Councillors: are you sure our LEP and your council are operating properly?

If not, read this:

Click to access bis-14-1241-local-enterprise-partnership-LEP-national-assurance-framework.pdf

Just a couple of examples:

the LEP and councils should:

…. publish their arrangements for making, and recording decisions, and for ensuring that papers, decisions, minutes, agendas etc are published in line with existing local authority rules and regulations [access to information, Schedule 12A of the LGA 1972, as amended by the FOI 2000];

and they should:

….. ensure that there is appropriate local engagement – both with public and private stakeholders to inform key decisions and with the general public around future LEP strategy development, and progress against delivery of the SEP, including key projects and spend against those;

Juicy judicial review material!

Local Enterprise Partnership Network

Keep an eye on what the gangs are doing here:

http://www.lepnetwork.net/

and read their less-than-impressive Newsletter here:

http://www.lepnetwork.net/modules_site_specific/newsletter/index.html

Read about their “promotions” here:

http://www.lepnetwork.net/latest-promotions/

and read this blog which attempts to tackle the real concerns we all have and – in Owl’s opinion – just makes matters worse and appears to confirm our worst fears:

http://www.lepnetwork.net/blog/are-we-really-witnessing-a-great-devolution-deception/

Devolution: Independent DCC Councillor Claire Wright and East Devon Alliance express grave concerns on the process

Councils across Devon and Somerset are on the verge of submitting a bid to government on devolving control and funding for some services to a local level.

On Thursday Devon County Council will debate a broadbrush bid that is set to be signed off by cabinet tomorrow.

This might sound like a very positive move, however, there are concerns. Mainly around transparency and consultation.

The government has decreed that the process must be “business led” which means that the Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP) has been heavily involved in discussions on what will be included in the bid to central government.

The LEP meets in private and does not publish its minutes or agendas.

Councillors have not been involved in the process, save for the forthcoming agenda item coming to full council on Thursday.

There has been no public consultation.

In the paper that goes to full council on Thursday, the list of topics to be included in the bid are:

– Health, care and wellbeing
– Connectivity and resilience
– Housing and planning
– Employment and skills
– Business support

What is always true in my experience is that the devil is in the detail.

The bid must be with central government by 18 December.

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

Here’s a press release from the East Devon Alliance, which is also unhappy about the process.

• To most people ‘devolution’ implies greater local involvement: local democratic power

• The process being followed for the ‘Heart of the South West’ devolution bid has no democratic element at all:

o No public consultation

 Input has been sought from the business community but not the public or elected representatives

o No consultation with elected Councillors regarding the process or on the content of the bid

 The information submitted so far has the logos of the Councils and implies endorsement that has not been explicitly sought or given

 Nolan Principles not followed

o It has been suggested that government guidance is to keep devolution planning confidential

o The Heart of the South West LEP (Local Enterprise Partnership) meetings, including those on the devolution bid, are not open to the public or press; agendas and minutes are not published

o The Electoral Reform Society are concerned about the lack of democracy and public engagement in the devolution process of England

http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/press-releases
• Timing is extremely tight, the final ‘bid’ is due to be submitted on Dec 18th with a deal expected to be agreed with central government in March 2016

• EDDC Joint Overview and Scrutiny committee and Cabinet on Dec 2nd are being asked to give delegated authority to the Leader to sign off on the bid – the draft of which has not been shown to Councillors

o EDDC full Council have not and will not get to debate the bid (or the benefits and risks of the proposal)

o Information suggests that this situation is being repeated in Devon County Council with limited information or opportunity for debate

• Past history of unelected bodies delivering services and economic benefits does not bode well: East Devon Business Forum

Click to access scaring-the-living-daylights-final.pdf

and Connecting Devon and Somerset (broadband)
https://eastdevonwatch.org/2015/11/23/broadband-for-devon-and-somerset-the-fantasy-saga-continues/

• EDA calls for:

o The Heart of the South West devolution planning process to be more open and democratic from now on

o The public and elected representatives to be regularly consulted

o Decisions involving the use of public funds (e.g. business rate revenue) to be made in public by accountable, elected representatives

http://www.claire-wright.org/index.php/post/devolution_more_locally_funded_services_or_a_deal_largely_struck_in_secret

EDDC and Rural Broadband – the facts

Excellent analysis on the East Devon Alliance website of the current situation regarding the rural broadband situation now that EDDC has announced its intention to ” go it alone” and arrange its own coverage …

http://www.eastdevonalliance.org.uk/district-issues/rural-broadband/

Would that our majority-party councillors were so well- informed.

Exmouth Town Council unhappy about Dinan Way Section 106 fait-accompli

Honestly, some of Exmouth’s town councillors are also majority party district councillors (including Councillor Maddie Chapman).  You would think that the left hand ought to know what the right hand is doing!  However, she IS on the EDDC Scrutiny Committee, so she might like to ask them to have a look at how this happened!

“Exmouth Town Council’s planning committee this week considered amended plans for 98 homes at Higher Marley Road.

But during the debate, councillors criticised a Devon County Highways statement saying that ‘Section 106’ money from the developers could be used to fund the completion of Dinan Way, between Hulham Road and the A376, and possible traffic calming works. Devon County Council later denied any wrongdoing.

During the town planning meeting, town mayor Councillor Maddy Chapman said: “I would like this council to object to the fact that a county council department is making deals with developers, behind the planning authority [East Devon District Council] and the town council’s back, by saying that Section 106 money can be used for traffic calming in Higher Marley.

“It’s not up to the county council to decide. [Section 106] is supposed to be community infrastructure, not spent on roads.”

Councillor Cherry Nicholas said: “What disturbs me is that they’ve already calculated, if they end up with 98 residential buildings, a contribution amounting to £5,000 per dwelling, ie £490,000, would be appropriate and consistent with the amounts required under a Section 106 agreement which can be applied to the Dinan Way extension.

“I just think that it is rather morally reprehensible that they’ve already jumped that far ahead.”

Town councillors voted to oppose the planning application – an outline application seeking approval for access only – with concerns also raised about overdevelopment, the loss of part of a Devon bank and a lack of community infrastructure. East Devon District Council will decide on planning permission.

A Devon County Council spokesman denied that the authority had gone behind the council’s back, and added: “Ultimately, Section 106s are a matter of negotiation between the county and district councils, because those authorities are responsible for highways and local planning, and the developer. But there’s no reason why the town council cannot suggest what it thinks the priorities for Section 106 contributions may be.”

http://www.sidmouthherald.co.uk/news/homes_opposed_amid_dinan_way_funding_dispute_1_4335249

How Japan is supporting its ageing population

“Japan’s imaginative initiatives for its older population show that prevention, postponement and interventions do not have to be dull or rooted in a context of care and that there is a strong link between social capital and health.”

http://www.theguardian.com/healthcare-network/2015/dec/08/casinos-leaf-picking-new-god-supporting-older-people-japan-cities

Will innovations such as these happen in East Devon? Not a chance as older people were last week classed as “unproductive” by EDDC CEO Mark Williams and therefore, by implication, unworthy of attention or funds from East Devon District Council plc – a sub- division of Local Enterprise Partnerships Conglomerate Inc.

Devolution: South Devon has major concerns

A correspondent in South Devon writes ( the views expressed are his or her own). The final paragraph and citation makes for particularly worrying reading for East Devon where, despite much opposition, we treasure our environment.

South Devonians have grave concerns about devolution to big business.

In South Devon we read your article with interest. We are also interested in the operations of the LEP and how they appear to be run by big business with much benefit and profits advantage for big business.

It seems to work like this……

A nice organisation that most people love like eg a large charity, colleges, universities etc wish for more money to fund pet projects. “Mr Big Developers” who makes loads of money from building open-market houses, expensive apartments, roads, nuclear power stations etc, are very unpopular locally. Most people support schemes for families on low income and the homeless.

So the Local Enterprise Partnerships broker schemes where the “nice organisation” gets the money for their pet project by partnering it with a “big developer” and with district & county council executives & LEP members ….. the general public and parish councils are usually kept in the dark about these arrangements, which they classify as “commercially confidential”.

They often justify the scheme as delivering affordable houses but the scheme does little to make truly affordable houses and nothing for the homeless, local people are ignored or overruled.

Local democracy in action…. No …. money for big business, and its friends …. Yes

These may also be of interest:

http://www.heartofswlep.co.uk/
The small print at the bottom is interesting where they mention things like their involvement with building 11,000 houses on the back of business support.

I have just come across some documents that show they now partner with organisations like Natural England and Dartmoor National Park and The enviroment Agency. http://www.lepnetwork.net/key-activities/natural-environment/

and a great one where:

“Purpose of report

This report identifies the key opportunities from and threats to the economic plans of the Heart of the South West Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP) which stem from the economy’s dependence on the environment.”

http://www.naturaldevon.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Local-Environment-and-Economic-Development-toolkit-report-%E2%80%93-Heart-of-the-South-West-LEP-a

Want to know about EDDC HQ move? Be a Heathpark tenant

image

It seems that tenants at Heathpark are going to be better informed about EDDC’s moving plans than the rest of us – including councillors, according to the front page of the View from Honiton today!

Flood defences: time for a rethink?

“… On Monday, experts called for new measures to be implemented –such as raising new buildings a metre above ground – to help cope with global warming-induced flooding.

Prof David Balmforth, a former president of the Institution of Civil Engineers, said that conventional defences, such as the barriers that line the river Greta in Keswick, had to be supplemented with more innovative methods.

We tend to design defences to a particular standard, to give an annual probability against flooding, which might be, say, a one-in-100- or one-in-200-year chance of the defence being overtopped,” he said.

“That would be a typical sort of figure that would be used. The question that now remains is: were the events that we’ve now seen in recent days so excessive that it’s reasonable to expect them to overtop defences?

Suggesting ways of coping with future deluges, Balmforth cited work that was done in Nepal. He said: “They have regulated minimum threshold levels about a metre above surrounding ground for any new major development, whether or not it’s in a flood risk area.”

http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/dec/07/britain-flood-defences-storm-desmond-fit-for-purpose

Skypark jobs: now you see them, now you don’t …

July 2014: new parcel depot at Skypark will create
147
new jobs:
http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Delivery-firm-DPD-set-expand-Skypark-East-Devon/story-21640859-detail/story.html

November 2015: new parcel depot at Skypark has created
35
new jobs:
http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/New-DPD-super-depot-Skypark-near-Exeter-creates/story-28212288-detail/story.html

Devolution: Scrutiny 1, EDDC Leader and CEO own goal

As Owl has already hooted, the Tory Government, for ideological reasons, is very keen to devolve some power over public spending to new regional bodies.

Local authorities in Devon and Somerset- including EDDC- have responded enthusiastically setting up a consortium, the Heart of the South-West (HotSW) to bid for more power to spend central government money.

But critics believe that the Government wants to boost local productivity by letting rip construction, housebuilding, and manufacturing, and by encouraging the selling off of public assets to be more economically exploited by the “free market”. Farming, tourism, and renewable energy seem low priorities. Climate change and the environment seem hardly to figure as concerns.

The negotiations at HotSW involve a business organisation, the Local Enterprise Panel, (LEP) but it’s difficult to know exactly who calls the tune, because the meetings so far have been closed to press and public and no minutes are published. A draft bid is almost ready and is intended to be sent to Whitehall before Christmas.

EDDC representative on HotSW is Council Leader Paul Diviani, and, true to form, a recommendation was about to be slipped through for Cabinet approval, to give Cllr Diviani delegated authority to agree to whatever bid HotSW comes up with!

But thanks to the insistence of Chair of the Scrutiny Committee , Independent Cllr Roger Giles, the context of the recommendation was openly discussed first, at a special meeting (Combined Overview & Scrutiny) called in the nick of time, just hours before the Cabinet meeting last Wednesday (2nd Dec).

The meeting began with a presentation by EDDC Chief Officer Mark Williams, which confirmed that the thrust of HotSW was to boost the local economy by expanding construction, industry and commerce – productivity was too low, he said, because there were a lot of old people in the area! The new digital economy would benefit from better training and apprenticeships, especially “Greater Exeter” (including part of East Devon).

Councillors were sceptical. Tory Mike Allen said HotSW negotiations should be more transparent, and Independent Cllr Rob Longhurst followed up his idea, putting forward the motion that a group of councillors with appropriate responsibilities should be kept informed of developments and consulted before decisions were made.

This was accepted, and it was also proposed that no delegated authority should be given to the Leader until the Full Council Meeting on 16th December, by which time all councillors would be sent a copy of the bid.

A triumph for transparency? Not quite— the bid will still not be put in the public domain before it goes to Westminster.

EDW note: Two previous posts on the subject here https://eastdevonwatch.org/2015/12/03/devolution-eddc-ceo-asks-us-to-trust-him-and-diviani/

and here https://eastdevonwatch.org/2015/12/05/that-devolution-meeting-part-2-the-dark-gets-darker/

“Parliament’s expenses watchdog hiding names of MPs being investigated for misusing public money”

“Rules dictate that MPs under investigation for unjustified or fraudulent expense claims must be publicly identified.

…Under rules set by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa), MPs under investigation for unjustified or fraudulent expense claims must be publicly identified.

But the organisation’s compliance officer, Peter Davis, has avoided naming individuals by carrying out detailed “assessments” of the complaints, denying they amount to formal “investigations”.

The loophole last week allowed Mr Davis to refer two MPs to the police over expenses fraud without ever launching a formal investigation, which would have triggered a public announcement.

It has also allowed other MPs to avoid publicity about using taxpayer-funded websites for party-political material by paying back website domain fees to Ipsa, or simply removing content from sites.

Ipsa previously proposed conducting probes in secret to prevent “reputational damage” to MPs – but the idea was dropped after criticism from the Commons Standards Committee and Committee for Standards in Public Life. It now appears that Ipsa is using “assessments” to get around calls for transparency.

According to a breakdown of cases, released by Mr Davis’s office in response to a Freedom of Information request, 40 “assessments” of allegations against politicians were carried out in 2014-15. But just one – relating to Conservative MP Bob Blackman’s mileage claims – was classified as a formal investigation and disclosed publicly.

Among those listed as “closed prior to an investigation” was a case in June last year where an unnamed MP claimed for a taxi journey that was not allowable. The compliance office concluded it had been a “legitimate error by a member of staff” and said it had been “repaid in full”.

In another case, an allegation was made that an MP’s staff had filed duplicate claims for a hotel. Mr Davis considered the matter closed after “the MP provided a valid explanation for why two separate hotels were claimed inadvertently for the same night and… repaid”.

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/parliaments-expenses-watchdog-hiding-names-of-mps-being-investigated-for-misusing-public-money-a6764016.html

All I want for Christmas ….

Will Diviani and Williams go head-to-head on this one, or does Swire have it in the Santa sack already (presuming it isn’t too far beneath him)?

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Lordship-East-Devon-village-grabs/story-28312790-detail/story.html

” One in a hundred/ two hundred years” floods

What would have happened if Storm Desmond had chosen East Devon for its landing, with all its rivers and estuaries?

What the Environment Agency DOESN’T tell you is that the phrase ” one in a hundred or two hundred year event” does NOT mean such floods will ONLY happen once in a hundred or two hundred years: they mean 5 or 10 times in a thousand years – which could be five or ten years in a row! However, if we do get 10 years in a row and we query them when it happens in year 11 – they will tell us it is an acceptable statistical variation, etc. etc.

Plus the EA uses PAST events to work out what to do where the past is no guide whatsoever to the future.

In any case, with climate changes going haywire and El Nino playing up more than usual, it is all pretty meaningless.

What CAN you do? DON’T BUILD ON FLOOD PLAINS – the clue is in the name! And perhaps even extend the said floodplains!

Local Government Association Housing Commission calls for submissions

Evidence should be no more than 3,000 words, which should concentrate minds. Though the press release below is somewhat misleading. It is true that more council housing was built between 2010 and 2015 than the previous five years but it neglects to say that many, many more council houses were built each year in the 20th century. For example, 11,740 council houses were built during the time of the coalition government, yet it was not unusual to see 100,000 – 180,000 council homes being built each year in the latter half of the twentieth century – only 15-20 years ago.

One also must note that right-to-buy took many of those homes out of social renting.

“The Local Government Association is today launching a Housing Commission to explore new routes to housebuilding so councils can enable the building of more desperately-needed homes.

Councils built nine times more homes between 2010 and 2015 than between 2000 and 2005 and are desperate to dramatically increase the availability of new homes in their local areas.

The LGA said this is vital to building the 230,000 new homes the country needs each year as private developers have not built more than 150,000 homes a year for more than three decades.

The Housing Commission will also explore the importance of effective housing in boosting jobs and growth, helping meeting needs of an ageing population, saving social care and the NHS money, and helping people into work. It will focus on four themes:

Housebuilding – new ways that councils can enable investment in new homes;

Place making, community and infrastructure – the role of councils in shaping homes within prosperous places and communities;

Employment, welfare reform and social mobility – the role of housing in supporting tenants to find and progress in sustained employment;

Health and quality of life for an ageing population – the role of housing in adapting to an ageing population and preventing onward costs onto social care and health services.

Evidence is sought on the key issues for communities, partners and councils, on good practice that has successfully addressed those issues, and what is needed to build on those successes. Councils, partners, organisations and individuals to contribute their issues, evidence, and examples of effective housing and ideas to the Commission’s Advisory Panel, made up of experts and academics.

The Commission will take a medium-term view incorporating current housing reforms but will look beyond them in making the case for councils to be able to deliver the homes our communities and places need. Findings will be brought together in a report in Spring 2016 and presented at the LGA Annual Conference in June 2016.

http://www.local.gov.uk/web/guest/housing/-/journal_content/56/10180/7594397/NEWS

Submissions to:
LGAhousingcommission@local.gov.uk

Some houses to have non- opening windows due to pollution

“FRESH air, once thought to be essential for a healthy lifestyle, is being banished from some of Britain’s newest homes and schools — because it is so polluted.

Developers are being told they will get permission to build houses, flats and schools on some sites only if they fit them with windows that cannot be opened and mechanical ventilation systems that filter toxins from incoming air.

The “hermetic homes” policy is being forced on councils by the Department for Communities and Local Government, which fears the designation of 700 air pollution zones by local authorities is blighting the 1,400 square miles of prime land within their borders.

Under the department’s national planning policy framework, developments in such areas can now go ahead provided buildings have features such as unopenable windows and filtration.”

http://www.thesundaytimes.co.uk/sto/news/uk_news/Health/article1641677.ece

Quiz question on Cranbrook

Which EDDC web page, updated only this month, lauds the employment opportunities available to Cranbrook residents at the inter-modal freight terminal – a project never started and totally abandoned in August 2014?

That Devolution meeting part 2: the dark gets darker

Mark Williams, CEO of East Devon District Council, was given a rough ride by majority and opposition Party Councillors alike, following his presentation this week (Weds 2nd Dec), to the District Council’s two watchdog committees.

The combined Overview and Scrutiny Committees (O&S) met to find out what lies at the heart of the Heart of the South West (HOTSW) devolution bid, shortly to be sent to Westminster.

Mr Williams compared the devolution bid to a train just starting on its journey from the heart of South West to London. But one Tory Councillor warned the CEO, “Before we get to Exeter, the lines may be broken because we’ll have run out of money”.

(There’s a summary of the presentation in our earlier post https://eastdevonwatch.org/2015/12/03/devolution-eddc-ceo-asks-us-to-trust-him-and-diviani/ )

After hearing it, the O&S Councillors expressed three areas of major concern:

1. Finance
2. Health service provision
3. Governance

Here is a sample of their questions to Mark Williams (MW) with some answers received:

Cllr Roger Giles (Ind, Ottery St Mary Town : Has any attempt been made to assess the cost savings of devolution?
MW : “No. It’s too early.” He went on to add, “We all know there is waste in (any) system” and “It’s better to have shared outcomes for a hope of savings.”

RG: “Has there been any estimate of officer time?”
MW: “No.”

Cllr Alison Greenhalgh (Con, Exmouth Littleham) “How do we make a decision about governance?“

MW replied that he thinks the bid will be for a combined authority, though “the Government will struggle to understand” why a mayor is not appropriate for this region.

Cllr Marianne Rixson (IEDA, Sidmouth,Sidford ), referring to other enterprise zones asked, “ What’s the certainty of us being successful against bids from elsewhere?”

MW: HOTSW “can operate independently from enterprise zones.”

MR also wanted to know “how financially viable are the councils involved?”

MW referred the point to Ian Baker, of the South West Audit Partnership (SWAP), who confirmed that at a recent seminar attended by Cllr Rixson, a representative of external auditors Grant Thornton had warned that SOME councils are due to go bust by 2020.

Cllr Peter Faithfull (INdependent, Ottery St Mary Town) made the point that Councillors are “still largely in the dark”. “Can we have an independent observer, to understand what’s going on in (HOTSW) meetings?” We only get feedback AFTERWARDS, he said.

MW: There is “no need” to have an impartial report.
RG: Can the public attend?
MW: No. They are private meetings.

Cllr Mike Allen (Con, Honiton St Michael’s) had a barrage of questions: “Where is the money going to come from for business support?” How would the retraining of older people work? “How will infrastructure for planning issues get financed?” “Where is the money going to come from, for example, for schools?”

MW: There is money, but it gets lost in the system.

Matt Booth (Ind, Sidmouth Town ) asked “How much of health service will be outsourced to private businesses?” and wondered what would be the knock-on effect on health services already facing further cuts. He also wanted to know “Where do Neighbourhood Plans fit into the HOTSW devolution bid, in terms of protecting areas?”

MW : “Neighbourhood Plans (NPs) will continue irrespective.” But he was not sure that those preparing the NPs “would see the opportunity of tapping into growth possibilities”.

Cllr Ben Ingham( IEDA, Woodbury &Lympstone), citing the “complete lack of control in recent years regarding health care”, said that HOTSW’s 5 year view for ‘health & wellbeing’, is “just pie in the sky”. “We are being given an option we know nothing about”, he continued. “Are we being given a hospital pass?”

MW replied that Manchester, for example, has received invitations to develop a plan for integrating health and social care. And Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCG) have been present at two HOTSW meetings, although “I don’t think they were committing themselves,” he mentioned….. leaving some people wondering, if CCG were not cooperative, would this kill the bid?

(More to follow…)

Independent councillors get creative (and help charity) at Mill Street car park, Sidmouth

” … EDDC chief executive Mark Williams replied that Mill Street car park would not be developed ‘for the foreseeable future’ – before clarifying that he meant ‘the next two or three years’.

Opening Mill Street for a local cause was the brainchild of Sidmouth councillors Cathy Gardner, John Dyson and Matt Booth.

Councillor Iain Chubb, portfolio holder for the environment, said: “Having a car park with unoccupied spaces is of benefit to no-one, so it makes sense to take the opportunity to test public demand for reserved off-street car parking and at the same time use this exercise to help a terrific cause.”

He said the move will ensure the spaces are not wasted while EDDC prepares to implement a pay and display system next year.

Rotary club treasurer Bill Titley welcomed the donations.

He said it will be spent on the volunteers’ various projects supporting elderly and youth groups locally.

The council’s business support team will collect donations and issue permits lasting one, two or three weeks.

Anyone interested in applying for one should call 01395 571780 or email carparks@eastdevon.gov.uk”

http://www.sidmouthherald.co.uk/news/mill_street_cash_to_boost_rotary_club_of_sidmouth_1_4336831