Taxpayers Alliance wants most planning rules to be abolished

“The government should scrap stamp duty and ease planning restrictions to address the worsening housing crisis, the TaxPayers’ Alliance has said today.

In a new report, the group called for “real reform” to tackle the housing shortage accusing successive governments of merely tinkering around the edges instead of dealing with underlying issues facing the sector. …

… the fundamental problem with housing markets in Britain is overly tight planning restrictions, the group suggests. The alliance urges the government to declassify swathes of green-belt land to tackle the chronic lack of new house building. For example, it estimates that allowing just 5% of the greenbelt around London to be built on will enable the city to grow by one sixth.

Taller, denser housing construction should be also encouraged, as well as more infilling, despite the likely increased pressure on traffic systems and public services.

The alliance cites the work of groups such as the Campaign to Protect Rural England, the Victorian Society, and the “thousands” of local groups who successfully protect the character of communities.

However, protecting land from development restricts the supply of new properties and inevitably raises the cost of housing, the alliance argues. It says: “The political fact is that housing cannot become more affordable unless it becomes cheaper and easier to build more of it in the places where … groups object.”

Jonathan Isaby, chief executive of the TaxPayers’ Alliance, said: “For decades politicians have failed to tackle the root causes of the housing crisis: a chronic lack of supply. What’s more, stamp duty is still punitively high and gimmicky tweaks to the tax system will ultimately end up penalising tenants and increasing rents.”

Isaby is urging new chancellor Phillip Hammond to seize the opportunity “to drastically simplify and reduce property taxes, while removing planning restrictions which prevent huge swathes of land from being built on for no good reason at all”.

http://www.publicfinance.co.uk/news/2016/07/abolish-stamp-duty-and-ease-planning-restrictions-urges-taxpayers-alliance

“Planning applications for new shops fell 9% in past year”

“There were 6,700 applications for new retail developments in 2015, down from 7,360, according to commercial law firm EMW. They are down by nearly a half from the pre-recession peak of 11,900 in 2008.

The fall shows the continuing pressures on shopkeepers as consumers desert the high street in favour of online shopping with e-commerce companies. EMW said that despite traditional retailers increasingly focusing on and expanding their online services, many are often failing to compete effectively with online-only retailers, such as Asos and Boohoo.

It said the recent failures of traditional retailers BHS, Austin Reed, and convenience store chain My Local were partly caused by the continued success of online-only brands.”

http://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/jul/25/planning-applications-new-shops-fell-nine-per-cent-past-year?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

“Post-truth’ politics are a debasement of standards in public life”

“Verbal dexterity, inconsistency and ‘spin’ are part and parcel of normal politics but the exaggerations and distortions of the EU referendum campaign has led to concerns about ‘post-truth’ politics.

Nicholas Allen and Sarah Birch write there is a need for someone to provide a moral lead, and argue the Committee for Standards in Public Life could play a valuable role by establishing some relevant basic markers. …

… current trends, first identified in the context of US politics and more recently in the context of British politics, risk stretching beyond breaking-point a basic commitment to truth and honesty that is essential for liberal democracy. Without it, citizens cannot hope to achieve ‘enlightened understanding’ and learn about what best serve their interests, one of five criteria identified by Robert Dahl that define modern democratic government. Someone in government, or at least in officialdom, needs to take note. Someone needs to provide a moral lead. …

… Morality in politics needs to come from somewhere. The CSPL [Committee for Standards in Public Life] is charged with overseeing standards in public life. The new prime minister should give it the resources and remit to do just this.

‘Post-truth’ politics are a debasement of standards in public life

School academies: what they REALLY cost US, the taxpayer

“The leaders of academy schools are spending taxpayers’ money on luxury hotels, top-end restaurants, first-class travel, private health care and executive cars, a joint investigation by Channel 4’s Dispatches and the Observer can reveal.

Expense claims released under the Freedom of Information Act lay bare for the first time what critics claim is an extraordinary extravagance by some academy chain chief executives and principals, at a time when schools are struggling financially.

The taxpayer is paying Ian Cleland, the £180,000-a-year chief executive at Academy Transformation Trust, to lease and have joint insurance with his wife on an XJ Premium Luxury V6 Jaguar car, it can be disclosed. Included in nearly £3,000 worth of receipts is payment for servicing the car and the purchase of new tyres.

Cleland has also spent £3,000 of taxpayers’ money on first-class rail travel, while dining expenses racked up on his taxpayer-funded credit card include a meal with other staff at Marco Pierre White totalling £471, and the Bank restaurant in Birmingham, at a cost £703.45. …

… The Paradigm Trust pays for its CEO, Amanda Phillips, to have broadband at her holiday home in France, even though she earns £195,354 a year.

Meanwhile, as former education secretary Michael Gove’s vision of a more market-led school system has materialised, in which multi-academy trusts have taken the place of local authorities, salary levels have soared within the management tier, it can be revealed. More than half of the largest 50 chains pay their chief executives more than the prime minister (£143,000). Sir Daniel Moynihan, the chief executive of the high-performing Harris Federation, earns £395,000 a year.

The chief executive of the Aspirations Academies Trust, which runs 12 schools, pays its chief executive and founder, Stewart Kenning, a total package of £225,000, while his wife, Paula Kenning, receives £175,000 as executive principal and founder. And as the salaries have shot up, the so-called related party transactions – where companies with close links to directors of academy trusts are paid for services to those trusts – have also multiplied.

Take, for example, the US organisation founded by Dr Russell Quaglia, the American-based co-founder of the Aspirations Academy Trust (AAT). In a document uncovered through a freedom of information request, the trust claims to the regulator that it is abiding by the no-profit rule governing such transactions, and it is suggested that the American is working at a discount.

It actually costs Quaglia $8,300 (£6,330) a time to come to Britain, AAT claims. “This is based on transportation costs to and from the US, including parking and travel to and from airports in the US – $5,000,” the document says, adding of further costs: “Hotels and meals: $3,000; internal travel (trains/cabs/tubes): $300. For six visits a year, the [annual] average cost would therefore be $49,800.”

The trust adds that the provision of Quaglia’s top-of-the-range staff and student surveys to the schools costs an additional $20,000 a year. And his normal consultancy rates range from $9,600 a day to $18,000 a day, plus travel costs, it is said. “The amounts paid directly to Dr Quaglia, in lieu of basic salary, range from $8,000 to $15,000.

“Based on 15 days’ consultancy for the AAT, the total day rate cost would be a minimum of $120,000. We can confirm that Dr Quaglia is in high demand and turns down 75% of approaches, so any time not devoted to ATT would be easily filled by other paying engagements. In conclusion, the cost … equates to £114,337, which is significantly above the charged amount of £89,724.” …

http://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/jul/23/education-academies-funding-expenses

” The inanities of the National Planning Policy Framework “

Letters page Daily Telegraph 23 July 2016:

SIR –

It is the kind of self-interested view of the planning system given by Professor Adam that got us into this mess in the first place. Developers play the system to obtain permissions that they land-bank rather than build-out.

The inanities of the National Planning Policy Framework then allow them to use the lack of five-year housing supply to demand even more permissions, often in places that command higher prices than those that communities have identified for development.

Developers are businesses and they are interested in profit. It is time for a rather obtuse government to understand that this doesn’t deliver either mass housing or specific housing such as bungalows.

There is selective deafness on the part of the Government in respect of the failure of the National Planning Policy Framework. Maybe this is yet another example of why there was selective deafness on the part of the electorate to the wishes of the Government in relation to the referendum.

Jenny Unsworth
Congleton, Cheshire

You want an NHS dentist in East Devon? Tough, join the other 560 people on the waiting list

The number of patients who were unallocated and on the waiting list for a NHS dentists:

Exeter as of July 1, 2016, was 3,900, previously 846 as of July 1, 2015

East Devon as of July 1, 2016, was 560, previously 120 as of July 1, 2015

Mid Devon as of July 1, 2016 was 370, previously 113 as of July 1, 2015

http://www.exeterexpressandecho.co.uk/huge-rise-in-waiting-list-to-see-an-nhs-dentist-in-exeter/story-29543976-detail/story.html

Local NHS: cut, burn, slash, destroy

“Out of hours doctors care is to undergo some radical changes in Devon with the number of treatment centres being reduced and others having no overnight service.

Exmouth will entirely lose its treatment centre at Exmouth Hospital, as will Teignmouth, while other areas such Tiverton will see its hours significantly reduced.

As of October 3, they will reduce to nine, and some centres will no longer have out of hours services between 12am and 8am, such as Tiverton and Honiton.

It is also believed the amount of Devon Doctor cars to cover the region from 12am to 8am will be reduced by two. This will leave four cars to undertake home visits and return the their bases to see previous arranged treatment patients.

And a spokesperson said :- In Exmouth, there is NHS services available. The hospital is there and the minor injuries unit, and patients will be offered to attend Exeter treatment centre.

“There will still be overnight urgent care. Patients with a clinical need who are not able to get to a treatment centre will still receive a home visit as they do now.”

Source: Bay FM, Facebook

EDDC “Communications”: pigs, flying, sky …. and ” avoiding the barking mad”!

Here is the introduction to EDDC’s new communications policy:

“Communications Plan 2016-2020

… Purpose and scope of the communications plan

This plan aims to ensure we have good communications which improve residents’ lives, keep them informed and help them access services more easily.

This plan will help develop EDDC’s brand so that it becomes instantly recognisable and synonymous with our council plan priorities, values and key drivers of great customer service and value for money services in an outstanding place.

The more we involve and tell people about what we are doing and why, the better more informed they will feel. We have a great story to tell and we need to tell it well – this means effectively and consistently. …

Addressing local priorities

This plan aims to deliver effective communications to our customers. We strongly believe that customers who are informed about our services and benefits are more positive in their view of the Council than those who are not so informed.

Our Council Plan outlines that we will ‘continuously improve to be an outstanding council’ and that we will ‘prioritise keeping our residents informed’.

This communication plan will support the communication of the priorities and outcomes in the Council Plan:

 Encouraging communities to be outstanding
 Developing an outstanding local economy
 Delivering and promoting our outstanding environment
 Continuously improving to be an outstanding council

Principles underpinning this action plan:
 Communication and reputation management is a top-table issue

It’s about avoiding the ‘barking mad’ by thinking about everything we do and everything we say/don’t say from a reputation management perspective

 Stop talking about ‘they’ and start talking about ‘we’!

 We are all responsible for reputation management and communications.

 We think about different audiences: residents, members, officers, towns and
parishes, partners, business groups. …”

Click to access 280616-overview-agenda-combined.pdf

Whoops, big omission: they missed out developers from the last sentence!

Devolution: Horses, carts, stable doors …

EDDC issues a press release on 21 July 2016 saying that on 13 July 2016 its Cabinet decided to press ahead with devolution plans:

http://www.midweekherald.co.uk/news/cabinet_agrees_to_continue_east_devon_devolution_talks_in_principle_1_4625365

THEN

the Overview Committee discusses it on 28 July:

Click to access 280616-overview-agenda-combined.pdf

And STILL we are not allowed our say!

Priceless.

Please don’t let this give our Police and Crime Commissioner ideas!

Funds are so tightly squeezed in Police Scotland that officers have been sent to trawl charity shops for equipment, according to the leader of the Scottish Police Federation.

In an abrasively-worded article on the SPF website, general secretary Calum Steele also claims that police dog-handlers had been called off from following trails for fear of running into overtime. He says that service quality has become a postcode lottery where “cash is king” in determining operational priorities.

On one occasion, Steele says, officers were told to “scour charity shops” to buy car sun blinds in order to keep out of view a child that was being driven in a police car.

“At a time when so much emphasis is being placed on the cost of policing, it’s long overdue that we had a real conversation about its value,” Steele writes.

“Cash is king and woe betide anyone who isn’t playing their part in making cuts. Theorising on paper that the service will be improved by cutting is a fool’s errand and the public is being misled over the policing realities of today.” …

http://www.publicfinance.co.uk/news/2016/07/cuts-prompt-police-scotland-source-equipment-charity-shops

EDF raided by French authorities

EDF raided by French authorities ahead of Hinkley greenlight

French finance authorities have raided the offices of EDF just days before the state-backed energy giant is expected to give the go-ahead to its controversial Hinkley Point new nuclear project.

The long-awaited final decision on the Hinkley project is scheduled to take place at a board meeting next Thursday, even as authorities in both the UK and France escalate concerns over the costs of the £18bn project.

French investigators from the Financial Markets Authority (AMF) swooped on EDF’s Paris headquarters on Thursday morning as part of a probe into EDF’s disclosure of information to the market. Investigators are said to be concerned about the reporting of its domestic nuclear maintenance costs as well as the plans to develop new nuclear reactors in Somerset.

Local media reports say the AMF recovered a series of documents from the EDF offices and requested a meeting with EDF general secretary Pierre Todorov.

Just hours after the raid the company said it would hold a board meeting on Thursday 28 July to agree a final decision on the project, feeding speculation that the company is preparing to push ahead with the 3.2GW project.

The company also has a scheduled extraordinary general meeting on Tuesday next week, seeking approval from shareholders for its proposed £3bn recapitalistion.

Meanwhile, the head of the UK’s National Audit Office has raised further concerns over the UK’s plans to subside EDF’s plans in the face of a “tidal wave” of pressures from an impending Brexit and a pipeline of existing infrastructure projects requiring a total of £405bn.

Sir Amyas Morse, comptroller and auditor general at the NAO, told the Guardian in an interview that projects such as the Hinkley Point C nuclear plant, a third runway at Heathrow and the ambitious HS2 rail project would have to be reassessed as the government decides which can be done without, according to a report in the Guardian.

“We need to ask ourselves, can the public sector deliver Hinkley Point C, a third runway, HS2, a Northern Powerhouse, nuclear decommissioning, Trident renewal and restoration and renewal of the Palace of Westminster all at the same time?” asked Sir Amyas.

“There is a policy at the moment to have lots of infrastructure projects. I say fine, but some of them will have very big consequences in terms of your ability to deliver your other goals,” he said.

In a recent report, the NAO heaped criticism on the Hinkley Point plans saying the spiralling costs will hit consumers in the pocket, even as other low carbon energy options offer an increasingly better deal.

The subsidy bill to be paid by households and businesses for Hinkley Point has more than quadrupled since the agreement for the new nuclear plant was signed in 2013.

At the time the deal was signed, power price projections had implied a lifetime cost to consumers of £6.1bn for the subsidies. But as of March this year, that had more than quadrupled to £29.7bn due to significant cuts to official power price forecasts.

EDF declined to comment on the raid, and the AMF was unavailable.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/07/22/edf-raided-by-french-authorities-ahead-of-hinkley-greenlight/

A conundrum – EDDC: less money, less services, more (expensive) staff

Is there any reason why the publishing of EDDC’s employee statistics is two months late?

The last year has seen a substantial rise in employee numbers, particularly senior officers, with growth of between twenty and thirty new staff, depending upon which measure you prefer.

With average wages for senior staff at EDDC at £30,000+, plus all additional costs such as pensions, expenses, etc., this brings the cost per employee to around £50,000 per annum, this mean that the wage bill may have climbed by between £1 and £1.5 million. This was presumably not budgeted for, so where is the money coming from? More debt, perhaps?

And, of course, the extra staff will have to be housed in the new HQ … so maybe that will have to expand, too.

Election results in East Devon … amongst the slowest – unless you read the “Conservative Home” website!

There were eleven district, borough or county council by-elections throughout the country yesterday. According to the Twitter account “Britain Elects”, Honiton was ninth out of the eleven to declare and, as of this moment, after ten declarations, the only result awaited is Exmouth Littleham.

Yet the ” Conservative Home” website is already showing it as a Conservative Hold:

image

Is our Electoral Returning Officer, EDDC CEO Mark Williams, resourcing the counts in East Devon appropriately?

Swire: economical with the truth at the Foreign Office?

Who was the Minister responsible for this part of the world until the recent government reshuffle? Hugo Swire.

The reason this is important is explained at the end of the quote: there are attempts to stop arms sales to Saudi Arabia and if it were shown that they are using British-made cluster bombs in Yemen, this would hugely increase the possibility of this happening.

Tobias Ellwood, a minister at the Foreign Office, last night issued ‘corrections’ to six statements to Parliament about the use of British-made cluster bombs by Saudi forces in Yemen. …

… Ministers have repeatedly misled Parliament about the use of British-made cluster bombs by Saudi Arabian forces in Yemen, the Foreign Office admitted last night.

In an unprecedented move, Tobias Ellwood, a minister at the department, issued ‘corrections’ to six statements on the Yemen crisis dating back almost six months.

MPs and campaigners have been pressing the Government over the use by Saudi Arabia of British weapons and expertise in its bloody incursion in neighbouring Yemen.

In statements dating back to February, ministers have said that ‘we have assessed that there has not been a breach of international humanitarian law by the coalition’.

But yesterday Mr Ellwood admitted that they should have said ‘we have been unable to assess that there has been a breach of international humanitarian law by the Saudi-led coalition’.

The written answer also said it was not for the UK Government to assess the Saudi bombing operation.

Liberal Democrat leader Tim Farron said it was an outrage that it had been slipped out on the final day of the parliamentary sitting along with a torrent of other bad news. …

…The Government is facing a court case that it should ban all arms sales to Saudi Arabia. The European Parliament has also voted overwhelmingly for an arms embargo on the Saudis while the conflict with Yemen continues.”

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3702440/Parliament-misled-six-times-Saudi-Arabia-forces-use-UK-cluster-bombs.html

Knock-on effect of closing community hospitals and council nursing homes and sheltered housing

“The Royal Cornwall Hospital Trust (RCHT) and the Royal Devon and Exeter (RD&E) hospital are among the worst in the country for delays in discharging patients.

There were over 20,000 delayed discharges from the RD&E hospital last year, while the RCHT had more than 17,000 delays.

The report from the Commons Public Accounts Committee urges the government to address the scale and cost of bed-blocking across the country.”

Source- BBC Devon live news 08.11 am

Less space for urgent cases, more distress for patients

Local politics is beginning to change … a Progressive Alliance would change it further

The results for the recent Honiton by-election were

Conservative 362
East Devon Alliance 211
Labour 197
UKIP 140

Whilst the Conservative candidate retained the seat, the results show a strong showing by East Devon Alliance and a particularly strong response for the Labour candidate.

Had all non-Tory parties entered into a Progressive Alliance where only one of the three candidates had stood, it is likely the chosen candidate would have won the seat.

Now Exmouth seafront is up for grabs again, what of Seaton Heights?

East Devon District Council really is having problems with regeneration in Exmouth and Seaton.

In Exmouth, the relationship with preferred developer Moirai Capital Investments (see many East Devon Watch posts) has spectacularly bitten the dust. And what of the development at the old motel site in Seaton – grandly marketed as Seaton Heights:

http://lymebayleisure.co.uk/

which continues to deteriorate badly, despite promises made (many times) to either finish or start construction in June 2016 (it varies a lot depending just which press release you read) having been broken (though the company website STILL touts the off-plan £1,000 deposits it has been marketing for years).

EDDC Deputy CEO Richard Cohen was brought in specially for his regeneration expertise in London but, alas, he seems to have spent the vast majority of his time spearheading the relocation of council offices to Honiton and mopping up development issues in Cranbrook.

Now we have no less than THREE of our major towns with regeneration committees, as Axminster has joined Exmouth and Seaton as being in need of major new investment. Perhaps to be followed by Sidmouth when it is deserted by EDDC and has its replacement influx of more pensioners and Ottery as it struggles with more housing without accompanying infrastructure.

Not really a very good track record, is it?

Still, perhaps our LocalEnterprise Partnership will pump funds into these deprived areas.

EDDC votes to continue devolution deal despite absence of consultation and facts

Talks on the devolution of power from Westminster to East Devon will continue ‘in principle’ amid calls for a public consultation and more concrete facts.

If successful, the Heart of the South West (HOTSW) bid would see local authorities work with the Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP) to take on more responsibility for economic growth and infrastructure in the region.

East Devon District Council’s cabinet agreed to carry on the conversation in principle at a meeting last Wednesday (July 13) but there was a consensus that more ‘concrete facts’ are needed.

[Independent, East Devon Alliance] Councillor Cathy Gardner said: “One thing that has concerned me since the beginning of this process is the complete absence of a public consultation. It could have a huge impact. It would be remiss of us to take this forward without seeing what people want.” EDDC’s full council will need to give the final go-ahead to continue talks.”

“Slum conditions return to Britain as housing crisis brings squalor, exploitation”

“Dickensian housing conditions reminiscent of the Victorian era have returned to Britain amid a rise in private renters living in squalid lodgings and rogue landlords demanding sex in return for delayed rent.
According to local authorities and housing activists the lack of housing stock, affordable homes and regulation is forcing more and more people, especially vulnerable and low-income workers into deceitful contracts and precarious rents.

A Sky News investigation spoke to dancer Sandrine Anterrion, who found herself in a homelessness cycle after being evicted for refusing to perform sexual favors on her landlord in exchange for rent. She now lives in a “flea-infested London flat with no hot water or working toilet.” …

https://www.rt.com/uk/352463-slum-conditions-rent-housing/