It’s official: Devon and Somerset councils plan to merge: whither EDDC’s new HQ?

“Councillors from across Devon and Somerset have agreed on a joint devolution bid to secure greater control over skills, growth and employment in the region.

The decision follows a summit of county, unitary and district council chiefs in Exeter today, which brought local authorities one step closer to a devolution deal for the region.

Current plans propose an organisation based on the boundaries of the Heart of the South West Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP), with a focus on economic development and job creation.

Commenting on the progress, Devon County Council leader John Hart said the level of agreement had been “very encouraging”.

“It’s important that we present a united front to the Government,” he said.

“I have always said that we can do things more effectively and more efficiently locally than being told what to do by London.

“The big themes we hope to focus on are on skills, economic growth and improving productivity, as well as infrastructure so we can ensure our road and rail network is more resilient than it has been in the past.

“Doing the very best for our older residents by coordinating health and social care and affordable homes for our young people are also key themes.”

The announcement follows the confirmation of a devolution offer for Cornwall last month – the first non-urban deal of its kind.

LEP chief executive Chris Garcia was at the meeting, along with leaders from Devon’s eight district councils and Torbay mayor Gordon Oliver.

Councillors have previously indicated a bid could involve a “double devolution” model, under which the counties and unitary authorities would receive powers from central government and pass them down – where appropriate – to districts.

There has also been discussion of “soft” boundaries which would enable different parts of the region to reach individual devolution deals while still collaborating with neighbouring authorities.

The next round of devolution applications are due for submission in September.”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Devon-Somerset-councillors-agree-joint-devolution/story-27648023-detail/story.html

New GP surgeries costing councils millions in appealed rating valuations

Good for GPs and local health authorities (who receive refunds) bad for councils.

If this applies to EDDC, it, together with the £7m black hole which is soon to appear in EDDC’s council rent account must surely lead some councillors to wish that EDDC had invested in Knowle maintenance rather than allowing the building to deteriorate so they can build themselves new, expensive, offices in Honiton and massive refurbishment charges for offices in Exmouth.

“… According to Wychavon District Council, a number of GP surgeries had made successful appeals to the Valuation Office against the value given to their property in 2005 and 2010.

The council estimated that surgeries in its area alone would receive a £3.5m refund and £600,000 a year on an ongoing basis from this financial year.

Wychavon, the county council and Hereford & Worcester Fire Authority are expected to be responsible for half of the total losses.

The district said it would have to pay the majority share which will total £1.4m and £250,000 a year ongoing. …”

http://www.localgovernmentlawyer.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=24008:councils-in-plea-for-help-after-tribunal-ruling-on-gp-surgeries-and-business-rates&catid=58&Itemid=26

We are not alone (unfortunately)

Others in other areas have similar experiences of information being hidden from them and end up having their day(s) in court trying to get it:

https://westwayconcern.wordpress.com/freedom-of-information/

though, in their case, it took a lot less time!

AND this is information we have not (yet) seen for Knowle relocation.

Freedom of Information request, anyone?!

EDDC faces £7 million “black hole” – and blames the Tory government!

“The council, along with other local authorities who have housing stock, has a 30-year business plan to ensure that it is able to maintain its properties.

According to the authority’s calculations, the one per cent rent cut could mean East Devon’s ring-fenced Housing Revenue Account would reduce by £77.2 million over the next three decades. The council said this loss of income makes the business plan unviable.

The proposal has also been described as “particularly unwelcome” because the Government required East Devon District Council to take on £84.5 million of debt in 2012 in return for freedoms and flexibilities to run its council housing free from government interference.

The debt was based on the Government’s assessment of income and expenditure over 30 years, and three years into that arrangement, the government has been accused of proposing to “move the goalposts”.

Councillor Elson is urging the Government to reconsider the policy. She said: “This is very short sighted and this policy has tough consequences on us as a council and on tenants too. We need to secure a more effective balance between the needs of present and future tenants in the long term”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/East-Devon-Council-facing-7m-black-hole/story-27530755-detail/story.html

But, of course, it won’t stop them spending £8m plus on a new HQ – just cut down the amount of social housing they will finance.

And how interesting they had a 30 year maintenance plan for their housing stock, but not for their HQ!

Someone has also added a trenchant comment:

More blackmail from the Council. Their response to anything is “if you don’t do what we say, we’ll throw our toys out of the pram” but I notice they’re still spending £££s on moving offices, and more £££s on the seafront scheme which no one wants. Priorities! They’re always blackmailing the residents about something, anytime they have to toe the line. they threaten to make someone suffer for it.

Anyone got £30 to spare for a good cause?

Sidmothian Jeremy Woodward (who began the Freedom if Information process that East Devon District Council lost in court about secret relocation meetings and papers) is, as of this moment, only £30 away from raising the £660 needed to begin another challenge to EDDC.

This time it is about appropriation of Knowle parkland to enable developers of luxury retirement homes to have a larger outside space.

https://www.crowdjustice.co.uk/case/save-knowle-parkland/

Anyone who thinks this is a good cause is urged to donate the remaining amount. As mentioned before – this is NOT just about Sidmouth. This is about EDDC favouring developers over its own citizens and could happen anywhere in the district where EDDC own land.

Bid to raise Knowle legal challenge letter raising funds

As of this morning, 50% of the £660 needed to begin the process of a possible legal challenge to EDDC’s appropriation of parkland to extend the private grounds of the planned Pegasus Life luxury retirement complex has been raised:

https://www.crowdjustice.co.uk/case/save-knowle-parkland/

This is not only a Sidmouth issue: this same land grab could happen anywhere in East Devon where a greedy developer fancies a slice of public land owned by EDDC.

Extraordinary Meeting of the Council – 138 page agenda and background papers

“Newly elected Councillors please note that the Extra Ordinary and Ordinary meetings will be preceded at 5.00 pm with a briefing in the Council Chamber – the Chief Executive will outline the business of the meeting and the procedures.”

 

http://eastdevon.gov.uk/media/1227756/290715-combined-council-agenda-and-minute-book.pdf

#http://eastdevon.gov.uk/council-and-democracy/committees-and-meetings/council/council-agendas/

http://eastdevon.gov.uk/media/1141091/270515-annual-council-item-15c-constitution-update.pdf

Pegasus senior officer has colourful (and expensive) local authority past

A perfect fit for East Devon! Perhaps they could also recruit him to build Diviani Towers as the new HQ in Honiton!

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10520269

Cart before horse and jumping the gun at Knowle with Pegasus Life ?

Mention is made in today’s Midweek Herald that contracts have been exchanged with Pegasus Life for a residential and assisted living complex at Knowle, with a spa and restaurant which will be open to the public.

Isn’t there just the little problem of putting in a planning application and getting it approved first?

Or is this not the way things are done in East Devon?

Their 16 storey high-rise development in Sutton Coldfield wasn’t popular:

http://www.birminghampost.co.uk/business/business-news/sutton-coldfield-care-village-plans-7872196

Network Rail is VERY unhappy with them in Dawlish and said they could be committing an “act of nuisance”:

http://www.railnews.co.uk/news/2015/01/09-dawlish-plan-could-be-act.html

and their demolition of part of a Grade 2 listed mansion in Sevenoaks to provide a car park and kitchens wasn’t well received either:

http://www.sevenoakschronicle.co.uk/8203-30m-renovation-Seal-mansion-set-green-light/story-26415596-detail/story.html

Hugo Swire – good or bad timing?

Isn’t it interesting that Hugo Swire seems to criticise controversial decisions in East Devon just after those decisions have been mad.

Knowle relocation – condemned only after the decision had been made and just before the election.

Closure of local hospitals – criticised the day AFTER the decision was made.

Good or bad timing?

Knowle sold to Pegasus today

http://saveoursidmouth.com/2015/07/15/knowle-sold-today-to-pegasus-life/

Interesting that they would take it on without planning permission (or maybe it is an option to purchase dependent on planning permission ) …. but presumably they assume it will be a straightforward formality which will be rubber-stamped when the time comes.

http://saveoursidmouth.com/2015/07/15/knowle-sold-today-to-pegasus-life/

Exmouth slipway work postponed “because of mating birds”

Anyone find this story a bit odd? Did no-one realise that birds mate? And how come concern for mating birds in Exmouth and no concern for Horshoe Bats at Knowle?

And when the over-wintering birds have gone north, surely they are replaced by the over-summer birds from the south – and north!

You can tell that the owl is no ornithologist.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Work-1m-slipway-Exmouth-postponed-avoid-upsetting/story-26891834-detail/story.html

Devolution, Relocation – spanners in works

“Fixing the foundations: Creating a more prosperous nation”, published by the government today:

“15.3 To rebalance the economy, cities need effective governance. OECD research has shown that cities around the world with fragmented governance structures have up to 6% lower levels of productivity than those that do not.

15.4 England currently has 353 local authorities with over 18,000 elected members.5 This can lead to fragmented decision making and blurred accountability; even within the same city region, urban and suburban leaders do not always work together on shared objectives. The experience of London and other major international cities suggests that a directly elected mayor can cut through these difficulties. The government has therefore been clear that devolution of significant powers will rest on cities agreeing to rationalise governance and put in place a mayor to inspire confidence.”

Click to access Productivity_Plan_print.pdf

The Knowle bats – a question

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/East-Devon-bat-population-hit-office-demolition/story-26803273-detail/story.html

Question: how did the buildings get into such a state of dereliction that bats entered them in the first olace?

DCC cost of relocating offices to 2 floors of Barnstaple building

This begs the question: if £4 million was the cost for moving a few staff into 2 floors of a building – what is the REAL cost of building a totally new HQ?

“The council was proposing to move its staff from the civic centre, which has recently been vacated, and on to the top two floors of the Barnstaple Library building, one of which houses the record office.

But it today announced it is instead looking into plans to convert the civic centre annex into a modern open plan office.

This would cost around £3 million – £1 million less than the estimated £4 million it would have cost to redevelop the library building. …

… Councillor John Clatworthy, the county council’s cabinet member with responsibility for council property, said: “It would be wrong to rush head-long into a project at the library when we can spend £1 million less moving to alternative accommodation which is also suitable. It’s prudent that we looked at the options, and I’m pleased that a better solution has been found.

Read more: http://www.northdevonjournal.co.uk/County-council-scraps-plans-staff-Barnstaple/story-26863194-detail/story.html

Best utilisation of council assets?

Is it perhaps time to sell leases on Knowle office car parking spaces – as with proposals for leases on beach hut

sites?  It might only be for a year or two but it definitely would make a profit on the current charge to staff and councillors of – nothing!

They can then do it in Honiton and Exmouth and make a tidy profit!

Tories of East Devon – You just don’t get it, do you?

Wednesday 3rd June

The motion to delay the Knowle Sale by 6 months was placed before Full Council by Cllr Cathy Gardner and Cllr Matt Booth.  They both presented very reasoned cases for the delay and were conciliatory in their approach.  They stressed Transparency to the residents of East Devon and in particular Sidmouth.  They did not oppose the move merely asked for more time to allow greater consultation to ensure that the Council made the right decision.

The reaction was set by Cllr Williamson who insisted that as the decision had already been validated by the Overview and Scrutiny Committee (with a set of “independent” auditors) there was no need to delay – in fact he maintained that there was a need for greater speed.  Other speakers opposing the motion spoke of the need to move and how inappropriate the current building was.

Tories – you just don’t get it!  It is recognised that the current buildings are not fit for purpose AND SOMETHING HAS TO BE DONE – but what that is and how due process is applied is the central issue in this motion.

Previous Committees and Councils sanctioned a move to Sky Park – not a mention of that! Then a sudden concept of two premises – why the change?

The appeal to the Freedom of Information request was scathing of the Council – no acceptance of that or any explanation of what was so important within the papers that they could not be released – I doubt most Tory members had even read (or been able to read) them.

Reference to election results and other “facts” but no concept of the Perception of the public – they rightly feel marginalised.

Tories – you seem to have forgotten that you serve your community – these assets are not yours – they are not even EDDC’s – they are owned by the Council Tax Payers of East Devon – you merely act as temporary custodians in the passage of time.  You MUST consult with your Community – you have failed to do this as on other occasions.  You were given the opportunity last night to make a fresh start with Openness and Transparency – you rejected that offer with your customary arrogance.

The motion was defeated by a recorded vote – this may come back to bite you!

Owl

 

If only …..

“Yesterday Sid Valley was represented at EDDC by 7 Conservative couoncillors. Today by just one, with six Independents! The three Sidmouth Town Independents gathered 71% of the votes cast in the ward. The former Vice Chairman of the Council was ousted from Sidford Rural.

If only the incumbents had taken the opportunity last December to vote for delay until after the election before pressing on with relocation and been seen to be speaking up for their electors.”