And here isn’t the news

Tiny, tiny piece of “In Brief” news on page 2 of Midweek Herald covering the news about the bad behaviour exhibited by some long-serving councillors at Axminster during the recent council meeting where a new mayor (Paul Hayward) was chosen. Alongside big spreads for future opportunities to paddle canoes down the River Axe and dog mess on a playing field. ….

And a slightly larger piece welcoming our new Police and Crime Commissioner with not a mention of the controversy surrounding her appointment.

Oh, and a letter from the EDA Chairman Paul Arnott about the PCC elections together with a very strangely placed photo, completely out of context of a 3 year old child meeting Star Wars Chewbacca.

Journalism?

MPs pay family members an average of £5,600 more than other staff

Our MP Hugo Swire, employs his wife.

“Family members employed by MPs are paid on average £5,600 more than other staff, a watchdog has revealed.

Pay of such “connected parties” has also risen at twice the rate of other staff, the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa) found.
The group called for a review of whether MPs should be allowed to employ relatives in the future, arguing jobs must not be “personal benefits”.
In total, 139 MPs employ family members at a public annual cost of about £4.5m.

The review will only apply to future staffing as the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa) said it would be “unfair and legally challengeable” to investigate existing contractual arrangements.

The watchdog, which is responsible for determining MPs’ pay and expenses, said there was a lingering “perception of risk” about whether the taxpayer was getting value for money in terms of the number of family members and close business associates working for MPs.

After reviewing the matter in 2010, Ipsa decided against prohibiting the employment of family members, saying it did not believe the system was being abused and family members played a “valuable role” in assisting MPs – while limiting their numbers to one per MP.

‘Limited controls’

The watchdog said it was still happy with the majority of contractual arrangements but believed that controls preventing the misuse of funds were “limited”. Since relatives generally occupied more senior roles it found they were paid “significantly more” than other staff.

“Public concern about the employment of connected parties has remained,” it said.

“In order to determine whether these constitute any grounds for concern, Ipsa would need to undertake intrusive and potentially disproportionate work to investigate the employment practices in MPs’ offices. “But, given that there remains a perception of risk to taxpayers’ money, we are obliged to address it. Therefore we are consulting again on the practice, but only in respect of the employment by MPs of any new staff.”

The issue will be considered as part of a wider review of business costs and expenses payable to MPs – with any change to the rules likely to take effect either next year or after the next election, scheduled for 2020.

Ipsa is also looking into the £4.4m cost of paying off staff who worked for the 182 MPs who retired at the last election or lost their seats.
While all the sums were within the rules, it expressed concern that £975,000 was paid to 125 staff who were taken on by newly elected MPs within the subsequent 10 weeks – “sometimes in the same constituency and in the same role”.

As MPs are all separately self-employed, it said the election represented a “legal break” in the staffers’ employment but it noted that in other areas of the public sector the rules had been changed to prevent staff from getting pay-offs if they are soon taken on in a similar field.”

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-36260573

“Rude Chinese”

If Chinese officials were rude to the Queen, imagine what it may be like for those who will have to deal with Chinese officials at Hinkley C, where they will own at least one-third of the nuclear energy plant.

Perhaps some of those LEP business cafe “experts” doing the rounds could deal with this so that relationships can run smoothly.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-36263685

Why is Exeter not represented at the LEP yet East Devon is?

As long ago as March 2011 Exeter City Council CEO Karime Hassan knew exactly how our LEP would be constituted and who would be on it and was making this complaint and prediction:

“The Heart of the South West Local Enterprise Partnership, which is currently awaiting government approval, has come under fire at an Insider panel debate for failing to properly represent Exeter and its economy in its proposed form.

Speaking at an Insider breakfast debate held the University of Exeter’s Reed Hall, Exeter City Council’s economic development director Karim Hassan pointed out that his council does not have a seat at the table of the Heart of the South West LEP. “I don’t see how Exeter and its growth point can therefore get the messages out there to government that can make a difference,” said Hassan.

He went on: “LEPs need to work effectively, but the prospects aren’t necessarily good. The Heart of the South West LEP already looks like it holds tensions in it, because the needs of cities like Exeter are different from the needs of the rural market towns of Devon and Somerset. It is hard to tell one story to central government because there are so many different localised agendas built into an LEP like this.”

Hassan also said the South West had to work at getting better at arguing its case for a slice of the national cake. “We have lost out many times to others elsewhere, who have been better organised. But the region has not always worked well together, with too much internal competition and rivalry, so this new LEP structure is a real challenge. We have already seen the competitive element surface, with Cornwall’s decision to go it alone with its LEP.”

Others on the panel also saw gaps in the proposed LEP arrangements. Ben de Cruz, senior partner at accountancy firm Haines Watts, said: “It certainly looks like the Heart of the South West LEP proposal will be accepted by the government, but the biggest problem with LEPs is that the funding they will have is still unclear.”

And de Cruz said it would be harder to make strategic decisions in the basis of more local interests. “The South West RDA, for all its shortcomings, was able to look at the bigger picture when assessing projects or funding proposals. Once things are divided up – into Cornwall, Devon and Somerset combined, the West of England, and so on – the question is how wider issues will be tackled. It feels like co-operation will be required, but no-one knows quite how that will work.”

Hassan added that he wanted LEPs to work well but was unsure whether this would happen in practice. “Whitehall needs intelligence, and the LEPs could be that vehicle,” he said. “But equally I’m fearful that the LEP won’t deliver the information it needs to.

“A LEP should be able to prioritise investments, but it will need to work in a clear, transparent way. Potentially it could make a big difference. But first we need to grab the opportunity – partly by getting Exeter fully involved in the planning for the Heart of the South West LEP.”

https://www.insidermedia.com/insider/southwest/50007-

Now, it could be argued that Cranbrook (officially in East Devon and just getting off the ground) was the dealmaker – but, in fact, the town is much closer to Exeter than most other East Devon towns.

Why was there not a seat for Exeter as the county town?

Chief Constable’s statement on Hernandez investigation

Just one problem: there are only days left to decide whether to extend the time limit for this investigation: how long will it take to choose and brief a new force?

Hernandez is NOT here to support the police

Alison Hernandez said at her swearing in (reported on BBC Spotlight this evening) that she is “here to support the police”.

NO SHE IS NOT!

“The role of the PCCs is to be the voice of the people and hold the police to account. They are responsible for the totality of policing. PCCs aim to cut crime and deliver an effective and efficient police service within their force area.”

http://www.apccs.police.uk/role-of-the-pcc/

Seaton Town Council on the warpath as EDDC attempts to slip no affordables on the Tesco (Bovis) site under the radar

Full details here:

Click to access Planning%20agenda%2009.05.16.pdf

Fish, smell, rotten … EDDC.

A tale of two local newspapers …

Both reporting on the democratic election of Councillor Paul Hayward as Mayor of Axminster:

First, the Midweek Herald – a local newspaper owned by one of the small number of powerful regional chains:

“Axminster elected a new town mayor and deputy tonight (Monday May 09)

“Paul Hayward won a secret ballot to deny veteran councillor Douglas Hull the customary second term in office.

Cllr Lara Rowe was elected unopposed as his deputy – replacing Graham Godbeer who said he was not prepared to accept Cllr John Jeffery’s nomination to serve a second term.

Meanwhile two members of the council have resigned – Joy Raymond and Chris Tipping.”

http://www.midweekherald.co.uk/news/change_of_leaders_at_axminster_town_council_1_4528621

and here the totally local and very independent View from Axminster:

“A “NEW generation” took over the reins of Axminster Town Council tonight (Monday) as Councillor Paul Hayward was elected mayor of the town.

Councillor Hayward takes over the role from the council’s longest-serving member, Councillor Douglas Hull.

Councillor Hull was nominated to serve another year by his deputy, Councillor Graham Godbeer, seconded by Councillor Andrew Moulding who pointed out that it was tradition for mayors to serve two years and said Councillor Hull should be offered his second year.

However, Councillor Jeremy Walden nominated Councillor Hayward for the position, seconded by Councillor Carol Doherty.

Members then carried out an anonymous ballot and Councillor Hayward was announced as the new mayor.

He then received the mayoral chains from Councillor Hull, who commented: “Thank you to all those who supported me. I now have time to do lots of other things and will enjoy my future time on the town council.”

Councillor John Jeffery said that the town owed “a great deal of gratitude” to Councillor Hull and his wife, fellow councillor Joy Hull, for their long service.

“Time moves on and it’s sad to see Councillor Hull go from the top stop, but he’s still got lots of good work to do on the council,” he added.

“We now move to a new generation with younger people with lots of new ideas, but we owe Douglas and Joy a great deal of gratitude.”

Councillor Hayward thanked Councillor Jeffery for his comments, saying he “wholeheartedly agreed”.

Nominations were then taken for deputy mayor with Councillor Jeffery nominating existing deputy mayor, Councillor Godbeer. However, Councillor Godbeer said he was not prepared to accept his nomination.

Councillor Lara Rowe was then nominated by Councillor Walden, and with no other nominations was elected.

Councillor Hayward thanked Councillor Godbeer for his tenure as deputy mayor and said he hoped he could call on him and Councillor Hull for advice during his first term.

Open and transparent

Speaking later in the meeting during the town forum, the new mayor was questioned over the council and Guildhall’s finances and administration by a resident, and said it was his “heartfelt promise” to be as open and transparent as possible.

“I won’t say there will be changes, but there will be progress,” he added.

Councillor Mervyn Symes added: “We hope that it will be more transparent and that we will know what’s going on in that council office rather than not knowing.”

Councillor Hull asked Councillor Symes to give an example of what he was referring to, adding that he had made a “slanderous comment”.

Councillors Symes replied: “It was not a slanderous comment. We don’t all know what is going on in the office.”

Councillor Hayward said that all councillors were equal and no one councillor should have more power than others.

He added: “All councillors need to be fully aware of all decisions and discussions. Without that information we are acting blind which is not constitutionally correct.

“I will be working with our administrative staff to ensure all members have the information they need to do their job legally and to the satisfaction of the public.”

Resignation

It was also announced at the meeting that Councillor Joy Raymond had tendered her resignation.

Councillor Hayward said that Councillor Raymond had announced her resignation that morning, adding to the vacancy already caused by the recent resignation of Chris Tipping.

He said that due process would be followed to fill the two vacancies and urged people to step forward for by-election, asking: “What can you do for your town?”

Town clerk Hilary Kirkcaldie added that if no candidates came forward the vacancies would be filled by co-option.

‘New generation’ takes over as Paul Hayward elected Mayor of Axminster

Owl would say again, pays yer money takes yer choice, but they are both free newspapers!

As expected: EDDC will build more than the 17,100 houses in the Local Plan

Many, many more ….

“EDDC says a grand total of 18,391 net new dwellings are now projected to have been completed over the full plan period – well above the minimum figure for housing need.”

http://www.midweekherald.co.uk/news/east_devon_on_track_to_deliver_surplus_of_new_homes_1_4529154

So, if it is above the figure for housing need – who needs the extra ones?

Watch Michael Crick of Channel 4 news ask Ms Hernandez a REALLY awkward Question!

Scroll down article for short video – he is the second questioner and also allowed to ask only two questions. Ms Hernandez’s background in PR and selling wasn’t quite enough to help her out. And as regards openness and transparency – she is mistress of avoiding answering a straight question.

This does not bode well for her, us or the Chief Constable.

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/WATCH-PCC-Alison-Hernandez-faces-tough-questions/story-29253467-detail/story.html

Who is that sitting next to Alison Fernandez at her swearing in?

None other than our own former regeneration supremo and now Exeter City Council CEO Karime Hassan, dressed in very natty official robes accentuated with gold chain!

She had two minders from Conservative Central Office with her and Spotlight was allowed to ask only two questions.

Open … transparent … yeah, right!

PCC Hernandez sworn in against wishes of Police Federation

The Police and Crime Commissioner is to be sworn in today but not everyone is happy.

“THE Police Federation has joined calls for new Police and Crime Commissioner Alison Hernandez to stand aside during any investigation over expenses claims.

Nigel Rabbitts, chairman of the Devon and Cornwall Police Federation, which represents rank and file police officers, said the former Torbay councillor should not commence her duties until the investigation is complete.

Ms Hernandez was due to be sworn into the role of Devon and Cornwall PCC today, Tuesday. She was elected by a public vote on Thursday last week.

The expenses row centres on her role in submitting expenses for Conservative MP Kevin Foster at the 2015 General Election. She was Mr Foster’s agent during the campaign.

Ms Hernandez has denied doing anything wrong.

It was announced on Monday that another police force will be asked to investigate any claims about improper electoral spending.

Nigel Rabbitts said the position of the federation was that if anyone was subject to an investigation the rules should be the same as for a police officer.”

http://www.torquayheraldexpress.co.uk/Police-Federation-says-new-PCC-Alison-Henandez/story-29252176-detail/story.html

Our PCC’s Experience

June 2015 – Feb 2016: Chief of Staff, Kevin Foster MP, Torbay Constituency
Sept 2013 – June 2015: Campaign Manager/Election Agent, Torbay Conservatives
July 2013 – present: Elected Member Peer, Local Government Association
Oct 2010 – Sept 2013: Business/Management Consultant, Universal Improvement Company
Jan 2007 – Jan 2011: Director and Company Secretary, Improve Plus Limited
Aug 2004 – Mar 2009: Strategic Partnership Manager, Plymouth 2020
Jan 2004 – Aug 2004: Regional Crime Reduction Adviser, Home Office Secondee
July 2001 – Jan 2004: Crime & Disorder Reduction Co-ordinator, Safer Communities Torbay
July 1990 – July 2001: Press & PR/Supervisor, Torbay Council/Riviera Centre
July 1987 – Sept 1994: Market Trader, Family business in South Devon

http://www.alisonhernandez.co.uk/about-alison-hernandez

So, we are in the very safe hands of someone with a wealth of experience.

Our new PCC favours podcasts and iPhone to face-to-face discussion

From an article written by Alison Hernandez in The Guardian in 2013:

“Promotion becomes a choice between your money or your life. Either you can spend huge amounts of money on old-fashioned promotion, or spend vast amounts of your time – spending evenings, weekends, and every other unsociable hour imaginable, out and about spreading your message. Finding either time or resources is a great challenge for many people coping with the combined pressures of a career, family commitments and childcare.

My aim is to use podcasting to help others to promote their ideas and projects to the local community. To do it, I have personally invested in the latest iPhone. I already use social media actively, especially as part of budget discussions, where hundreds more have been joining in the debate about how we spend our money.

Promoting civic involvement is a core activity of all councillors and we need more platforms to do this in Torbay. Podcasts will help break through the vast mess of online information in an interactive way. By engaging more people, we can create the solutions needed to overcome complex and entrenched problems.”

http://gu.com/p/3de53

Newton Poppleford: Will developer’s new plans avoid affordable homes ” ghetto”.

Cavanna Homes controversial full planning permission for 40 homes on AONB land in Newton Poppleford was agreed in principle by EDDC but held up because affordable homes were clustered together instead of being ” pepper potted” throughout the development.

New plans appear to show two homes on the western edge of the site, four to the north and nine in a cul-de-sac facing north towards the end of the estate road.

Is this “pepper potting”? The officers think so. Hhhmmmm … quite a lot of pepper in the remotest and possibly least attractive corner of the plate.

‘New generation’ takes over in Axminster

Unfortunately, only at the Town Council, where scourge of the old ways, Paul Hayward, has been elected Mayor after long decrying the old method of “Buggin’s Turn” and campaigning strongly for openness and transparency.

At district level, the town, now a regeneration area because it has slipped so far behind all the other towns in East Devon (including Seaton) is still in the firm grip of long-time councillors Moulding and Godbeer.

After an effusive speech thanking Councillor Hull (past Mayor) Councillor Godbeer refused to be nominated for the post of Deputy Mayor:

“Nominations were then taken for deputy mayor with Councillor Jeffery nominating existing deputy mayor, Councillor Godbeer. However, Councillor Godbeer said he was not prepared to accept his nomination.”

‘New generation’ takes over as Paul Hayward elected Mayor of Axminster

Hinkley C: we could end up selling our highly subsidised electricity cheaply – to France!

Physicist claims Hinkley Point deal means UK taxpayer could get £53bn bill to supply cheap nuclear energy to France

Electricity from planned nuclear plant ‘could all end up being exported to countries with fewer renewables, like France, at a price massively subsidised by Britain’s hard-working bill payers’.

It is a claim that, if true, would mean Britain is about to make one of the biggest economic mistakes in its history, a blunder that would damage our country’s finances for decades and almost inevitably cause the Government to fall.

For, according to Keith Barnham, an emeritus professor of physics, the total subsidy paid to the planned Hinkley Point nuclear power station by the British taxpayer could reach a staggering £53 billion over its lifetime – and the main beneficiaries will be French.

He argues that such is the likely growth of renewables that the UK will not actually need the Hinkley’s electricity, so it will be sold abroad. And, he says, the most likely customers are in France, home of energy giant EDF, which is expected to build the plant. …

… If Hinkley starts in 2025 with the performance Department for Energy and Climate Change expects, the nuclear subsidy will be around £820m each year on the ‘no-subsidy’ renewable scenario.

“The subsidy will double should the second Hinkley reactor come on stream around 2030, leading to a total bill, over the 35 years of the guarantee, of £53bn, which could all end up supporting low electricity prices abroad.”

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/hinkley-point-nuclear-power-station-france-edf-subsidy-53bn-professor-keith-barnham-a7021161.html

Hernandez resigned from Torbay Council Executive as she said she couldn’t do the job as a single parent and the allowance was too low

Hope she now has a partner.

“Cllr Hernandez said she offered her resignation with ‘great sadness’, but said it was ‘untenable to carry out this role effectively when one is a working parent’.

The 39-year-old, who has a five-year-old daughter, said: “The lack of flexibility, lack of decision-making ability, lack of the use of technology, low allowances and extremely limited officer support has exacerbated this.”

She said that unless the mayor changes working practices, she cannot consider being an executive lead again, but she will continue to be a ward councillor.

She said: “I support the mayoral system, but executive leads are advisors not decision-makers and nobody does anything unless the mayor says so. I recognise he’s a very busy man, but it’s Gordon Oliver who sets the standards and makes the decisions and I believe he is not driving change where it’s needed.”

… “You have to be at meetings to input your view. But meetings are usually at school pick-up time. You get £6,000 for being an executive lead and it’s not sustainable. I spend more than that on things like petrol, printing posters and leaflets for community information, and buying coffee or lunch for people I’m trying to persuade.” …

http://www.westernmorningnews.co.uk/Leading-Torbay-councillors-quit-posts/story-18471567-detail/story.html