Unitary Devon and Somerset – hypocrisy at its finest

Recall 2009, when unitisation was last on the agenda. Here is what then EDDC Leader Sarah Randall-Johnson (thankfully ousted at the 2011 local elections) said. Recall, the exercise she led (with enthusiastic support from current Tory Councillors including Diviani and Moulding) cost this district at least £250,000 which they all agreed to take from reserves.

The Government of the day back then was New Labour.

“The idea of spending millions of pounds to create dozens of redundancies in councils across Devon makes even less sense now than it might have done in 2008.

“The unitary adventure was an unwanted distraction last year; it is even more unwanted now, as councils try to plan for the future against a background of financial stringency.”

Cllr Randall Johnson said she would be waiting to see if the “questionable” legislation would be rushed through Parliament before the General Election.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Council-leader-puzzled-reorganisation-ruling/story-11806940-detail/story.html

Sarah Randall-Johnson, the parliamentary seat-chasing Tory leader of East Devon District Council who spent loadsa money fighting the seemingly inevitable progression of a Devon Unitary Council, has said of the latest unitary edict: “The only thing more surprising than the ridiculous single Devon unitary proposal is the period of time allowed for the public to comment – six weeks, to include the distraction of the Christmas and New Year holidays.”

http://www.theprsd.co.uk/tag/sarah-randall-page/

The leader of East Devon District Council Sara Randall Johnson said she wanted assurances that this would not prompt a “land grab” over the borders into neighbouring East Devon.

She said: “I want an assurance from the Government this will not be the precursor to a crude land grab in which the boundaries of Exeter are moved so that the city can expand into East Devon.

“We already know that East Devon has the space that a growing Exeter will need if its economy is to thrive. We are happy to be a good neighbour and to collaborate with the city on an equal basis, but we would be very protective of our borders.”

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Mixed-reaction-Exeter-decision/story-11817720-detail/story.html

It’s official: Devon and Somerset councils plan to merge: whither EDDC’s new HQ?

“Councillors from across Devon and Somerset have agreed on a joint devolution bid to secure greater control over skills, growth and employment in the region.

The decision follows a summit of county, unitary and district council chiefs in Exeter today, which brought local authorities one step closer to a devolution deal for the region.

Current plans propose an organisation based on the boundaries of the Heart of the South West Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP), with a focus on economic development and job creation.

Commenting on the progress, Devon County Council leader John Hart said the level of agreement had been “very encouraging”.

“It’s important that we present a united front to the Government,” he said.

“I have always said that we can do things more effectively and more efficiently locally than being told what to do by London.

“The big themes we hope to focus on are on skills, economic growth and improving productivity, as well as infrastructure so we can ensure our road and rail network is more resilient than it has been in the past.

“Doing the very best for our older residents by coordinating health and social care and affordable homes for our young people are also key themes.”

The announcement follows the confirmation of a devolution offer for Cornwall last month – the first non-urban deal of its kind.

LEP chief executive Chris Garcia was at the meeting, along with leaders from Devon’s eight district councils and Torbay mayor Gordon Oliver.

Councillors have previously indicated a bid could involve a “double devolution” model, under which the counties and unitary authorities would receive powers from central government and pass them down – where appropriate – to districts.

There has also been discussion of “soft” boundaries which would enable different parts of the region to reach individual devolution deals while still collaborating with neighbouring authorities.

The next round of devolution applications are due for submission in September.”

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Devon-Somerset-councillors-agree-joint-devolution/story-27648023-detail/story.html

Devon County Council abdicates responsibility for grass cutting: expects town and parish councils to take it on

Yet another example of shifting tasks to smaller councils without the resources (equipment and personnel) to deal with them.

The town and parish councils then have to raise more money from their precepts and the county (and also) district councils can say they are cost-cutting and/or keeping down their share of council tax.

Sure they are – but WE still pay via the increased precepts.

Not cricket?

Who ya gonna call? Pot-hole Buster DCC councillor Stuart Hughes!

According to the “Driving” section of today’s Sunday Times page 7), DCC Councillor Stuart Hughes (Highways portfolio) has trained to act as a Road Warden in Sidmouth.

“If there’s a pothole that people are concerned about then they can give me a call and I can do a temporary fill … “.

he is quoted as saying in the article.

Now, that should come in VERY useful if Sidford Fields is developed into an industrial estate, though he may not have time for the day job!

Devon and Somerset county merger “not ruled out” by Somerset

According to a tweet by Martyn Oates, BBC Political Correspondent today:

“.@SomersetCouncil leader @JDOsman1 on single authority for Dev & Som: Everything’s a possibility – Govt want single point of accountability.
10:15 AM – 5 Aug 2015
3 RETWEETS”

That could lead to a merged Somerset and Devon having to deal with the consortium currently consisting of Exeter, East Devon and Teignbridge!

Whither EDDC HQ then one wonders … whither ANY district council’s HQ come further amalgamation and/or devolution!

What a potential mess – from the government which originally refused to allow Devon to become a unitary authority and the district council (East Devon) that spent hundreds of thousands of pounds on refusing to merge with ANYONE back in 2007!

Cranbrook: the numbers just don’t stack up

Following on from the post where Devon County Council foresees a town “as big as Barnstaple” at Cranbrook. we have received the following comment which is upscaled to a post here:

Here are some historical EDDC statements about the size of Cranbrook:

Cabinet 2 May 2012 – “The Local Plan anticipates the completion of 6,000 homes at Cranbrook in the period to 2026 representing a likely population in excess of 13,000 people.”

Cabinet 3 April 2013 – “More broadly this pace of delivery is fundamental to supporting the achievement of the Local Plan, with circa. 60% of the remaining strategic housing requirement due to be accommodated at Cranbrook with expansion up to circa 6,500 homes over the plan period.”

Cabinet 4 Sept 2013 – “It is anticipated that by 2026, 6,000 new homes and associated town centre and other facilities will have been built. Assuming an occupancy rate of 2.2 persons per dwelling this is likely to mean that Cranbrook’s population will reach approximately 13,000 people – similar to Honiton by 2026. These 6,000 new homes are anticipated to come forward as a consequence of the following: Outline planning application 03/P1900 granted in October 2010 for the first 2,900; A Full Planning application for 600 homes (submitted on 2 August 2013) and (at the time of writing, being checked for validation) the ‘East and West Expansion Areas’ – allocated for approximately 2,500 homes in the emerging Submission East Devon Local Plan 2006-2026.”

Cabinet 4 June 2014 – “The vision for Cranbrook clearly anticipates that it will be much more than a housing estate with it being seen instead as a “new East Devon ‘market town’” with a “fully functional town centre” that is “ideally placed to perform a role in serving tourism in East Devon”.”

Cabinet 5 Nov 2014 – “The new Local Plan identifies both east and west expansion areas for Cranbrook to bring the overall level of development to about 6,000 houses. The new local plan does also show an indicative location for about 1500 houses to the south of the old A30 Honiton Road after 2016. New Community Partners (NCP) have advised that they will be submitting an outline planning application for the east, west and southern expansion of Cranbrook comprising possibly 4,000 houses before the end of 2014. The NCP held a “Cranbrook to 2031’ public exhibition on 15 and 16 October and before the end of this calendar year we expect to receive an application or applications for the largest residential scheme East Devon DC has seen in many years.”

EDDC Web site today – What is Cranbrook all about? – “Currently, a total of 3,561 homes, two primary schools, a secondary school, town centre, local centre and associated infrastructure and green spaces have planning permission but there are plans for a further 4,000 homes and associated infrastructure set out in the New Local Plan meaning that the town is planned to grow to a total of around 6,000 homes by the year 2026 and to 7,500 homes beyond that. This equates to a town of approximately 15,500 people (slightly larger than Sidmouth or Honiton).”

So, EDDC’s official position is originally 6,000 houses / 13,000 people , and now targeted at 7,500 homes (which would be c. 16,250 people). So I am not sure where 30,000 people has come from – or why a second station is needed when the population is actually projected to be only half the size of Barnstaple.

Cranbrook to be “bigger than Barnstaple”?

The Cranbrook Herald is running a front page story which says that, according to Devon County Council, Cranbrook will need a second railway station because eventually “it could be bigger than Barnstaple” (pop: 30,000 plus).

http://www.cranbrookherald.com/home

This is an even bigger increase than that announced late last year (around 20,000):

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/Cranbrook-set-double-size-new-proposals/story-23165420-detail/story.htmlj

The current population estimate of Cranbrook is around 2,500:

http://eastdevon.gov.uk/news/2015/07/a-bright-future-for-a-brand-new-town-writing-the-next-chapter-in-cranbrooks-history/

It’s 7 shops will open later this year: a cafe, fish and chip shop, a Chinese takeaway, a small Co-op, an estate agent, a pharmacy and a charity shop.

Talks about new roads into Cranbrook (which the new town council don’t like because they are “dull and not pretty” with insufficient access for the planned supermarket and a pub) seem to hint that there may also be a bigger supermarket in the offing.

Not much infrastructure for 30,000 people! Still at least they can eat, drink, be merry, sort out their hangovers and buy cheap clothes and then, when they are ready to move, they can use the estate agency! Though with many homes likely to be buy-to-let from cashed-in pensions and the like, the rental side may be busier.

Devolution, Relocation – spanners in works

“Fixing the foundations: Creating a more prosperous nation”, published by the government today:

“15.3 To rebalance the economy, cities need effective governance. OECD research has shown that cities around the world with fragmented governance structures have up to 6% lower levels of productivity than those that do not.

15.4 England currently has 353 local authorities with over 18,000 elected members.5 This can lead to fragmented decision making and blurred accountability; even within the same city region, urban and suburban leaders do not always work together on shared objectives. The experience of London and other major international cities suggests that a directly elected mayor can cut through these difficulties. The government has therefore been clear that devolution of significant powers will rest on cities agreeing to rationalise governance and put in place a mayor to inspire confidence.”

Click to access Productivity_Plan_print.pdf

DCC cost of relocating offices to 2 floors of Barnstaple building

This begs the question: if £4 million was the cost for moving a few staff into 2 floors of a building – what is the REAL cost of building a totally new HQ?

“The council was proposing to move its staff from the civic centre, which has recently been vacated, and on to the top two floors of the Barnstaple Library building, one of which houses the record office.

But it today announced it is instead looking into plans to convert the civic centre annex into a modern open plan office.

This would cost around £3 million – £1 million less than the estimated £4 million it would have cost to redevelop the library building. …

… Councillor John Clatworthy, the county council’s cabinet member with responsibility for council property, said: “It would be wrong to rush head-long into a project at the library when we can spend £1 million less moving to alternative accommodation which is also suitable. It’s prudent that we looked at the options, and I’m pleased that a better solution has been found.

Read more: http://www.northdevonjournal.co.uk/County-council-scraps-plans-staff-Barnstaple/story-26863194-detail/story.html

Devon and Somerset county councils heavily criticised for poor management of broadband upgrade

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Calls-broadband-team-disbanded-wake-BT-fiasco/story-26850967-detail/story.html

EDDC in secret talks with DCC to build (some) affordable housing in Exmouth

But remember that “affordable” means 90% of market rent.

Why not a Community Land Teust for 100% affordable housing for lical people as has been done in other areas. And what about self-builds?

And surely these political decisions did not take place behind closed doirs during the Purdah period?

And it will be SO interesting to see which housebuilder they pair with!

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/East-Devon-Council-buy-buildings-Exmouth-site/story-26400487-detail/story.html

Increased charges to sheltered accommodation: EDDC’s response to FOI

Remember this recent article in the Express &Echo?

Disabled tenant fears she may be evicted from home.’
A DISABLED East Devon District Council tenant fears that she and her elderly husband could face “eviction” from their home under the authority’s plans to charge its sheltered accommodation residents for its services.
Because Devon County Council has pulled half-a-million pounds of funding, East Devon’s sheltered housing tenants were informed in the autumn that they will be eligible to pay for the Home Safeguard alarm service and home visits made by Mobile Support Officers – which comes to about £10 a week.
The council has stressed that the charge will be phased in over the next three years and tenants on benefits will receive discounts and a means-tested hardship fund will be available.
The council said it would do “everything it possibly can” to assist residents to meet the new service charge, but that non-payment would be pursued through the courts.
Because the alarm service and support scheme are integral to the sheltered housing, a council spokesperson said residents who do not want both elements will be supported in finding alternative options, including accommodation.
But 71-year-old Kathy Moyle, a tenant in East Budleigh, says she is fearful about the impact of the new charge, but also that the prospect of having to move out if she does not want to pay for both the alarm and support visit elements, is akin to “eviction”.
“We’re being asked to pay for both the alarm and the warden support, and if we don’t want to pay we’ll be classified as not needing the support and could be evicted,” said Kathy. “They’re refusing us the right to say no.
“It will be a case that we choose between heating and food or this – £10 a week is a lot of money. This is no more than an Old Age Pensioner bedroom tax.”

Now more details on the same topic have emerged, from a Freedom of Information (FOI) request by a member of East Devon Alliance: https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/increased_charges_to_sheltered_a 

Seems EDA is beavering away on all sorts of election matters right now.  We especially recommend the video introductions on the candidates’ pages. http://www.eastdevonalliance.org.uk  ….or try them on Youtube . Type eastdevonalliance, then candidate’s name.

Many East Devon schools at 95%+ capacity and still we allow rampant development

The following schools are oversubscribed or at 95% or more capacity and still we allow free-for-all development without infrastructure:
 
In East Devon:
 
Woodbury Church of England Primary, Broadclyst Primary, Exeter Road Primary and Brixington Primary schools in Exmouth, West Hill Primary near Ottery St Mary, Kilmington Primary, Stockland Primary near Honiton, Lady Seaward’s Primary at Clyst St George and Mrs Ethelston’s Primary near Axminster, are all over subscribed. 
 
This autumn, six more East Devon primary schools join the list by being at 95 per cent capacity or over: Ottery St Mary, Bassetts Farm Primary in Exmouth, Sidbury Church of England Primary School, The Beacon Church of England Primary School, St Joseph’s Catholic Primary School in Exmouth and Feniton Church of England School.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/8220-Considerable-pressure-8221-Exeter-East-Devon/story-26359651-detail/story.html

Purdah – again

Should those standing for town and/or district council seats be allowed to trumpet their Devon County Council “influence” – especially when said trumpeting is hot air rather than anything else?

At least one local newspaper seems to think it’s fine.

Purdah? What’s purdah? Oh, that’s when you ban stories about those not in power – yet!

Sidmouth’s flood risk “plan” gets “council approval”

Except it isn’t a plan – it is a currently preferred option. And it hardly merits approval as there is as yet no money to fund it.

[Sidmouth DCC Councillor Stuart Hughes] said: “Future plans depend on what, if any, scheme can be promoted with a robust business case and justified cost benefit for national funding.

“Additional partnership funding will also need to be sourced.”

Can unfunded, aspirational ideas really be plans – or are they election “promises”?

http://www.devon24.co.uk/news/sidmouth_s_flood_risk_plan_gets_council_approval_1_3990483

Devon Libraries to become mutually owned

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-devon-31846907

But, of course, if money is being saved, it has to come from somewhere. Volunteers (although dedicated, already fully stretched it communities and unfortunately inherently unreliable due to age and other committments) will need to run their local libraries on a shoestring, opening when they can be found rather than when the service is most needed.

Buildings will presumably be retained by DCC. If not, this will be an insurmountable problem for some libraries in older, outdated buildings, which will soon close or move to smaller and smaller and cheaper and cheaper premises until they gently disappear into the night with ne’er a trace.

When will this end? When we pay our community charges for no services, just to keep councillors and officers in meaningless jobs or( in EDDC’s case) to finance plush offices where all they do is service developers.

And, of course, if libraries do fail, they are on prime development land …

Oversubscribed schools in East Devon

Woodbury C of E (large development planned)
Exeter Road Primary and Brixingham Primary Exmouth (large developments planned)
West Hill Primary (large development in Ottery, development in West Hill)
Stockland Primary (no development there)
Lady Seward at Clyst St George (large developments planned)
Mrs Ethelstone’s Primary in Uplyme (large developments planned in Axminster nearby)

95% subscribed schools:
Ottery St Mary
Bassetts Farm Primary, Exmouth
Sidbury C of E (near where large industrial estate planned)
The Beacon and St Joseph’s in Exmouth
Feniton C of E (Wainhomes want to extend development)

Source:today’s Express and Echo newspaper

Tory dirty tricks?

https://susiebond.wordpress.com/2015/03/06/hes-behind-you/

Shameful – politics before people, politics before common sense, politics before the safety of children.

How can you sleep at night, councillors?