Seeds of change

In this period of rebellion in the ballot box, the incumbent East Devon Member of Parliament may be expecting to have a battle on his hands at the next election, less than twelve months’ from now  (May 2015). As signalled in our earlier post, one very popular, Independent, County and District Councillor, a signatory of the EDA Charter, has today declared her intention to stand against him, and others may of course follow ( We’ll keep you informed).  This was how Councillor Roger Giles, the long-standing and much respected District Councillor for Ottery St Mary, introduced her to the assembly in Sidmouth:

“A very warm welcome to everyone. Welcome to the Dissenters’ Room, which was provided by Annie Leigh Browne. Annie Leigh Bowne is a local heroine who not only gave Sidmouth the Byes and the Cottage Hospital, but was also a leading suffragist who successfully led the national campaign for women`s representation in local government, which was achieved in 1907.

A very appropriate location for the launch of Claire`s parliamentary campaign!

Many of you will know of all the fantastic work that Claire has done whilst she has been an East Devon District Councillor. She has been a beacon in the cause of openness and transparency and fairness at EDDC – often in the face of animosity and hostility from conservative party councillors.

One of her great successes was to expose the undue influence of East Devon Business Forum members on EDDC`s planning policies, and also the undue influence in their own members` planning applications. The Chairman of EDBF was former Councillor Graham Brown.

When Claire raised this matter at the EDDC meeting on 25 July 2012, she was accused by senior Conservative Councillors of:

“impugning integrity”; of engaging in “speculation, misinformation and
innuendo”; “debating through the media”; and making “scurrilous”
allegations.

There never has been an apology. Not even after the Daily Telegraph exposure of March 2013.

Claire has been amazingly energetic and persistent. Just look at some of the things she has done:

* Successfully campaigned to retain maternity services at Honiton Hospital

* Provided the first play park at West Hill

* Pressed for better protection for trees

* Fought against the Government relaxation of planning policy (NPPF)

* Vigorously opposed unnecessary and damaging levels of development on
greenfield sites in East Devon

* Got EDDC to allow recording of its meetings

* Pressed for the creation of a cycleway from Feniton to Ottery to Tipton to
Sidmouth on the disused railway line

* Regularly engaged with and sought the views of people, young and old

* Communicated extensively with electorate by various means, including the
extensive use of her excellent blog

* Opposed planned cuts to local services, and is currently fighting to save
Ottery`s youth centre, childrens centre, and library

* Pressed for openness and transparency in planning at EDDC, demanding
that planning committee members reveal if they have been lobbied

* Fought EDDC`s vanity project to relocate its offices at a cost of millions
of pounds of taxpayers money at a time when EDDC is slashing the
services it provides to the public
That is an amazing level of energy and determination.

Claire`s work was recognised by the electorate of the Ottery Rural ward in the Devon County Council elections of May 2013. She obtained 74% of the vote. She got the biggest vote; the biggest share of the vote; and the biggest majority of any councillor in the South West.

We know what you have done Claire – and we thank you for it.

And we are delighted to come here today to endorse your campaign to be the next Member of Parliament for East Devon.

Ladies and gentlemen I give you Claire Wright – our next MP.”

More comment, with photographs of today’s campaign launch at http://susiebond.wordpress.com/2014/06/03/cllr-claire-wright-launches-her-campaign-for-a-seat-at-westminster/

 

 

Overview and Scrutiny Agenda – meeting 12 June 2014, 6.30 p.m. Knowle – very little overseeing and almost no scrutiny and two elephants not in the room

The 154 page agenda for the next Overview and Scrutiny committee on 12 June 2014 at 6.30 p.m. at the Knowle is HERE

Mostly it is a re-hash of some old reports and surveys, a new report (NHS) and some other surveys done with very few people (in one case just 7).  There is almost nothing that the Overview and Scrutiny Committee can do about any of the items on the agenda and one has to wonder why they are there as it is the items NOT on the agenda which are more important.  For example, not a mention of the Business Task and Finish Forum (examining the influence of the disbanded East Devon Business Forum, Chairman – disgraced ex-councillor Graham Brown).  It shows the current Overview and Scrutiny function as neither overseeing nor scrutinising.

They will not discuss relocation until at least the September 2014 meeting and even that is not guaranteed.

One little pearl hidden away in these 154 pages:

EDDC reviews a consultation exercise done in 2014 where many people were displeased with how EDDC runs its Planning function. Under “Actions we are taking” is this:

We will run an awareness campaign about the way we deal with planning applications especially how this operates within nationally laid down rules and regulations. This campaign will explain how the planning applicant is the council’s customer for the service as they have to pay for it.

And there’s us thinking that we are paying for this service through our Council Tax!

A little nugget on office relocation too which once again illustrates that the cart of desperately wanting shag pile has gone before the cart of what has to be done first:

Office Relocation

EDDC is looking to relocate their offices. This has already entailed some community consultation. We are also regularly engaging with a stakeholder group that includes Town and Parish Councils,

Chambers of Commerce and interested community groups. We are soon due to begin consulting widely on the impacts of moving to SkyPark of equalities groups and other affected people and organisations and carrying out Best Value consultation to make sure we get the best out of any move. This consultation will involve randomly selected households, businesses, equalities groups and others. The results will be presented to Cabinet as part of the decision making process.

If anyone is in one of the groups of randomly selected households, businesses, equalities groups and (ha, ha) “Others” we would love to know!

Oh, and if you come across the agenda item “Update on the corporate engagement work being carried out as part of the Organisational Development function of EDDC” – er, what this actually appears to mean is “Report on Public Consultation”!!!

Page 146 reveals that our Chief Executive budgeted as costing a total of £86,500 per year for 2.5 days work each week.  That would equate to an annual salary and extras totalling £173,000 (South Somerset pays 50% for their 2.5 days of his valuable time).

 

 

What would happen if they did this survey here?

http://www.westerndailypress.co.uk/Council-morale-rock/story-21179107-detail/story.html

100% of the staff would be happy 100% of the time with a 100% turnout wouldn’t they!

 

Claire Wright officially launches bid to become East Devon’s MP

Claire Wright, EDDC Councillor for West Hill and DCC Councillor for Ottery St Mary Rural officially launched her campaign to become Member of Parliament for the East Devon Constituency at the Annie Leigh Brown Room, Dissenters Chapel (URC) Sidmouth this morning. She will be up against current MP Hugo Swire (Conservative) and others standing for other parties at the General Election in May 2015.

She was introduced by fellow Independent Councillor Roger Giles and made a short speech to an invited audience which included journalists. She then answered questions from the audience.

Details of visits she will be making to towns and villages in the area during the next year will appear on her personal website www.claire-wright.org which also has a link to an online donation site for her campaign.

Claire has signed the EDA Charter.

Concern over EDDC interpretation of Freedom of Information requests

Concern has been expressed, over an annual report by EDDC officers, as to to how the council carries out its duties in dealing with requests under the Freedom of Information Act.

An EDA member, Tim Todd, has submitted a question to tomorrows meeting of EDDC Cabinet, at which the internal report is to be presented.  He has noticed that the report, when listing to all the complaints made to the Information Commissioners Office (ICO) ,EDDC appears to have failed to mention an important complaint about which the Information Commissioner was critical of the council’s handling of his request

He points out that the ICO ticked EDDC off saying:-

“….. However, the handling of this request was less than satisfactory in a number of respects and the Council will need to use this case as a learning tool to avoid similar procedural issues arising in future”.  …..

When the council did respond with some of the information Tim had sought about EDDC’s £50,000 plus buy out of Exmouth’s Seaside Covenants from Clinton Devon Estates, EDDC presented their reply, after a delay of more than eight months, in a manner in which EDDC suggested they had revisited the question on their own initiative. They made no reference to the ICO’s involvement.

Tim says “Aside from the fact that EDDC’s last reply made no mention of the involvement of the ICO, the omission of any reference of to my ICO complaint in EDDC’s annual FOI report, suggests to me that not only have EDDC failed to take the ICO’s advice on board but their actions may now be seen as to extend to misleading councillors, the public and the press”. He also adds that no mention is made of the excessive number of times FOI requests go unanswered well beyond the statutory 20 working day deadline.

The ICO complaint forms part of

https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/further_background_papers_re_50k#comment-47067
The EDDC agenda item is at

http://www.eastdevon.gov.uk/cabinet_040614__-_public_version.pdf

(pages 86 onwards)

———————————–
For your information, Tim Todd’s question for Cabinet on 4th June,  is as follows: (He has requested Diane Vernon to arrange for it to be put, in accordance with Equality Act provisions, as he is unable to be present himself.)

Will the chairman arrange for an investigation into the production of the annual report on Freedom of Information Act requests 2013/2014 (agenda item 23, pages 86 to 88)?

The report as proposed is likely to mislead members, the public and the press, as to the operation, by EDDC, of their duties under the Act. It is incomplete and inaccurate, and suggests all has been well during the year in question when that is demonstrably not the case. Specifically, in stating that five (listed) complaints were considered by the Information Commissioners Office (ICO) in the period, it omits mention of a important complaint made to the ICO, (their reference FS50512425.)

It is a significant omission for a number of reasons, not least its criticism of EDDC’s handling of the FOI request.

The ICO’s letter to EDDC, dated 23 January 2014, includes the words “However, the handling of this request was less than satisfactory in a number of respects and the Council will need to use this case as a learning tool to avoid similar procedural issues arising in future.”

In omitting all references to this complaint in their FOI report, and with other pertinent omissions, those concerned might be deemed to have mispresented  the situuation to the council, the press, and the public with a misleading annual account of EDDC’s compliance with both FOI law and their more general openness and transparency obligations.

East Devon empyt homes figure corrected but still bad

…

East Devon has 663 empty homes, up on the year by 152…

so, its up BY 152 not FROM 152 – so it’s still bad and still ? Cranbrook.

Read more: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Exeter-East-Devon-sees-rise-number-homes/story-21177296-detail/story.html#ixzz33Yg5qpxG

East Devon “has 663 empty homes” compared to 11 last year

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/10-000-homes-stand-Devon-Cornwall-Somerset/story-21176229-detail/story.html

… East Devon has 663 empty homes, up on the year by 152. …

One can only hope this is a typing error but the Express and Echo is usually reliable on such figures.  If it is correct (a) how shocking and (b) Cranbrook perchance?

And then watch builders develop in multiples of 50!

Will the government never learn – or perhaps it doesn’t want to:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/liberaldemocrats/10868579/Small-housing-developers-exempt-from-zero-carbon-home-regulations.html

Flooding to become more common in Devon

Following on from the post below:

 

http://www.westerndailypress.co.uk/Boscastles-future-Met-Office-admit-underestimated/story-21175814-detail/story.html

“Flood schemes a disaster for South West Communities

“Councillor Stuart Hughes, Devon County Council cabinet member for flood prevention, said the council has not been successful in securing funding through the “partnership” model.

He said: “We have submitted further bids for more than £2.5 million to be considered for the next six year programme. We reported to Defra during the consultation process that there is a difficulty in obtaining funding for rural communities where there are low numbers of properties and little opportunity for large-scale contributions. This is a real issue for Devon which we feel needs to be addressed.”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Flood-scheme-disaster-South-West-communities/story-21172775-detail/story.html

Cranbook: its gain, our loss?

Anyone else in East Devon feeling short-changed as our play areas become concrete for housing or big sheds and our youth facilities are cut?

… The builders contributed £59,330 towards a play area, while other payments have also included nearly £6,000 towards a community development worker at Cranbrook and £22,231 towards youth facilities, including a temporary youth centre and a youth worker.

Read more: http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Cranbrook-developer-reveals-paid-80-000-community/story-21172746-detail/story.html#ixzz33QxBunhE

Will new UKIP and Independent councillors get the support they need?

Thought-provoking article HERE.

Given that EDDC has punished only Lib Dem and Independent councillors for transgressions this year (transgressions that have patently been either minor or those of ALL parties) it seems unlikely.

Still, our council vote is not until May 2015 – along with the General Election if the coalition can keep itself together that long – and it will be one of the yardsticks against which current councillors will be judged.

Hit out only at your opposition, ignore your own failings and one gets the distinct impression that it is fear and jealousy rather than right that are the drivers.

 

 

 

Deputy Leader suspended for sending texts under different names

It wouldn’t happen here would it …. and if it did, would the Monitoring Officer report the offender to the Standards Committee if he were the Deputy Leader of the majority party?

Paul Shotton [Deputy Leader, Stoke council] contributed to debates on BBC Radio Stoke both supporting the council and criticising the opposition over a period of six months. Staff rumbled the councillor after he sent text messages from the same mobile number under names such as Alison, Jean and Dave. He also pretended to be from different areas of Stoke-on-Trent, including Fenton and Smallthorne.

Mr Shotton yesterday admitted sending the texts and will now face a council standards board hearing. He said: “I apologise fully for my actions. They were plain stupid. I will never do anything like this again.”

BBC Stoke presenter Tim Wedgwood warned listeners recently that DJs at the station can see the phone number of people texting the station. A BBC spokesman said: “Audience interaction is an important part of our programmes and we read out texts from listeners in good faith but we are reliant on the audience being up front and honest about who they are. “In this case, we became suspicious after recognising the phone number and then referred the issue to the council.”

The Labour party has now launched an investigation into the incident after suspending the councillor. A spokesman said: “The Labour party takes these matters very seriously. Councillor Paul Shotton has been suspended pending an investigation.”

Mr Shotton is cabinet member for economic development and a ward councillor for Fenton East. He recently fought off a challenge to his position as deputy leader from Janine Bridges, cabinet member for housing.

Mr Shotton was not at a meeting of the council’s cabinet held last night, but it was reported that Stoke-on-Trent City Council leader Mohammed Pervez has taken on his cabinet responsibilities. Mr Pervez, said: “I was informed of the issue yesterday and immediately contacted the Labour party. The Labour party suspended councilor Shotton pending investigation.”

Gerry Clarke, the council’s deputy monitoring officer, said: “We have been alerted to allegations made against the deputy leader of the council. On the basis of information that has been provided, the council will initiate a standards board process to enable the facts of this case to be investigated.

“We understand an internal investigation is also being undertaken by the Labour Party, and it would therefore be inappropriate for the council to comment further until such investigations have been concluded.”
Read more at http://www.stokesentinel.co.uk/Stoke-Trent-deputy-city-council-leader-suspended/story-21164310-detail/story.html#BqgY7xkFw1GVUozr.99

 

EDDC & Planning…a comparison with nearby authorities.

Changes to rules for public speaking is one of the most sensitive items on the agenda at the next EDDC Cabinet meeting (Weds 4th June, 5.30pm at Knowle).

Many questions from the public are to do with Planning. Why is this issue so acute here? How does East Devon compare with nearby areas?  Here’s what an EDA researcher found, in a study done earlier this year Public speaking analysis_EDDC

 

EDDC HQ for Seaton?

Why not?  New build on virgin site exactly like Skypark but with the added benefit of helping to regenerate the town.  On the far edge of the district, just like Skypark so just about as difficult for people to get to.  In an area that desperately needs jobs (probably more than Cranbrook does with its proximity to Exeter), next to a lovely big Tesco and with a great walk by the sea at lunchtime!

Do your job, click and collect, walk by the sea, go home – what could be easier.

But it isn’t next to Exeter or its airport …..  ah well.  Bring on the Zimmer frames.

Protest group formed in Seaton after site on regeneration site for hotel changed to McCarthy and Stone retirement flats

We have received the following message from Seaton:

 The Seaton Regeneration area (Tesco site) had a plot set aside for a hotel to replace tourist beds lost when the holiday camp was demolished but the developers of the site (Tesco and Bovis Homes) say they were unsuccessful in marketing the site for a hotel.

Now McCarthy and Stone has take an option for yet another block of retirement flats.  Seaton is already highly over-represented with elderly people and retirement blocks which are to the north (Jubilee Lodge), east (Haven Court) and south (Homebaye House) of the regeneration area and will nowtotally encircle the planned new Visitor Centre.

Recently Tesco won the right to delete all the affordable housing that had been planned for the site.  No affordable housing has been built for many years in Seaton.

A protest group has been set up to oppose the latest development and will have its first meeting at

The Hook and Parrot

on Seaton seafront at

7.30 p.m. on

Thursday 5 June 1014 at 7.30 pm

to which anyone who objects to this planning application is warmly welcome.

 

Public access to EDDC accounts

We are once again approaching that time of year when the public have the right to inspect the council accounts for 20 days, full details of which rights can be found at

Click to access Council-accounts-Know-your-rights-July-20132.pdf

This right is a powerful tool and gives exceptional public access to this material, so we are encouraging people, a few weeks beforehand, to seriously think about what accounts information might be useful and how they might use it to their best advantage.
Those who wish to examine any accounts should make their own arrangements, as EDA is not able to make enquiries for other individuals or campaign groups.
When making an enquiry, please try to be specific as possible with regard to the information you want to look at, as the staff need to find what you want, rather than give you a pile of papers to fish around in. The lady at EDDC is most helpful and giving early notice of what you might like to examine is strongly recommended- not least as it gives time for follow up requests before the statutory 20 day period is expired.

The start date is variable, so we will be keeping an eye on the public notices in the local press and as soon as we have confirmation of the dates, we will let you know.

No-one gets paid anything …

Just to reassure EDDC:  no-one gets paid anything for posts on the EDA website – see this attempt to stop a blogger in Whitby criticising his local council – they had him investigated by the Department of Work and Pensions but it backfired spectacularly on the council:

http://www.real-whitby.co.uk/private-eye-slams-scarred-borough-council

and no councillor or officer is involved it its ramblings!

Mr Pickles LOVES citizen bloggers and is doing his best to make life easier for us!

http://talkaboutlocal.org.uk/eric-pickles-to-use-law-to-open-up-town/

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/citizen-journalists-and-bloggers-should-be-let-in-to-public-council-meetings

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-12543554

http://www.communityjournalism.co.uk/blog/2014/04/30/tweeting-at-community-council-meetings-the-role-of-community-journalists-in-local-government-scrutiny/

Voter dissatisfaction: direct action – what WE could do

Here a council must change from the tight-knit Cabinet only model (as EDDC has) where a Leader appoints his own Cabinet for a Committee model where committes make binding decisions and are made up in proportion to the parties voted in:

http://www.localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=18670:voters-require-nw-council-to-axe-cabinet-model-and-return-to-committees&catid=59&Itemid=27

Some background to this is given here:

http://www.rottenborough.org.uk/RachelBattersby.html

And here a town is petitioning to leave one local authority to join another:

http://www.localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=18688:voters-call-for-town-to-become-responsibility-of-different-local-authorities&catid=59&Itemid=27

and the background to this is here:

http://www.gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-news/emphatic-yarm-yorkshire-vote-leads-7181783#.U4X7TA1ezvQ.twitter

Seaton to West Dorset, Axminster to South Somerset, Cranbrook to Exeter City, Exmouth to Teignbridge, Budleigh Salterton to Kensington and Chelsea (sorry, got carried away there!) – interesting!

Progress of Local Plan: anyone know the difference between “could and should” and “can and will”?

It is almost an embarrassment to publish the latest correspondence between EDDC and the Local Plan Inspector, Mr Thickett.  The letter from EDDC with its “action plan” is so vague and indeterminate that it is simply a “wish list” (could and should) rather than an “action plan” (can and will).

You can almost hear the irritation in Mr Thickett’s reply.  However, he at least does try to set some sort of timetable (October/November) for the next stage of the process.

Interesting that the whole process will take us up to election time – so developer free-for-all will probably continue till then.

The correspondence:

Letter from EDDC:

lettertomrthickett-220514

The “action plan”

actionplan8may14

and Mr Thickett’s reply

letterno10toeast_devon

All correspondence and details of information provided for the Local Plan is HERE