision.”

Di Fuller, Chair of Sid Valley Patient Participation Group has asked that people turn up on Monday to show their support for the Practice. We also want them to sign a petition asking Jeremy Hunt to allow NHSPS to sell Blackmore to the Practice to protect its future and to write to Hugo Swire and Jeremy Hunt with the same request.”

No more out-of-hours GP service for Exmouth

Interesting because Exmouth at around 35,000 population is substantially bigger than Honiton, with its 12,000 population.

“Devon Doctors, which runs the out-of-hours GP services in the region, is planning to combine the scheme with Devon’s NHS 111 service, which it will take over next month.

Under the plans due to take effect on October 1, treatment centres such as the one at Exmouth Hospital will close in favour of patients phoning the 111 service for help.

Currently, there is one GP who provides out-of-hours care on weekday evenings and two at the weekends.

This change means there will be no GP working in Exmouth and patients may face having to travel to Exeter or Honiton for treatment.”

http://www.exmouthjournal.co.uk/news/exmouth_set_to_lose_out_of_hours_gp_1_4689459